Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4/2017

01-12-2017 | Short Communication

Understanding patient needs without understanding the patient: the need for complementary use of professional interpreters in end-of-life care

Authors: Demi Krystallidou, Ignaas Devisch, Dominique Van de Velde, Peter Pype

Published in: Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy | Issue 4/2017

Login to get access

Abstract

High-quality doctor-patient communication in end-of-life care results in better quality of life for patients. In linguistically and culturally diverse societies, language discordant consultations become daily practice, leading to difficulties in eliciting patient preferences toward end-of-life care. Although family members invariably act as informal interpreters, this may cause some ethical dilemmas. We present a case of a palliative patient whose son acted as an interpreter. This case generated a triple- layered ethical dilemma: (i) how to safeguard patient autonomy against paternalistic interventions by family members, (ii) how to respect the relational context in which patient autonomy can be realized, and (iii) how to respect the ethno-cultural values of the patient and his family. These issues are being discussed and reflected upon within the framework shared decision making involving informal- and professional interpreters. The complementary use of professional interpreters next to family members acting as informal interpreters is recommended.
Literature
go back to reference Angelelli, C.V. 2004. Medical interpreting and cross-cultural communication. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRef Angelelli, C.V. 2004. Medical interpreting and cross-cultural communication. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRef
go back to reference Bauer, A.M., and Margarita Alegria. 2010. Impact of patient language proficiency and interpreter service use on the quality of psychiatric care: A systematic review. Psychiatric Services 61 (8): 765–773.CrossRef Bauer, A.M., and Margarita Alegria. 2010. Impact of patient language proficiency and interpreter service use on the quality of psychiatric care: A systematic review. Psychiatric Services 61 (8): 765–773.CrossRef
go back to reference Benkel, Inger, H. Wijk, and U. Molander. 2009. Family and friends provide most social support for the bereaved. Palliative Medicine 23 (2): 141–149.CrossRef Benkel, Inger, H. Wijk, and U. Molander. 2009. Family and friends provide most social support for the bereaved. Palliative Medicine 23 (2): 141–149.CrossRef
go back to reference Bischoff, Alexander, Thomas V. Perneger, Patrick A. Bovier, Louis Loutan, and Hans Stalder. 2003. Improving communication between physicians and patients who speak a foreign language. The British Journal of General Practice 53: 541–546. Bischoff, Alexander, Thomas V. Perneger, Patrick A. Bovier, Louis Loutan, and Hans Stalder. 2003. Improving communication between physicians and patients who speak a foreign language. The British Journal of General Practice 53: 541–546.
go back to reference Black, Jill D., and Larry D. Purnell. 2002. Cultural competence for the physical therapy professional. Journal of Physical Therapy Education 16 (1): 3–10. Black, Jill D., and Larry D. Purnell. 2002. Cultural competence for the physical therapy professional. Journal of Physical Therapy Education 16 (1): 3–10.
go back to reference Butow, Phyllis N., Elizabeth Lobb, Michael Jefford, David Goldstein, Maurice Eisenbruch, Afaf Girgis, Madeleine King, Ming Sze, Lynley Aldridge, and Penelope Schofield. 2012. A bridge between cultures: Interpreters’ perspectives of consultations with migrant oncology patients. Supportive Care in Cancer 20 (2): 235–244.CrossRef Butow, Phyllis N., Elizabeth Lobb, Michael Jefford, David Goldstein, Maurice Eisenbruch, Afaf Girgis, Madeleine King, Ming Sze, Lynley Aldridge, and Penelope Schofield. 2012. A bridge between cultures: Interpreters’ perspectives of consultations with migrant oncology patients. Supportive Care in Cancer 20 (2): 235–244.CrossRef
go back to reference Butow, N. Phyllis, Ming Sze, Maurice Eisenbruch, Melaine L. Bell, Lynley J. Aldridge, Sarah Abdo, Michelle Tanious, Skye Dong, Rick Iedema, Janette Vardy, Rina Hui, Francis Boyle, Winston Liauw, and David Goldstein. 2013. Should culture affect practice? A comparison of prognostic discussions in consultations with immigrant versus native-born cancer patients. Patient Education and Counseling 92: 246–252.CrossRef Butow, N. Phyllis, Ming Sze, Maurice Eisenbruch, Melaine L. Bell, Lynley J. Aldridge, Sarah Abdo, Michelle Tanious, Skye Dong, Rick Iedema, Janette Vardy, Rina Hui, Francis Boyle, Winston Liauw, and David Goldstein. 2013. Should culture affect practice? A comparison of prognostic discussions in consultations with immigrant versus native-born cancer patients. Patient Education and Counseling 92: 246–252.CrossRef
go back to reference Clayton, M. Josephine, Butow N. Phyllis, and Martin H.N. Tattersall. 2005. The needs of terminally ill cancer patients versus those of caregivers for information regarding prognosis and end-of-life issues. Cancer 103 (9): 1957–1964.CrossRef Clayton, M. Josephine, Butow N. Phyllis, and Martin H.N. Tattersall. 2005. The needs of terminally ill cancer patients versus those of caregivers for information regarding prognosis and end-of-life issues. Cancer 103 (9): 1957–1964.CrossRef
go back to reference Crawley, M. Lavera. 2005. Racial, cultural, and ethnic factors influencing end-of-life care. Journal of Palliative Medicine 8 (Suppl 1): 58–69. Crawley, M. Lavera. 2005. Racial, cultural, and ethnic factors influencing end-of-life care. Journal of Palliative Medicine 8 (Suppl 1): 58–69.
go back to reference Crawley, M. Lavera, Patricia A. Marshall, Bernard Lo, and Barbara A. Koening. 2002. Strategies for culturally effective end-of-life care. Annals of Internal Medicine 136: 673–679.CrossRef Crawley, M. Lavera, Patricia A. Marshall, Bernard Lo, and Barbara A. Koening. 2002. Strategies for culturally effective end-of-life care. Annals of Internal Medicine 136: 673–679.CrossRef
go back to reference Delany, M. Clare. 2005. Respecting patient autonomy and obtaining their informed consent: Ethical theory–missing in action. Physiotherapy 91 (4): 197–203.CrossRef Delany, M. Clare. 2005. Respecting patient autonomy and obtaining their informed consent: Ethical theory–missing in action. Physiotherapy 91 (4): 197–203.CrossRef
go back to reference Dening, H. Karen, Louise Jones, and Elizabeth L. Sampson. 2013. Preferences for end-of-life care: A nominal group study of people with dementia and their family givers. Palliative Medicine 27 (5): 409–417.CrossRef Dening, H. Karen, Louise Jones, and Elizabeth L. Sampson. 2013. Preferences for end-of-life care: A nominal group study of people with dementia and their family givers. Palliative Medicine 27 (5): 409–417.CrossRef
go back to reference Detering, M. Karen, Andrew D. Hancock, Michael C. Reade, and William Silvester. 2010. The impact of advance care planning on end of life care in elderly patients: Randomised controlled trial. The British Medical Journal 340: c1345.CrossRef Detering, M. Karen, Andrew D. Hancock, Michael C. Reade, and William Silvester. 2010. The impact of advance care planning on end of life care in elderly patients: Randomised controlled trial. The British Medical Journal 340: c1345.CrossRef
go back to reference Flores, Glenn. 2005. The impact of medical interpreter services on the quality of healthcare: A systematic review. Medical Care Research and Review 62 (3): 255–299.CrossRef Flores, Glenn. 2005. The impact of medical interpreter services on the quality of healthcare: A systematic review. Medical Care Research and Review 62 (3): 255–299.CrossRef
go back to reference Giannousi, Zoe, Evangelos C. Karademas, and Georiga Dimitraki. 2016. Illness representations and psychological adjustment of Greek couples dealing with a recently-diagnosed cancer: Dyadic, interaction and perception-dissimilarity effect. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 39 (1): 85–93.CrossRef Giannousi, Zoe, Evangelos C. Karademas, and Georiga Dimitraki. 2016. Illness representations and psychological adjustment of Greek couples dealing with a recently-diagnosed cancer: Dyadic, interaction and perception-dissimilarity effect. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 39 (1): 85–93.CrossRef
go back to reference Goldstein, D., B. Thewes, and Phyllis N. Butow. 2002. Communicating in a multicultural society II: Greek community attitudes towards cancer in Australia. Internal Medicine Journal 32: 289–296.CrossRef Goldstein, D., B. Thewes, and Phyllis N. Butow. 2002. Communicating in a multicultural society II: Greek community attitudes towards cancer in Australia. Internal Medicine Journal 32: 289–296.CrossRef
go back to reference Hagerty, G. Rebecca, Phyllis N. Butow, Peter A. Ellis, Elizabeth A. Lobb, Susan Pendlebury, Natasha Leighl, David Goldstein, Sing Kai Lo, and Martin H.N. Tattersall. 2004. Cancer patient preferences for communication of prognosis in the metastatic setting. Journal of Clinical Oncology 22 (9): 1721–1730.CrossRef Hagerty, G. Rebecca, Phyllis N. Butow, Peter A. Ellis, Elizabeth A. Lobb, Susan Pendlebury, Natasha Leighl, David Goldstein, Sing Kai Lo, and Martin H.N. Tattersall. 2004. Cancer patient preferences for communication of prognosis in the metastatic setting. Journal of Clinical Oncology 22 (9): 1721–1730.CrossRef
go back to reference Hagerty, G. Rebecca, Phyllis N. Butow, Peter Ellis, Dimitry, S., and M.H.N. Tattersall. 2005. Communicating prognosis in cancer care: A systematic review of the literature. Annals of Oncology 16 (7): 1005–1053.CrossRef Hagerty, G. Rebecca, Phyllis N. Butow, Peter Ellis, Dimitry, S., and M.H.N. Tattersall. 2005. Communicating prognosis in cancer care: A systematic review of the literature. Annals of Oncology 16 (7): 1005–1053.CrossRef
go back to reference Haroon-Iqbal, H., D. Field, H. Parker, and Z. Iqbal. 1995. Palliative care services for ethnic groups in Leicester. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 1: 114–116. Haroon-Iqbal, H., D. Field, H. Parker, and Z. Iqbal. 1995. Palliative care services for ethnic groups in Leicester. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 1: 114–116.
go back to reference Heyland, K. Daren, Diane E. Allan, Graeme Rocker, Peter Dodek, Deb Pinchora, Amiram Gafni, and Canadian Researchers at the End-of-Life Network (CARENET). 2009. Discussing prognosis with patients and their families near the end-of-life: Impact on satisfaction with end-of-life care. Open Medicine 3 (2): e101–e110. Heyland, K. Daren, Diane E. Allan, Graeme Rocker, Peter Dodek, Deb Pinchora, Amiram Gafni, and Canadian Researchers at the End-of-Life Network (CARENET). 2009. Discussing prognosis with patients and their families near the end-of-life: Impact on satisfaction with end-of-life care. Open Medicine 3 (2): e101–e110.
go back to reference Holroyd, Jules. 2009. Relational autonomy and paternalistic interventions. Res Publica 15: 321–336.CrossRef Holroyd, Jules. 2009. Relational autonomy and paternalistic interventions. Res Publica 15: 321–336.CrossRef
go back to reference Horvat, Lidia, Dell Horey, Panayiota Romios, and John Kis-Rigo. 2014. Cultural competence education for health professionals. Cochrane Database Systematic Review, 5: p. CD009405. Horvat, Lidia, Dell Horey, Panayiota Romios, and John Kis-Rigo. 2014. Cultural competence education for health professionals. Cochrane Database Systematic Review, 5: p. CD009405.
go back to reference Huang, X., Phyllis Butow, B. Meiser, and David Goldstein. 1999. Attitudes and information needs of Chinese migrant cancer patients and their relatives. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Medicine 29: 207–213.CrossRef Huang, X., Phyllis Butow, B. Meiser, and David Goldstein. 1999. Attitudes and information needs of Chinese migrant cancer patients and their relatives. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Medicine 29: 207–213.CrossRef
go back to reference Hwang, S. Shirley, Victor T. Chang, Yvette Alejandro, Pamela Osenenko, Davis Casaundra, Janet Cogswell, Shanthi Srinivas, and Basil Kasimis. 2003. Caregiver unmet needs, burden, and satisfaction in symptomatic advanced cancer patients at a Veterans Affairs (VA) medical center. Palliative Support Care 1 (4): 319–329.CrossRef Hwang, S. Shirley, Victor T. Chang, Yvette Alejandro, Pamela Osenenko, Davis Casaundra, Janet Cogswell, Shanthi Srinivas, and Basil Kasimis. 2003. Caregiver unmet needs, burden, and satisfaction in symptomatic advanced cancer patients at a Veterans Affairs (VA) medical center. Palliative Support Care 1 (4): 319–329.CrossRef
go back to reference McNamara, Beverley, Karen Martin, Charles Waddell, and Kevin Yuen. 1997. Palliative care in a multicultural society: Perceptions of health care professionals. Palliative Medicine 11 (5): 359–367.CrossRef McNamara, Beverley, Karen Martin, Charles Waddell, and Kevin Yuen. 1997. Palliative care in a multicultural society: Perceptions of health care professionals. Palliative Medicine 11 (5): 359–367.CrossRef
go back to reference Mitchison, Debbie, Phyllis Butow, Ming Sze, Lynley Aldridge, Rina Hui, Janette Vardy, Melaine Eisenbruch, Rick Iedema, and David Goldstein. 2012. Prognostic communication preferences of migrant patients and their relatives. Psycho-oncology 21 (5): 496–504.CrossRef Mitchison, Debbie, Phyllis Butow, Ming Sze, Lynley Aldridge, Rina Hui, Janette Vardy, Melaine Eisenbruch, Rick Iedema, and David Goldstein. 2012. Prognostic communication preferences of migrant patients and their relatives. Psycho-oncology 21 (5): 496–504.CrossRef
go back to reference Mystakidou, Kyriaki, Christina Liossi, Lambros Vlachos, and Joannis Papadimitriou. 1996. Disclosure of diagnostic information to cancer patients in Greece. Palliative Medicine 10 (3): 195–200.CrossRef Mystakidou, Kyriaki, Christina Liossi, Lambros Vlachos, and Joannis Papadimitriou. 1996. Disclosure of diagnostic information to cancer patients in Greece. Palliative Medicine 10 (3): 195–200.CrossRef
go back to reference Norris, Wendi M., Marjorie D. Wenrich, Elizabeth L. Nielsen, Patsy D. Treece, Carey J. Jackson, and Randall J. Curtis. 2005. Communication about end-of-life care between language-discordant patients and clinicians: Insights from medical interpreters. Journal of Palliative Medicine 8 (5): 1016–1024.CrossRef Norris, Wendi M., Marjorie D. Wenrich, Elizabeth L. Nielsen, Patsy D. Treece, Carey J. Jackson, and Randall J. Curtis. 2005. Communication about end-of-life care between language-discordant patients and clinicians: Insights from medical interpreters. Journal of Palliative Medicine 8 (5): 1016–1024.CrossRef
go back to reference O’Neill, J. 1994. Ethnic minorities—neglected by palliative care providers? Journal of Cancer Care 3: 215–220. O’Neill, J. 1994. Ethnic minorities—neglected by palliative care providers? Journal of Cancer Care 3: 215–220.
go back to reference Park, Elyse, Joseph Betancourt, Elizabeth Miller, Michael Nathan, Ellie MacDonald, Owusu Ananeh-Firempong 2nd, and Valerie Stone. 2006. Internal medicine residents’ perceptions of cross-cultural training. Barriers, needs, and educational recommendations. Journal of General Internal Medicine 21: 476–480.CrossRef Park, Elyse, Joseph Betancourt, Elizabeth Miller, Michael Nathan, Ellie MacDonald, Owusu Ananeh-Firempong 2nd, and Valerie Stone. 2006. Internal medicine residents’ perceptions of cross-cultural training. Barriers, needs, and educational recommendations. Journal of General Internal Medicine 21: 476–480.CrossRef
go back to reference Parker, M. Sharon, Josephine M. Clayton, Karen Hancock, Sharon Walder, Phyllis N. Butow, Sue Carrick, David Currow, Davina Ghersi, Paul Glare, Rebecca Hagerty, and Martin H. Tattersall. 2007. A systematic review of prognostic/end-of-life communication with adults in the advanced stages of a life-limiting illness: Patient/caregiver preferences for the content, style, and timing of information. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 34 (1): 81–93.CrossRef Parker, M. Sharon, Josephine M. Clayton, Karen Hancock, Sharon Walder, Phyllis N. Butow, Sue Carrick, David Currow, Davina Ghersi, Paul Glare, Rebecca Hagerty, and Martin H. Tattersall. 2007. A systematic review of prognostic/end-of-life communication with adults in the advanced stages of a life-limiting illness: Patient/caregiver preferences for the content, style, and timing of information. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 34 (1): 81–93.CrossRef
go back to reference Rahmani, Azad, Akram Ghahramanian, and Atefeh Alahbakhshian. 2010. Respecting to patients’ autonomy in viewpoint of nurses and patients in medical-surgical wards. Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research 15 (1): 14–19. Rahmani, Azad, Akram Ghahramanian, and Atefeh Alahbakhshian. 2010. Respecting to patients’ autonomy in viewpoint of nurses and patients in medical-surgical wards. Iranian Journal of Nursing and Midwifery Research 15 (1): 14–19.
go back to reference Repetto, Lazzaro, Pierluca Piselli, Mimma Raffaele, and Carola Locatelli. 2009. Communicating cancer diagnosis and prognosis: When the target is the elderly patient—a GIOGer study. European Journal of Cancer 45: 374–383.CrossRef Repetto, Lazzaro, Pierluca Piselli, Mimma Raffaele, and Carola Locatelli. 2009. Communicating cancer diagnosis and prognosis: When the target is the elderly patient—a GIOGer study. European Journal of Cancer 45: 374–383.CrossRef
go back to reference Sandman, Lars, and Christian Munthe. 2010. Shared decision making, paternalism and patient choice. Health Care Analysis 18 (1): 60–84.CrossRef Sandman, Lars, and Christian Munthe. 2010. Shared decision making, paternalism and patient choice. Health Care Analysis 18 (1): 60–84.CrossRef
go back to reference Sheldon, Frances. 1995. Will the doors open? Multicultural issues in palliative care. Palliative Medicine 9 (2): 89–90.CrossRef Sheldon, Frances. 1995. Will the doors open? Multicultural issues in palliative care. Palliative Medicine 9 (2): 89–90.CrossRef
go back to reference Silva, D. Milagros, Margaux Genoff, Alexandra Zaballa, Sarah Jewell, Stacy Stabler, Francesca M. Gany, and Lisa C. Diamond. 2016. Interpreting at the end of life: A systematic review of the impact of interpreters on the delivery of palliative care services to cancer patients with limited English proficiency. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 51 (3): 569–580.CrossRef Silva, D. Milagros, Margaux Genoff, Alexandra Zaballa, Sarah Jewell, Stacy Stabler, Francesca M. Gany, and Lisa C. Diamond. 2016. Interpreting at the end of life: A systematic review of the impact of interpreters on the delivery of palliative care services to cancer patients with limited English proficiency. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 51 (3): 569–580.CrossRef
go back to reference Smith, K. Alexander, Rebecca L. Sudore, and Eliseo J. Perez-Stable. 2009. Palliative care for Latino patients and their families: Whenever we prayed, she wept. The Journal of the American Medical Association 301: 1047–1057.CrossRef Smith, K. Alexander, Rebecca L. Sudore, and Eliseo J. Perez-Stable. 2009. Palliative care for Latino patients and their families: Whenever we prayed, she wept. The Journal of the American Medical Association 301: 1047–1057.CrossRef
go back to reference Surbone, Antonella. 2008. Cultural aspects of communication in cancer care. Supportive Care in Cancer 16: 235–240.CrossRef Surbone, Antonella. 2008. Cultural aspects of communication in cancer care. Supportive Care in Cancer 16: 235–240.CrossRef
go back to reference Vaught, Wayne. 2003. A moral framework for multicultural education in healthcare. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 24 (4): 301–328.CrossRef Vaught, Wayne. 2003. A moral framework for multicultural education in healthcare. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 24 (4): 301–328.CrossRef
go back to reference Vidaeff, Alex C., Anthony J. Kerrigan, and Manju Monga. 2015. Cross-cultural barriers to health care. Southern Medical Journal 108 (1): 1–4.CrossRef Vidaeff, Alex C., Anthony J. Kerrigan, and Manju Monga. 2015. Cross-cultural barriers to health care. Southern Medical Journal 108 (1): 1–4.CrossRef
go back to reference Walczak, Adam, Phyllis N. Butow, Patricia M. Davidson, Frances A. Bellemore, Martin H.N. Tattersall, Josephine M. Clayton, Jane Young, Benjamin Mazer, Susan Ladwig, and Ronald M. Epstein. 2013. Patient perspectives regarding communication about prognosis and end-of-life issues: How can it be optimized? Patient Education and Counseling 90 (3): 307–314.CrossRef Walczak, Adam, Phyllis N. Butow, Patricia M. Davidson, Frances A. Bellemore, Martin H.N. Tattersall, Josephine M. Clayton, Jane Young, Benjamin Mazer, Susan Ladwig, and Ronald M. Epstein. 2013. Patient perspectives regarding communication about prognosis and end-of-life issues: How can it be optimized? Patient Education and Counseling 90 (3): 307–314.CrossRef
go back to reference Wang, Xiaohui, Youyi Huang, Lalit Radha Krishna, and Rukshni Puvanendran. 2016. Role of the nasogastric tube and lingzhi (Ganoderma lucidum) in palliative care. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 51 (4): 794–799.CrossRef Wang, Xiaohui, Youyi Huang, Lalit Radha Krishna, and Rukshni Puvanendran. 2016. Role of the nasogastric tube and lingzhi (Ganoderma lucidum) in palliative care. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 51 (4): 794–799.CrossRef
go back to reference Wright, A. Alexi, Baohui Zhang, Alaka Ray, Jennifer W. Mack, Elizabeth Trice, Tracy Balboni, Susan L. Mitchell, Vicki A. Jackson, Susan D. Block, Paul K. Maciejewski, and Holly G. Prigerson. 2008. Associations between end-of-life discussions, patient mental health, medical care near death, and caregiver bereavement adjustment. The Journal of the American Medical Association 300: 1665–1673.CrossRef Wright, A. Alexi, Baohui Zhang, Alaka Ray, Jennifer W. Mack, Elizabeth Trice, Tracy Balboni, Susan L. Mitchell, Vicki A. Jackson, Susan D. Block, Paul K. Maciejewski, and Holly G. Prigerson. 2008. Associations between end-of-life discussions, patient mental health, medical care near death, and caregiver bereavement adjustment. The Journal of the American Medical Association 300: 1665–1673.CrossRef
go back to reference Zhang, Baohui, Alexi A. Wright, Haiden A. Huskamp, Matthew E. Nilsson, Matthew L. Maciejewski, Craig C. Earle, Susan D. Block, Paul K. Maciejewski, and Holly G. Prigerson. 2009. Health care costs in the last week of life: Associations with end-of-life conversations. Archives of Internal Medicine 169 (5): 480–488.CrossRef Zhang, Baohui, Alexi A. Wright, Haiden A. Huskamp, Matthew E. Nilsson, Matthew L. Maciejewski, Craig C. Earle, Susan D. Block, Paul K. Maciejewski, and Holly G. Prigerson. 2009. Health care costs in the last week of life: Associations with end-of-life conversations. Archives of Internal Medicine 169 (5): 480–488.CrossRef
Metadata
Title
Understanding patient needs without understanding the patient: the need for complementary use of professional interpreters in end-of-life care
Authors
Demi Krystallidou
Ignaas Devisch
Dominique Van de Velde
Peter Pype
Publication date
01-12-2017
Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Published in
Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy / Issue 4/2017
Print ISSN: 1386-7423
Electronic ISSN: 1572-8633
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-017-9769-y

Other articles of this Issue 4/2017

Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4/2017 Go to the issue

Short literature notice

Short literature notices