Skip to main content
Top
Published in: EcoHealth 1/2005

01-03-2005 | Original Contributions

Sustainability, Health, and the Human Population

Author: Charles W. Fowler

Published in: EcoHealth | Issue 1/2005

Login to get access

Abstract

A sustainable human population (e.g., range, density, and total numbers) is essential to health and in management. The notion of sustainability applies to all species and ecosystems and to the biosphere. Sustainability involves the health not only of individual humans, but also of ecosystems and other species. Thus, sustainability of the human population is important because of the wealth of factors involved: both the elements of systems it affects and those that contribute to its size. In this article, I address the sustainability of the human population on the basis of the argument that other species serve as examples of sustainability at the species level—an example of an application of systemic management that simultaneously accounts for complexity and achieves measurable health for individuals, species, and ecosystems. I conclude that the human population is two to four orders of magnitude larger than is optimally sustainable when compared with the populations of other mammalian species of similar body size and that this is a significant contributor to health problems for our species, other species, and ecosystems—a systemic pathology.
Literature
go back to reference Allen, TFH, Starr, TB 1982Hierarchy: Perspectives for Ecological ComplexityUniversity of Chicago PressChicago Allen, TFH, Starr, TB 1982Hierarchy: Perspectives for Ecological ComplexityUniversity of Chicago PressChicago
go back to reference American Society of Mammalogists1970Resolution on population growthJournal of Mammalogy51856 American Society of Mammalogists1970Resolution on population growthJournal of Mammalogy51856
go back to reference Aplet, GHJohnson, NOlson, JTSample, VA eds. 1993Defining Sustainable ForestryIsland PressWashington, DC Aplet, GHJohnson, NOlson, JTSample, VA eds. 1993Defining Sustainable ForestryIsland PressWashington, DC
go back to reference Arnold, AJ, Fristrup, K 1982The theory of evolution by natural selection: a hierarchical expansionPaleobiology8113129 Arnold, AJ, Fristrup, K 1982The theory of evolution by natural selection: a hierarchical expansionPaleobiology8113129
go back to reference Backus, RHBourne, DW eds. 1986Georges BankMIT PressBoston Backus, RHBourne, DW eds. 1986Georges BankMIT PressBoston
go back to reference Basset, Y, Kitching, RL 1991Species number, species abundance, and body length of arboreal arthropods associated with an Australian rainforest treeEcological Entomology16391402CrossRef Basset, Y, Kitching, RL 1991Species number, species abundance, and body length of arboreal arthropods associated with an Australian rainforest treeEcological Entomology16391402CrossRef
go back to reference Bateson, G 1972Steps to an Ecology of MindChandlerSan Francisco Bateson, G 1972Steps to an Ecology of MindChandlerSan Francisco
go back to reference Bateson, G 1979Mind and Nature: A Necessary UnityDuttonNew York Bateson, G 1979Mind and Nature: A Necessary UnityDuttonNew York
go back to reference Benyus, JM 1997Biomimicry Innovation Inspired by NatureWilliam MorrowNew York Benyus, JM 1997Biomimicry Innovation Inspired by NatureWilliam MorrowNew York
go back to reference Blackburn, TM, Harvey, PH, Pagel, MD 1990Species number, population density and body size relationships in natural communitiesJournal of Animal Ecology59335346 Blackburn, TM, Harvey, PH, Pagel, MD 1990Species number, population density and body size relationships in natural communitiesJournal of Animal Ecology59335346
go back to reference Blackburn, TM, Brown, VK, Doube, BM, Greedwood, JJD, Lawton, JH, Stork, NE 1993The relationship between abundance and body size in natural animal assemblagesJournal of Animal Ecology62519528 Blackburn, TM, Brown, VK, Doube, BM, Greedwood, JJD, Lawton, JH, Stork, NE 1993The relationship between abundance and body size in natural animal assemblagesJournal of Animal Ecology62519528
go back to reference Boulter, M 2002Extinction: Evolution and the End of ManColumbia University PressNew York Boulter, M 2002Extinction: Evolution and the End of ManColumbia University PressNew York
go back to reference Brewer, CA, Doyle, KM, Honaker, JJ, Krumm, JC, Parsons, WFJ, Schulz, TT 1992The sustainable biosphere initiative: a student critique and call to actionBulletin of the Ecological Society of America732325 Brewer, CA, Doyle, KM, Honaker, JJ, Krumm, JC, Parsons, WFJ, Schulz, TT 1992The sustainable biosphere initiative: a student critique and call to actionBulletin of the Ecological Society of America732325
go back to reference Brown, JH 1981Two decades of homage to Santa Rosalia: toward a general theory of diversityAmerican Zoologist21877888 Brown, JH 1981Two decades of homage to Santa Rosalia: toward a general theory of diversityAmerican Zoologist21877888
go back to reference Brown, JH 1984On the relationship between abundance and distribution of speciesAmerican Naturalist124255279 Brown, JH 1984On the relationship between abundance and distribution of speciesAmerican Naturalist124255279
go back to reference Brown, JH 1995MacroecologyUniversity of Chicago PressChicago Brown, JH 1995MacroecologyUniversity of Chicago PressChicago
go back to reference Brown, JH, Maurer, BA 1987Evolution of species assemblages: effects of energetic constraints and species dynamics on the diversification of the North American avifaunaAmerican Naturalist130117 Brown, JH, Maurer, BA 1987Evolution of species assemblages: effects of energetic constraints and species dynamics on the diversification of the North American avifaunaAmerican Naturalist130117
go back to reference Brown, JH, Nicoletto, PF 1991Spatial scaling of species composition: body masses of North American land mammalsAmerican Naturalist13814781512 Brown, JH, Nicoletto, PF 1991Spatial scaling of species composition: body masses of North American land mammalsAmerican Naturalist13814781512
go back to reference Campbell, DT 1974‘Downward causation’ in hierarchically organized biological systemsAyala, FJDobzhansky, T eds. Studies in Physiology of BiologyUniversity of California PressBerkeley179185 Campbell, DT 1974‘Downward causation’ in hierarchically organized biological systemsAyala, FJDobzhansky, T eds. Studies in Physiology of BiologyUniversity of California PressBerkeley179185
go back to reference Carpenter, RA 1995A consensus among ecologists for ecosystem managementBulletin of the Ecological Society of America76161162 Carpenter, RA 1995A consensus among ecologists for ecosystem managementBulletin of the Ecological Society of America76161162
go back to reference Catton, WR,Jr 1980Overshoot: The Ecological Basis of Revolutionary ChangeUniversity of Illinois PressChicago Catton, WR,Jr 1980Overshoot: The Ecological Basis of Revolutionary ChangeUniversity of Illinois PressChicago
go back to reference Christensen, NL, Bartuska, AM, Brown, JH, Carpenter, SR, D’Antonio, C, Francis, R, et al. 1996The report of the Ecological Society of America Committee on the scientific basis for ecosystem managementEcological Applications6665691 Christensen, NL, Bartuska, AM, Brown, JH, Carpenter, SR, D’Antonio, C, Francis, R,  et al. 1996The report of the Ecological Society of America Committee on the scientific basis for ecosystem managementEcological Applications6665691
go back to reference Coale, AJ 1974The history of the human populationScientific American2314051CrossRef Coale, AJ 1974The history of the human populationScientific American2314051CrossRef
go back to reference Cohen, JE 1995aPopulation growth and Earth’s human carrying capacityScience269341346 Cohen, JE 1995aPopulation growth and Earth’s human carrying capacityScience269341346
go back to reference Cohen, JE 1995bHow Many People Can the Earth Support?NortonNew York Cohen, JE 1995bHow Many People Can the Earth Support?NortonNew York
go back to reference Cohen, JE 1997Population, economics, environment and culture: an introduction to human carrying capacityJournal of Applied Ecology3413251333 Cohen, JE 1997Population, economics, environment and culture: an introduction to human carrying capacityJournal of Applied Ecology3413251333
go back to reference Colborn, T, Dumanoski, D, Myers, JP 1997Our Stolen Future: Are We Threatening Our Fertility, Intelligence, and Survival? A Scientific Detective StoryPenguin GroupNew York Colborn, T, Dumanoski, D, Myers, JP 1997Our Stolen Future: Are We Threatening Our Fertility, Intelligence, and Survival? A Scientific Detective StoryPenguin GroupNew York
go back to reference Cristoffer, C 1990Nonrandom Extinction and the Evolution and Conservation of Continental Mammal Faunas, PhD DissertationUniversity of FloridaGainesville Cristoffer, C 1990Nonrandom Extinction and the Evolution and Conservation of Continental Mammal Faunas, PhD DissertationUniversity of FloridaGainesville
go back to reference Damuth, JD 1987Interspecific allometry of population density in mammals and other animals: the independence of body mass and population energy-useBiological Journal of the Linnnean Society31193246 Damuth, JD 1987Interspecific allometry of population density in mammals and other animals: the independence of body mass and population energy-useBiological Journal of the Linnnean Society31193246
go back to reference Darwin, CG 1953The Next Million YearsDoubledayGarden City, NY Darwin, CG 1953The Next Million YearsDoubledayGarden City, NY
go back to reference Dumond, DE 1975The limitation of human population: a natural historyScience187713721 Dumond, DE 1975The limitation of human population: a natural historyScience187713721
go back to reference Ehrlich, PR 1995The scale of the human enterprise and biodiversity lossLawton, JHMay, RM eds. Extinction RatesOxford University PressNew York214226 Ehrlich, PR 1995The scale of the human enterprise and biodiversity lossLawton, JHMay, RM eds. Extinction RatesOxford University PressNew York214226
go back to reference Fowler CW (1999) Nature’s Monte Carlo experiments in sustainability. In: Proceedings of the Fifth NMFS Stock Assessment Workshop: Providing Scientific Advice to Implement the Precautionary Approach under the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, Restrepo VR (editor), U.S. Department of Commerce, NOAA Technical Memorandum, Washington, DC: National Marine Fisheries Service-40, pp 25–32 Fowler CW (1999) Nature’s Monte Carlo experiments in sustainability. In: Proceedings of the Fifth NMFS Stock Assessment Workshop: Providing Scientific Advice to Implement the Precautionary Approach under the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, Restrepo VR (editor), U.S. Department of Commerce, NOAA Technical Memorandum, Washington, DC: National Marine Fisheries Service-40, pp 25–32
go back to reference Fowler, CW 2002SustainabilityPerrin, WFWürsig, BThewissen, HGM eds. Encyclopedia of Marine MammalsAcademic PressSan Diego12051208 Fowler, CW 2002SustainabilityPerrin, WFWürsig, BThewissen, HGM eds. Encyclopedia of Marine MammalsAcademic PressSan Diego12051208
go back to reference Fowler, CW 2003Tenets, principles, and criteria for management: the basis for systemic managementMarine Fisheries Review65155 Fowler, CW 2003Tenets, principles, and criteria for management: the basis for systemic managementMarine Fisheries Review65155
go back to reference Fowler, CW, Crawford, RJM 2004Systemic management of fisheries in space and time: tradeoffs, complexity, ecosystems, sustainabilityBiosphere Conservation62542 Fowler, CW, Crawford, RJM 2004Systemic management of fisheries in space and time: tradeoffs, complexity, ecosystems, sustainabilityBiosphere Conservation62542
go back to reference Fowler, CW, Hobbs, L 2002Limits to natural variation: implications for systemic managementAnimal Biodiversity and Conservation25745 Fowler, CW, Hobbs, L 2002Limits to natural variation: implications for systemic managementAnimal Biodiversity and Conservation25745
go back to reference Fowler, CW, Hobbs, L 2003Is humanity sustainable?Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B: Biological Sciences27025792583 Fowler, CW, Hobbs, L 2003Is humanity sustainable?Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B: Biological Sciences27025792583
go back to reference Fowler, CW, MacMahon, JA 1982Selective extinction and speciation: their influence on the structure and functioning of communities and ecosystemsAmerican Naturalist119480498 Fowler, CW, MacMahon, JA 1982Selective extinction and speciation: their influence on the structure and functioning of communities and ecosystemsAmerican Naturalist119480498
go back to reference Fowler CW, Perez MA (1999) Constructing Species Frequency Distributions—A Step toward Systemic Management, NOAA Technical Memo NMFS-AFSC-109, Seattle, WA: U.S. Department of Commerce Fowler CW, Perez MA (1999) Constructing Species Frequency Distributions—A Step toward Systemic Management, NOAA Technical Memo NMFS-AFSC-109, Seattle, WA: U.S. Department of Commerce
go back to reference Fowler, CW, Smith, TD 2004Preface to the 2004 printingFowler, CWSmith, TD eds. Dynamics of Large Mammal PopulationsBlackburn PressCaldwell, NJ Fowler, CW, Smith, TD 2004Preface to the 2004 printingFowler, CWSmith, TD eds. Dynamics of Large Mammal PopulationsBlackburn PressCaldwell, NJ
go back to reference Fowler, CW, Baker, JD, Shelden, KEW, Wade, PR, DeMaster, DP, Hobbs, RC 1999Sustainability: Empirical Examples and Management Implications. Ecosystem Approaches for Fishery ManagementUniversity of Alaska Sea Grant, AK-SGFairbanks, Alaska305314 Fowler, CW, Baker, JD, Shelden, KEW, Wade, PR, DeMaster, DP, Hobbs, RC 1999Sustainability: Empirical Examples and Management Implications. Ecosystem Approaches for Fishery ManagementUniversity of Alaska Sea Grant, AK-SGFairbanks, Alaska305314
go back to reference Freedman, B 1989Environmental Ecology: The Impacts of Pollution and Other Stresses on Ecosystem Structure and FunctionAcademic PressNew York Freedman, B 1989Environmental Ecology: The Impacts of Pollution and Other Stresses on Ecosystem Structure and FunctionAcademic PressNew York
go back to reference Gaston, KJ, Blackburn, TM 2000Patterns and Process in MacroecologyBlackwellOxford Gaston, KJ, Blackburn, TM 2000Patterns and Process in MacroecologyBlackwellOxford
go back to reference Hassan, FA 1981Demographic ArcheologyAcademic PressNew York Hassan, FA 1981Demographic ArcheologyAcademic PressNew York
go back to reference Hern, WM 1993Is human culture carcinogenic for uncontrolled population growth and ecological destruction? BioScience43768773 Hern, WM 1993Is human culture carcinogenic for uncontrolled population growth and ecological destruction? BioScience43768773
go back to reference Holling, CS, Meffe, GK 1996Command and control and the pathology of natural resource managementConservation Biology10328337CrossRef Holling, CS, Meffe, GK 1996Command and control and the pathology of natural resource managementConservation Biology10328337CrossRef
go back to reference Hopfenberg, R 2003Human carrying capacity is determined by food availabilityPopulation and Environment25109117 Hopfenberg, R 2003Human carrying capacity is determined by food availabilityPopulation and Environment25109117
go back to reference Hyams, E 1976Soil and CivilizationHarper and RowNew York Hyams, E 1976Soil and CivilizationHarper and RowNew York
go back to reference Kowak, RM eds. 1991Walker’s Mammals of the World5thJohns Hopkins University PressBaltimore Kowak, RM eds. 1991Walker’s Mammals of the World5thJohns Hopkins University PressBaltimore
go back to reference LaBarbera, M 1989Analyzing body size as a factor in ecology and evolutionAnnual Review of Ecology and Systematics2097117 LaBarbera, M 1989Analyzing body size as a factor in ecology and evolutionAnnual Review of Ecology and Systematics2097117
go back to reference Law, RMcGlade, JMStokes, TK eds. 1993The Exploitation of Evolving Resources: Proceedings of an International Conference Held at Julich, Germany, Sept. 3-5, 1991 (Lecture Notes in Biomathematics, 99)Springer-VerlagBerlin Law, RMcGlade, JMStokes, TK eds. 1993The Exploitation of Evolving Resources: Proceedings of an International Conference Held at Julich, Germany, Sept. 3-5, 1991 (Lecture Notes in Biomathematics, 99)Springer-VerlagBerlin
go back to reference Lawton, JH 1989What is the relationship between population density and body size in animals?Oikos55429434 Lawton, JH 1989What is the relationship between population density and body size in animals?Oikos55429434
go back to reference Levinton, JS 1988Genetics, Paleontology, and MacroevolutionCambridge University PressNew York Levinton, JS 1988Genetics, Paleontology, and MacroevolutionCambridge University PressNew York
go back to reference Livingston, PA 1993Importance of predation by groundfish, marine mammals and birds on walleye pollock Theragra chalcogramma and Pacific herring Clupea pallasi in the eastern Bering SeaMarine Ecology Progress Series102205215 Livingston, PA 1993Importance of predation by groundfish, marine mammals and birds on walleye pollock Theragra chalcogramma and Pacific herring Clupea pallasi in the eastern Bering SeaMarine Ecology Progress Series102205215
go back to reference Ludwig, D 1993Environmental sustainability: magic, science and religion in natural resource managementEcological Applications3555558 Ludwig, D 1993Environmental sustainability: magic, science and religion in natural resource managementEcological Applications3555558
go back to reference Mangel, M, Talbot, LM, Meffe, GK, Agardy, MT, Alverson, DL, Barlow, J, et al. 1996Principles for the conservation of wild living resourcesEcological Applications6338362 Mangel, M, Talbot, LM, Meffe, GK, Agardy, MT, Alverson, DL, Barlow, J,  et al. 1996Principles for the conservation of wild living resourcesEcological Applications6338362
go back to reference May, RM 1986The search for patterns in the balance of nature: advances and retreatsEcology6711151126 May, RM 1986The search for patterns in the balance of nature: advances and retreatsEcology6711151126
go back to reference Meffe, GK 1994Human population control: the missing awarenessConservation Biology8310313 Meffe, GK 1994Human population control: the missing awarenessConservation Biology8310313
go back to reference Meffe, GK, Ehrlich, AH, Ehrenfeld, DJ 1993Human population control: the missing agendaConservation Biology713 Meffe, GK, Ehrlich, AH, Ehrenfeld, DJ 1993Human population control: the missing agendaConservation Biology713
go back to reference Nash, J 1950Non-cooperative Games, PhD ThesisMathematics Department, Princeton UniversityPrinceton, MA Nash, J 1950Non-cooperative Games, PhD ThesisMathematics Department, Princeton UniversityPrinceton, MA
go back to reference Pagel, MD, May, RM, Collie, AR 1991Ecological aspects of the geographical distribution and diversity of mammalian speciesAmerican Naturalist137791815 Pagel, MD, May, RM, Collie, AR 1991Ecological aspects of the geographical distribution and diversity of mammalian speciesAmerican Naturalist137791815
go back to reference Peters, RH 1983The Ecological Implications of Body SizeCambridge University PressNew York Peters, RH 1983The Ecological Implications of Body SizeCambridge University PressNew York
go back to reference Ponting, C 1991A Green History of the World: The Environment and the Collapse of Great CivilizationsSinclair-StevensonLondon Ponting, C 1991A Green History of the World: The Environment and the Collapse of Great CivilizationsSinclair-StevensonLondon
go back to reference Pulliam, HR, Haddad, NM 1994Human population growth and the carrying capacity conceptBulletin of the Ecological Society of America75141157 Pulliam, HR, Haddad, NM 1994Human population growth and the carrying capacity conceptBulletin of the Ecological Society of America75141157
go back to reference Ricker, WE 1973Linear regression in fishery researchJournal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada30409434 Ricker, WE 1973Linear regression in fishery researchJournal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada30409434
go back to reference Ricker, WE 1984Computation and uses of central trend linesCanadian Journal of Zoology6218971905CrossRef Ricker, WE 1984Computation and uses of central trend linesCanadian Journal of Zoology6218971905CrossRef
go back to reference Ridgway, SHHarrison, RJ eds. 1981Handbook of Marine Mammals, Vol 1: The Walrus, Sea Lions, Fur Seals and Sea OttersAcademic PressNew York Ridgway, SHHarrison, RJ eds. 1981Handbook of Marine Mammals, Vol 1: The Walrus, Sea Lions, Fur Seals and Sea OttersAcademic PressNew York
go back to reference Rosenzweig, ML 1974And Replenish the Earth: The Evolution, Consequences, and Prevention of OverpopulationHarper and RowNew York Rosenzweig, ML 1974And Replenish the Earth: The Evolution, Consequences, and Prevention of OverpopulationHarper and RowNew York
go back to reference Rosenzweig, ML 1995Species Diversity in Space and TimeCambridge University PressNew York Rosenzweig, ML 1995Species Diversity in Space and TimeCambridge University PressNew York
go back to reference Salthe, SN 1985Evolving Hierarchical Systems: Their Structure and RepresentationColumbia University PressNew York Salthe, SN 1985Evolving Hierarchical Systems: Their Structure and RepresentationColumbia University PressNew York
go back to reference Santos, MA 1990Managing Planet Earth: Perspectives on Population, Ecology, and the LawBergin and GarveyNew York Santos, MA 1990Managing Planet Earth: Perspectives on Population, Ecology, and the LawBergin and GarveyNew York
go back to reference Schoenly, K, Beaver, RA, Heumier, TA 1991On the trophic relations of insects: a food-web approachAmerican Naturalist137597638 Schoenly, K, Beaver, RA, Heumier, TA 1991On the trophic relations of insects: a food-web approachAmerican Naturalist137597638
go back to reference Sieving, K, Bechta, S, Burmester, D, Casazza, M, Finan, M, Hunting, J, et al. 1994The population crisis demands a focused agendaConservation Biology8303307 Sieving, K, Bechta, S, Burmester, D, Casazza, M, Finan, M, Hunting, J,  et al. 1994The population crisis demands a focused agendaConservation Biology8303307
go back to reference Sinclair, ARE 1996Mammal populations: fluctuation, regulation, life history theory and their implications for conservationFloyd, RBSheppard, AWDe Barro, PJ eds. Frontiers of Population EcologyCSIRO PublishingMelbourne127154 Sinclair, ARE 1996Mammal populations: fluctuation, regulation, life history theory and their implications for conservationFloyd, RBSheppard, AWDe Barro, PJ eds. Frontiers of Population EcologyCSIRO PublishingMelbourne127154
go back to reference Slatkin, M 1981A diffusion model of species selectionPaleobiology7421425 Slatkin, M 1981A diffusion model of species selectionPaleobiology7421425
go back to reference Spencer, PD, Collie, JS 1997Patterns of population variability in marine fish stocksFisheries Oceanography6188204 Spencer, PD, Collie, JS 1997Patterns of population variability in marine fish stocksFisheries Oceanography6188204
go back to reference Stanley, TR 1995Ecosystem management and the arrogance of humanismConservation Biology9255262CrossRef Stanley, TR 1995Ecosystem management and the arrogance of humanismConservation Biology9255262CrossRef
go back to reference Union of Concerned Scientists (1992) World Scientists’ Warning to Humanity. Cambridge, MA: Union of Concerned Scientists, Available: http://www.ucsusa.org/ucs/about/page.cfm?pageID= 1009 Union of Concerned Scientists (1992) World Scientists’ Warning to Humanity. Cambridge, MA: Union of Concerned Scientists, Available: http://​www.​ucsusa.​org/​ucs/​about/​page.​cfm?​pageID=​ 1009
go back to reference Walters, C 1986Adaptive Management of Renewable ResourcesMacmillanNew York Walters, C 1986Adaptive Management of Renewable ResourcesMacmillanNew York
go back to reference Walters, C 1992Perspectives on adaptive policy design in fisheries managementJain, SKBotsford, LW eds. Applied Population BiologyKluwer AcademicDordrecht, The Netherlands249262 Walters, C 1992Perspectives on adaptive policy design in fisheries managementJain, SKBotsford, LW eds. Applied Population BiologyKluwer AcademicDordrecht, The Netherlands249262
go back to reference Wilber, K 1995Sex, Ecology, Spirituality: The Spirit of EvolutionShambhala PublicationsBoston Wilber, K 1995Sex, Ecology, Spirituality: The Spirit of EvolutionShambhala PublicationsBoston
go back to reference Zeide, B 1996Is “the scientific basis” of ecosystem management indeed scientific?Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America77123124 Zeide, B 1996Is “the scientific basis” of ecosystem management indeed scientific?Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America77123124
Metadata
Title
Sustainability, Health, and the Human Population
Author
Charles W. Fowler
Publication date
01-03-2005
Publisher
Springer-Verlag
Published in
EcoHealth / Issue 1/2005
Print ISSN: 1612-9202
Electronic ISSN: 1612-9210
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10393-004-0078-6

Other articles of this Issue 1/2005

EcoHealth 1/2005 Go to the issue

OriginalPaper

Acknowledgments