Top

Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy

Published in:

01-12-2015 | Knee

Cartilage failures. Systematic literature review, critical survey analysis, and definition

Authors: Giuseppe Filardo, Luca Andriolo, Federica Balboni, Maurilio Marcacci, Elizaveta Kon

Published in: Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy | Issue 12/2015

Abstract

Purpose

While midterm results of matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation (MACT) are now available, less attention has been paid to the evaluation of failures of this surgical approach. Aim of this study was to analyse how “failures” are generally defined in cartilage surgery, in order to understand how the survival rate may change according to different definitions of failure.

Methods

A systematic review on MACT in the knee was conducted to report failure rates as well as different failure definitions in the available literature. Afterwards, we analysed the survival curve at 8.5-year follow-up of a survey of 193 patients treated with MACT. Using different definitions to identify failures, we compared how the survival rate changed according to the different definitions of failure.

Results

The systematic review on 93 papers showed that the average failure rate reported on 3,289 patients was 5.2 % at a mean 34 months of follow-up. However, 41 studies (44.1 %) did not even consider this aspect, and failures were variously defined, thus generating confusing data that make a meta-analysis or a study comparison meaningless. The failure analysis of the MACT survey showed that the survival curve changed significantly depending on the definition applied; in fact, the failure rate ranged from 3.6 to 33.7 %. According to a critical literature and survey analysis, we proposed a combined surgical- and improvement-based definition which led to a failure rate of 25.9 % at midterm/long-term follow-up.

Conclusion

Nowadays, failure definitions of cartilage treatments differ in scientific articles, thus generating confusion and heterogeneous data even when applied to the same cohort of patients. While the literature analysis shows a low number of failures, this study demonstrated that if properly addressed with a comprehensive definition, the real failure rate of cartilage surgical procedures in the knee is higher than previously reported. Recognizing failures would give a better understanding and a more realistic prognosis to patients and physicians seeking treatment for cartilage lesions.

Level of evidence

IV.

Adachi N, Ochi M, Deie M, Nakamae A, Kamei G, Uchio Y, Iwasa J (2013) Implantation of tissue-engineered cartilage-like tissue for the treatment for full-thickness cartilage defects of the knee. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 22(6):1241–1248PubMedCrossRef

Bauer S, Khan RJ, Ebert JR, Robertson WB, Breidahl W, Ackland TR, Wood DJ (2012) Knee joint preservation with combined neutralising high tibial osteotomy (HTO) and matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI) in younger patients with medial knee osteoarthritis: a case series with prospective clinical and MRI follow-up over 5 years. Knee 19(4):431–439PubMedCrossRef

Behrens P, Bitter T, Kurz B, Russlies M (2006) Matrix-associated autologous chondrocyte transplantation/implantation (MACT/MACI)–5-year follow-up. Knee 13(3):194–202PubMedCrossRef

Brittberg M, Lindahl A, Nilsson A, Ohlsson C, Isaksson O, Peterson L (1994) Treatment of deep cartilage defects in the knee with autologous chondrocyte transplantation. N Engl J Med 331(14):889–895PubMedCrossRef

Della Villa S, Kon E, Filardo G, Ricci M, Vincentelli F, Delcogliano M, Marcacci M (2010) Does intensive rehabilitation permit early return to sport without compromising the clinical outcome after arthroscopic autologous chondrocyte implantation in highly competitive athletes? Am J Sports Med 38(1):68–77PubMedCrossRef

Dozin B, Malpeli M, Cancedda R, Bruzzi P, Calcagno S, Molfetta L, Priano F, Kon E, Marcacci M (2005) Comparative evaluation of autologous chondrocyte implantation and mosaicplasty: a multicentered randomized clinical trial. Clin J Sport Med 15(4):220–226PubMedCrossRef

Ebert JR, Fallon M, Ackland TR, Wood DJ, Janes GC (2012) Arthroscopic matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation: 2-year outcomes. Arthroscopy 28 (7):952–964 e951–e952

Ebert JR, Fallon M, Zheng MH, Wood DJ, Ackland TR (2012) A randomized trial comparing accelerated and traditional approaches to postoperative weightbearing rehabilitation after matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation: findings at 5 years. Am J Sports Med 40(7):1527–1537PubMedCrossRef

Ebert JR, Robertson WB, Lloyd DG, Zheng MH, Wood DJ, Ackland T (2008) Traditional vs accelerated approaches to post-operative rehabilitation following matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI): comparison of clinical, biomechanical and radiographic outcomes. Osteoarthr Cartil 16(10):1131–1140PubMedCrossRef

10.

Ebert JR, Robertson WB, Woodhouse J, Fallon M, Zheng MH, Ackland T, Wood DJ (2011) Clinical and magnetic resonance imaging-based outcomes to 5 years after matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation to address articular cartilage defects in the knee. Am J Sports Med 39(4):753–763PubMedCrossRef

11.

Ebert JR, Smith A, Edwards PK, Hambly K, Wood DJ, Ackland TR (2013) Factors predictive of outcome 5 years after matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation in the tibiofemoral joint. Am J Sports Med 41(6):1245–1254PubMedCrossRef

12.

Erggelet C, Kreuz PC, Mrosek EH, Schagemann JC, Lahm A, Ducommun PP, Ossendorf C (2010) Autologous chondrocyte implantation versus ACI using 3D-bioresorbable graft for the treatment of large full-thickness cartilage lesions of the knee. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 130(8):957–964PubMedCrossRef

13.

Ferruzzi A, Buda R, Faldini C, Vannini F, Di Caprio F, Luciani D, Giannini S (2008) Autologous chondrocyte implantation in the knee joint: open compared with arthroscopic technique. Comparison at a minimum follow-up of five years. J Bone Joint Surg Am 90(Suppl 4):90–101PubMedCrossRef

14.

Filardo G, Kon E, Andriolo L, Di Martino A, Zaffagnini S, Marcacci M (2014) Treatment of “patellofemoral” cartilage lesions with matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation: a comparison of patellar and trochlear lesions. Am J Sports Med 42(3):626–634PubMedCrossRef

15.

Filardo G, Kon E, Andriolo L, Di Matteo B, Balboni F, Marcacci M (2014) Clinical profiling in cartilage regeneration: prognostic factors for midterm results of matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation. Am J Sports Med 42(4):898–905PubMedCrossRef

16.

Filardo G, Kon E, Andriolo L, Vannini F, Buda R, Ferruzzi A, Giannini S, Marcacci M (2013) Does patient sex influence cartilage surgery outcome? Analysis of results at 5-year follow-up in a large cohort of patients treated with matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation. Am J Sports Med 41(8):1827–1834PubMedCrossRef

17.

Filardo G, Kon E, Berruto M, Di Martino A, Patella S, Marcheggiani Muccioli GM, Zaffagnini S, Marcacci M (2012) Arthroscopic second generation autologous chondrocytes implantation associated with bone grafting for the treatment of knee osteochondritis dissecans: results at 6 years. Knee 19(5):658–663PubMedCrossRef

18.

Filardo G, Kon E, Di Martino A, Iacono F, Marcacci M (2011) Arthroscopic second-generation autologous chondrocyte implantation: a prospective 7-year follow-up study. Am J Sports Med 39(10):2153–2160PubMedCrossRef

19.

Filardo G, Kon E, Di Martino A, Patella S, Altadonna G, Balboni F, Bragonzoni L, Visani A, Marcacci M (2012) Second-generation arthroscopic autologous chondrocyte implantation for the treatment of degenerative cartilage lesions. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 20(9):1704–1713PubMedCrossRef

20.

Filardo G, Kon E, Roffi A, Di Martino A, Marcacci M (2013) Scaffold-based repair for cartilage healing: a systematic review and technical note. Arthroscopy 29(1):174–186PubMedCrossRef

21.

Filardo G, Vannini F, Marcacci M, Andriolo L, Ferruzzi A, Giannini S, Kon E (2013) Matrix-assisted autologous chondrocyte transplantation for cartilage regeneration in osteoarthritic knees: results and failures at midterm follow-up. Am J Sports Med 41(1):95–100PubMedCrossRef

22.

Gobbi A, Kon E, Berruto M, Filardo G, Delcogliano M, Boldrini L, Bathan L, Marcacci M (2009) Patellofemoral full-thickness chondral defects treated with second-generation autologous chondrocyte implantation: results at 5 years’ follow-up. Am J Sports Med 37(6):1083–1092PubMedCrossRef

23.

Harris JD, Siston RA, Brophy RH, Lattermann C, Carey JL, Flanigan DC (2011) Failures, re-operations, and complications after autologous chondrocyte implantation–a systematic review. Osteoarthr Cartil 19(7):779–791PubMedCrossRef

24.

International Cartilage Repair Society (ICRS) (2002) Cartilage Injury Evaluation Package: 2000. Available at: http://www.cartilage.org/_files/contentmanagement/ICRS_evaluation.pdf

25.

Irrgang JJ, Anderson AF, Boland AL, Harner CD, Neyret P, Richmond JC, Shelbourne KD (2006) Responsiveness of the international knee documentation committee subjective knee form. Am J Sports Med 34(10):1567–1573PubMedCrossRef

26.

Jungmann PM, Salzmann GM, Schmal H, Pestka JM, Sudkamp NP, Niemeyer P (2012) Autologous chondrocyte implantation for treatment of cartilage defects of the knee: what predicts the need for reintervention? Am J Sports Med 40(1):58–67PubMedCrossRef

27.

Kon E, Di Martino A, Filardo G, Tetta C, Busacca M, Iacono F, Delcogliano M, Albisinni U, Marcacci M (2011) Second-generation autologous chondrocyte transplantation: MRI findings and clinical correlations at a minimum 5-year follow-up. Eur J Radiol 79(3):382–388PubMedCrossRef

28.

Kon E, Filardo G, Berruto M, Benazzo F, Zanon G, Della Villa S, Marcacci M (2011) Articular cartilage treatment in high-level male soccer players: a prospective comparative study of arthroscopic second-generation autologous chondrocyte implantation versus microfracture. Am J Sports Med 39(12):2549–2557PubMedCrossRef

29.

Kon E, Filardo G, Condello V, Collarile M, Di Martino A, Zorzi C, Marcacci M (2011) Second-generation autologous chondrocyte implantation: results in patients older than 40 years. Am J Sports Med 39(8):1668–1675PubMedCrossRef

30.

Kon E, Filardo G, Di Martino A, Marcacci M (2012) ACI and MACI. J Knee Surg 25(1):17–22PubMedCrossRef

31.

Kon E, Gobbi A, Filardo G, Delcogliano M, Zaffagnini S, Marcacci M (2009) Arthroscopic second-generation autologous chondrocyte implantation compared with microfracture for chondral lesions of the knee: prospective nonrandomized study at 5 years. Am J Sports Med 37(1):33–41PubMedCrossRef

32.

Konst YE, Benink RJ, Veldstra R, van der Krieke TJ, Helder MN, van Royen BJ (2012) Treatment of severe osteochondral defects of the knee by combined autologous bone grafting and autologous chondrocyte implantation using fibrin gel. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 20(11):2263–2269PubMedCentralPubMedCrossRef

33.

Kreuz PC, Muller S, Erggelet C, von Keudell A, Tischer T, Kaps C, Niemeyer P, Hirschmuller A (2014) Is gender influencing the biomechanical results after autologous chondrocyte implantation? Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 22(1):72–79PubMedCrossRef

34.

Kreuz PC, Muller S, Freymann U, Erggelet C, Niemeyer P, Kaps C, Hirschmuller A (2011) Repair of focal cartilage defects with scaffold-assisted autologous chondrocyte grafts: clinical and biomechanical results 48 months after transplantation. Am J Sports Med 39(8):1697–1705PubMedCrossRef

35.

Kreuz PC, Muller S, Ossendorf C, Kaps C, Erggelet C (2009) Treatment of focal degenerative cartilage defects with polymer-based autologous chondrocyte grafts: four-year clinical results. Arthr Res Ther 11(2):R33CrossRef

36.

Macmull S, Parratt MT, Bentley G, Skinner JA, Carrington RW, Morris T, Briggs TW (2011) Autologous chondrocyte implantation in the adolescent knee. Am J Sports Med 39(8):1723–1730PubMedCrossRef

37.

Marcacci M, Berruto M, Brocchetta D, Delcogliano A, Ghinelli D, Gobbi A, Kon E, Pederzini L, Rosa D, Sacchetti GL, Stefani G, Zanasi S (2005) Articular cartilage engineering with Hyalograft C: 3-year clinical results. Clin Orthop Relat Res 435:96–105PubMedCrossRef

38.

Marlovits S, Aldrian S, Wondrasch B, Zak L, Albrecht C, Welsch G, Trattnig S (2012) Clinical and radiological outcomes 5 years after matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation in patients with symptomatic, traumatic chondral defects. Am J Sports Med 40(10):2273–2280PubMedCrossRef

39.

Marlovits S, Striessnig G, Kutscha-Lissberg F, Resinger C, Aldrian SM, Vecsei V, Trattnig S (2005) Early postoperative adherence of matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation for the treatment of full-thickness cartilage defects of the femoral condyle. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 13(6):451–457PubMedCrossRef

40.

Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ 339:b2535PubMedCentralPubMedCrossRef

41.

Nehrer S, Dorotka R, Domayer S, Stelzeneder D, Kotz R (2009) Treatment of full-thickness chondral defects with hyalograft C in the knee: a prospective clinical case series with 2 to 7 years’ follow-up. Am J Sports Med 37(Suppl 1):81S–87SPubMedCrossRef

42.

Niemeyer P, Pestka JM, Kreuz PC, Erggelet C, Schmal H, Suedkamp NP, Steinwachs M (2008) Characteristic complications after autologous chondrocyte implantation for cartilage defects of the knee joint. Am J Sports Med 36(11):2091–2099PubMedCrossRef

43.

Niemeyer P, Steinwachs M, Erggelet C, Kreuz PC, Kraft N, Kostler W, Mehlhorn A, Sudkamp NP (2008) Autologous chondrocyte implantation for the treatment of retropatellar cartilage defects: clinical results referred to defect localisation. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 128(11):1223–1231PubMedCrossRef

44.

Niethammer TR, Pietschmann MF, Horng A, Rossbach BP, Ficklscherer A, Jansson V, Muller PE (2013) Graft hypertrophy of matrix-based autologous chondrocyte implantation: a two-year follow-up study of NOVOCART 3D implantation in the knee. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 22(6):1329–1336PubMedCrossRef

45.

Pavesio A, Abatangelo G, Borrione A, Brocchetta D, Hollander AP, Kon E, Torasso F, Zanasi S, Marcacci M (2003) Hyaluronan-based scaffolds (Hyalograft C) in the treatment of knee cartilage defects: preliminary clinical findings. Novartis Found Symp 249:203–217PubMedCrossRef

46.

Peterson L, Vasiliadis HS, Brittberg M, Lindahl A (2010) Autologous chondrocyte implantation: a long-term follow-up. Am J Sports Med 38(6):1117–1124PubMedCrossRef

47.

Pietschmann MF, Horng A, Niethammer T, Pagenstert I, Sievers B, Jansson V, Glaser C, Muller PE (2009) Cell quality affects clinical outcome after MACI procedure for cartilage injury of the knee. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 17(11):1305–1311PubMedCrossRef

48.

Tohyama H, Yasuda K, Minami A, Majima T, Iwasaki N, Muneta T, Sekiya I, Yagishita K, Takahashi S, Kurokouchi K, Uchio Y, Iwasa J, Deie M, Adachi N, Sugawara K, Ochi M (2009) Atelocollagen-associated autologous chondrocyte implantation for the repair of chondral defects of the knee: a prospective multicenter clinical trial in Japan. J Orthop Sci 14(5):579–588PubMedCrossRef

49.

Trattnig S, Ba-Ssalamah A, Pinker K, Plank C, Vecsei V, Marlovits S (2005) Matrix-based autologous chondrocyte implantation for cartilage repair: noninvasive monitoring by high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 23(7):779–787PubMedCrossRef

50.

Vasiliadis HS, Danielson B, Ljungberg M, McKeon B, Lindahl A, Peterson L (2010) Autologous chondrocyte implantation in cartilage lesions of the knee: long-term evaluation with magnetic resonance imaging and delayed gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging technique. Am J Sports Med 38(5):943–949PubMedCrossRef

51.

Vijayan S, Bartlett W, Bentley G, Carrington RW, Skinner JA, Pollock RC, Alorjani M, Briggs TW (2012) Autologous chondrocyte implantation for osteochondral lesions in the knee using a bilayer collagen membrane and bone graft: a two- to eight-year follow-up study. J Bone Joint Surg Br 94(4):488–492PubMedCrossRef

52.

Welsch GH, Mamisch TC, Zak L, Blanke M, Olk A, Marlovits S, Trattnig S (2010) Evaluation of cartilage repair tissue after matrix-associated autologous chondrocyte transplantation using a hyaluronic-based or a collagen-based scaffold with morphological MOCART scoring and biochemical T2 mapping: preliminary results. Am J Sports Med 38(5):934–942PubMedCrossRef

53.

Zak L, Aldrian S, Wondrasch B, Albrecht C, Marlovits S (2012) Ability to return to sports 5 years after matrix-associated autologous chondrocyte transplantation in an average population of active patients. Am J Sports Med 40(12):2815–2821PubMedCrossRef

54.

Zaslav K, Cole B, Brewster R, DeBerardino T, Farr J, Fowler P, Nissen C (2009) A prospective study of autologous chondrocyte implantation in patients with failed prior treatment for articular cartilage defect of the knee: results of the study of the treatment of articular repair (STAR) clinical trial. Am J Sports Med 37(1):42–55PubMedCrossRef

Title: Cartilage failures. Systematic literature review, critical survey analysis, and definition
Authors: Giuseppe Filardo
Luca Andriolo
Federica Balboni
Maurilio Marcacci
Elizaveta Kon
Publication date: 01-12-2015
Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Published in: Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy / Issue 12/2015
Print ISSN: 0942-2056
Electronic ISSN: 1433-7347
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-014-3272-2

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on medication adherence

Springer Medicine

Cartilage failures. Systematic literature review, critical survey analysis, and definition

Abstract

Purpose

Methods

Results

Conclusion

Level of evidence

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on medication adherence

Springer Medicine

Abstract

Purpose

Methods

Results

Conclusion

Level of evidence

Please log in to get access to this content

Other articles of this Issue 12/2015

Biomechanical comparison of three methods for distal Achilles tendon reconstruction

Posterior lateral meniscal root tear due to a malpositioned double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction tibial tunnel

Predictive parameters for return to pre-injury level of sport 6 months following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery

Combined anterior and rotational laxity measurements allow characterizing personal knee laxity profiles in healthy individuals

Improving tibial component alignment in total knee arthroplasty

Does flexible tunnel drilling affect the femoral tunnel angle measurement after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction?