Skip to main content
Key Specialties
Cardiology Diabetology Endocrinology Gastroenterology Geriatrics and Gerontology Gynecology and Obstetrics Hematology Infectious Disease Internal Medicine Nephrology Neurology Oncology Pediatrics Respiratory Medicine Rheumatology Surgery
Congress Coverage
2024 ACC Congress 2023 ESMO Congress 2023 EASD Congress 2023 ERS Congress 2023 ESC Congress 2023 EHA Congress 2023 ASCO Annual Meeting
Clinical Collections
Advances in Alzheimer’s

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on sleep in brain health

LIVE: Thursday 2nd May 2024, 18:00-19:30 (CEST)

Quality sleep is essential for health. But what happens to our brains when sleep patterns are disturbed? Join our experts to explore the interplay between sleep disruption and neurological diseases, and the questions that you need to be asking your patients to help you prevent the harmful effects of sleep deprivation.
ADVANCED SEARCH
Log in
Top
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
Published in: Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 8/2017

01-08-2017 | Review

Do racial patterns in psychological distress shed light on the Black–White depression paradox? A systematic review

Authors: David M. Barnes, Lisa M. Bates

Published in: Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology | Issue 8/2017

Login to get access

Abstract

Purpose

Major epidemiologic studies in the US reveal a consistent “paradox” by which psychiatric outcomes such as major depressive disorder (MDD) are less prevalent among Blacks relative to Whites, despite greater exposure to social and economic stressors and worse physical health outcomes. A second paradox, which has received less attention and has never been systematically documented, is the discrepancy between these patterns and Black–White comparisons in psychological distress, which reveal consistently higher levels among Blacks. By systematically documenting the latter paradox, this paper seeks to inform efforts to explain the first paradox.

Methods

We conduct a systematic review of the literature estimating the prevalence of MDD and levels of psychological distress in Blacks and Whites in the US.

Results

The literature review yielded 34 articles reporting 54 relevant outcomes overall. Blacks have a lower prevalence of MDD in 8 of the 9 comparisons observed. In contrast, Blacks have higher levels of psychological distress (in terms of “high distress” and mean scores) than Whites in 42 of the 45 comparisons observed. Tests of statistical significance, where available, confirm this discrepant pattern.

Conclusions

A systematic review of the epidemiologic evidence supports the existence of a “double paradox” by which Blacks’ lower prevalence of MDD relative to Whites’ is inconsistent with both the expectations of social stress theory and with the empirical evidence regarding psychological distress. Efforts to resolve the Black–White depression paradox should account for the discordant distress results, which seem to favor artifactual explanations.
Literature
1.
Dressler WW, Oths KS, Gravlee CC (2005) Race and ethnicity in public health research: models to explain health disparities. Annu Rev Anthr 34:231–252CrossRef
2.
Horwitz AV (2002) Outcomes in the sociology of mental health: where have we been and where are we going? J Health Soc Behav 43:143–151PubMedCrossRef
3.
Pearlin LI, Meneghan EG, Lieberman MA, Mullan JT (1981) The stress process. J Health Soc Behav 22:337–356PubMedCrossRef
4.
Schwartz S, Meyer IH (2010) Mental health disparities research: the impact of within and between group analyses on tests of social stress hypotheses. Soc Sci Med 70:1111–1118PubMedCrossRef
5.
Turner RJ (2010) Health disparities and the stress hypothesis: a commentary on Schwartz and Meyer. Soc Sci Med 70:1119–1120PubMedCrossRef
6.
Muntaner C, Ng E, Vanroelen C et al (2013) Social stratification, social closure, and social class as determinants of mental health disparities. In: Aneshensel CS, Phelan JC, Bierman A (eds) The Sociology of Mental Health. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 205–227CrossRef
7.
Williams DR, Yu Y, Jackson JS, Anderson NB (1997) Racial differences in physical and mental health, socio-economic status, stress and discrimination. J Health Psychol 2:335–351PubMedCrossRef
8.
Conley D (1999) Being black, living in the red: race, wealth, and social policy in America. University of California Press, Berkeley
9.
Wilson WJ (2009) More than just race: being black and poor in the inner city. W.W. Norton & Company, New York
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
Neighbors HW, Njai R, Jackson JS (2007) Race, ethnicity, John Henryism, and depressive symptoms: the national survey of American life adult reinterview. Res Hum Dev 4:71–87CrossRef
15.
Sue S, Chu JY (2003) The mental health of ethnic minority groups: challenges posed by the supplement to the Surgeon General’s report on mental health. Cult Med Psychiatry 27:447–465PubMedCrossRef
16.
Mouzon DM (2010) Can social relationships explain the race paradox in mental health?. Rutgers University, Graduate School, New Brunswick
17.
Kiecolt K, Hughes M, Keith VM (2008) Race, social relationships, and mental health. Pers Relatsh 15:229–245CrossRef
18.
Jackson JS, Knight KM, Rafferty JA (2010) Race and unhealthy behaviors: chronic stress, the HPA axis, and physical and mental health disparities over the life course. Am J Public Health 100:933–939PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRef
19.
Breslau J, Javaras KN, Blacker D et al (2008) Differential item functioning between ethnic groups in the epidemiological assessment of depression. J Nerv Ment Dis 196:297–306PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRef
20.
21.
Link B, Dohrenwend BP (1980) Formulation of hypotheses about the true prevalence of demoralization. In: Dohrenwend BP, Dohrenwend BS, Gould MS, Link B, Neugebauer R, Wunsch-Hitzig R (eds) Mental illness in the United States: epidemiological estimates. Praeger Publishers, New York, pp 114–132
22.
Blazer DG (2008) Epidemiology of psychiatric illness. In: Fatemi SH, Clayton PJ (eds) The medical basis of psychiatry. Springer, New York, pp 547–559CrossRef
23.
Rosenfield S, Smith D (2009) Gender and mental health: do men and women have different amounts or types of problems? In: Horwitz AV, Scheid TL (eds) Handbook for the study of mental health: social contexts, theories, and systems. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 256–267CrossRef
24.
Centers for Disease and Control and Prevention (2004) Self-reported frequent mental distress among adults—United States, 1993–2001. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 53(41):963–966
25.
Kessler RC, Neighbors HW (1986) A new perspective on the relationships among race, social class, and psychological distress. J Health Soc Behav 27:107–115PubMedCrossRef
26.
Mehta K, Kramer H, Durazo-Arvizu R et al (2015) Depression in the US population during the time periods surrounding the Great Recession. J Clin Psychiatry 76:e499–e504PubMedCrossRef
27.
28.
Horwitz AV, Wakefield JC (2007) The loss of sadness: how psychiatry transformed normal sorrow into depressive disorder. Oxford University Press, New York
29.
Conway CC, Hammen C, Brennan PA et al (2010) Interaction of chronic stress with serotonin transporter and catechol-O-methyltransferase polymorphisms in predicting youth depression. Depress Anxiety. doi:10.​1002/​da.​20715 PubMedPubMedCentral
30.
Ressler KJ, Bradley B, Mercer KB et al (2009) Polymorphisms in CRHR1 and the serotonin transporter loci: gene × gene × environment interactions on depressive symptoms. Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet. doi:10.​1002/​ajmg.​b.​31052 PubMedCentral
31.
Dodge KA, Rutter M (2011) Gene-environment interactions in developmental psychopathology. Guilford Press, New York
32.
Kilpatrick DG, Koenen KC, Ruggiero KJ et al (2007) The serotonin transporter genotype and social support and moderation of posttraumatic stress disorder and depression in hurricane-exposed adults. Am J Psychiatry 164:1693–1699PubMedCrossRef
33.
34.
Kessler RC, Andrews G, Colpe LJ et al (2002) Short screening scales to monitor population prevalences and trends in non-specific pscyhological distress. Psychol Med 32:959–976PubMedCrossRef
35.
Dohrenwend BP, Shrout PE, Egri G, Mendelsohn FS (1980) Nonspecific psychological distress and other dimensions of psychopathology: measures for use in the general population. Arch Gen Psychiatry 37:1229PubMedCrossRef
36.
Andrews G, Slade T (2001) Interpreting scores on the Kessler psychological distress scale (K10). Aust N Z J Public Health 25:494–497PubMedCrossRef
37.
Fechner-Bates S, Coyne JC, Schwenk TL (1994) The relationship of self-reported distress to depressive disorders and other psychopathology. J Consult Clin Psychol 62:550PubMedCrossRef
38.
39.
Brown TN (2003) Critical race theory speaks to the sociology of mental health: mental health problems produced by racial stratification. J Health Soc Behav 44:292–301PubMedCrossRef
40.
41.
42.
Somervell PD, Leaf PJ, Weissman MM et al (1989) The prevalence of major depression in black and white adults in five United States communities. Am J Epidemiol 130:725–735PubMedCrossRef
43.
Vega WA, Rumbaut RG (1991) Ethnic minorities and mental health. Annu Rev Sociol 17:351–383CrossRef
44.
45.
Thompson R, Bogner HR, Coyne JC et al (2004) Personal characteristics associated with consistency of recall of depressed or anhedonic mood in the 13-year follow-up of the Baltimore Epidemiologic Catchment Area Survey. Acta Psychiatr Scand 109:345–354PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRef
46.
Aneshensel CS, Estrada AL, Hansell MJ, Clark VA (1987) Social psychological aspects of reporting behavior: lifetime depressive episode reports. J Health Soc Behav 28:232–246PubMedCrossRef
47.
Dohrenwend BP (2000) The role of adversity and stress in psychopathology: some evidence and its implications for theory and research. J Health Soc Behav 41:1–19PubMedCrossRef
48.
Monroe SM, Slavich GM, Georgiades K (2009) The social environment and life stress in depression. In: Gotlib IH, Hammen CL (eds) Handbook of depression. The Guilford Press, New York, pp 340–360
49.
Shrout PE, Link BG, Dohrenwend BP et al (1989) Characterizing life events as risk factors for depression: the role of fateful loss events. J Abnorm Psychol 98:460PubMedCrossRef
50.
Turner RJ, Lloyd DA (2004) Stress burden and the lifetime incidence of psychiatric disorder in young adults: racial and ethnic contrasts. Arch Gen Psychiatry 61:481PubMedCrossRef
51.
52.
Blazer DG, Kessler RC (1994) The prevalence and distribution of major depression in a national community sample: the National Comorbidity Survey. Age Years 15:24–27
53.
54.
Compton W, Conway K, Stinson F, Grant B (2006) Changes in the prevalence of major depression and comorbid substance use disorders in the United States between 1991–1992 and 2001–2002. Am J Psychiatry 163:2141–2147PubMedCrossRef
55.
Hasin DS, Goodwin RD, Stinson FS, Grant BF (2005) Epidemiology of major depressive disorder: results from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcoholism and Related Conditions. Arch Gen Psychiatry 62:1097–1106PubMedCrossRef
56.
Regier DA, Farmer ME, Rae DS et al (1993) One-month prevalence of mental disorders in the United States and sociodemographic characteristics: the epidemiologic catchment area study. Acta Psychiatr Scand 88:35–47PubMedCrossRef
57.
Weissman MM, Bruce ML, Leaf PJ et al (1991) Affective disorders. In: Robbins L, Regier DA (eds) Psychiatric disorders in America. Simon and Schuster, New York, pp 53–80
58.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (2001) Mental health: culture, race, and ethnicity—a supplement to mental health: a report of the surgeon general. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Center for Mental Health Services, Rockville, MD
59.
Bratter JL, Eschbach K (2005) Race/ethnic differences in nonspecific psychological distress: evidence from the national health interview survey*. Soc Sci Q 86:620–644CrossRef
60.
Centers for Disease and Control and Prevention (2010) Current depression among adults—United States, 2006 and 2008. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 59:1229–1235
61.
Chowdhury PP, Balluz L, Strine TW (2008) Health-related quality of life among minority populations in the United States, BRFSS 2001–2002. Ethn Dis 18:483–487PubMed
62.
Dey AN, Lucas JW (2006) Physical and mental health characteristics of US-and foreign-born adults, United States, 1998–2003. Adv Data Vital Health Stat CDC 369:1–20
63.
Eaton W, Kessler LG (1981) Rates of symptoms of depression in a national sample. Am J Epidemiol 114:528–538PubMedCrossRef
64.
Fiscella K, Franks P (1997) Does psychological distress contribute to racial and socio-economic disparities in mortality? Soc Sci Med 45:1805–1809PubMedCrossRef
65.
Fleischman JA (2007) Measurement equivalence for three mental health status measures. Department of Health and Human Services, Peachtree City, pp 55–62
66.
Harris KM, Edlund MJ, Larson S (2005) Racial and ethnic differences in the mental health problems and use of mental health care. Med Care 43:775–784PubMedCrossRef
67.
68.
69.
Mellinger GD, Balter MB, Manheimer DI et al (1978) Psychic distress, life crisis, and use of psychotherapeutic medications: national household survey data. Arch Gen Psychiatry 35:1045–1052PubMedCrossRef
70.
Mukherjee S (2013) Comparing adult males and females in the United States to examine the association between body mass index and frequent mental distress: an analysis of data from BRFSS 2011. Psychiatry J 2013:1–11. doi:10.​1155/​2013/​230928 CrossRef
71.
Mulia N, Ye Y, Zemore SE, Greenfield TK (2008) Social disadvantage, stress, and alcohol use among black, Hispanic, and white Americans: findings from the 2005 US National Alcohol Survey. J Stud Alcohol Drugs 69:824PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRef
72.
Nuru-Jeter A, Williams CT, LaVeist TA (2008) A methodological note on modeling the effects of race: the case of psychological distress. Stress Health 24:337–350. doi:10.​1002/​smi.​1215 CrossRef
73.
74.
75.
Reeves WC, Strine TW, Pratt LA et al (2011) Mental illness surveillance among adults in the United States. MMWR Suppl 60:1–29PubMed
76.
77.
Wu L-T, Anthony JC (2000) The estimated rate of depressed mood in US adults: recent evidence for a peak in later life. J Affect Disord 60:159–171PubMedCrossRef
78.
Zahran HS, Kobau R, Moriarty DG et al (2005) Health-related quality of life surveillance—United States, 1993–2002. MMWR Surveill Summ 54:1–35PubMed
79.
80.
Li C-M, Zhang X, Hoffman HJ et al (2014) Hearing impairment associated with depression in US adults, National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2005–2010. JAMA Otolaryngol Neck Surg 140:293. doi:10.​1001/​jamaoto.​2014.​42 CrossRef
81.
82.
Breslau J, Kendler KS, Su M et al (2005) Lifetime risk and persistence of psychiatric disorders across ethnic groups in the United States. Psychol Med 35:317–327PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRef
83.
Williams DR, Gonzalez HM, Neighbors H et al (2007) Prevalence and distribution of major depressive disorder in African Americans, Caribbean blacks, and non-Hispanic whites: results from the National Survey of American Life. Arch Gen Psychiatry 64:305PubMedCrossRef
84.
Wang PS, Lane M, Olfson M et al (2005) Twelve-month use of mental health services in the United States: results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch Gen Psychiatry 62:629–640PubMedCrossRef
85.
Wang PS, Berglund P, Olfson M et al (2005) Failure and delay in initial treatment contact after first onset of mental disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch Gen Psychiatry 62:603–613PubMedCrossRef
86.
Keyes CLM (2009) The black–white paradox in health: flourishing in the face of social inequality and discrimination. J Pers 77:1677–1706PubMedCrossRef
87.
Mays VM, Cochran SD, Ponce NA (2004) Thinking about race and ethnicity in population-based studies of health. In: Beech BM, Goodman M (eds) Race and research: perspectives on minority participation in health studies. American Public Health Association, Washington, DC, pp 79–100
88.
Williams DR, Harris-Reid M (1999) Race and mental health: emerging patterns and promising approaches. In: Horwitz AV, Scheid TL (eds) Handbook for the study of mental health: social contexts, theories, and systems. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 295–314
89.
90.
Alegria M, McGuire T (2003) Rethinking a universal framework in the psychiatric symptom-disorder relationship. J Health Soc Behav 44:257–274PubMedCrossRef
91.
Breslau J, Aguilar-Gaxiola S, Kendler KS et al (2006) Specifying race-ethnic differences in risk for psychiatric disorder in a US national sample. Psychol Med 36:57–68PubMedCrossRef
92.
Mezuk B, Rafferty JA, Kershaw KN et al (2010) Reconsidering the role of social disadvantage in physical and mental health: stressful life events, health behaviors, race, and depression. Am J Epidemiol 172:1238–1249PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRef
93.
Keyes KM, Barnes DM, Bates LM (2011) Stress, coping, and depression: testing a new hypothesis in a prospectively studied general population sample of U.S.-born whites and blacks. Soc Sci Med 72:650–659PubMedCrossRef
94.
Courtenay WH (2000) Constructions of masculinity and their influence on men’s well-being: a theory of gender and health. Soc Sci Med 50:1385–1401PubMedCrossRef
95.
96.
Cadoret RJ, Wilson D (1983) Somatization among depressed patients in industrialized nations. Am J Psychiatry 140:1103–1104PubMedCrossRef
97.
98.
Kirmayer LJ, Robbins JM, Dworkind M, Yaffe MJ (1993) Somatization and the recognition of depression and anxiety in primary care. Am J Pyschiatry 150:734–741CrossRef
99.
Lehmann HE (1959) Psychiatric concepts of depression: nomenclature and classification. Can Psychiatr Assoc J 4:1–12PubMedCrossRef
100.
Simon GE, VonKorff M, Piccinelli M et al (1999) An international study of the relation between somatic symptoms and depression. N Engl J Med 341:1329–1335PubMedCrossRef
101.
102.
Baker FM (2001) Diagnosing depression in African Americans. Commun Ment Health J 37:31–38CrossRef
103.
Carter JH (1974) Recognizing psychiatric symptoms in black Americans. Geriatrics 29:95–99PubMed
104.
Das AK, Olfson M, McCurtis HL, Weissman MM (2006) Depression in African Americans: breaking barriers to detection and treatment. J Fam Pract 55:30PubMed
105.
Fabrega H Jr, Mezzich J, Ulrich RF (1988) Black–White differences in psychopathology in an urban psychiatric population. Compr Psychiatry 29:285–297PubMedCrossRef
106.
107.
Hasin DS, Stinson FS, Ogburn E, Grant BF (2007) Prevalence, correlates, disability, and comorbidity of DSM-IV alcohol abuse and dependence in the United States. Arch Gen Psychiatry 64(7):830–842PubMedCrossRef
Metadata
Title
Do racial patterns in psychological distress shed light on the Black–White depression paradox? A systematic review
Authors
David M. Barnes
Lisa M. Bates
Publication date
01-08-2017
Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Published in
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology / Issue 8/2017
Print ISSN: 0933-7954
Electronic ISSN: 1433-9285
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-017-1394-9

Other articles of this Issue 8/2017

Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 8/2017 Go to the issue

Original Paper

Risk factors of coercion among psychiatric inpatients: a nationwide register-based cohort study

Original Paper

Proximity to healthcare clinic and depression risk in South Africa: geospatial evidence from a nationally representative longitudinal study

Original Paper

The Social Aptitudes Scale: looking at both “ends” of the social functioning dimension

Study Protocols and Samples

The Lausanne–Geneva cohort study of offspring of parents with mood disorders: methodology, findings, current sample characteristics, and perspectives

Original Paper

Socioeconomic inequalities in treatment of individuals with common mental disorders regarding subsequent development of mental illness

Original Paper

Trends in non-help-seeking for mental disorders in Germany between 1997–1999 and 2009–2012: a repeated cross-sectional study