Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Trials 1/2022

Open Access 01-12-2022 | Methodology

Trial Forge Guidance 3: randomised trials and how to recruit and retain individuals from ethnic minority groups—practical guidance to support better practice

Authors: Shoba Dawson, Katie Banister, Katie Biggs, Seonaidh Cotton, Declan Devane, Heidi Gardner, Katie Gillies, Gosala Gopalakrishnan, Talia Isaacs, Kamlesh Khunti, Alistair Nichol, Adwoa Parker, Amy M. Russell, Victoria Shepherd, Frances Shiely, Gillian Shorter, Bella Starling, Hywel Williams, Andrew Willis, Miles D. Witham, Shaun Treweek

Published in: Trials | Issue 1/2022

Login to get access

Abstract

Randomised trials, especially those intended to directly inform clinical practice and policy, should be designed to reflect all those who could benefit from the intervention under test should it prove effective. This does not always happen. The UK National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) INCLUDE project identified many groups in the UK that are under-served by trials, including ethnic minorities.
This guidance document presents four key recommendations for designing and running trials that include the ethnic groups needed by the trial. These are (1) ensure eligibility criteria and recruitment pathway do not limit participation in ways you do not intend, (2) ensure your trial materials are developed with inclusion in mind, (3) ensure staff are culturally competent and (4) build trusting partnerships with community organisations that work with ethnic minority groups. Each recommendation comes with best practice advice, public contributor testimonials, examples of the inclusion problem tackled by the recommendation, or strategies to mitigate the problem, as well as a collection of resources to support implementation of the recommendations.
We encourage trial teams to follow the recommendations and, where possible, evaluate the strategies they use to implement them. Finally, while our primary audience is those designing, running and reporting trials, we hope funders, grant reviewers and approvals agencies may also find our guidance useful.
Appendix
Available only for authorised users
Literature
1.
go back to reference Witham MD, Anderson E, Carroll C, et al. Developing a roadmap to improve trial delivery for under-served groups: results from a UK multi-stakeholder process. Trials. 2020;21:694.CrossRefPubMed Witham MD, Anderson E, Carroll C, et al. Developing a roadmap to improve trial delivery for under-served groups: results from a UK multi-stakeholder process. Trials. 2020;21:694.CrossRefPubMed
3.
go back to reference Khunti K, Bellary S, Karamat MA, et al. Representation of people of South Asian origin in cardiovascular outcome trials of glucose-lowering therapies in Type 2 diabetes. Diabet Med. 2016;34:64–8.CrossRefPubMed Khunti K, Bellary S, Karamat MA, et al. Representation of people of South Asian origin in cardiovascular outcome trials of glucose-lowering therapies in Type 2 diabetes. Diabet Med. 2016;34:64–8.CrossRefPubMed
4.
go back to reference Smart A, Harrison E. The under-representation of minority ethnic groups in UK medical research. Ethn Health. 2017;2:65–82.CrossRef Smart A, Harrison E. The under-representation of minority ethnic groups in UK medical research. Ethn Health. 2017;2:65–82.CrossRef
6.
go back to reference Treweek S, Banister K, Bower P, et al. Developing the INCLUDE Ethnicity Framework—a tool to help trialists design trials that better reflect the communities they serve. Trials. 2021;22:337.CrossRefPubMed Treweek S, Banister K, Bower P, et al. Developing the INCLUDE Ethnicity Framework—a tool to help trialists design trials that better reflect the communities they serve. Trials. 2021;22:337.CrossRefPubMed
9.
go back to reference Mbuagbaw L, Aves T, Shea BJ, J, Welch V, Taljaard M, Yoganathan M, Greer-Smith R, Wells G, Tugwell P. Considerations and guidance in designing equity-relevant clinical trials. Int J Equity Health. 2017;16:93.CrossRefPubMed Mbuagbaw L, Aves T, Shea BJ, J, Welch V, Taljaard M, Yoganathan M, Greer-Smith R, Wells G, Tugwell P. Considerations and guidance in designing equity-relevant clinical trials. Int J Equity Health. 2017;16:93.CrossRefPubMed
10.
go back to reference Bodicoat DH, Routen AC, Willis A, Ekezie W, Gillies C, Lawson C, et al. Promoting inclusion in clinical trials—a rapid review of the literature and recommendations for action. Trials. 2021;22:880.CrossRefPubMed Bodicoat DH, Routen AC, Willis A, Ekezie W, Gillies C, Lawson C, et al. Promoting inclusion in clinical trials—a rapid review of the literature and recommendations for action. Trials. 2021;22:880.CrossRefPubMed
11.
go back to reference Orkin AM, Nicoll G, Persaud N, Pinto AD. Reporting of sociodemographic variables in randomized clinical trials, 2014-2020. JAMA Netw Open. 2021;4(6):e2110700–0.CrossRefPubMed Orkin AM, Nicoll G, Persaud N, Pinto AD. Reporting of sociodemographic variables in randomized clinical trials, 2014-2020. JAMA Netw Open. 2021;4(6):e2110700–0.CrossRefPubMed
12.
go back to reference Pan D, Sze S, Minhas JS, Bangash MN, Pareek N, Divall P, et al. The impact of ethnicity on clinical outcomes in COVID-19: A systematic review. EClinicalMedicine. 2020;23:100404.CrossRefPubMed Pan D, Sze S, Minhas JS, Bangash MN, Pareek N, Divall P, et al. The impact of ethnicity on clinical outcomes in COVID-19: A systematic review. EClinicalMedicine. 2020;23:100404.CrossRefPubMed
13.
go back to reference Cragg WJ, McMahon K, Oughton JB, Sigsworth R, Taylor C, Napp V. Clinical trial recruiters’ experiences working with trial eligibility criteria: results of an exploratory, cross-sectional, online survey in the UK. Trials. 2021;22:736.CrossRefPubMed Cragg WJ, McMahon K, Oughton JB, Sigsworth R, Taylor C, Napp V. Clinical trial recruiters’ experiences working with trial eligibility criteria: results of an exploratory, cross-sectional, online survey in the UK. Trials. 2021;22:736.CrossRefPubMed
15.
go back to reference Ramke J, Jordan V, Vincent AL, Harwood M, Murphy R, Ameratunga S. Diabetic eye disease and screening attendance by ethnicity in New Zealand: a systematic review. Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2019;47:937–47.CrossRefPubMed Ramke J, Jordan V, Vincent AL, Harwood M, Murphy R, Ameratunga S. Diabetic eye disease and screening attendance by ethnicity in New Zealand: a systematic review. Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2019;47:937–47.CrossRefPubMed
16.
go back to reference Rowe RE, Garcia J. Social class, ethnicity and attendance for antenatal care in the United Kingdom: a systematic review. J Public Health Med. 2003;25:113–9 Contemp Clin Trials 2012;33 1197-205.CrossRefPubMed Rowe RE, Garcia J. Social class, ethnicity and attendance for antenatal care in the United Kingdom: a systematic review. J Public Health Med. 2003;25:113–9 Contemp Clin Trials 2012;33 1197-205.CrossRefPubMed
17.
go back to reference Masood Y, Bower P, Waheed MW, Brown G, Waheed W. Synthesis of researcher reported strategies to recruit adults of ethnic minorities to clinical trials in the United Kingdom: A systematic review. Contemp Clin Trials. 2019;78:1–10.CrossRefPubMed Masood Y, Bower P, Waheed MW, Brown G, Waheed W. Synthesis of researcher reported strategies to recruit adults of ethnic minorities to clinical trials in the United Kingdom: A systematic review. Contemp Clin Trials. 2019;78:1–10.CrossRefPubMed
18.
go back to reference Badger F, Clarke L, Pumphrey R, Clifford C. A survey of issues of ethnicity and culture in nursing homes in an English region: nurse managers’ perspectives. J Clin Nurs. 2012;21:1726–35.CrossRefPubMed Badger F, Clarke L, Pumphrey R, Clifford C. A survey of issues of ethnicity and culture in nursing homes in an English region: nurse managers’ perspectives. J Clin Nurs. 2012;21:1726–35.CrossRefPubMed
19.
go back to reference Anderson AS, Chong HY, Craigie AM, Donnan PT, Gallant S, Hickman A, et al. A novel approach to increasing community capacity for weight management a volunteer-delivered programme (ActWELL) initiated within breast screening clinics: a randomised controlled trial. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2021;18:34.CrossRefPubMed Anderson AS, Chong HY, Craigie AM, Donnan PT, Gallant S, Hickman A, et al. A novel approach to increasing community capacity for weight management a volunteer-delivered programme (ActWELL) initiated within breast screening clinics: a randomised controlled trial. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2021;18:34.CrossRefPubMed
20.
go back to reference Bansal N, Bhopal R, Steiner M, et al. Major ethnic group differences in breast cancer screening uptake in Scotland are not extinguished by adjustment for indices of geographical residence, area deprivation, long-term illness and education. Br J Cancer. 2012;106:1361–6.CrossRefPubMed Bansal N, Bhopal R, Steiner M, et al. Major ethnic group differences in breast cancer screening uptake in Scotland are not extinguished by adjustment for indices of geographical residence, area deprivation, long-term illness and education. Br J Cancer. 2012;106:1361–6.CrossRefPubMed
23.
go back to reference Madoc-Jones I, Dubberley S. Language and the provision of health and social care in Wales. Divers Health Soc Care. 2005;2:127–34. Madoc-Jones I, Dubberley S. Language and the provision of health and social care in Wales. Divers Health Soc Care. 2005;2:127–34.
25.
go back to reference Sousa VD, Rojjanasrirat W. Translation, adaptation and validation of instruments or scales for use in cross-cultural health care research: a clear and user-friendly guideline. J Eval Clin Pract. 2011;2:268–74.CrossRef Sousa VD, Rojjanasrirat W. Translation, adaptation and validation of instruments or scales for use in cross-cultural health care research: a clear and user-friendly guideline. J Eval Clin Pract. 2011;2:268–74.CrossRef
26.
go back to reference Lloyd CE, Johnson MR, Mughal S, et al. Securing recruitment and obtaining informed consent in minority ethnic groups in the UK. BMC Health Serv Res. 2008;8:68.CrossRefPubMed Lloyd CE, Johnson MR, Mughal S, et al. Securing recruitment and obtaining informed consent in minority ethnic groups in the UK. BMC Health Serv Res. 2008;8:68.CrossRefPubMed
27.
go back to reference Santoyo-Olsson J, Cabrera J, Freyre R, Grossman M, Alvarez N, Mathur D, et al. An innovative multiphased strategy to recruit underserved adults into a randomized trial of a community-based diabetes risk reduction program. Gerontologist. 2011;51(suppl 1):S82–93.CrossRefPubMed Santoyo-Olsson J, Cabrera J, Freyre R, Grossman M, Alvarez N, Mathur D, et al. An innovative multiphased strategy to recruit underserved adults into a randomized trial of a community-based diabetes risk reduction program. Gerontologist. 2011;51(suppl 1):S82–93.CrossRefPubMed
28.
go back to reference Hsieh E. Understanding medical interpreters: reconceptualizing bilingual health communication. Health Commun. 2006;20:2, 177–86.CrossRef Hsieh E. Understanding medical interpreters: reconceptualizing bilingual health communication. Health Commun. 2006;20:2, 177–86.CrossRef
29.
go back to reference Rosenberg E, Seller R, Leanza Y. Through interpreters’ eyes: comparing roles of professional and family interpreters. Patient Educ Couns. 2008;70:87–93.CrossRefPubMed Rosenberg E, Seller R, Leanza Y. Through interpreters’ eyes: comparing roles of professional and family interpreters. Patient Educ Couns. 2008;70:87–93.CrossRefPubMed
30.
go back to reference Dawson S. Patient and public involvement in health services research: exploring the views and experiences of South Asians and Health Services Researchers. PhD thesis, 2018. University of Manchester. Dawson S. Patient and public involvement in health services research: exploring the views and experiences of South Asians and Health Services Researchers. PhD thesis, 2018. University of Manchester.
32.
go back to reference Schouler-Ocak M, Graef-Calliess IT, Tarricone I, Qureshi A, Kastrup MC, Bhugra D. EPA guidance on cultural competence training. European Psychiatry. 2015;30:431–40.CrossRefPubMed Schouler-Ocak M, Graef-Calliess IT, Tarricone I, Qureshi A, Kastrup MC, Bhugra D. EPA guidance on cultural competence training. European Psychiatry. 2015;30:431–40.CrossRefPubMed
33.
go back to reference Tham J, Gómez AG, Garasic MD. Cross-cultural and religious critiques of informed consent. Abingdon-on-Thames (UK): Routledge; 2022. Tham J, Gómez AG, Garasic MD. Cross-cultural and religious critiques of informed consent. Abingdon-on-Thames (UK): Routledge; 2022.
34.
go back to reference Langford AT, Resnicow K, Dimond EP, Denicoff AM, Germain DS, McCaskill-Stevens W, et al. Racial/ethnic differences in clinical trial enrollment, refusal rates, ineligibility, and reasons for decline among patients at sites in the National Cancer Institute’s Community Cancer Centers Program. Cancer. 2014;120:877–84.CrossRefPubMed Langford AT, Resnicow K, Dimond EP, Denicoff AM, Germain DS, McCaskill-Stevens W, et al. Racial/ethnic differences in clinical trial enrollment, refusal rates, ineligibility, and reasons for decline among patients at sites in the National Cancer Institute’s Community Cancer Centers Program. Cancer. 2014;120:877–84.CrossRefPubMed
35.
go back to reference Svensson K, Ramírez OF, Peres F, Barnett M, Claudio L. Socioeconomic determinants associated with willingness to participate in medical research among a diverse population. Contemp Clin Trials. 2012;33:1197–205.CrossRefPubMed Svensson K, Ramírez OF, Peres F, Barnett M, Claudio L. Socioeconomic determinants associated with willingness to participate in medical research among a diverse population. Contemp Clin Trials. 2012;33:1197–205.CrossRefPubMed
36.
go back to reference National Institute for Health Research. Increasing participation of Black Asian and Minority Ethnic groups in health and social care research. Centre for ethnic health research. 2018. https://arc-em.nihr.ac.uk/clahrcs-store/increasing-participation-black-asian-and-minority-ethnic-bame-groups-health-and-social. [Accessed 14/7/2021]. National Institute for Health Research. Increasing participation of Black Asian and Minority Ethnic groups in health and social care research. Centre for ethnic health research. 2018. https://​arc-em.​nihr.​ac.​uk/​clahrcs-store/​increasing-participation-black-asian-and-minority-ethnic-bame-groups-health-and-social.​ [Accessed 14/7/2021].
37.
go back to reference Kerasidou A. Trust me, I’m a researcher!: Tte role of trust in biomedical research. Med Health Care Philos. 2017;20:43–50.CrossRefPubMed Kerasidou A. Trust me, I’m a researcher!: Tte role of trust in biomedical research. Med Health Care Philos. 2017;20:43–50.CrossRefPubMed
38.
go back to reference Ekezie W, Czyznikowska BM, Rohit S, Harrison J, Miah N, Campbell-Morris P, et al. The views of ethnic minority and vulnerable communities towards participation in COVID-19 vaccine trials. J Public Health. 2021;43:e258–60.CrossRef Ekezie W, Czyznikowska BM, Rohit S, Harrison J, Miah N, Campbell-Morris P, et al. The views of ethnic minority and vulnerable communities towards participation in COVID-19 vaccine trials. J Public Health. 2021;43:e258–60.CrossRef
40.
go back to reference Islam S, Joseph O, Chaudry A, et al. “We are not hard to reach, but we may find it hard to trust” …. Involving and engaging ‘seldom listened to’ community voices in clinical translational health research: a social innovation approach. Res Involv Engagem. 2021;7:46.CrossRefPubMed Islam S, Joseph O, Chaudry A, et al. “We are not hard to reach, but we may find it hard to trust” …. Involving and engaging ‘seldom listened to’ community voices in clinical translational health research: a social innovation approach. Res Involv Engagem. 2021;7:46.CrossRefPubMed
41.
go back to reference O’Neill, O. “Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics; M. Geier & P. Schröder.” The Concept of Human Dignity in Biomedical Law, in 146. 2002. O’Neill, O. “Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics; M. Geier & P. Schröder.” The Concept of Human Dignity in Biomedical Law, in 146. 2002.
43.
go back to reference Tierney S, Dawson S, Boylan AM, et al. Broadening diversity through creative involvement to identify research priorities. Res Involv Engagem. 2021;7:3.CrossRefPubMed Tierney S, Dawson S, Boylan AM, et al. Broadening diversity through creative involvement to identify research priorities. Res Involv Engagem. 2021;7:3.CrossRefPubMed
45.
go back to reference He J, Morales DR, Guthrie B. Exclusion rates in randomized controlled trials of treatments for physical conditions: a systematic review. Trials. 2020;21:228.CrossRefPubMed He J, Morales DR, Guthrie B. Exclusion rates in randomized controlled trials of treatments for physical conditions: a systematic review. Trials. 2020;21:228.CrossRefPubMed
46.
go back to reference King NMP. Defining and describing benefit appropriately in clinical trials. J Law, Med Ethics. 2000;28:332–43.CrossRef King NMP. Defining and describing benefit appropriately in clinical trials. J Law, Med Ethics. 2000;28:332–43.CrossRef
48.
go back to reference James DC, Harville C, Sears C, Efunbumi O, Bondoc I. Participation of African Americans in e-health and m-health studies: a systematic review. Telemed J E Health. 2017;23:351–64.CrossRefPubMed James DC, Harville C, Sears C, Efunbumi O, Bondoc I. Participation of African Americans in e-health and m-health studies: a systematic review. Telemed J E Health. 2017;23:351–64.CrossRefPubMed
49.
go back to reference Choi E, Heo GJ, Song Y, Han H. Community health worker perspectives on recruitment and retention of recent immigrant women in a randomized clinical trial. Fam Community Health. 2016;39:53–61.CrossRefPubMed Choi E, Heo GJ, Song Y, Han H. Community health worker perspectives on recruitment and retention of recent immigrant women in a randomized clinical trial. Fam Community Health. 2016;39:53–61.CrossRefPubMed
50.
go back to reference Sankaré IC, Bross R, Brown AF, Del Pino HE, Jones LF, Morris DM, et al. Strategies to build trust and recruit African American and Latino community residents for health research: a cohort study. Clin Transl Sci. 2015;8:412–20.CrossRefPubMed Sankaré IC, Bross R, Brown AF, Del Pino HE, Jones LF, Morris DM, et al. Strategies to build trust and recruit African American and Latino community residents for health research: a cohort study. Clin Transl Sci. 2015;8:412–20.CrossRefPubMed
51.
go back to reference Hwang DA, Lee A, Song JM, Han HR. Recruitment and retention strategies among racial and ethnic minorities in web-based intervention trials: retrospective qualitative analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2021;23(7):e23959.CrossRefPubMed Hwang DA, Lee A, Song JM, Han HR. Recruitment and retention strategies among racial and ethnic minorities in web-based intervention trials: retrospective qualitative analysis. J Med Internet Res. 2021;23(7):e23959.CrossRefPubMed
52.
go back to reference Treweek S, Bevan S, Bower P, Campbell M, Christie J, Clarke; M, Collett, C, Cotton S, Devane D, Feky AE, Flemyng E, Galvin S, Gardner H, Gillies K, Jansen J, Littleford R, Parker P, Ramsay R, Restrup L, Sullivan F, Torgerson D, Tremain L, Westmore M, Williamson PR. Trial Forge Guidance 1: what is a study within a trial (SWAT)? Trials. 2018;19:139.CrossRefPubMed Treweek S, Bevan S, Bower P, Campbell M, Christie J, Clarke; M, Collett, C, Cotton S, Devane D, Feky AE, Flemyng E, Galvin S, Gardner H, Gillies K, Jansen J, Littleford R, Parker P, Ramsay R, Restrup L, Sullivan F, Torgerson D, Tremain L, Westmore M, Williamson PR. Trial Forge Guidance 1: what is a study within a trial (SWAT)? Trials. 2018;19:139.CrossRefPubMed
Metadata
Title
Trial Forge Guidance 3: randomised trials and how to recruit and retain individuals from ethnic minority groups—practical guidance to support better practice
Authors
Shoba Dawson
Katie Banister
Katie Biggs
Seonaidh Cotton
Declan Devane
Heidi Gardner
Katie Gillies
Gosala Gopalakrishnan
Talia Isaacs
Kamlesh Khunti
Alistair Nichol
Adwoa Parker
Amy M. Russell
Victoria Shepherd
Frances Shiely
Gillian Shorter
Bella Starling
Hywel Williams
Andrew Willis
Miles D. Witham
Shaun Treweek
Publication date
01-12-2022
Publisher
BioMed Central
Published in
Trials / Issue 1/2022
Electronic ISSN: 1745-6215
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13063-022-06553-w

Other articles of this Issue 1/2022

Trials 1/2022 Go to the issue