Top

Israel Journal of Health Policy Research

Published in:

Open Access 01-12-2020 | Care | Integrative article

From civilian service to military service: what led policy-makers to remove nursing care from field units of the Israeli defense force (IDF) and return it later?

Author: Ronen Segev

Published in: Israel Journal of Health Policy Research | Issue 1/2020

Abstract

Background

From the very onset, Israeli military nurses served in supporting positions on the front lines, shoulder to shoulder with men. When the IDF was established in 1948, nurses were sent to serve near areas of conflict and were not included in compulsory military service in field units. Once the military hospitals were closed in 1949, nursing in the Medical Corps lost a clear military purpose, and its main contribution was in the civilian arena. From 1949 until 2000, most recruited military nurses operated their mandatory service mainly in a civilian framework according to the integration agreement between the ministry of defense to the ministry of health. Between 2000 to 2018, military nurses served at home front military clinics and in headquarters jobs at the Medicine Corps. In2018, the Medical Corps decided to integrate military nurses into the Israeli military service in order to cope with the shortage of military physicians, among other things, and ensure appropriate availability of medical and health services for military units.. This study examines, for the first time, the considerations that led to the closure of military hospitals and the transfer of the military service of nurses in the IDF to the Ministry of Health in 1949 and the decision in 2018 to return the military nurses to the field’s military battalions.

Methods

The study was based on an analysis of documents from the IDF archives, the Israeli parliament archive, the David Ben-Gurion archive, articles from periodical newspapers, and interviews with nurses and partners in the Israeli Medical Corps.

Results

During almost 70 years, Israeli military nursing’s main contribution was to the civilian hospitals. The return of nursing care to the IDF field units in recent years intended to supplement the medicine corps demands in field units by placing qualified academic nurses.

Conclusions

The removal of nursing care from the IDF field units was provided as a response to the needs of the health demands of the emerging state. Until 2018 there was no significant need for military nurses except in emergency time. This is in contrast to other military nursing units.

Telford JC. The American nursing shortage during world war I: the debate over the use of nurses' aid. Bull Can Hist Med. 2010;27:85–99.

Sarnecky MT. A history of the U.S. Army nurse corps. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 1999.

Piggott P. Queen Alexandra's Royal Army Nursing Corps. London: Leo Cooper Ltd; 1990. p. 41–5.

Toman C. Sister soldiers of the great war: the nurses of the Canadian Army medical corps. Vancouver: The University of British Columbia; 2016. p. 3–17.

Brooks J, Hallett C, editors. One hundred years of wartime nursing practices, 1854–1953. Manchester: Manchester University Press; 2015.

Toman C. Help us, serve England: first world war military nursing and national identities. Bull Can Med Hist. 2013;30:143–66.

Segev R. The Israeli Defense Forces' nursing development between 1948–1983. [PhD dissertation] Tel-Aviv University, 2018 [Hebrew].

Bondi R. Sheba, Every man's physician. Tel Aviv: Zmora, Bitan, Modan; 1981. p. 108 [Hebrew].

Gelber Y. A core for a regular service Hebrew military. Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi; 1986. p. 318. (including note 403)

10.

Horowitz B. Every soldier's a front: the military's medical service in the Land of Israel and the State of Israel during the Arab-Israeli War 1947–1949. Tel Aviv: Ministry of Defense; 2000. p. 48–51. [Hebrew]

11.

Ostfeld Z. An army is born. Tel Aviv: Ministry of Defense; 1994. p. 423–8. [Hebrew]

12.

Military hospitals' nurses workforce list. IDF Archives. 1948. File 179/121/1950.

13.

Grissaro Y. The service of women at IDF: historical view. In: Yechzek’eli P, editor. Gender and military. Tel Aviv: Ministry of Defense; 2010. p. 9–14. [Hebrew].

14.

Jerby I. The double price: women status and military service in Israel. Tel Aviv: Ramot and Tel Aviv University; 1996. p. 65–72. [Hebrew]

15.

Structure of the Women’s Corps. IDF Archives. Undated. File 435/1308/1950, 139–146 [Hebrew].

16.

Miriam, a booklet in memory of Miriam Kaufer. Published by the family; 2004.

17.

Pe’er M. Capable woman: landmarks in Ruchama Rosenberg Lachman's life: nurse, nursing teacher, and a feminist before her time. Bar’am: Korot; 2006. p. 48–55.

18.

Steiner-Freud Y. Leaders in nursing in Israel: Malka Zagagi [lecture]. Yehudit Steiner-Freud Collection. 2008 [Hebrew].

19.

Segev R. Nurses in arms: the service of the IDF nurses in the first years of the State, olive leaves and sword: studies in the security of the Yishuv and the State of Israel; 2018. p. 173–92. [Hebrew]

20.

Y. Amir to the head of the minister of defense’ headquarters: “comments on Mrs. ben-Nun’s letter”. IDF archives. 15 Apr 1959. File 34/799/1960, 180.

21.

Hospital number 5, Activity reports 1952–1959: summary of the meeting at the Minister of Defense from 28 Aug 1949 about the medical service. Ben-Gurion Archive. File 417, 1–2 [Hebrew].

22.

Eliezer Perry (CEO, Ministry of Defense) to Lieutenant Colonel Dr. Scheiber: the transference of the military hospitals to the authority of the Ministry of Health”. IDF Archives 20 Apr 1949. File 433/1308/1950, 11–13 [Hebrew].

23.

Eliezer Perry’s letter to Lieutenant Colonel Dr. Scheiber. IDF Archives. 8 May 1949. File 176/776/1953, 960 [Hebrew].

24.

Medical Corps’ action report from February 1949 to Sept 1949. IDF Archives. File 125/776/1958, 4–8 [Hebrew].

25.

Nadav D. White and khaki: The history of the medical corps. Tel-Aviv: Ministry of Defense; 2000. p. 73–8. [Hebrew]

26.

Major General Moshe Tzadok, General Staff Officer for general preparations for emergencies, to the CEO of the Ministry of Defense: “Agreement for the inclusion of military hospitalization in general hospitalization in governmental hospitals”. IDF Archives. 5 Feb 1957. File 137/20/1974, 20–22 [Hebrew].

27.

Aliza Toledano [interview]. 6 Nov 2015.

28.

Colonel Menachem Kfir, assistant to the head medical officer, to the vice president of the Ministry of Health: “regular service certified nurses: prolonging the agreement”. IDF archives. 5 July 1976. File 35/72/1982, 54.

29.

Colonel Menachem Kfir to vice president HRU: “Recruitment of certified nurses to IDF under regular service conditions”. IDF Archives. 31 Aug 1975. File 50/64/2012, 33 [Hebrew].

30.

Margalit G, Rosen Y, Tekes-Manova D, Golan M, Benedek P, Levi Y, Martonovits G, Bar-Dayan Y. Recommendations for nursing requirements at a field hospital, based on the Israel defense forces field hospital at the earthquake disaster in Turkey-august 1999. Accid Emerg Nurs. 2002;10(4):217–20.CrossRefPubMed

31.

Lieutenant Colonel Gila Shoval, Nursing unit headquarters, to the assistant to the head medical officer: "A proposal - service track for registered nurses in the Medical Corps". IDF Archives. 12 Jan 1999. File 9/10/2013.

32.

Sasson-Levy O. Research on gender and the military in Israel from a gendered organization to inequality regimes. Isr Stud Rev. 2011;26(2):73–98.

33.

Sasson-Levy O. Feminism and military gender practices: Israeli women soldiers in "masculine" roles. Sociol Inq. 2003;73(3):440–65.CrossRef

34.

Horowitz PK, Shemesh AA, Horev T. Is there a doctor in the house? Availability of Israeli physicians to the workforce. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2017;6(31):1–9.

35.

Hartal M, Yavnai N, Yaniv G, Gertz SD, Flescher E, Kriess Y. Old challenges and new perspectives on developing military physicians: the first 4 years of the new Israeli model. Mil Med. 2016;181(2):129–35.CrossRefPubMed

36.

Shrier E, Yavnai N, Nissim S, Mezan R. Expanding nurse's authorities in the IDF: The future is still ahead of us. Ahot Beyisrael. 2016;199:8–14 [Hebrew].

37.

Elizera R. Nurse for arms: the Medical Corps increases the number of students in nursing studies by five times, and for the first time combines those who have been trained as nurses in combat units. 2018. ynet. http://m.yediot.co.il/Articles/5084146. Accessed 22 Aug 2019.

Title: From civilian service to military service: what led policy-makers to remove nursing care from field units of the Israeli defense force (IDF) and return it later?
Author: Ronen Segev
Publication date: 01-12-2020
Publisher: BioMed Central
Keyword: Care
Published in: Israel Journal of Health Policy Research / Issue 1/2020
Electronic ISSN: 2045-4015
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13584-019-0360-2

At a glance: The ONWARDS insulin icodec trials

Springer Medicine

From civilian service to military service: what led policy-makers to remove nursing care from field units of the Israeli defense force (IDF) and return it later?

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusions

At a glance: The ONWARDS insulin icodec trials

Springer Medicine

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusions

Please log in to get access to this content

Other articles of this Issue 1/2020

Sex for seniors: how physicians discuss older adult’s sexuality

Association between trust in the public healthcare system and selecting a surgeon in public hospitals in Israel: a cross-sectional population study

Enhancing primary care and preventive services through Interprofessional practice and education

A COVID-19 call center for healthcare providers: dealing with rapidly evolving health policy guidelines

Lessons learned from an evaluation of referrals to the emergency department

The patient–physician relationship: an account of the physician’s perspective