Published in:
Open Access
01-12-2021 | Scientific Contribution
The case for biotechnological exceptionalism
Author:
Jan-Hendrik Heinrichs
Published in:
Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
|
Issue 4/2021
Login to get access
Abstract
Do biomedical interventions raise special moral concerns? A rising number of prominent authors claim that at least in the case of biomedical enhancement they do not. Treating biomedical enhancements different from non-biomedical ones, they claim, amounts to unjustified biomedical exceptionalism. This article vindicates the familiar thesis that biomedical enhancement raises specific concerns. Taking a close look at the argumentative strategy against biomedical exceptionalism and provides counterexamples showing that the biomedical mode of interventions raises concerns not relevant otherwise. In particular, biomedical interventions throughout raise concerns of informed consent, which only rarely turn up in comparable non-biomedical interventions.