Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Strahlentherapie und Onkologie 4/2022

Open Access 01-04-2022 | Radiotherapy | Review Article

125 years of head and neck radiotherapy: could organ-sparing radiotherapy of larynx cancer have prevented World War I?

Authors: Thomas B. Brunner, MD, Herbert Wördehoff, MD, Ahmed Gawish, MD, Uwe Busch, PhD

Published in: Strahlentherapie und Onkologie | Issue 4/2022

Login to get access

Abstract

Purpose

We aim to recapitulate the rapid development of head and neck radiotherapy in the context of otorhinolaryngology (ORL) medicine starting 125 years ago. This is put into context with the unsuccessful treatment of the laryngeal cancer (LC) of the German emperor Frederick III and its historical consequences.

Methods

The three-step process consisted in the analysis of (1) historical sources of the development of ORL radiotherapy from the discovery of x‑rays and radioactivity until World War I, (2) course and treatment of Frederick’s III LC, (3) political context with a special focus on the escalation towards World War I. Pertinent historical illustrations of technical developments of radiotherapy were summarized in a video.

Results

ORL radiotherapy initiated on 03 February 1896, only 65 days after the discovery of X‑rays. By 1914, organ-sparing LC radiotherapy was established with a predominance of curietherapy over roentgentherapy. Correct diagnosis of Frederick III’s primarily radiocurable cT1a glottic LC was delayed by one year, which resulted in advancement to a fatal pT4 pN1 Mx tumour stage. Historically, his successor, William II, was assumed to have contributed to the causes of World War I.

Conclusion

ORL radiotherapy came only eight years late to treat Frederick III who might have impeded World War I. This illustrates the potential impact of modern curative radiotherapy on the future course of public life beyond the personal fate of the patient himself.
Appendix
Available only for authorised users
Literature
1.
go back to reference Bonomi MR, Blakaj A, Blakaj D (2018) Organ preservation for advanced larynx cancer: A review of chemotherapy and radiation combination strategies. Oral Oncol 86:301–306PubMedCrossRef Bonomi MR, Blakaj A, Blakaj D (2018) Organ preservation for advanced larynx cancer: A review of chemotherapy and radiation combination strategies. Oral Oncol 86:301–306PubMedCrossRef
2.
go back to reference Weindling P (1992) Scientific elites and laboratory organization in fin de siècle Paris and Berlin: the Pasteur Institute and Robert Koch’s Institute for Infectious Diseases compared. In: Cunningham A, Williams P (eds) The Laboratory Revolution in Medicine. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 170–188 Weindling P (1992) Scientific elites and laboratory organization in fin de siècle Paris and Berlin: the Pasteur Institute and Robert Koch’s Institute for Infectious Diseases compared. In: Cunningham A, Williams P (eds) The Laboratory Revolution in Medicine. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 170–188
3.
go back to reference Crowther MA, Dupree MW (2007) Medical lives in the age of surgical revolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Crowther MA, Dupree MW (2007) Medical lives in the age of surgical revolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
4.
go back to reference Lederman M (1975) Panel discussion: the historical development of laryngectomy. VI. History of radiotherapy in the treatment of cancer of the larynx, 1896–1939. Laryngoscope 85(2):333–353PubMedCrossRef Lederman M (1975) Panel discussion: the historical development of laryngectomy. VI. History of radiotherapy in the treatment of cancer of the larynx, 1896–1939. Laryngoscope 85(2):333–353PubMedCrossRef
5.
go back to reference Glasser O (1993) Wilhelm Conrad Röntgen and the early history of the Roentgen rays. Norman Publishing, Glasser O (1993) Wilhelm Conrad Röntgen and the early history of the Roentgen rays. Norman Publishing,
6.
go back to reference Becquerel H (1986) Émission de radiation nouvelles par l’uranium métallique. Comptes Rendus 122:1086 Becquerel H (1986) Émission de radiation nouvelles par l’uranium métallique. Comptes Rendus 122:1086
7.
go back to reference Curie P (1898) Sur une nouvelle substance fortement radio-active, contenue dans la pechblende. Comptes Rendus 127:1215–1217 Curie P (1898) Sur une nouvelle substance fortement radio-active, contenue dans la pechblende. Comptes Rendus 127:1215–1217
8.
go back to reference Lenmalm F (1900) Förhandlingarvid Svenska Lakare-Sallskapets Saammankomster ar 1899. Isaac Marcus, Stockholm Lenmalm F (1900) Förhandlingarvid Svenska Lakare-Sallskapets Saammankomster ar 1899. Isaac Marcus, Stockholm
9.
go back to reference Coolidge WD (1913) A powerful Röntgen ray tube with a pure electron discharge. Phys Rev 2(6):409CrossRef Coolidge WD (1913) A powerful Röntgen ray tube with a pure electron discharge. Phys Rev 2(6):409CrossRef
10.
go back to reference Goldberg SW, London ES (1903) Zur Frage der Beziehungen zwischen Becquerelstrahlen und Hautaffectionen. Dermatol Z 10(5):457–462CrossRef Goldberg SW, London ES (1903) Zur Frage der Beziehungen zwischen Becquerelstrahlen und Hautaffectionen. Dermatol Z 10(5):457–462CrossRef
11.
go back to reference Voigt A (1896) Behandlung eines inoperablen Pharynxkarzinoms mit Roentgenstrahlen, 3rd edn. Ärztlicher Verin, Hamburg Voigt A (1896) Behandlung eines inoperablen Pharynxkarzinoms mit Roentgenstrahlen, 3rd edn. Ärztlicher Verin, Hamburg
12.
go back to reference Freund L (1948) Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Entstehung der Röntgentherapie. In: Maudrich W (ed) Festschrift zum 80. Geburtstag Max Neuburgers. Verlag Wilhelm Maudrich, Wien, pp 144–151 Freund L (1948) Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Entstehung der Röntgentherapie. In: Maudrich W (ed) Festschrift zum 80. Geburtstag Max Neuburgers. Verlag Wilhelm Maudrich, Wien, pp 144–151
13.
go back to reference Glasser O (1933) The science of radiology. Radiology Glasser O (1933) The science of radiology. Radiology
14.
go back to reference Dobson L (1904) A case of carcinoma of the larynx treated by x‑ray and high frequency currents. West Lond Med J 9:46–49 Dobson L (1904) A case of carcinoma of the larynx treated by x‑ray and high frequency currents. West Lond Med J 9:46–49
15.
go back to reference Leland GA (1902) In discussion after Delavan’s paper. 24th Annual congress Trans Amer Laryngol Assn. Leland GA (1902) In discussion after Delavan’s paper. 24th Annual congress Trans Amer Laryngol Assn.
16.
go back to reference Turner D (1902) A manual of practical medical electricity, the Röntgen rays and Finsen light, 3rd edn. Baillère, Tindall and Cox, London, pp 360–361 Turner D (1902) A manual of practical medical electricity, the Röntgen rays and Finsen light, 3rd edn. Baillère, Tindall and Cox, London, pp 360–361
17.
go back to reference Lowe GM (1903) X‑ray cures in private practice. Arch Roentgen Ray 7:74–77CrossRef Lowe GM (1903) X‑ray cures in private practice. Arch Roentgen Ray 7:74–77CrossRef
18.
go back to reference Delavan DB (1902) The results of treatment of laryngeal cancer by means of the X‑ray. Laryngoscope 12:899–902CrossRef Delavan DB (1902) The results of treatment of laryngeal cancer by means of the X‑ray. Laryngoscope 12:899–902CrossRef
19.
go back to reference Fletcher IE (ed) (1902) In discussion after Delavan’s paper. Trans Amer Laryngol Assn, 24th Annual Congress. Fletcher IE (ed) (1902) In discussion after Delavan’s paper. Trans Amer Laryngol Assn, 24th Annual Congress.
20.
go back to reference Payson CJ (ed) (1902) In discussion after Delavan’s paper. Trans Amer Laryngol Assn, 24th Annual Congress. Payson CJ (ed) (1902) In discussion after Delavan’s paper. Trans Amer Laryngol Assn, 24th Annual Congress.
21.
go back to reference Scheppergrell W (1902) A case of cancer of the larynx cured by the X‑rays. N Y Med J 76:984–986 Scheppergrell W (1902) A case of cancer of the larynx cured by the X‑rays. N Y Med J 76:984–986
22.
go back to reference Massier H (1904) Note sur un cas de cancer du larynx traité par les rayons de Roentgen. Rev Hebdomadaire Laryngol 24:273–284 (Part 1) Massier H (1904) Note sur un cas de cancer du larynx traité par les rayons de Roentgen. Rev Hebdomadaire Laryngol 24:273–284 (Part 1)
23.
go back to reference Béclère A, Viollet P (1904) Un cas de néoplasme du larynx traité avec succès par les rayons de Röntgen. Bull Soc Franc Otol 20:106–111 (Part 2) Béclère A, Viollet P (1904) Un cas de néoplasme du larynx traité avec succès par les rayons de Röntgen. Bull Soc Franc Otol 20:106–111 (Part 2)
24.
go back to reference Mader L (1906) Über Röntgentherapie in den oberen Luftwegen. Arch Laryngol 18:1–19 Mader L (1906) Über Röntgentherapie in den oberen Luftwegen. Arch Laryngol 18:1–19
25.
go back to reference Knipers A (1906) A case of laryngeal carcinoma treated by the X rays. Arch Roentgen Ray 11(5):150CrossRef Knipers A (1906) A case of laryngeal carcinoma treated by the X rays. Arch Roentgen Ray 11(5):150CrossRef
26.
go back to reference Regaud C, Coutard H, Hautant A (1922) Proceedings of the 10th Congrès Internationale d’Otologie, Paris, France, July, 1922: Traitement du cancer du larynx (Paper No. 96). Arch Int Laryngol 1:1161–1162 Regaud C, Coutard H, Hautant A (1922) Proceedings of the 10th Congrès Internationale d’Otologie, Paris, France, July, 1922: Traitement du cancer du larynx (Paper No. 96). Arch Int Laryngol 1:1161–1162
27.
go back to reference Pusey WA, Caldwell EW (1904) The practical application of the Roentgen rays in therapeutics and diagnosis. The British Institute of Radiology, W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, London, New York, p. 437–627 Pusey WA, Caldwell EW (1904) The practical application of the Roentgen rays in therapeutics and diagnosis. The British Institute of Radiology, W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, London, New York, p. 437–627
28.
go back to reference Gradenigo G (1908) Sull’azione terapeutica dei raggi Roentgen e del radium nelle affezioni delle prime vie aeree. Arch Ital Otol 19:236–252 Gradenigo G (1908) Sull’azione terapeutica dei raggi Roentgen e del radium nelle affezioni delle prime vie aeree. Arch Ital Otol 19:236–252
29.
go back to reference Dominici H (1908) Du traitement des tumeurs malignes par le rayonnement ultrapénétrant du radium. Bull Cancer 1:124–156 Dominici H (1908) Du traitement des tumeurs malignes par le rayonnement ultrapénétrant du radium. Bull Cancer 1:124–156
30.
go back to reference Finzi NS (1909) Untitled letter to Lancet. Lancet 1(868):1896–1939 Finzi NS (1909) Untitled letter to Lancet. Lancet 1(868):1896–1939
31.
go back to reference Delsaux V (1903) Note préliminaire sur le traitement du lupus des premières voies aériennes par le radium. La presse oto-laryngologique Belge 2, 456–62 Delsaux V (1903) Note préliminaire sur le traitement du lupus des premières voies aériennes par le radium. La presse oto-laryngologique Belge 2, 456–62
32.
go back to reference Gradenigo G (1908) Sull’azione terapeutica dei raggi Roentgen e del radium nelle affezioni delle prime vie aeree. Arch. Ital. Otol. 19:236–252 Gradenigo G (1908) Sull’azione terapeutica dei raggi Roentgen e del radium nelle affezioni delle prime vie aeree. Arch. Ital. Otol. 19:236–252
33.
go back to reference Mackenzie DJ (1904) Radium bromide: notes on some cases in which it has been tried. BMJ 1:181–182CrossRef Mackenzie DJ (1904) Radium bromide: notes on some cases in which it has been tried. BMJ 1:181–182CrossRef
34.
go back to reference Delsaux V (1902) En discussion après Béclère et Viollet. Société française d’oto-rhino-laryngologie, Paris. Bull Memoires Soc France Otorhinolaryngol 18:106–111 Delsaux V (1902) En discussion après Béclère et Viollet. Société française d’oto-rhino-laryngologie, Paris. Bull Memoires Soc France Otorhinolaryngol 18:106–111
35.
go back to reference Beck JC (1904) Experiments with radium in some nose, throat and ear diseases. Laryngoscope 14:897–915CrossRef Beck JC (1904) Experiments with radium in some nose, throat and ear diseases. Laryngoscope 14:897–915CrossRef
36.
go back to reference Abbe R (1913) The use of radium in malignant disease. Lancet 2:524–527CrossRef Abbe R (1913) The use of radium in malignant disease. Lancet 2:524–527CrossRef
37.
go back to reference Nicolai V (1908) Röntgen- e radium-terapia nella specialità. Casi Clin Arch Ital Otol 19:295–320 Nicolai V (1908) Röntgen- e radium-terapia nella specialità. Casi Clin Arch Ital Otol 19:295–320
38.
go back to reference Wickham L, Degrais P (1910) Radium therapy. Cassel and Company, LondonCrossRef Wickham L, Degrais P (1910) Radium therapy. Cassel and Company, LondonCrossRef
40.
go back to reference Costiniu (1911) Reports made to the Société d’Oto-Rhino-Laryngologie de Roumanie Séances mars et avril. Arch Int Laryngol 32:235 Costiniu (1911) Reports made to the Société d’Oto-Rhino-Laryngologie de Roumanie Séances mars et avril. Arch Int Laryngol 32:235
41.
go back to reference Price-Brown J (1912) Malignant diseases of the upper air-passages with notes upon two cases of epithelioma. Jour Laryngol 27:600–607 Price-Brown J (1912) Malignant diseases of the upper air-passages with notes upon two cases of epithelioma. Jour Laryngol 27:600–607
42.
go back to reference Hill W (1914) The treatment of inoperable growths of the nose and throat by radium. Jour Laryngol 29:487–496 Hill W (1914) The treatment of inoperable growths of the nose and throat by radium. Jour Laryngol 29:487–496
43.
go back to reference Turner D (1914) Report to meeting of the Edinburgh medico-chirurgical society. Lancet 1:826–827 Turner D (1914) Report to meeting of the Edinburgh medico-chirurgical society. Lancet 1:826–827
44.
go back to reference Duane W (1917) Methods of preparing and using radioactive substances in the treatment of malignant disease, and of estimating suitable dosages. Boston Med Surg J 177(23):787–799CrossRef Duane W (1917) Methods of preparing and using radioactive substances in the treatment of malignant disease, and of estimating suitable dosages. Boston Med Surg J 177(23):787–799CrossRef
45.
46.
go back to reference Stevenson WC (1914) An economical method of using radium for therapeutic purposes. Med Press Circular 97:251 Stevenson WC (1914) An economical method of using radium for therapeutic purposes. Med Press Circular 97:251
49.
50.
51.
go back to reference Hussein K, Panning B (2018) Reconstruction of the examination of the laryngeal carcinoma of Emperor Frederick III by Rudolf Virchow. Pathologe 39(2):172–177PubMedCrossRef Hussein K, Panning B (2018) Reconstruction of the examination of the laryngeal carcinoma of Emperor Frederick III by Rudolf Virchow. Pathologe 39(2):172–177PubMedCrossRef
52.
go back to reference Rudert H, Werner JA (2016) The laryngeal disease of the German Emperor Friedrich III: treatment failure or fateful course. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 273(6):1489–1506PubMedCrossRef Rudert H, Werner JA (2016) The laryngeal disease of the German Emperor Friedrich III: treatment failure or fateful course. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 273(6):1489–1506PubMedCrossRef
53.
go back to reference Wolfenden R, Norris J (1888) On extirpation of the larynx. J Laryngol Otol 2(1):8–13 Wolfenden R, Norris J (1888) On extirpation of the larynx. J Laryngol Otol 2(1):8–13
54.
go back to reference Mackenzie M (1888) Case of Emperor Frederik III. Edgar S. Werner, New York Mackenzie M (1888) Case of Emperor Frederik III. Edgar S. Werner, New York
55.
go back to reference Buschke F (1971) Radiation therapy. Historical perspectives. Radiol Clin Biol 40(4):217–220PubMed Buschke F (1971) Radiation therapy. Historical perspectives. Radiol Clin Biol 40(4):217–220PubMed
56.
go back to reference Weir NF (1973) Theodore Billroth: the first laryngectomy for cancer. J Laryngol Otol 87(12):1162–1170CrossRef Weir NF (1973) Theodore Billroth: the first laryngectomy for cancer. J Laryngol Otol 87(12):1162–1170CrossRef
57.
go back to reference Cardesa A, Zidar N, Alos L, Nadal A, Gale N, Kloppel G (2011) The Kaiser’s cancer revisited: was Virchow totally wrong? Virchows Arch 458(6):649–657PubMedCrossRef Cardesa A, Zidar N, Alos L, Nadal A, Gale N, Kloppel G (2011) The Kaiser’s cancer revisited: was Virchow totally wrong? Virchows Arch 458(6):649–657PubMedCrossRef
58.
go back to reference Förster-Nietzsche E (2014) Friedrich Nietzsche und die Frauen seiner Zeit. Severus, Förster-Nietzsche E (2014) Friedrich Nietzsche und die Frauen seiner Zeit. Severus,
60.
go back to reference Baumgart W (2012) Tagebuch. Kaiser Friedrich III-Tagebücher 1866–1888. Ferdinand Schöningh, , pp 41–567CrossRef Baumgart W (2012) Tagebuch. Kaiser Friedrich III-Tagebücher 1866–1888. Ferdinand Schöningh, , pp 41–567CrossRef
Metadata
Title
125 years of head and neck radiotherapy: could organ-sparing radiotherapy of larynx cancer have prevented World War I?
Authors
Thomas B. Brunner, MD
Herbert Wördehoff, MD
Ahmed Gawish, MD
Uwe Busch, PhD
Publication date
01-04-2022
Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Published in
Strahlentherapie und Onkologie / Issue 4/2022
Print ISSN: 0179-7158
Electronic ISSN: 1439-099X
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00066-022-01902-9

Other articles of this Issue 4/2022

Strahlentherapie und Onkologie 4/2022 Go to the issue