Top

Published in:

01-11-2013 | Scientific Contribution

Transparency and accountability in mass media campaigns about organ donation: a response to Morgan and Feeley

Authors: Mohamed Y. Rady, Joan L. McGregor, Joseph L. Verheijde

Published in: Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy | Issue 4/2013

Abstract

We respond to Morgan and Feeley’s critique on our article “Mass Media in Organ Donation: Managing Conflicting Messages and Interests.” We noted that Morgan and Feeley agree with the position that the primary aims of media campaigns are: “to educate the general public about organ donation process” and “help individuals make informed decisions” about organ donation. For those reasons, the educational messages in media campaigns should not be restricted to “information from pilot work or focus groups” but should include evidence-based facts resulting from a comprehensive literature research. We consider the controversial aspects about organ donation to be relevant, if not necessary, educational materials that must be disclosed in media campaigns to comply with the legal and moral requirements of informed consent. With that perspective in mind, we address the validity of Morgan and Feeley’s claim that media campaigns have no need for informing the public about the controversial nature of death determination in organ donation. Scientific evidence has proven that the criteria for death determination are inconsistent with the Uniform Determination of Death Act and therefore potentially harmful to donors. The decision by campaign designers to use the statutory definition of death without disclosing the current controversies surrounding that definition does not contribute to improved informed decision making. We argue that if Morgan and Feeley accept the important role of media campaigns to enhance informed decision making, then critical controversies should be disclosed. In support of that premise, we will outline: (1) the wide-spread scientific challenges to brain death as a concept of death; (2) the influence of the donor registry and team-huddling on the medical care of potential donors; (3) the use of authorization rather than informed consent for donor registration; (4) the contemporary religious controversy; and (5) the effects of training desk clerks as organ requestors at the Department of Motor Vehicles offices. We conclude that organ donation is a medical procedure subject to all the ethical obligations that the medical profession must uphold including that of transparency and truthfulness.

Badri, S., J. Chen, J. Barber, N. Temkin, S. Dikmen, R. Chesnut, et al. 2012. Mortality and long-term functional outcome associated with intracranial pressure after traumatic brain injury. Intensive Care Medicine 38(11): 1800–1809.PubMedCrossRef

Bernat, J.L., A.M. D’Alessandro, F.K. Port, T.P. Bleck, S.O. Heard, J. Medina, et al. 2006. Report of a national conference on donation after cardiac death. American Journal of Transplantation 6(2): 281–291.PubMedCrossRef

Billeter, A.T., S. Sklare, G.A. Franklin, J. Wright, G. Morgan, P.E. O’Flynn, et al. 2012. Sequential improvements in organ procurement increase the organ donation rate. Injury 43(11): 1805–1810.PubMedCrossRef

Bohannon, R. 2012. Despite the wishes of his doctor, patient makes incredible recovery. Life News @ Texas Right to Life. Published Friday, October 05, 2012. Retrieved 16 October 2012, from http://www.texasrighttolife.com/a/947/Despite-the-wishes-of-his-doctor-patient-makes-incredible-recovery.

Byrne, P., and W. Weaver. 2004. “Brain death” is not death. Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology 550: 43–49.PubMedCrossRef

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. 2006. Medicare and medicaid programs; conditions for coverage for organ procurement organizations (OPOs). Final rule. Federal Register 71(104): 30981–31054.

Cohen, J., T. Ashkenazi, E. Katvan, and P. Singer. 2012. Brain death determination in Israel: The first two years experience following changes to the brain death law—opportunities and challenges. American Journal of Transplantation 12(9): 2514–2518.PubMedCrossRef

Coimbra, C.G. 1999. Implications of ischemic penumbra for the diagnosis of brain death. Brazilian Journal of Medical and Biological Research 32: 1479–1487.PubMedCrossRef

Cote, N., Turgeon, A.F., Lauzier, F., Moore, L., Scales, D.C., Bernard, F., et al. 2012. Factors Associated with the withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies in patients with severe traumatic brain injury: A Multicenter Cohort Study. Neurocritical Care 18(1). doi:10.1007/s12028-012-9787-9.

D’Alessandro, A.M., J.W. Peltier, and A.J. Dahl. 2012. The impact of social, cognitive and attitudinal dimensions on college students’ support for organ donation. American Journal of Transplantation 12(1): 152–161.PubMedCrossRef

Davoudian, V. 2008. Bupropion overdose mimicking brain death. Presentation at the American College of Physicians Colorado, Chapter Annual Meeting, Colorado Springs, CO, Broadmoor Hotel., from http://www.acponline.org/about_acp/chapters/co/davoudian.pdf.

Feeley, T.H., and S.-I. Moon. 2009. A meta-analytic review of communication campaigns to promote organ donation. Communication Reports 22(2): 63–73.CrossRef

Fugate, J.E., M. Stadtler, A.A. Rabinstein, and E.F.M. Wijdicks. 2011. Variability in donation after cardiac death protocols: A national survey. Transplantation 91(4): 386–389.PubMed

Glazier, A.K. 2011. The principles of gift law and the regulation of organ donation. Transplant International 24(4): 368–372.PubMedCrossRef

Groot, Y.J., H.F. Lingsma, M. van der Jagt, J. Bakker, J.N. Ijzermans, and E.J. Kompanje. 2011. Remarkable changes in the choice of timing to discuss organ donation with the relatives of a patient: a study in 228 organ donations in 20 years. Critical Care 15(5): R235. Retrieved from http://ccforum.com/content/15/5/R235 PubMedCrossRef

Harrison, T.R., S.E. Morgan, and M.J. Di Corcia. 2008. Effects of information, education, and communication training about organ donation for gatekeepers: clerks at the Department of Motor Vehicles and organ donor registries. Progress in Transplantation 18(4): 301–309.PubMed

Harrison, T.R., S.E. Morgan, A.J. King, M.J. Di Corcia, E.A. Williams, R.K. Ivic, et al. 2010. Promoting the Michigan organ donor registry: Evaluating the impact of a multifaceted intervention utilizing media priming and communication design. Health Communication 25(8): 700–708.PubMedCrossRef

Harrison, T.R., S.E. Morgan, A.J. King, and E.A. Williams. 2011. Saving lives branch by branch: The effectiveness of driver licensing Bureau Campaigns to promote organ donor registry sign-ups to African Americans in Michigan. Journal of Health Communication: International Perspectives 16(8): 805–819.CrossRef

Health Resources & Services Administration. 2010. Religious Views on Donation. Retrieved 16 December 2012, from http://www.organdonor.gov/about/religiousviews.html.

Honeybul, S., G. Gillett, K. Ho, and C. Lind. 2012. Ethical considerations for performing decompressive craniectomy as a life-saving intervention for severe traumatic brain injury. Journal of Medical Ethics 38(11): 657–661.PubMedCrossRef

James, S.D. 2011. Readied To Donate Organs, 21-Year-Old Emerges From Coma. ABC Good Morning America. ABC News, ABC News Internet Ventures. Posted on Thursday 22 December 2011. Retrieved 16 October, 2012, from http://abcnews.go.com/Health/arizona-accident-victim-emerges-coma-poised-donate-organs/story?id=15208351.

Joffe, A.R. 2007. The neurological determination of death: What does it really mean? Issues in Law and Medicine 23(2): 119–140.PubMed

Joffe, A.R., Anton, N., Duff, J., and deCaen, A. 2012. A survey of American neurologists about brain death: understanding of the conceptual basis and diagnostic tests for brain death. Annals of Intensive Care, 2, 1, 4. Retrieved from http://www.annalsofintensivecare.com/content/2/1/4.

Joffe, A.R., Carcillo, J., Anton, N., deCaen, A., Han, Y., Bell, M., et al. 2011. Donation after cardiocirculatory death: A call for a moratorium pending full public disclosure and fully informed consent. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine, 6(1):17. Retrieved from http://www.peh-med.com/content/6/1/17.

Joffe, A.R., H. Kolski, J. Duff, and A.R. deCaen. 2009. A 10-month-old infant with reversible findings of brain death. Pediatric Neurology 41(5): 378–382.PubMedCrossRef

Jones, D.A. 2012. Loss of faith in brain death: Catholic controversy over the determination of death by neurological criteria. Clinical Ethics 7(3): 133–141.CrossRef

Jotkowitz, A.B., and S. Glick. 2009. Navigating the chasm between religious and secular perspectives in modern bioethics. Journal of Medical Ethics 35(6): 357–360.PubMedCrossRef

Karakatsanis, K.G. 2008. Brain death: Should it be reconsidered? Spinal Cord 46(6): 396–401.PubMedCrossRef

Karakatsanis, K.G., and J.N. Tsanakas. 2002. A critique on the concept of ‘Brain Death’. Issues in Law and Medicine 18(2): 127–141.PubMed

Lipworth, W., I. Kerridge, B. Morrell, C. Bonfiglioli, and R. Forsyth. 2012. Medicine, the media and political interests. Journal of Medical Ethics 38(12): 768–770.PubMedCrossRef

Lustbader, D., D. O’Hara, E.F.M. Wijdicks, L. MacLean, W. Tajik, A. Ying, et al. 2011. Second brain death examination may negatively affect organ donation. Neurology 76(2): 119–124.PubMedCrossRef

Malinoski, D.J., M.S. Patel, M.C. Daly, C. Oley-Graybill, and A. Salim. 2012. The impact of meeting donor management goals on the number of organs transplanted per donor: Results from the United Network for Organ Sharing Region 5 prospective donor management goals study. Critical Care Medicine 40(10): 2773–2780.PubMedCrossRef

Malm, S. 2012. Carina Melchior:The girl who wouldn’t die.Incredible story of the 19-year-old who woke up as doctors were preparing to harvest her organs. Carina Melchior was in a coma and was not expected to wake up. Doctors at the Danish hospital had started preparing her for organ donations and the family agreed for life support to be switched off. Less than 24 hours after the breathing equipment was turned off, Carina opened her eyes. Her parents are now suing the hospital for damages. MailOnline at The Daily Mail Associated Newspapers Ltd. Published: 10:05 EST, 17 October 2012 | Updated: 04:34 EST, 18 October 2012 from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2219085/Carina-Melchior-The-girl-wouldnt-die-Miracle-Danish-girl-woke-doctors-prepared-organs-donated.html.

Marik, P.E., and J. Varon. 2010. Prolonged and profound therapeutic hypothermia for the treatment of “brain death” after a suicidal intoxication. Challenging conventional wisdoms. The American journal of emergency medicine 28(2): 258.e1–258.e4.

McGregor, J.L., J.L. Verheijde, and M.Y. Rady. 2008. The entertainment media framing of organ donation: Second-hand reality balancing the ideological bias of education campaigns. Health Communication 23(4): 394–395.PubMedCrossRef

Michael, G.E., and J.E. Jesus. 2012. Treatment of potential organ donors in the emergency department: A review. Annals of Emergency Medicine 60(4): 485–491.PubMedCrossRef

Milligan, E., S. Winch, and R. Adams. 2012. Marketing to register organ donors may circumvent principles of informed consent. BMJ 345: e5850. Retrieved from http://www.bmj.com/content/345/bmj.e5850 PubMedCrossRef

Morales, N. 2008. ‘Dead’ man recovering after ATV accident. Doctors said he was dead, and a transplant team was ready to take his organs – until a young man came back to life. Dateline NBC News, NBCNews.com. Posted on March 23, 2008. Retrieved 16 October, 2012, from http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23768436/ns/dateline_nbc-newsmakers/t/dead-man-recovering-after-atv-accident/.

Morgan, S.E., and Feeley, T.H. 2012. Clarifications on mass media campaigns promoting organ donation: A response to Rady, McGregor, and Verheijde (2012). Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy. doi:10.1007/s11019-012-9458-9.

Morgan, S.E., T.R. Harrison, L. Chewning, L. Davis, and M. DiCorcia. 2007. Entertainment (mis)education: The framing of organ donation in entertainment television. Health Communication 22(2): 143–151.PubMedCrossRef

Mundi, J.P., J. Betancourt, O. Ezziddin, B. Tremayne, T. Majic, and Z. Mosenifar. 2012. Dilated and unreactive pupils and burst-suppression on electroencephalography due to buproprion overdose. Journal of Intensive Care Medicine 27(6): 384–388.PubMedCrossRef

Organ Procurement Organization and Organ Availability Committees. 2011. Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network -Health Resources and Services Administration of the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services: Proposal to Update and Clarify Language in the DCD Model Elements Retrieved 8 October, 2012, from http://optn.transplant.hrsa.gov/policiesAndBylaws/publicComment/proposals.asp.

Organ Procurement Organization Committee. 2011. Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network- Health Resources and Services Administration of the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services: Proposal to Change the Term “Consent” to “Authorization” Throughout Policy When Used in Reference to Organ Donation. Retrieved 8 October, 2012, from http://optn.transplant.hrsa.gov/policiesAndBylaws/publicComment/proposals.asp.

Perman, S.M., J.N. Kirkpatrick, A.M. Reitsma, D.F. Gaieski, B. Lau, T.M. Smith, et al. 2012. Timing of neuroprognostication in postcardiac arrest therapeutic hypothermia. Critical Care Medicine 40(3): 719–724.PubMedCrossRef

Potts, M., P.A. Byrne, and R.G. Nilges. 2000. Beyond brain death. In The case against brain based criteria for human death, vol. 66, 2000th ed, ed. M. Potts, P.A. Byrne, and R.G. Nilges, 1–20. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

Quick, B.L., D. Bosch, and S.E. Morgan. 2012. Message framing and medium considerations for recruiting newly eligible teen organ donor registrants. American Journal of Transplantation 12(6): 1593–1597.PubMedCrossRef

Rady, M.Y., J.L. McGregor, and J.L. Verheijde. 2012. Mass media campaigns and organ donation: managing conflicting messages and interests. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 15(2): 229–241.CrossRef

Rhee, J.Y., R. Ruthazer, K. O’Connor, F.L. Delmonico, R.S. Luskin, and R.B. Freeman. 2011. The impact of variation in donation after cardiac death policies among donor hospitals: A regional analysis. American Journal of Transplantation 11(8): 1719–1726.PubMedCrossRef

Roberts, D., K. MacCulloch, E. Versnick, and R. Hall. 2010. Should ancillary brain blood flow analyses play a larger role in the neurological determination of death? Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d’anesthésie 57(10): 927–935.CrossRef

Rodriguez-Arias, D., I. Ortega-Deballon, and S.J. Youngner. 2012. Protocols for uncontrolled donation after circulatory death—Authors’ reply. The Lancet 380(9846): 975.CrossRef

Saposnik, G., V.S. Basile, and G.B. Young. 2009. Movements in brain death: A systematic review. Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences 36(2): 154–160.PubMed

Sheth, K., Stein, D., Aarabi, B., Hu, P., Kufera, J., Scalea, T., et al. 2012. Intracranial pressure dose and outcome in traumatic brain injury. Neurocritical Care: Published online: 9 October 2012. doi:10.1007/s12028-012-9780-3.

Shewmon, D.A. 1998. ‘Brainstem death’, ‘Brain death’ and death: A critical re-evaluation of the purported equivalence. Issues in Law and Medicine 14(2): 125–145.PubMed

Shewmon, D.A. 2009. Brain death: can it be resuscitated? Issues in Law and Medicine 25(1): 3–14.PubMed

Shewmon, D.A. 2012a. Brain death or brain dying? Journal of Child Neurology 27(1): 4–6.PubMedCrossRef

Shewmon, D.A. 2012b. You only die once: why brain death is not the death of a human being. A reply to Nicholas Tonti-Filippini. Communio: International Catholic Review, 39(Fall issue): 422–494.

Sullivan, R., M.J. Hodgman, L. Kao, and L.M. Tormoehlen. 2012. Baclofen overdose mimicking brain death. Clinical Toxicology 50(2): 141–144.PubMedCrossRef

The Lancet. 2011. Religion, organ transplantation, and the definition of death. The Lancet 377(9762): 271.CrossRef

The President’s Council on Bioethics. 2008. Controversies in the determination of death. A white paper of the President’s council on bioethics. Retrieved 28 November, 2012, from http://bioethics.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/death/.

Thomas, A.G. 2012. Continuing the definition of death debate: the report of the president’s council on bioethics on controversies in the determination of death. Bioethics 26(2): 101–107.PubMedCrossRef

Traino, H.M., G.P. Alolod, T. Shafer, and L.A. Siminoff. 2012. Interim results of a national test of the rapid assessment of hospital procurement barriers in donation (RAPiD). American Journal of Transplantation 12(11): 3094–3103.PubMedCrossRef

Turgeon, A.F., F. Lauzier, J.-F. Simard, D.C. Scales, K.E.A. Burns, L. Moore, et al. 2011. Mortality associated with withdrawal of life-sustaining therapy for patients with severe traumatic brain injury: A Canadian multicentre cohort study. Canadian Medical Association Journal 183(14): 1581–1588.PubMedCrossRef

Varelas, P., M. Rehman, T. Abdelhak, A. Patel, V. Rai, A. Barber, et al. 2011. Single brain death examination is equivalent to dual brain death examinations. Neurocritical Care 15(3): 547–553.PubMedCrossRef

Wall, S.P., and L.R. Goldfrank. 2012. Death on the waiting list: A failure in public health. Annals of Emergency Medicine 60(4): 492–494.PubMedCrossRef

Webb, A.C., and O.B. Samuels. 2011. Reversible brain death after cardiopulmonary arrest and induced hypothermia. Critical Care Medicine 39(6): 1538–1542.PubMedCrossRef

Wijdicks, E.F. 2010. The case against confirmatory tests for determining brain death in adults. Neurology 75(1): 77–83.PubMedCrossRef

Yoo, J.H., and Y. Tian. 2011. Effects of entertainment (mis) education: Exposure to entertainment television programs and organ donation intention. Health Communication 26(2): 147–158.PubMedCrossRef

Zamperetti, N., and R. Bellomo. 2009. Total brain failure: a new contribution by the President’s council on bioethics to the definition of death according to the neurological standard. Intensive Care Medicine 35(7): 1305–1307.PubMedCrossRef

Zamperetti, N., R. Bellomo, C.A. Defanti, and N. Latronico. 2004. Irreversible apnoeic coma 35 years later. Towards a more rigorous definition of brain death? Intensive Care Medicine 30(9): 1715–1722.PubMedCrossRef

Title: Transparency and accountability in mass media campaigns about organ donation: a response to Morgan and Feeley
Authors: Mohamed Y. Rady
Joan L. McGregor
Joseph L. Verheijde
Publication date: 01-11-2013
Publisher: Springer Netherlands
Published in: Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy / Issue 4/2013
Print ISSN: 1386-7423
Electronic ISSN: 1572-8633
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-013-9466-4

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on medication adherence

Springer Medicine

Transparency and accountability in mass media campaigns about organ donation: a response to Morgan and Feeley

Abstract

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on medication adherence

Springer Medicine

Abstract

Please log in to get access to this content

Other articles of this Issue 4/2013

Can our understanding of informed consent be strengthened using the idea of cluster concepts?

The Singleton case: enforcing medical treatment to put a person to death

Respect for cultural diversity in bioethics is an ethical imperative

E-care as craftsmanship: virtuous work, skilled engagement, and information technology in health care

Chronic disease, prevention policy, and the future of public health and primary care

What justifies the United States ban on federal funding for nonreproductive cloning?