Evaluation of tremor interference with control of voluntary reaching movements in patients with Parkinson’s disease

A large population of patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) displays the symptom of resting tremor. However, the extent that resting tremor may affect the performance of movement control has not been evaluated specifically. This study aims at establishing methods to quantitatively evaluate motor performance in PD patients with tremor, and at analyzing the interfering effects of tremor on control of reaching movements.

Ten PD patients with tremor and Ten healthy control subjects were recruited to participate in this study. All patients and healthy control subjects performed point-to-point reaching movements with their tremor affected arm or preferred arm. We verified that a smoothing model of minimum-jerk trajectory (MJT) can be used to extract voluntary movement trajectory from tremor-corrupted movement trajectory in the reaching tasks by the patients. Performance indices of reaction time (RT) and movement time (MT) of reaching movements by the PD subjects with tremor were evaluated using MJT trajectories. Differences of RT and MT between the recorded trajectories and MJT in PD and control subjects were calculated to investigate the extent that tremor may affect their motor performance. Linear mixed-effects model was used to identify the contributions of tremor, bradykinesia and rigidity to the performance indices of RT and MT based on UPDRS scores. The power spectrum densities (PSD) of tremor were also evaluated using hand velocities to represent tremor intensity and to analyze their correlations with RT and MT.

The MJT model demonstrated good fit to recorded trajectory with a more consistent estimation of motor performance for both PD and control subjects. The RT and MT of patients were found to be 43.4 and 79.5% longer respectively than those of healthy control subjects. Analysis of the linear mixed-effects model was not able to reveal that tremor, bradykinesia and rigidity each had a significant contribution to RT or MT in PD patients with tremor. However, the PSD of tremor was found to correlate significantly to RT, but not to MT, in both linear regression and linear mixed-effects model.

The minimum-jerk trajectory and power spectrum densities are effective quantitative tools for evaluating motor performance for PD patients with tremor. Resting tremor is one of the factors prolonging the initiation of voluntary reaching movement in these patients.