Skip to main content
Top
Published in: European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology 8/2019

01-12-2019 | Osteoarthrosis | Original Article • HIP - ARTHROPLASTY

Comparative outcomes between collared versus collarless and short versus long stem of direct anterior approach total hip arthroplasty: a systematic review and indirect meta-analysis

Authors: Phonthakorn Panichkul, Suthorn Bavonratanavech, Alisara Arirachakaran, Jatupon Kongtharvonskul

Published in: European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology | Issue 8/2019

Login to get access

Abstract

Introduction

Early research shows several advantages of the direct anterior approach (DAA) in THA that claimed to be as effective but less invasive than the posterior approach. However, due to the difficult femoral exposure and possible complications related to femoral preparation, this approach may result in a higher rate of undersized stems when compared to other approaches. The present authors believe that the femoral implant design (collar or collarless stem, short or long stem) in a collared femoral stem may relate to lower rates of stem subsidence and limb length discrepancy (LLD) in mid-term to long-term follow-up when compared to collarless femoral stems. However, currently, there is no consensus as to which femoral implant design is the most suitable for DAA in THA.

Methods

This systematic review and meta-analysis aim to assess and compare postoperative complications (neurapraxia, wound infection, LFCN, hematoma, artery injury, cup malposition, embolism, fracture and implant loosening) and revision rates due to dislocation, periprosthetic fracture and implant migration after DAA using collared compared to collarless femoral stem and short femoral stem compared to long femoral stem in THA. These clinical outcomes consist of the postoperative complications and revision femoral stem due to neurapraxia, wound, LFCN and LLD. This systematic review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines.

Results

Relevant studies that reported postoperative complications and revision of either implant were identified from Medline and Scopus from inception to June 6, 2018. Thirty-four studies were included for the analysis of DAA in THA; 23 studies were retrospective cohorts, four studies were prospective cohorts, and seven studies were RCTs. Thirty-one studies and three studies were included for analysis of collarless and collared femoral stems. Twenty-six studies were long femoral stems and eight studies were short femoral stems. Overall, there were 6825 patients (6457 in the collarless group and 368 in the collared group, 4280 in long stem and 2545 in short stem). A total of 469 and 66 patients had complications and revisions in the collarless group, and no patient had complications and revisions in the collared stem group. The total complication and revision rate per patient were 5% (95%CI 3.3%, 7%) and 0.9% (95%CI 0.6%, 1.2%) in all patients. The complication rate and revision rate were 5.7% (95%CI 3.8%, 7.7%) and 0.9% (95%CI 0.6, 1.2) in the collarless group. There was no prevalence of complications and revisions in the collared stem group. The complication rate and revision rate were 10.2% (95%CI 9%, 11.4%), 0.7% (95%CI 0.3%, 1%) and 5.2% (95%CI 3.1, 7.2), 1.5% (95%CI 1%, 2%) in short and long femoral stems, respectively. Indirect meta-analysis shows that collared femoral stem provided a lower risk of complications of 0.02 (95%CI 0.001, 0.30) when compared to collarless femoral stem. Long femoral stems had a lower risk of having complications of 0.57 (95%CI 0.48, 0.68) when compared to short femoral stems. In terms of revision, there is no statistically significant difference in collared femoral stem compared to collarless femoral stem and long femoral stem compared to short femoral stem.

Conclusion

In DAA THA, collared femoral stem and long femoral stem had decreased complication rates when compared to collarless femoral stem and short femoral stem by both direct and indirect meta-analysis methods. However, in terms of revision rates, there were no differences between all femoral stems (short versus long and collared versus collarless). Prospective randomized controlled studies are needed to confirm these findings as the current literature is still insufficient.
Appendix
Available only for authorised users
Literature
1.
go back to reference Baker AS, Bitounis VC (1989) Abductor function after total hip replacement. An electromyographic and clinical review. J Bone Jt Surg Br 71(1):47–50CrossRef Baker AS, Bitounis VC (1989) Abductor function after total hip replacement. An electromyographic and clinical review. J Bone Jt Surg Br 71(1):47–50CrossRef
5.
11.
go back to reference De Geest T, Vansintjan P, De Loore G (2013) Direct anterior total hip arthroplasty: complications and early outcome in a series of 300 cases. Acta Orthop Belg 79(2):166–173PubMed De Geest T, Vansintjan P, De Loore G (2013) Direct anterior total hip arthroplasty: complications and early outcome in a series of 300 cases. Acta Orthop Belg 79(2):166–173PubMed
16.
go back to reference Fransen B, Hoozemans M, Vos S (2016) Direct anterior approach versus posterolateral approach in total hip arthroplasty: one surgeon, two approaches. Acta Orthop Belg 82(2):240–248PubMed Fransen B, Hoozemans M, Vos S (2016) Direct anterior approach versus posterolateral approach in total hip arthroplasty: one surgeon, two approaches. Acta Orthop Belg 82(2):240–248PubMed
25.
go back to reference Homma Y, Baba T, Kobayashi H, Desroches A, Ozaki Y, Ochi H, Matsumoto M, Yuasa T, Kaneko K (2016) Safety in early experience with a direct anterior approach using fluoroscopic guidance with manual leg control for primary total hip arthroplasty: a consecutive one hundred and twenty case series. Int Orthop 40(12):2487–2494. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-016-3159-6 CrossRefPubMed Homma Y, Baba T, Kobayashi H, Desroches A, Ozaki Y, Ochi H, Matsumoto M, Yuasa T, Kaneko K (2016) Safety in early experience with a direct anterior approach using fluoroscopic guidance with manual leg control for primary total hip arthroplasty: a consecutive one hundred and twenty case series. Int Orthop 40(12):2487–2494. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s00264-016-3159-6 CrossRefPubMed
29.
31.
40.
go back to reference Pogliacomi F, De Filippo M, Paraskevopoulos A, Alesci M, Marenghi P, Ceccarelli F (2012) Mini-incision direct lateral approach versus anterior mini-invasive approach in total hip replacement: results 1 year after surgery. Acta Bio-medica Atenei Parmensis 83(2):114–121PubMed Pogliacomi F, De Filippo M, Paraskevopoulos A, Alesci M, Marenghi P, Ceccarelli F (2012) Mini-incision direct lateral approach versus anterior mini-invasive approach in total hip replacement: results 1 year after surgery. Acta Bio-medica Atenei Parmensis 83(2):114–121PubMed
42.
go back to reference Putananon C, Tuchinda H, Arirachakaran A, Wongsak S, Narinsorasak T, Kongtharvonskul J (2018) Comparison of direct anterior, lateral, posterior and posterior-2 approaches in total hip arthroplasty: network meta-analysis. 28(2):255–267. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00590-017-2046-1 Putananon C, Tuchinda H, Arirachakaran A, Wongsak S, Narinsorasak T, Kongtharvonskul J (2018) Comparison of direct anterior, lateral, posterior and posterior-2 approaches in total hip arthroplasty: network meta-analysis. 28(2):255–267. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s00590-017-2046-1
48.
go back to reference Sendtner E, Borowiak K, Schuster T, Woerner M, Grifka J, Renkawitz T (2011) Tackling the learning curve: comparison between the anterior, minimally invasive (Micro-hip(R)) and the lateral, transgluteal (Bauer) approach for primary total hip replacement. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 131(5):597–602. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00402-010-1174-4 CrossRefPubMed Sendtner E, Borowiak K, Schuster T, Woerner M, Grifka J, Renkawitz T (2011) Tackling the learning curve: comparison between the anterior, minimally invasive (Micro-hip(R)) and the lateral, transgluteal (Bauer) approach for primary total hip replacement. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 131(5):597–602. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s00402-010-1174-4 CrossRefPubMed
55.
go back to reference Thakkinstian A, McEvoy M, Minelli C, Gibson P, Hancox B, Duffy D, Thompson J, Hall I, Kaufman J, Leung TF, Helms PJ, Hakonarson H, Halpi E, Navon R, Attia J (2005) Systematic review and meta-analysis of the association between {beta}2-adrenoceptor polymorphisms and asthma: a HuGE review. Am J Epidemiol 162(3):201–211. https://doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwi184 CrossRefPubMed Thakkinstian A, McEvoy M, Minelli C, Gibson P, Hancox B, Duffy D, Thompson J, Hall I, Kaufman J, Leung TF, Helms PJ, Hakonarson H, Halpi E, Navon R, Attia J (2005) Systematic review and meta-analysis of the association between {beta}2-adrenoceptor polymorphisms and asthma: a HuGE review. Am J Epidemiol 162(3):201–211. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1093/​aje/​kwi184 CrossRefPubMed
59.
go back to reference Watanabe K, Mitsui K, Usuda Y, Nemoto K (2019) An increase in the risk of excessive femoral anteversion for relatively younger age and types of femoral morphology in total hip arthroplasty with direct anterior approach. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong) 27(2):2309499019836816. https://doi.org/10.1177/2309499019836816 CrossRef Watanabe K, Mitsui K, Usuda Y, Nemoto K (2019) An increase in the risk of excessive femoral anteversion for relatively younger age and types of femoral morphology in total hip arthroplasty with direct anterior approach. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong) 27(2):2309499019836816. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1177/​2309499019836816​ CrossRef
61.
go back to reference Weale AE, Newman P, Ferguson IT, Bannister GC (1996) Nerve injury after posterior and direct lateral approaches for hip replacement. A clinical and electrophysiological study. J Bone Jt Surg Br 78(6):899–902CrossRef Weale AE, Newman P, Ferguson IT, Bannister GC (1996) Nerve injury after posterior and direct lateral approaches for hip replacement. A clinical and electrophysiological study. J Bone Jt Surg Br 78(6):899–902CrossRef
63.
go back to reference Witzleb WC, Stephan L, Krummenauer F, Neuke A, Gunther KP (2009) Short-term outcome after posterior versus lateral surgical approach for total hip arthroplasty—a randomized clinical trial. Eur J Med Res 14(6):256–263CrossRef Witzleb WC, Stephan L, Krummenauer F, Neuke A, Gunther KP (2009) Short-term outcome after posterior versus lateral surgical approach for total hip arthroplasty—a randomized clinical trial. Eur J Med Res 14(6):256–263CrossRef
Metadata
Title
Comparative outcomes between collared versus collarless and short versus long stem of direct anterior approach total hip arthroplasty: a systematic review and indirect meta-analysis
Authors
Phonthakorn Panichkul
Suthorn Bavonratanavech
Alisara Arirachakaran
Jatupon Kongtharvonskul
Publication date
01-12-2019
Publisher
Springer Paris
Published in
European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology / Issue 8/2019
Print ISSN: 1633-8065
Electronic ISSN: 1432-1068
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00590-019-02516-1

Other articles of this Issue 8/2019

European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology 8/2019 Go to the issue