Top

International Journal of Legal Medicine

Published in:

01-03-2016 | Original Article

Renaissance of criticism on the concept of brain death—the role of legal medicine in the context of the interdisciplinary discussion

Authors: L. Markert, B. Bockholdt, M. A. Verhoff, S. Heinze, M. Parzeller

Published in: International Journal of Legal Medicine | Issue 2/2016

Abstract

Background

In the practice of legal medicine in Germany, the assessment of brain death is of minor importance and attracts little attention. However, since several years, international criticism on the concept of brain death has culminated. By reviewing literature and the results of a questionnaire distributed among the participants of the 93rd Annual Congress of the Germany Society of Legal Medicine, the state of knowledge and the current views on brain death were evaluated.

Materials and methods

Literature search of recent publications regarding brain death was performed (PubMed database, references of legal medicine, Report of the President’s Council on Bioethics, USA 2008). A questionnaire was developed and distributed among the participants of the Congress.

Results

The assumption that individual and brain death are synonymous is criticized. Internationally, there are trends to harmonize the very different clinical criteria to assess brain death. The diagnostic advantage of novel techniques such as CT angiography is controversially discussed. It becomes apparent that procedures which record the blood flow and perfusion of the brain will be applied more in the future. Regrettably, these developments are not described in the literature of legal medicine. Moreover, among German forensic scientists, different views concerning brain death exist. The majority favors its equivalent treatment with individual death. The thanatological background can be improved concerning certain aspects of brain death as well as its legal implications.

Conclusion

Teaching and research in legal medicine should include the subject brain death. Expertise in forensic science may contribute to the interdisciplinary discussion on brain death. The transfer of actual knowledge, also on disputed ethical aspects of thanatology, to physicians of all disciplines is of great importance.

President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research (1981) Defining death. https://repository.library.georgetown.edu/handle/10822/559345. Accessed 6 Mar 2015

President’s Council on Bioethics (2008) Controversies in the determination of death: a white paper by the President’s Council on Bioethics. https://bioethicsarchive.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/death/. Accessed 6 Mar 2015

Shewmon DA (2009) Brain death: can it be resuscitated? Issues Law Med 25:3–14PubMed

Truog RD, Miller FG (2014) Defining death: the importance of scientific candor and transparency. Intensive Care Med 40:885–7. doi:10.1007/s00134-014-3301-0 CrossRefPubMed

Joffe AR (2009) Brain death is not death: a critique of the concept, criterion, and tests of brain death. Rev Neurosci 20:187–98CrossRefPubMed

Zuckier LS, Kolano J (2008) Radionuclide studies in the determination of brain death: criteria, concepts, and controversies. Semin Nucl Med 38:262–73. doi:10.1053/j.semnuclmed.2008.03.003 CrossRefPubMed

Wijdicks EFM (2010) The case against confirmatory tests for determining brain death in adults. Neurology 75:77–83. doi:10.1212/WNL.0b013e3181e62194 CrossRefPubMed

Shemie SD, Hornby L, Baker A, Teitelbaum J, Torrance S, Young K, Capron AM, Bernat JL, Noel L (2014) International guideline development for the determination of death. Intensive Care Med 40:788–97. doi:10.1007/s00134-014-3242-7 PubMedCentralCrossRefPubMed

Wijdicks EFM (2002) Brain death worldwide: accepted fact but no global consensus in diagnostic criteria. Neurology 58:20–5CrossRefPubMed

10.

Bernat JL (2008) How can we achieve uniformity in brain death determinations? Neurology 70:252–3. doi:10.1212/01.wnl.0000298089.91799.b5 CrossRefPubMed

11.

Smith M (2012) Brain death: time for an international consensus. Br J Anaesth 108 Suppl:i6–9. doi:10.1093/bja/aer355

12.

Citerio G, Crippa IA, Bronco A, Vargiolu A, Smith M (2014) Variability in brain death determination in Europe: looking for a solution. Neurocrit Care 21:376–82. doi:10.1007/s12028-014-9983-x CrossRefPubMed

13.

Markert L, Bockholdt B, Verhoff MA, Parzeller M (2014) Im Vorfeld der 4. Fortschreibung der Richtlinien zur Feststellung des Hirntods. Rechtsmedizin 24:272–282. doi:10.1007/s00194-014-0971-4 CrossRef

14.

Parzeller M, Dettmeyer R (2008) Der Nachweis des Todes bei der postmortalen Gewebespende: Unvollständige und praxisuntaugliche Vorgaben. StoffR 2008:288–297

15.

Parzeller M, Henze C (2006) Richtlinienkompetenz zur Hirntod-Feststellung erneut bei Bundesärztekammer - Sind Demokratie- und Wesentlichkeitsprinzip hirntot? ZRP 39:176–180

16.

Choi E-K, Fredland V, Zachodni C, Lammers JE, Bledsoe P, Helft PR (2008) Brain death revisited: the case for a national standard. J Law Med Ethics 36(824–36):611. doi:10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00340.x

17.

Nair-Collins M (2010) Death, brain death, and the limits of science: why the whole-brain concept of death is a flawed public policy. J Law Med Ethics 38:667–83. doi:10.1111/j.1748-720X.2010.00520.x CrossRefPubMed

18.

Ishikawa T, Michiue T, Quan L, Zhao D, Komatsu A, Bessho Y, Maeda H (2009) Morphological and functional alterations in the adenohypophysis in cases of brain death. Legal Med (Tokyo) 11(Suppl 1):S234–7. doi:10.1016/j.legalmed.2009.03.005 CrossRef

19.

Jousset N, Gaudin A, Mauillon D, Penneau M, Rougé-Maillart C (2009) Organ donation in France: legislation, epidemiology and ethical comments. Med Sci Law 49:191–9CrossRefPubMed

20.

Molina DK, McCutcheon JR, Rulon JJ (2009) Head injuries, pentobarbital, and the determination of death. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 30:75–7. doi:10.1097/PAF.0b013e31818738dd CrossRefPubMed

21.

Okii Y, Akane A, Kawamoto K, Iwase M, Yoshida M, Mitani T, Yoshimura S, Tokiyasu T, Kobayashi T (2009) The proof of flat-line scalp EEGs of brain dead patients by an automatic EEG analysis system. Legal Med (Tokyo) 11(Suppl 1):S401–3. doi:10.1016/j.legalmed.2009.01.084 CrossRef

22.

Beltramello A, Ricciardi GK, Pizzini FB, Piovan E (2010) Updates in the determination of brain death. Neuroradiol J 23:145–50CrossRefPubMed

23.

Joffe AR, Anton N, Mehta V (2007) A survey to determine the understanding of the conceptual basis and diagnostic tests used for brain death by neurosurgeons in Canada. Neurosurgery 61:1039–45. doi:10.1227/01.neu.0000303200.84994.ae, discussion 1046–7 CrossRefPubMed

24.

Joffe AR, Anton NR, Duff JP, Decaen A (2012) A survey of American neurologists about brain death: understanding the conceptual basis and diagnostic tests for brain death. Ann Intensive Care 2:4. doi:10.1186/2110-5820-2-4 PubMedCentralCrossRefPubMed

25.

Wissenschaftlicher Beirat der Bundesärztekammer (1998) Richtlinien zur Feststellung des Hirntodes (Dritte Fortschreibung). Dtsch Ärztebl 95:A1861–A1868

26.

Bernat JL, Culver CM, Gert B (1981) On the definition and criterion of death. Ann Intern Med 94:389–94CrossRefPubMed

27.

Feinendegen N, Höver G (2013) Der Hirntod – Ein “zweites Fenster” auf den Tod des Menschen? Zum Neuansatz in der Debatte um das neurologische Kriterium durch den US-Bioethikrat. Königshausen & Neumann, pp 69–77, 104–128

28.

Bernat JL (1998) A defense of the whole-brain concept of death. Hastings Cent Rep 28:14–23CrossRefPubMed

29.

Soifer B, Gelb AW (1989) The multiple organ donor: identification and management. Ann Intern Med 110:814–23CrossRefPubMed

30.

Shewmon DA (1998) Chronic “brain death”: meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology 51:1538–45CrossRefPubMed

31.

Shewmon AD (2001) The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating “brain death” with death. J Med Philos 26:457–78. doi:10.1076/jmep.26.5.457.3000 CrossRefPubMed

32.

Truog RD, Robinson WM (2003) Role of brain death and the dead-donor rule in the ethics of organ transplantation. Crit Care Med 31:2391–6. doi:10.1097/01.CCM.0000090869.19410.3C CrossRefPubMed

33.

Truog RD, Miller FG (2012) “Brain death” is a useful fiction. Crit Care Med 40:1393–4. doi:10.1097/CCM.0b013e3182451a08, author reply 1394 CrossRefPubMed

34.

Wijdicks EF, Bernat JL (1999) Chronic “brain death”: meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology 53:1369–70, author reply 1371–2 CrossRefPubMed

35.

Bernat JL (2006) The whole-brain concept of death remains optimum public policy. J Law Med Ethics 34(35–43):3. doi:10.1111/j.1748-720X.2006.00006.x

36.

Magnus DC, Wilfond BS, Caplan AL (2014) Accepting brain death. N Engl J Med 370:891–4. doi:10.1056/NEJMp1400930 CrossRefPubMed

37.

Brugger EC (2013) D. Alan Shewmon and the PCBE’s White Paper on Brain Death: are brain-dead patients dead? J Med Philos 38:205–18. doi:10.1093/jmp/jht009 CrossRefPubMed

38.

Zamperetti N, Bellomo R (2009) Total brain failure: a new contribution by the President’s Council on Bioethics to the definition of death according to the neurological standard. Intensive Care Med 35:1305–7. doi:10.1007/s00134-009-1499-z CrossRefPubMed

39.

Deutscher Ethikrat (2015) Hirntod und Entscheidung zur Organspende. http://www.ethikrat.org/dateien/pdf/stellungnahme-hirntod-und-entscheidung-zur-organspende.pdf. Accessed 6 Mar 2015

40.

Pallis C (1982) ABC of brain stem death. From brain death to brain stem death. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 285:1487–90CrossRef

41.

Academy of Medical Royal Colleges (2008) A code of practice for the diagnosis and confirmation of death. http://www.bts.org.uk/Documents/A%20CODE%20OF%20PRACTICE%20FOR%20THE%20DIAGNOSIS%20AND%20CONFIRMATION%20OF%20DEATH.pdf. Accessed 6 Mar 2015

42.

Karakatsanis KG, Tsanakas JN (2002) A critique on the concept of “brain death”. Issues Law Med 18:127–41PubMed

43.

Joffe A (2010) Are recent defences of the brain death concept adequate? Bioethics 24:47–53. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8519.2008.00709.x CrossRefPubMed

44.

Wijdicks EFM, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM (2010) Evidence-based guideline update: determining brain death in adults: report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology 74:1911–8. doi:10.1212/WNL.0b013e3181e242a8 CrossRefPubMed

45.

Wijdicks EFM, Pfeifer EA (2008) Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology 70:1234–7. doi:10.1212/01.wnl.0000289762.50376.b6 CrossRefPubMed

46.

Evans DW (2009) Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology 72:677. doi:10.1212/01.wnl.0000339390.48966.e2, author reply 677–8 CrossRefPubMed

47.

Potts M (2009) Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology 72:677, author reply 677–8 CrossRefPubMed

48.

Suzuki Y, Mogami Y, Toribe Y, Yamada K, Yanagihara K, Hirata I, Mano T (2012) Prolonged elevation of serum neuron-specific enolase in children after clinical diagnosis of brain death. J Child Neurol 27:7–10. doi:10.1177/0883073811416663 CrossRefPubMed

49.

Young GB, Lee D (2004) A critique of ancillary tests for brain death. Neurocrit Care 1:499–508. doi:10.1385/NCC:1:4:499 CrossRefPubMed

50.

Welschehold S, Boor S, Reuland K, Thömke F, Kerz T, Reuland A, Beyer C, Gartenschläger M, Wagner W, Giese A, Müller-Forell W (2012) Technical aids in the diagnosis of brain death: a comparison of SEP, AEP, EEG, TCD and CT angiography. Dtsch Arztebl Int 109:624–30. doi:10.3238/arztebl.2012.0624 PubMedCentralPubMed

51.

Hoffmann O, Masuhr F (2014) Zugang zur Hirntoddiagnostik. Nervenarzt 85:1573–81. doi:10.1007/s00115-014-4171-y CrossRefPubMed

52.

Young GB, Shemie SD, Doig CJ, Teitelbaum J (2006) Brief review: the role of ancillary tests in the neurological determination of death. Can J Anaesth 53:620–7. doi:10.1007/BF03021855 CrossRefPubMed

53.

Canadian Council for Donation and Transplantation (2003) Severe brain injury to neurological determination of death: a Canadian forum. Report and Recommendations. http://www.giftoflife.on.ca/resources/pdf/SevereBrainInjury.pdf. Accessed 6 Mar 2015

54.

Lustbader D, O’Hara D, Wijdicks EFM, MacLean L, Tajik W, Ying A, Berg E, Goldstein M (2011) Second brain death examination may negatively affect organ donation. Neurology 76:119–24. doi:10.1212/WNL.0b013e3182061b0c CrossRefPubMed

55.

Varelas PN, Rehman M, Abdelhak T, Patel A, Rai V, Barber A, Sommer S, Corry JJ, Venkatasubba Rao CP (2011) Single brain death examination is equivalent to dual brain death examinations. Neurocrit Care 15:547–53. doi:10.1007/s12028-011-9561-4 CrossRefPubMed

56.

Joffe AR, Rady MY, Verheijde JL (2011) Second brain death examination may negatively affect organ donation. Neurology 77:1314–6. doi:10.1212/WNL.0b013e31822944fb, author reply 1315–6 CrossRefPubMed

57.

Uwano I, Kudo K, Sasaki M, Christensen S, Østergaard L, Ogasawara K, Ogawa A (2012) CT and MR perfusion can discriminate severe cerebral hypoperfusion from perfusion absence: evaluation of different commercial software packages by using digital phantoms. Neuroradiology 54:467–74. doi:10.1007/s00234-011-0905-8 CrossRefPubMed

58.

Roberts DJ, MacCulloch KAM, Versnick EJ, Hall RI (2010) Should ancillary brain blood flow analyses play a larger role in the neurological determination of death? Can J Anaesth 57:927–35. doi:10.1007/s12630-010-9359-4 CrossRefPubMed

59.

Busl KM, Greer DM (2009) Pitfalls in the diagnosis of brain death. Neurocrit Care 11:276–87. doi:10.1007/s12028-009-9231-y CrossRefPubMed

60.

Sawicki M, Bohatyrewicz R, Walecka A, Sołek-Pastuszka J, Rowiński O, Walecki J (2014) CT angiography in the diagnosis of brain death. Pol J Radiol 79:417–21. doi:10.12659/PJR.891114 PubMedCentralCrossRefPubMed

61.

Munari M, Zucchetta P, Carollo C, Gallo F, De Nardin M, Marzola MC, Ferretti S, Facco E (2005) Confirmatory tests in the diagnosis of brain death: comparison between SPECT and contrast angiography. Crit Care Med 33:2068–73CrossRefPubMed

62.

Karantanas AH, Hadjigeorgiou GM, Paterakis K, Sfiras D, Komnos A (2002) Contribution of MRI and MR angiography in early diagnosis of brain death. Eur Radiol 12:2710–6. doi:10.1007/s00330-002-1336-z PubMed

63.

Frampas E, Videcoq M, de Kerviler E, Ricolfi F, Kuoch V, Mourey F, Tenaillon A, Dupas B (2009) CT angiography for brain death diagnosis. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 30:1566–70. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A1614 CrossRefPubMed

64.

Kramer AH, Roberts DJ (2014) Computed tomography angiography in the diagnosis of brain death: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Neurocrit Care 21:539–50. doi:10.1007/s12028-014-9997-4 CrossRefPubMed

65.

Berenguer CM, Davis FE, Howington JU (2010) Brain death confirmation: comparison of computed tomographic angiography with nuclear medicine perfusion scan. J Trauma 68:553–9. doi:10.1097/TA.0b013e3181cef18a CrossRefPubMed

66.

Dupas B, Gayet-Delacroix M, Villers D, Antonioli D, Veccherini MF, Soulillou JP (1998) Diagnosis of brain death using two-phase spiral CT. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 19:641–7PubMed

Title: Renaissance of criticism on the concept of brain death—the role of legal medicine in the context of the interdisciplinary discussion
Authors: L. Markert
B. Bockholdt
M. A. Verhoff
S. Heinze
M. Parzeller
Publication date: 01-03-2016
Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Published in: International Journal of Legal Medicine / Issue 2/2016
Print ISSN: 0937-9827
Electronic ISSN: 1437-1596
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-015-1224-0

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on medication adherence

Springer Medicine

Renaissance of criticism on the concept of brain death—the role of legal medicine in the context of the interdisciplinary discussion

Abstract

Background

Materials and methods

Results

Conclusion

Keynote webinar | Spotlight on medication adherence

Springer Medicine

Abstract

Background

Materials and methods

Results

Conclusion

Please log in to get access to this content

Other articles of this Issue 2/2016

Detection of the ethanol consumption markers ethyl glucuronide and ethyl sulfate in urine samples from inmates of two German prisons

Genetic investigation of sudden unexpected death in epilepsy cohort by panel target resequencing

Postmortem degradation of skeletal muscle proteins: a novel approach to determine the time since death

Postmortem redistribution of the heroin metabolites morphine and morphine-3-glucuronide in rabbits over 24 h

Phosphatidylethanol (PEth) in blood samples from “driving under the influence” cases as indicator for prolonged excessive alcohol consumption

Response of forest soil euglyphid testate amoebae (Rhizaria: Cercozoa) to pig cadavers assessed by high-throughput sequencing