Skip to main content
Key Specialties
Cardiology Diabetology Endocrinology Gastroenterology Geriatrics and Gerontology Gynecology and Obstetrics Hematology Infectious Disease Internal Medicine Nephrology Neurology Oncology Pediatrics Respiratory Medicine Rheumatology Surgery
Congress Coverage
2024 ACC Congress 2023 ESMO Congress 2023 EASD Congress 2023 ERS Congress 2023 ESC Congress
Clinical Collections
Advances in Alzheimer’s

At a glance: The STEP trials

A round-up of the STEP phase 3 clinical trials evaluating semaglutide for weight loss in people with overweight or obesity.
ADVANCED SEARCH
Log in
Top
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research®
Published in: Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® 8/2013

01-08-2013 | Review

Swiss Contributions to War Surgery During the Great War

Author: Marcelin Oliver Draenert, PhD

Published in: Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® | Issue 8/2013

Login to get access

Abstract

Background

The role of neutral Switzerland during World War I is somewhat mysterious and its diplomatic history has never been fully disclosed. One of the activities might have determined its role: based on its relationship to the International Committee of the Red Cross, wounded multinational prisoners-of-war were interned in Swiss hospitals and Swiss physicians worked in a medical capacity in military hospitals on both sides of the front.

Questions/purposes

The main question is whether the activities of the Swiss authorities reflected a charitable diplomatic role while retaining the country’s traditional neutral stance. Supplementary practical questions included: How did Switzerland carry out the exchange of severely wounded prisoners of war? How did Swiss physicians function in the war zones? What were the medical objectives and the ultimate results of wartime surgery in Switzerland?

Methods

This study is based on archival material from the Swiss Federal Archive in Bern (BAR) and original publications of Swiss and German physicians in professional journals. The search was performed manually in the BAR evaluating the file “Landesverteidigung (national defense)” from 1848 to 2009. Original publications and journals were searched manually in the central libraries of Munich, Heidelberg, Zurich, and Bern.

Results

The evaluation of Swiss diplomatic activities confirmed that Switzerland’s charitable mission was aimed to enforce its neutral position and that Swiss authorities were able to efficiently manage the resulting problems. The engagement of Swiss surgeons in war surgery contributed to their experience and knowledge and yielded the development of many innovative medical devices and operating procedures, numerous of which are still known today.

Conclusion

While maintaining its neutral position, Switzerland was able to deal with the practical problems while gaining innovative medical knowledge still valid today.
Literature
1.
Bardenheuer B. [Permanent traction treatment. Subcutaneous and Complex Fractures and Dislocations of the Extremities and Their Consequences] [in German]. Stuttgart, Germany: Ferdinand Enke; 1889.
2.
BAR (The Swiss Federal Archives) E 27 14044: Letter of Gustave Ador to Federal President Hoffmann; November 12th, 1914.
3.
BAR E 27 13980: Note III b 34658/170071 to the Swiss Ambassador in Berlin; November 16th, 1914.
4.
BAR E 27 14044: Protocol of the meeting of the Swiss Federal Council; January 9th, 1915.
5.
BAR E 27 13980: Letter of the French Legacy to the political department; November 13th, 1918.
6.
BAR E 27 13981: Letter of Cardinal Gasparri to Federal President Motta; April 28th, 1915.
7.
BAR E 27 13968: Letter of military physician Colonel Hauser to the Political Department; February 17th, 1916.
8.
BAR E 27 13986: Letter of Dunant to the Political Department; April 29th, 1918.
9.
BAR E 27 13978: Stovall to Federal President Calonder; May 22th, 1918.
10.
BAR E 27 13986: Stovall to Federal President Calonder; May 9th, 1918.
11.
BAR E 27 13986: Stovall to Federal President Calonder; July 20th, 1918; BAR E 27 13986.
12.
BAR E 27 13986: Communication to the Press; November 11th, 1918.
13.
BAR E 27 13966: Lieutenant-Colonel Aepli to the Commander of the Region of Internment of Davos; November 18th, 1918.
14.
BAR E 27 13980: Letter of the Political Department to the k.u.k. Austrian-Hungarian Legacy in Bern; November 27th, 1918.
15.
BAR E 27 13980: Swiss Embassy in London to the Political Department; December 18th, 1918.
16.
BAR E 27 13980: Letter of the Belgian Legacy to the Political department; December 24th, 1918.
17.
BAR E 27 13986: Letter of the Swiss ambassador in Washington to the Political Department; January 16th, 1919.
18.
BAR E 27 13980: Letter of the Political Department to the Prisoner of War Internment Section of the Medical Department of the Armed Forces Staff; April 7th, 1919.
19.
BAR E 27 13980: Letter Int. XXI c to the German Ambassador in Berne; July 14th, 1919.
20.
BAR E 27 13966: Circular letter Nr. 999 from the military physician Colonel Hauser to the commanding officers of the internment regions; July 14th, 1919.
21.
BAR E 27 13965: Letter of Captain Zigerli to the Political Department; April 25th, 1923.
22.
BAR 2001 (A) 693: Telegram from Consul Voegeli to the Political Department; November 1915.
23.
Becker A. [The Forgotten of the Great War. Humanitarity and Culture in War 1914–1918. The Occupied Populations, Deported Civilians, Prisoners of War] [in French]. Paris, France: Noêsis; 1998.
24.
Bernhard O. [84. Meeting of the Central Association of Doctors of 26 to 28 June, 1913.] 84. Versammlung des aerztlichen Zentral-Vereins vom 26. bis 28. Juni 1913. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte.1913;63:1591–1594.
25.
BIG EDA A 81-1: [Instructions to the commandants, responsible for the internment January 8th, 1917.] Instruktion für die Internierungs-Platzkommandanten vom 8. Januar 1917.
26.
Brun H. [A new and universal apparatus for traction treatment of fractures and mobilization of joints.] In: Brun H, Veraguth O, Hoessly H, eds. [About diagnosis and treatment of late complications of war injuries: Communications of the Army Hospital for the Internees in Lucerne (Switzerland)]. Vol IV. Zurich, Switzerland: Rascher & Cie; 1919:469–475.
27.
Brun H. [The pathology of pseudarthroses: First part.] In: Brun H, Veraguth O, Hoessly H, eds. [About diagnosis and treatment of late complications of war injuries: Communications of the Army Hospital for the Internees in Lucerne (Switzerland)]. Vol I. Zurich, Switzerland: Rascher & Cie;1918:1–82.
28.
Burckhardt A. [Four months in a Prussian field hospital during the War of 1870.] [in German]. Basel, Switzerland: Schweighaus; 1872.
29.
Cornioley CE. [Overview of the treatment of war wounds by the Carrel-Dakin method.] In: Brun H, Veraguth O, Hoessly H, eds. [About diagnosis and treatment of late complications of war injuries: Communications of the Army Hospital for the Internees in Lucerne (Switzerland)] Vol IV. Zurich, Switzerland: Rascher & Cie; 1919:439–458.
30.
31.
Favre E. [The internment of sick and wounded prisoners of war in Switzerland, 1916.] [in French]. Premier Rapport. Geneva, Switzerland: Bureau de L`Internement; 1916.
32.
Favre E. [The internment of sick and wounded prisoners of war in Switzerland, 1917.] L’internement en Suisse des prisoniers de guerre malades ou blessés 1917. Second Rapport. Geneva, Switzerland; 1917.
33.
Favre E. [The internment of sick and wounded prisoners of war in Switzerland.] L’internement en Suisse des prisoniers de guerre malades ou blessés. Trois volumes fait par l’ordre du colonel Hauser, médecin d’armée, Troisieme Rapport. Geneva, Switzerland: Bureau de L`Internement; 1918.
34.
Grounauér L., Matthey A. Réunion des Médecins Suisses. Le 26 septembre 1915, à Neuchâtel. Revue médicale de la Suisse Romande. 1915;35:997–1014.
35.
Hauser J. [Lessons of the war for the army medical service] Lehren des Weltkrieges für unser Armeesanitaetswesen. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1915;65:1441–1461.
36.
Heine C. [Bullet wounds of the lower extremities based on personal experience in the wars of Schleswig-Holstein.] Die Schussverletzungen der unteren Extremitaeten, nach eigenen Erfahrungen aus dem letzten Schleswig-Holsteinischen Kriege. Archiv für klinische Chirurgie. 1866;7:229–457; 515–692.
37.
Hénocque A. [The treatment of fractures of the extremities caused by firearms.] Du traitment des fractures des membres par armes à feu. Lettre de M.C. Sédilot a M. le professeur Stoeber. Strasbourg 1871. Gazette Hebdomadaire. 1871;19:310–311.
38.
39.
Julliard C. [Joint Meeting of the National Association of Doctors and the Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande, 25 September 1915.] Gemeinsame Sitzung des aerztlichen Zentralvereins und der Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande vom 25. September 1915. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:113–122.
40.
Kistler K. [The restoration of the Nunciature in Switzerland (1920): A contribution to the Swiss church policy 1914–1925.] Die Wiedererrichtung der Nuntiatur in der Schweiz (1920): Ein Beitrag zur Schweizerischen Kirchenpolitik 1914–1925. Bern/Frankfurt, Switzerland/Germany:Lang; 1974.
41.
Ledergerber J, Zollinger F. [War surgery news from the people’s war 1914/16. No. 38. Our experience with the Steinmann’s pin traction in bullet fractures of the thigh.] Kriegschirurgische Mitteilungen aus dem Voelkerkriege 1914/16. Nr. 38. Unsere Erfahrungen mit der Steinmannschen Nagelextension bei Oberschenkelschußfrakturen. Langenbecks Archiv für Chirurgie. 1916;137:437–454.
42.
Ledergerber J, Zollinger F. [War surgery experiences (continued)] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen (Fortsetzung). Schweizerische Rundschau für Medizin. 1916;16:575–579.
43.
Ledergerber J, Zollinger F. [War surgery experiences in treating femoral fractures.] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen bei der Behandlung von Oberschenkelfrakturen. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1917;67:10–19.
44.
Ledergerber J, Zollinger F. [War surgery experiences in treating femoral fractures (final).] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen bei der Behandlung von Oberschenkelfrakturen (Schluss). Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1917;67:33–49.
45.
Ledergerber J, Zollinger F. [War surgery experiences.] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen. Schweizerische Rundschau für Medizin. 1917;17:441–453.
46.
Matti H. [Observations and Experiences in war surgery (Continuation)] Kriegschirurgische Beobachtungen und Erfahrungen (Fortsetzung). Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1915;65:801–818.
47.
Matti H. [Fractures and Their Treatment. A textbook for students and physicians] Die Knochenbrueche und ihre Behandlung. Ein Lehrbuch für Studierende und Aerzte. Vol. I. Die Allgemeine Lehre von den Knochenbrüchen und ihre Behandlung. Berlin, Germany: Julius Springer, 1918.
48.
Moergeli C. [When death is about: the great flu pandemic of 1918 in Switzerland.] Wenn der Tod umgeht: Die grosse Grippe von 1918 in der Schweiz. NZZ Folio. 1995;95:31–39.
49.
Nicod P. [Joint meeting of the National Association of Doctors and the Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande, 25 September 1915.] Gemeinsame Sitzung des aerztlichen Zentralvereins und der Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande vom 25. September 1915. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:113–122.
50.
Nr. 94. [Autographic letter of the Holy Father to his Eminence very Reverend Father Cardinal Archbishop of Hartmann, 10 March 1919.] Eigenhaendiges Schreiben des heiligen Vaters an Se. Eminenz den hochwürdigen. Herrn Kardinal Erzbischof von Hartmann vom 10. Maerz 1919. Kirchlicher Anzeiger für die Erzdioezese Koeln. 1919;59.
51.
Neue Züricher Zeitung. 1918; 139: No 1505; November 17th, 1918.
52.
53.
Panzera F. [Benedict XV and Switzerland during the Great War.] Benedetto XV e la Svizzera negli anni della Grande Guerra. Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Geschichte. 1993;43:321–340.
54.
Pettavel C. [Surgical war experiences from a Red Cross hospital in Lyon (Final).] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen aus einem Rotkreuzspital in Lyon (Schluß). Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:367–378.
55.
Perrier C. [Five months of surgery in military hospitals in Chalon-sur-Saône.] Cinq mois de chirurgie dans les hôpitaux militaires de Chalon-sur-Saône. Revue médicale de la Suisse Romande. 1915;35:373–388.
56.
Pollard J. The Unknown Pope: Benedict XV (1914–1922) and the Pursuit of Peace. London, England:Geoffrey Chapman; 1999.
57.
Reinbold P. Société Vaudoise de Médecin. Sitzung vom 6. Mai 1916. Revue médicale de la Suisse Romande. 1916;36:518–531.
58.
Reverdin A. [Joint meeting of the National Association of Doctors and the Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande; September 25th, 1915.] Gemeinsame Sitzung des aerztlichen Zentralvereins und der Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande vom; September 25th, 1915. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66;113–122.
59.
Roux C. [On the treatment of gunshot wounds of the joints.] Über die Behandlung der Schußwunden der Gelenke. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:84–89.
60.
Sauerbruch F. [Surgical war experiences. Overview with particular reference to the gunshots of the thorax and abdomen.] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen. Übersichtsreferat mit besonderer Berücksichtigung der Thorax- und Abdominalschüsse. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:1315–1329.
61.
Scottà A. [Pope Benedict XV. The Church, the Great War, Peace (1914–1922).] Papa Benedetto XV. La Chiesa, la Grande Guerra, la Pace (1914–1922). Rome, Italy: Ed. Di Storia e Letteratura; 2009.
62.
Schlich T. [“What power over life and death”: The establishment of blood transfusion in the World War I.] ”Welche Macht über Tod und Leben”: Die Etablierung der Bluttransfusion im Ersten Weltkrieg. In: Eckart WU, Gradman C, eds. Die Medizin und der Erste Weltkrieg. Hebolzheim, Germany: Centaurus; 2003:109–130.
63.
Senn A. [Treatment of war joint injuries] Traitement des lésions de guerre des articulations. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:1405–1410.
64.
Speed R. Prisoners, Diplomats, and the Great War: A Study in the Diplomacy of Captivity. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press; 1990.
65.
Socin A. [Surgical war experiences. Collected in Karlsruhe 1870 and 1871.] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen. Gesammelt in Carlsruhe 1870 und 1871. Leipzig, Germany: Vogel: 1872.
66.
Steinmann F. [Medical and Pharmaceutical Society of Bern. Meeting of 28 November 1911.] Medizinisch-Pharmazeutischer Bezirksverein Bern. Sitzung vom 28. November 1911. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1912;62:160–163.
67.
Steinmann F. [Surgical considerations of the current War.] Kriegschirurgische Betrachtungen aus dem gegenwaertigen Kriege. Schweizerische Rundschau für Medizin. 1916;16:201–209.
68.
Steinmann F. [Surgical experience of gunshot fractures of the extremities.] Kriegschirurgische Erfahrungen über die Schussfrakturen der Extremitaeten. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:1359–1404.
69.
Steinmann F. [Joint meeting of the National Association of Doctors and the Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande; September 25th, 1915.] Gemeinsame Sitzung des aerztlichen Zentralvereins und der Société Médicale de la Suisse Romande vom; September 25th, 1915. Correspondenzblatt für Schweizer Aerzte. 1916;66:113–122.
70.
Stibbe M. The internment of civilians by belligerent states during the first world war and the response of the International Committee of the Red Cross. J Contemp Hist. 2006;41:5–19.CrossRef
71.
Vanneufville G. [Charitable initiatives and interventions of the Holy See during the war.] Initiatives et interventions charitables du St. Siège pendant la guerre. Revue internationale de la Croix Rouge. 1919;1:806–834.
72.
von Angerer O. [The general treatment of bullet wounds.] Ueber die Behandlung der Schusswunden im allgemeinen. Muenchner medizinische Wochenschrift. (Feldaerztliche Beilage Nr. 1). 1914:32:1–5.
73.
Vulliet H. [War surgery in a hospital at the front (continued).] La chirurgie de guerre dans un hôpital de l’avant (A suivre). Schweizerische Rundschau für Medizin. 1916;16:249–255.
74.
Weiler K. [A method for continuous drainage of deep wound cavities.] Eine Methode zur Dauerdrainage tiefer Wundhoehlen. Muenchner medizinische Wochenschrift. 1915;8:278–279.
75.
Wolf HW. [Steinmann: Developer of extended endosteal traction treatment (pin traction).Steinmann: Initiator der endostalen Dauerzugbehandlung (Nagelextension). Operative Orthopaedie und Traumatologie. 1990;2:227–231.
Metadata
Title
Swiss Contributions to War Surgery During the Great War
Author
Marcelin Oliver Draenert, PhD
Publication date
01-08-2013
Publisher
Springer US
Published in
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® / Issue 8/2013
Print ISSN: 0009-921X
Electronic ISSN: 1528-1132
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11999-013-3019-2

Other articles of this Issue 8/2013

Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® 8/2013 Go to the issue

Clinical Research

Which Functional Assessments Predict Long-term Wear After Total Hip Arthroplasty?

Erratum

Erratum to: Review of the Molecular Development of the Thumb: Digit Primera

Symposium: Advanced Hip Arthroscopy

Why Do Hip Arthroscopy Procedures Fail?

Clinical Research

Association Between Measures of Patella Height, Morphologic Features of the Trochlea, and Patellofemoral Joint Alignment: The MOST Study

Clinical Research

Results of Treatment of Femoroacetabular Impingement in Adolescents with a Surgical Hip Dislocation Approach

Obituary

Obituary: Kevin D. Harrington MD (1938–2013)