Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 2/2019

01-06-2019 | Scientific Contribution

The spectrum of end of life care: an argument for access to medical assistance in dying for vulnerable populations

Authors: Alysia C. Wright, Jessica C. Shaw

Published in: Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy | Issue 2/2019

Login to get access

Abstract

Medical assistance in dying (MAiD) was legalized by the Supreme Court of Canada in June 2016 and became a legal, viable end of life care (EOLC) option for Canadians with irremediable illness and suffering. Much attention has been paid to the balance between physicians’ willingness to provide MAiD and patients’ legal right to request medically assisted death in certain circumstances. In contrast, very little attention has been paid to the challenge of making MAiD accessible to vulnerable populations. The purpose of this paper was to examine the extant literature and resources that are available on the provision of MAiD in Canada. We found that the provision of EOLC in Canada offers insufficient access to palliative and EOLC options for Canadians and that vulnerable Canadians experience disproportional barriers to accessing these already limited resources. Consequently, we argue that palliative care, hospice care and MAiD must be considered a spectrum of EOLC that is inclusive and accessible to all Canadians. We conclude by imploring Canadian healthcare professionals, policy makers and legislators to consider MAiD as a viable EOLC option for all Canadians.
Literature
go back to reference Arenas, A., and Hippocrates. 2010. Hippocrates’ oath. Arion 17 (3): 73–74. Arenas, A., and Hippocrates. 2010. Hippocrates’ oath. Arion 17 (3): 73–74.
go back to reference Ball, I.M., and S. Anderson. 2017. Availability of medical assistance in dying can be therapeutic. CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 189 (9): E372.CrossRef Ball, I.M., and S. Anderson. 2017. Availability of medical assistance in dying can be therapeutic. CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 189 (9): E372.CrossRef
go back to reference Bostwick, J.M. 2015. When suicide is not suicide: Self-induced morbidity and mortality in the general hospital. Rambam Maimonides Medical Journal 6(2), e0013.CrossRef Bostwick, J.M. 2015. When suicide is not suicide: Self-induced morbidity and mortality in the general hospital. Rambam Maimonides Medical Journal 6(2), e0013.CrossRef
go back to reference Chambaere, K., and J.L. Bernheim. 2015. Does legal physician-assisted dying impede development of palliative care? The Belgian and Benelux experience. Journal of Medical Ethics 41 (8): 657–660.CrossRef Chambaere, K., and J.L. Bernheim. 2015. Does legal physician-assisted dying impede development of palliative care? The Belgian and Benelux experience. Journal of Medical Ethics 41 (8): 657–660.CrossRef
go back to reference Chochinov, H. M. 2007. Dignity and the essence of medicine: The A, B, C and D of dignity conserving care. British Medical Journal 335: 184–187.CrossRef Chochinov, H. M. 2007. Dignity and the essence of medicine: The A, B, C and D of dignity conserving care. British Medical Journal 335: 184–187.CrossRef
go back to reference Chochinov, H.M., and C. Frazee. 2016. Finding a balance: Canada’s law on medical assistance in dying. Lancet 388 (10044): 543–545.CrossRef Chochinov, H.M., and C. Frazee. 2016. Finding a balance: Canada’s law on medical assistance in dying. Lancet 388 (10044): 543–545.CrossRef
go back to reference Clarke, G., E. Fistein, A. Holland, M. Barclay, P. Theimann, and S. Barclay. 2017. Preferences for care towards the end of life when decision-making capacity may be impaired: A large-scale cross-sectional survey of public attitudes in Great Britain and the United States. PLoS ONE 12 (4): e0172104.CrossRef Clarke, G., E. Fistein, A. Holland, M. Barclay, P. Theimann, and S. Barclay. 2017. Preferences for care towards the end of life when decision-making capacity may be impaired: A large-scale cross-sectional survey of public attitudes in Great Britain and the United States. PLoS ONE 12 (4): e0172104.CrossRef
go back to reference Claxton-Oldfield, S., and K. Miller. 2015. A study of Canadian hospice palliative care volunteers’ attitudes toward physician-assisted suicide. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine 32 (3): 305–312.CrossRef Claxton-Oldfield, S., and K. Miller. 2015. A study of Canadian hospice palliative care volunteers’ attitudes toward physician-assisted suicide. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine 32 (3): 305–312.CrossRef
go back to reference Claxton-Oldfield, S., L. Gibbon, and K. Schmidt-Chamberlain. 2011. When to say “yes” and when to say “no”: Boundary issues for hospice palliative care volunteers. The American Journal of Hospice & Palliative Care 28 (6): 429.CrossRef Claxton-Oldfield, S., L. Gibbon, and K. Schmidt-Chamberlain. 2011. When to say “yes” and when to say “no”: Boundary issues for hospice palliative care volunteers. The American Journal of Hospice & Palliative Care 28 (6): 429.CrossRef
go back to reference Cohen-Almagor, R. 2015. An argument for physician-assisted suicide and against euthanasia. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health 1 (4): 431–441.CrossRef Cohen-Almagor, R. 2015. An argument for physician-assisted suicide and against euthanasia. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health 1 (4): 431–441.CrossRef
go back to reference Collins, A., and B. Leier. 2017. Can medical assistance in dying harm rural and remote palliative care in Canada? Canadian Family Physician 63 (3): 186. Collins, A., and B. Leier. 2017. Can medical assistance in dying harm rural and remote palliative care in Canada? Canadian Family Physician 63 (3): 186.
go back to reference Daly, P. 2015. Palliative sedation, foregoing life-sustaining treatment, and aid-in-dying: What is the difference? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 36 (3): 197–213.CrossRef Daly, P. 2015. Palliative sedation, foregoing life-sustaining treatment, and aid-in-dying: What is the difference? Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 36 (3): 197–213.CrossRef
go back to reference de Graeff, A., and M. Dean. 2007. Palliative sedation therapy in the last weeks of life: A literature review and recommendations for standards. Journal of Palliative Medicine 10 (1): 67–85.CrossRef de Graeff, A., and M. Dean. 2007. Palliative sedation therapy in the last weeks of life: A literature review and recommendations for standards. Journal of Palliative Medicine 10 (1): 67–85.CrossRef
go back to reference de Lima, L., R. Woodruff, K. Pettus, J. Downing, R. Buitrago, E. Munyoro, C. Venkateswaran, S. Bhatnagar, and L. Radbruch. 2017. International association for hospice and palliative care position statement: Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Journal of Palliative Medicine 20 (1): 8–14.CrossRef de Lima, L., R. Woodruff, K. Pettus, J. Downing, R. Buitrago, E. Munyoro, C. Venkateswaran, S. Bhatnagar, and L. Radbruch. 2017. International association for hospice and palliative care position statement: Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Journal of Palliative Medicine 20 (1): 8–14.CrossRef
go back to reference Gallagher, R., C. Baldwin, and D. Cargill. 2014. Palliative sedation. CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 186 (3): 212.CrossRef Gallagher, R., C. Baldwin, and D. Cargill. 2014. Palliative sedation. CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 186 (3): 212.CrossRef
go back to reference Huynh, L., B. Henry, and N. Dosani. 2015. Minding the gap: Access to palliative care and the homeless. BMC Palliative Care 14 (1): 62.CrossRef Huynh, L., B. Henry, and N. Dosani. 2015. Minding the gap: Access to palliative care and the homeless. BMC Palliative Care 14 (1): 62.CrossRef
go back to reference Institute of Medicine (IOM). 2014. Key findings and recommendations: Dying in America: Improving quality and honoring individual preferences near the end of life. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. Institute of Medicine (IOM). 2014. Key findings and recommendations: Dying in America: Improving quality and honoring individual preferences near the end of life. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
go back to reference Johnson, S.M., R.J. Cramer, M.A. Conroy, and B.O. Gardner. 2014. The role of and challenges for psychologists in physician assisted suicide. Death Studies 38 (6–10): 582–588.CrossRef Johnson, S.M., R.J. Cramer, M.A. Conroy, and B.O. Gardner. 2014. The role of and challenges for psychologists in physician assisted suicide. Death Studies 38 (6–10): 582–588.CrossRef
go back to reference Kim, S.Y.H., and T. Lemmens. 2016. Should assisted dying for psychiatric disorders be legalized in Canada? CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 188 (14): E337–E339.CrossRef Kim, S.Y.H., and T. Lemmens. 2016. Should assisted dying for psychiatric disorders be legalized in Canada? CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 188 (14): E337–E339.CrossRef
go back to reference Kouwenhoven, P.S., N.J. Raijmakers, J.J. van Delden, J.A. Rietjens, M.H. Schermer, G.J. van Thiel, M.J. Trappenburg, S. van de Vathorst, B.J. van der Vegt, C. Vezzoni, H. Weyers, D.G. van Tol, and A. van der Heide. 2013. Opinions of health care professionals and the public after eight years of euthanasia legislation in the Netherlands: A mixed methods approach. Palliative Medicine 27 (3): 273–280.CrossRef Kouwenhoven, P.S., N.J. Raijmakers, J.J. van Delden, J.A. Rietjens, M.H. Schermer, G.J. van Thiel, M.J. Trappenburg, S. van de Vathorst, B.J. van der Vegt, C. Vezzoni, H. Weyers, D.G. van Tol, and A. van der Heide. 2013. Opinions of health care professionals and the public after eight years of euthanasia legislation in the Netherlands: A mixed methods approach. Palliative Medicine 27 (3): 273–280.CrossRef
go back to reference Landry, J.T., T. Foreman, and M. Kekewich. 2015. Ethical considerations in the regulation of euthanasia and physician-assisted death in Canada. Health Policy 119 (11): 1490–1498.CrossRef Landry, J.T., T. Foreman, and M. Kekewich. 2015. Ethical considerations in the regulation of euthanasia and physician-assisted death in Canada. Health Policy 119 (11): 1490–1498.CrossRef
go back to reference Levy, T.B., S. Azar, R. Huberfeld, A.M. Siegel, and R.D. Strous. 2013. Attitudes towards euthanasia and assisted suicide: A comparison between psychiatrists and other physicians: Attitudes towards euthanasia and assisted suicide. Bioethics 27 (7): 402–408.CrossRef Levy, T.B., S. Azar, R. Huberfeld, A.M. Siegel, and R.D. Strous. 2013. Attitudes towards euthanasia and assisted suicide: A comparison between psychiatrists and other physicians: Attitudes towards euthanasia and assisted suicide. Bioethics 27 (7): 402–408.CrossRef
go back to reference Lewis, B. 2017. A deliberate departure: Making physician-assisted suicide comfortable for vulnerable patients. Arkansas Law Review 70 (1): 1. Lewis, B. 2017. A deliberate departure: Making physician-assisted suicide comfortable for vulnerable patients. Arkansas Law Review 70 (1): 1.
go back to reference Materstvedt, L.J., and G. Bosshard. 2009. Deep and continuous palliative sedation (terminal sedation): Clinical-ethical and philosophical aspects. Lancet Oncology, the 10 (6): 622–627.CrossRef Materstvedt, L.J., and G. Bosshard. 2009. Deep and continuous palliative sedation (terminal sedation): Clinical-ethical and philosophical aspects. Lancet Oncology, the 10 (6): 622–627.CrossRef
go back to reference McNeil, R., T. Kerr, B. Pauly, E. Wood, and W. Small. 2016. Advancing patient-centered care for structurally vulnerable drug-using populations: A qualitative study of the perspectives of people who use drugs regarding the potential integration of harm reduction interventions into hospitals. Addiction 111 (4): 685–694.CrossRef McNeil, R., T. Kerr, B. Pauly, E. Wood, and W. Small. 2016. Advancing patient-centered care for structurally vulnerable drug-using populations: A qualitative study of the perspectives of people who use drugs regarding the potential integration of harm reduction interventions into hospitals. Addiction 111 (4): 685–694.CrossRef
go back to reference Mechanic, D., and J. Tanner. 2007. Vulnerable people, groups, and populations: Societal view. Health Affairs 26 (5): 1220–1230.CrossRef Mechanic, D., and J. Tanner. 2007. Vulnerable people, groups, and populations: Societal view. Health Affairs 26 (5): 1220–1230.CrossRef
go back to reference Meghani, S.H., and P.S. Hinds. 2015. Policy brief: The Institute of Medicine report Dying in America: Improving quality and honoring individual preferences near the end of life. Nursing Outlook 63 (1): 51–59.CrossRef Meghani, S.H., and P.S. Hinds. 2015. Policy brief: The Institute of Medicine report Dying in America: Improving quality and honoring individual preferences near the end of life. Nursing Outlook 63 (1): 51–59.CrossRef
go back to reference National Ethics Committee, Veterans Health Administration. 2007. The ethics of palliative sedation as a therapy of last resort. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine 23 (6): 483–491.CrossRef National Ethics Committee, Veterans Health Administration. 2007. The ethics of palliative sedation as a therapy of last resort. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine 23 (6): 483–491.CrossRef
go back to reference Quill, T.E., A.L. Back, and S.D. Block. 2016. Responding to patients requesting physician-assisted death: Physician involvement at the very end of life. JAMA 315 (3): 245–246.CrossRef Quill, T.E., A.L. Back, and S.D. Block. 2016. Responding to patients requesting physician-assisted death: Physician involvement at the very end of life. JAMA 315 (3): 245–246.CrossRef
go back to reference Rodríguez-Prat, A., C. Monforte-Royo, J. Porta-Sales, X. Escribano, and A. Balaguer. 2016. Patient perspectives of dignity, autonomy and control at the end of life: Systematic review and meta-ethnography. PLoS ONE 11 (3): E0151435.CrossRef Rodríguez-Prat, A., C. Monforte-Royo, J. Porta-Sales, X. Escribano, and A. Balaguer. 2016. Patient perspectives of dignity, autonomy and control at the end of life: Systematic review and meta-ethnography. PLoS ONE 11 (3): E0151435.CrossRef
go back to reference Rys, S., R. Deschepper, F. Mortier, L. Deliens, and J. Bilsen. 2015. Bridging the gap between continuous sedation until death and physician-assisted death: A focus group study in nursing homes in Flanders, Belgium. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine 32 (4): 407–416.CrossRef Rys, S., R. Deschepper, F. Mortier, L. Deliens, and J. Bilsen. 2015. Bridging the gap between continuous sedation until death and physician-assisted death: A focus group study in nursing homes in Flanders, Belgium. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine 32 (4): 407–416.CrossRef
go back to reference Song, J., D.M. Bartels, E.R. Ratner, L. Alderton, B. Hudson, and J.S. Ahluwalia. 2007. Dying on the streets: Homeless persons’ concerns and desires about end of life care. Journal of General Internal Medicine 22 (4): 435–441.CrossRef Song, J., D.M. Bartels, E.R. Ratner, L. Alderton, B. Hudson, and J.S. Ahluwalia. 2007. Dying on the streets: Homeless persons’ concerns and desires about end of life care. Journal of General Internal Medicine 22 (4): 435–441.CrossRef
go back to reference Stienstra, D., and H.M. Chochinov. 2012. Palliative care for vulnerable populations. Palliative & Supportive Care 10 (1): 37.CrossRef Stienstra, D., and H.M. Chochinov. 2012. Palliative care for vulnerable populations. Palliative & Supportive Care 10 (1): 37.CrossRef
go back to reference Sumalinog, R., K. Harrington, N. Dosani, and S.W. Hwang. 2017. Advance care planning, palliative care, and end-of-life care interventions for homeless people: A systematic review. Palliative Medicine 31 (2): 109–119.CrossRef Sumalinog, R., K. Harrington, N. Dosani, and S.W. Hwang. 2017. Advance care planning, palliative care, and end-of-life care interventions for homeless people: A systematic review. Palliative Medicine 31 (2): 109–119.CrossRef
go back to reference Tan, A., and D. Manca. 2013. Finding common ground to achieve a “good death”: Family physicians working with substitute decision-makers of dying patients. A qualitative grounded theory study. BMC Family Practice 14 (1): 1–11.CrossRef Tan, A., and D. Manca. 2013. Finding common ground to achieve a “good death”: Family physicians working with substitute decision-makers of dying patients. A qualitative grounded theory study. BMC Family Practice 14 (1): 1–11.CrossRef
go back to reference ten Have, H., and J.V.M. Welie. 2014. Palliative sedation versus euthanasia: An ethical assessment. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 47 (1): 123.CrossRef ten Have, H., and J.V.M. Welie. 2014. Palliative sedation versus euthanasia: An ethical assessment. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 47 (1): 123.CrossRef
go back to reference Tibbetts, J. 2013. Quebec’s end-of-life bill makes palliative care more transparent. CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 185 (12): 1031–1032.CrossRef Tibbetts, J. 2013. Quebec’s end-of-life bill makes palliative care more transparent. CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal 185 (12): 1031–1032.CrossRef
go back to reference Van Bruchem-van de Scheur, G.G., Arie J.G. Van Der Arend, C. Spreeuwenberg, H. Huijer Abu-Saad, and R.H.J. Ter Meulen. 2007. Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide in the Dutch homecare sector: The role of the district nurse. Journal of Advanced Nursing 58 (1): 44–52.CrossRef Van Bruchem-van de Scheur, G.G., Arie J.G. Van Der Arend, C. Spreeuwenberg, H. Huijer Abu-Saad, and R.H.J. Ter Meulen. 2007. Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide in the Dutch homecare sector: The role of the district nurse. Journal of Advanced Nursing 58 (1): 44–52.CrossRef
go back to reference Vedel, I., V. Ghadi, L. Lapointe, C. Routelous, P. Aegerter, and F. Guirimand. 2014. Patients’, family caregivers’, and professionals’ perspectives on quality of palliative care: A qualitative study. Palliative Medicine 28 (9): 1128–1138.CrossRef Vedel, I., V. Ghadi, L. Lapointe, C. Routelous, P. Aegerter, and F. Guirimand. 2014. Patients’, family caregivers’, and professionals’ perspectives on quality of palliative care: A qualitative study. Palliative Medicine 28 (9): 1128–1138.CrossRef
go back to reference Watt, S., M. Li, M. Gardam, M. Escaf, G. Rodin, G. OELeary, and A. Heesters. 2017. Medical assistance in dying-implementing a hospital-based program in Canada. The New England Journal of Medicine 376 (21): 2082.CrossRef Watt, S., M. Li, M. Gardam, M. Escaf, G. Rodin, G. OELeary, and A. Heesters. 2017. Medical assistance in dying-implementing a hospital-based program in Canada. The New England Journal of Medicine 376 (21): 2082.CrossRef
go back to reference World Medical Association (WMA). 2015. End-of-life-issues. In The World Medical Association’s medical ethics manual. 3rd ed., 59–60 Ferney-Voltaire: World Medical Association (WMA). World Medical Association (WMA). 2015. End-of-life-issues. In The World Medical Association’s medical ethics manual. 3rd ed., 59–60 Ferney-Voltaire: World Medical Association (WMA).
go back to reference Yuill, K. 2015. The unfreedom of assisted suicide: How the right to die undermines autonomy. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health 1 (4): 494–502.CrossRef Yuill, K. 2015. The unfreedom of assisted suicide: How the right to die undermines autonomy. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health 1 (4): 494–502.CrossRef
go back to reference Zenz, J., M. Tryba, and M. Zenz. 2015. Palliative care professionals’ willingness to perform euthanasia or physician assisted suicide. BMC Palliative Care 14 (1): 60.CrossRef Zenz, J., M. Tryba, and M. Zenz. 2015. Palliative care professionals’ willingness to perform euthanasia or physician assisted suicide. BMC Palliative Care 14 (1): 60.CrossRef
Metadata
Title
The spectrum of end of life care: an argument for access to medical assistance in dying for vulnerable populations
Authors
Alysia C. Wright
Jessica C. Shaw
Publication date
01-06-2019
Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Published in
Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy / Issue 2/2019
Print ISSN: 1386-7423
Electronic ISSN: 1572-8633
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-018-9860-z

Other articles of this Issue 2/2019

Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 2/2019 Go to the issue