Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Journal of Urban Health 3/2020

01-06-2020 | COVID-19

Targeting the World’s Slums as Fat Tails in the Distribution of COVID-19 Cases

Author: Robert M. Buckley

Published in: Journal of Urban Health | Issue 3/2020

Login to get access

Abstract

A recent article by Corburn et al. lays out the policies that would help slum communities in the global south deal with COVID-19. That article notes the vulnerabilities of people in these informal settlements and argues that any assistance program must recognize these realities so that the policies do not further jeopardize the survival of large segments of the population of these communities. This note extends the arguments in that paper, focusing on some of the logistic issues involved in providing assistance to informal settlements. It argues that such assistance is essential not only for the help it would provide to people in these settlements but also because the residents of these communities should be key targets of assistance. Because of the location and occupation of most of the residents of these communities, targeting them simultaneously addresses health and economy-wide concerns generated by COVID-19. Their characteristics make them much more likely to be afflicted by the virus and spread it to others. The main conclusions of this note with respect to policy are that the scale of such assistance is likely to be larger than has so far been proposed, that in countries with limited testing ability slums provide one of the most effective places to target assistance, that the role of community groups in providing the assistance is difficult to exaggerate, and that philanthropy has a role to play in supporting innovation.
Literature
2.
go back to reference According to 24/7 Tempo, 2019, Mumbai’s population density in 2016 was almost three times higher than New York City’s, and the New York Times, Upshot, reported that the city’s density was a primary reason for the high virus infection rate, April 10, 2020. According to 24/7 Tempo, 2019, Mumbai’s population density in 2016 was almost three times higher than New York City’s, and the New York Times, Upshot, reported that the city’s density was a primary reason for the high virus infection rate, April 10, 2020.
3.
go back to reference The Census of India 2011 indicates that 37 percent of Indian urban households live in either one room or without any exclusive rooms, Table s00–0012: the distribution of households by size and number of dwelling units. In Ghana the share of urban households living in one room is almost 60 percent, Table 21, Ghana Housing Profile, UN Habitat, 2011. The Census of India 2011 indicates that 37 percent of Indian urban households live in either one room or without any exclusive rooms, Table s00–0012: the distribution of households by size and number of dwelling units. In Ghana the share of urban households living in one room is almost 60 percent, Table 21, Ghana Housing Profile, UN Habitat, 2011.
4.
go back to reference Job losses in the US In the first month of the current pandemic, 17 million, were double the amount of such losses in the 18 months of the 2008–2010 Great Recession. That recession reduced world GDP by 4 percent, and has had a lasting adverse effect on economic growth for the past decade. For example, in one of their Economic Letters, The San Francisco Federal Reserve estimates that the slower economic growth after the recession has reduced US per capita income by $70,000. See Lansing, K. Gauging the Impact of the Great Recession. July 11, 2011. Job losses in the US In the first month of the current pandemic, 17 million, were double the amount of such losses in the 18 months of the 2008–2010 Great Recession. That recession reduced world GDP by 4 percent, and has had a lasting adverse effect on economic growth for the past decade. For example, in one of their Economic Letters, The San Francisco Federal Reserve estimates that the slower economic growth after the recession has reduced US per capita income by $70,000. See Lansing, K. Gauging the Impact of the Great Recession. July 11, 2011.
5.
go back to reference A recession is at least two quarters of negative economic growth; a depression is marked by more prolonged and more significant reductions in economic growth, lasting for several years. A recession is at least two quarters of negative economic growth; a depression is marked by more prolonged and more significant reductions in economic growth, lasting for several years.
6.
go back to reference World Bank data and the International Monetary Fund. Sub-Saharan Africa Regional Economic Outlook: Navigating Uncertainty; 2019. World Bank data and the International Monetary Fund. Sub-Saharan Africa Regional Economic Outlook: Navigating Uncertainty; 2019.
7.
go back to reference Corburn J, et al. Slum health: arresting COVID-19 and improving well-being in urban informal settlements. J Urban Health. 2010; Corburn J, et al. Slum health: arresting COVID-19 and improving well-being in urban informal settlements. J Urban Health. 2010;
8.
go back to reference McKinsey Institute, Tackling COVID-19 in Africa, April 2020, discusses an apparent reluctance of government officials in Africa to actively prepare for the virus. McKinsey Institute, Tackling COVID-19 in Africa, April 2020, discusses an apparent reluctance of government officials in Africa to actively prepare for the virus.
9.
go back to reference The Economist. “Debt and disease,” April 11-17, 2020. The Economist. “Debt and disease,” April 11-17, 2020.
10.
go back to reference Mulligan, C., K. Murphy, and R. Topol. “Some basic economics of COVID-19 policy,” Chicago Booth Review, the University of Chicago estimate that in an unrestricted pandemic infecting 60 percent of the US population and an infection fatality rate below 1 percent would result in roughly 1.4 million deaths, heavily concentrated among the elderly with a total value of lost lives of about $6 trillion. To make a back of the envelop estimate of the costs for a similar infection rate for slum dwellers we take the following steps: (1) the above assumptions are applied to the one billion slum dwellers, so that 600,000,000 people are affected, (2) we use Stock’s (2020) estimate $9.3 million of the value of statistical life for the U.S. in 2019; and (3) apply Viscusi, K. and J. Aldy 2003. “The Value of a Statistical Life: a Critical Review of Market Estimates throughout the World,”J Risk Uncertain. Springer. 2020;27(1):5–76, August, their estimates of the income elasticity of the value of a statistical life of .5 or .6 to the difference in the per capita income of the U.S. and that of developing and emerging countries, $13,200, we find that the comparable cost estimate for slum dwellers exceeds $20 trillion. Mulligan, C., K. Murphy, and R. Topol. “Some basic economics of COVID-19 policy,” Chicago Booth Review, the University of Chicago estimate that in an unrestricted pandemic infecting 60 percent of the US population and an infection fatality rate below 1 percent would result in roughly 1.4 million deaths, heavily concentrated among the elderly with a total value of lost lives of about $6 trillion. To make a back of the envelop estimate of the costs for a similar infection rate for slum dwellers we take the following steps: (1) the above assumptions are applied to the one billion slum dwellers, so that 600,000,000 people are affected, (2) we use Stock’s (2020) estimate $9.3 million of the value of statistical life for the U.S. in 2019; and (3) apply Viscusi, K. and J. Aldy 2003. “The Value of a Statistical Life: a Critical Review of Market Estimates throughout the World,”J Risk Uncertain. Springer. 2020;27(1):5–76, August, their estimates of the income elasticity of the value of a statistical life of .5 or .6 to the difference in the per capita income of the U.S. and that of developing and emerging countries, $13,200, we find that the comparable cost estimate for slum dwellers exceeds $20 trillion.
11.
go back to reference Romer P. Princeton University Webinar, April 8, 2020 presents the macroeconomic case for fiscal policy. The McKinsey study also forecasts a 2020 drop in per capita income in Africa of as much as 10 percent. That would place the region at its 2008 level. Romer P. Princeton University Webinar, April 8, 2020 presents the macroeconomic case for fiscal policy. The McKinsey study also forecasts a 2020 drop in per capita income in Africa of as much as 10 percent. That would place the region at its 2008 level.
12.
go back to reference Financial Times on-line coronavirus update, April 30, 2020. Financial Times on-line coronavirus update, April 30, 2020.
13.
14.
go back to reference The IMF SUB-SAHARA Africa region report, op cit. 2020. The IMF SUB-SAHARA Africa region report, op cit. 2020.
15.
go back to reference The IMF Director forecasts a global recession in 2020 that will be deeper than the 2008 Great recession. IMF press release, March 23, 2020. The IMF Director forecasts a global recession in 2020 that will be deeper than the 2008 Great recession. IMF press release, March 23, 2020.
16.
go back to reference Eichenbaum M, Rebelo S, Trabandt M. The Macroeconomics of Epidemics. Northwestern University argue that because of the nature of the externalities involved with both consumption and the labor market, that the lack of aggressive early policies can be very costly in lives lost. 2020. Eichenbaum M, Rebelo S, Trabandt M. The Macroeconomics of Epidemics. Northwestern University argue that because of the nature of the externalities involved with both consumption and the labor market, that the lack of aggressive early policies can be very costly in lives lost. 2020.
17.
18.
go back to reference See Jones P, D’Aoust O, Bernard I. The urban wage premium in Africa. Global Research Program on Spatial Development of Cities, funded by the World Bank and supported by the UK Department for International Development, for a review of estimates of the urban wage premium. 2015. See Jones P, D’Aoust O, Bernard I. The urban wage premium in Africa. Global Research Program on Spatial Development of Cities, funded by the World Bank and supported by the UK Department for International Development, for a review of estimates of the urban wage premium. 2015.
19.
go back to reference Many would argue that this amount per day is a paltry sum and it certainly is. However, it exceeds the $1.90 per day figure used as the poverty threshold by 50 percent. Many would argue that this amount per day is a paltry sum and it certainly is. However, it exceeds the $1.90 per day figure used as the poverty threshold by 50 percent.
20.
go back to reference The African Development Bank creates a $10 billion fund for virus aid. Outlook, Abidjan. April 9, 2020 The African Development Bank creates a $10 billion fund for virus aid. Outlook, Abidjan. April 9, 2020
21.
go back to reference New York Times. see also “The World Bank group moves quickly to help countries respond to COVID-19” press release April 2, 2020. 2020. New York Times. see also “The World Bank group moves quickly to help countries respond to COVID-19” press release April 2, 2020. 2020.
22.
23.
go back to reference Assessing the Economic Impact of COVID-19 and Policy Responses in sub-Saharan Africa. World Bank. 2010. Assessing the Economic Impact of COVID-19 and Policy Responses in sub-Saharan Africa. World Bank. 2010.
25.
go back to reference Poorer Nations can’t compete even for Masks. NY Times. 2020. Poorer Nations can’t compete even for Masks. NY Times. 2020.
26.
go back to reference Berger D, Herkenhoff K, Mongey S. An SEIR infectious disease model with testing and conditional quarantine. Duke University economics Dept. find that testing of more than 7 percent of the population is required. 2020. Berger D, Herkenhoff K, Mongey S. An SEIR infectious disease model with testing and conditional quarantine. Duke University economics Dept. find that testing of more than 7 percent of the population is required. 2020.
27.
go back to reference By April 15th after 10 weeks of testing, Iceland had tested 10 percent of its population of 360,000, France 24. By April 15th after 10 weeks of testing, Iceland had tested 10 percent of its population of 360,000, France 24.
28.
go back to reference Stock J. Data gaps and the policy response to the novel coronavirus. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper, 26902 shows that given the considerable uncertainty as to the share of the population that is asymptomatic how high or low rates of such infection affect the optimal policy response. 2020. Stock J. Data gaps and the policy response to the novel coronavirus. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper, 26902 shows that given the considerable uncertainty as to the share of the population that is asymptomatic how high or low rates of such infection affect the optimal policy response. 2020.
29.
go back to reference Zandvoort K, Jarvis C, Pearson C et al. Response strategies for COVID-19 epidemics in African settings: a mathematical modelling study. Working Paper Centre for the Mathimatical Modeling of Infectious Diseases. 2020. Zandvoort K, Jarvis C, Pearson C et al. Response strategies for COVID-19 epidemics in African settings: a mathematical modelling study. Working Paper Centre for the Mathimatical Modeling of Infectious Diseases. 2020.
30.
go back to reference Leung N, Chu D, Shiu E, et al. Respiratory virus shedding in exhaled breath and efficacy of face masks. Nature/Medicine. 2020. Leung N, Chu D, Shiu E, et al. Respiratory virus shedding in exhaled breath and efficacy of face masks. Nature/Medicine. 2020.
32.
go back to reference SDI’s leadership has won numerous awards and honors as well as the support of many foundations and bi-lateral donors. Its leadership has also served as advisors to UN Habitat, the Cities Alliance, and the Governments of India and South Africa among others. SDI’s leadership has won numerous awards and honors as well as the support of many foundations and bi-lateral donors. Its leadership has also served as advisors to UN Habitat, the Cities Alliance, and the Governments of India and South Africa among others.
33.
go back to reference Battling coronavirus: nobel laureates Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo have this advice. Bus Today. 2020. Battling coronavirus: nobel laureates Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo have this advice. Bus Today. 2020.
34.
go back to reference Keynes JM. A treatise on money, reproduced in volume. In: Moggridge, DV, editor. The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes. London: MacMillan; 1930. Keynes JM. A treatise on money, reproduced in volume. In: Moggridge, DV, editor. The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes. London: MacMillan; 1930.
Metadata
Title
Targeting the World’s Slums as Fat Tails in the Distribution of COVID-19 Cases
Author
Robert M. Buckley
Publication date
01-06-2020
Publisher
Springer US
Keyword
COVID-19
Published in
Journal of Urban Health / Issue 3/2020
Print ISSN: 1099-3460
Electronic ISSN: 1468-2869
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11524-020-00450-w

Other articles of this Issue 3/2020

Journal of Urban Health 3/2020 Go to the issue