Top

Published in:

Open Access 01-12-2011 | original paper

‘There is a Time to be Born and a Time to Die’ (Ecclesiastes 3:2a): Jewish Perspectives on Euthanasia

Authors: Goedele Baeke, Jean-Pierre Wils, Bert Broeckaert

Published in: Journal of Religion and Health | Issue 4/2011

Abstract

Reviewing the publications of prominent American rabbis who have (extensively) published on Jewish biomedical ethics, this article highlights Orthodox, Conservative and Reform opinions on a most pressing contemporary bioethical issue: euthanasia. Reviewing their opinions against the background of the halachic character of Jewish (biomedical) ethics, this article shows how from one traditional Jewish textual source diverse, even contradictory, opinions emerge through different interpretations. In this way, in the Jewish debate on euthanasia the specific methodology of Jewish (bio)ethical reasoning comes forward as well as a diversity of opinion within Judaism and its branches.

Interdisciplinary Centre for the Study of Religion and World View (Catholic University Leuven, Belgium). Website: http://theo.kuleuven.be/page/icsrw.

Ament, J. (2005). American Jewish religious denominations. United Jewish communities report series on the national Jewish population survey 2000–01. New York: United Jewish Communities.

Bettan, I., & Jacob, W. (1983). Euthanasia. In W. Jacob (Ed.), American reform responsa. Collected responsa of the central conference of American Rabbis 1889–1983 (pp. 261–270). New York: CCAR.

Bleich, J. D. (1978). Karen Ann Quinlan: A Torah perspective. In M. M. Kellner (Ed.), Contemporary Jewish ethics (pp. 296–307). New York: Sanhedrin Press.

Bleich, J. D. (1979a). The obligation to heal in the Judaic tradition. A comparative analysis. In F. Rosner & J. D. Bleich (Eds.), Jewish bioethics (pp. 1–44). Brooklyn, NY: Hebrew Publishing Company.

Bleich, J. D. (1979b). The Quinlan case. A Jewish perspective. In F. Rosner & J. D. Bleich (Eds.), Jewish bioethics (pp. 266–276). Brooklyn, NY: Hebrew Publishing Company.

Bleich, J. D. (1981). Judaism and healing: Halakhic perspectives. New York: KTAV.

Bleich, J. D. (1993). Life as an intrinsic rather than instrumental good. The ‘spiritual’ case against euthanasia. Issues in Law and Medicine, 9(2), 139–150.PubMed

Bleich, J. D. (2010). The infinite value of human life in Judaism. In R. Guggenheim, L. Leupin, Y. Nordmann, & R. Patcas (Eds.), The value of human life. Contemporary perspectives in Jewish medical ethics (pp. 15–30). New York: Feldheim.

Brachfeld, S. (2000). Onze joodse buren. Antwerpen/Baarn: Houtekiet.

Brody, B. A. (1999). Jewish reflections on life and death decision making. In E. Pellegrino & A. I. Faden (Eds.), Jewish and catholic bioethics. An ecumenical dialogue (pp. 17–24). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

Carmel, S., & Mutran, E. (1997). Wishes regarding the use of life-sustaining treatments among elderly persons in Israel. An explanatory model. Social Science and Medicine, 45(11), 1715–1727.PubMedCrossRef

Cohen, P. M. (2005). Toward a methodology of Reform Jewish bioethics. CCAR Journal. A Reform Jewish Quarterly, 52(3), 3–20.

Cohen-Almagor, R., & Shmueli, M. (2000). Can life be evaluated? The Jewish Halachic approach vs. the quality of life approach in medical ethics. A critical view. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 21, 117–137.PubMedCrossRef

Coleman, K., Koffman, J., & Daniels, C. (2007). Why is this happening to me? Illness beliefs held by Haredi Jewish breast cancer patients: An exploratory study. Spirituality and Health International, 8, 121–134.CrossRef

Coleman-Brueckheimer, K., Spitzer, J., & Koffman, J. (2009). Involvement of rabbinic and communal authorities in decision-making by Haredi Jews in the UK with breast cancer: An interpretative phenomenological analysis. Social Science and Medicine, 68(2), 323–333.PubMedCrossRef

Daiches, S., Slotki, I. (Trans.), & Epstein, I. (Ed.). (1971). Hebrew-English Edition of the Babylonian Talmud. Kethuboth. London: Soncino Press.

De Lange, N. R. M. (2000). An introduction to Judaism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

DeKeyser Ganz, F., & Musgrave, C. F. (2006). Israeli critical care nurses’ attitudes toward physician-assisted dying. Heart and Lung, 35(6), 412–422.PubMedCrossRef

Dorff, E. N. (1998). Matters of life and death. A Jewish approach to modern medical ethics. Philadelphia/Jerusalem: The Jewish Publication Society.

Dorff, E. N. (2000). End-stage medical care. Halakhic concepts and values. In A. L. Mackler (Ed.), Life and death responsibilities in Jewish biomedical ethics (pp. 309–337). New York: The Jewish Theological Seminary of America.

Ejaz, F. K. (2000). The influence of religious and personal values on nursing home residents’ attitudes toward life-sustaining treatments. Social Work in Health Care, 32(2), 23–39.PubMedCrossRef

Ellenson, D. (1995). How to draw guidance from a heritage. Jewish approaches to mortal choices. In E. N. Dorff & L. E. Newman (Eds.), Contemporary Jewish ethics and morality. A reader (pp. 129–139). New York: Oxford University Press.

Flancbaum, L. (2001). And you shall live by them. Contemporary Jewish approaches to medical ethics. Pittsburgh: Mirkov Publications.

Freedman, B. (1999). Duty and healing. Foundations of a Jewish bioethic. New York: Routledge.

Freehof, S. B. (1960). Reform responsa. Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press.

Freehof, S. B. (1969). Current Reform responsa. Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press.

Freehof, S. B. (1971). Modern Reform responsa. Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press.

Freehof, S. B. (1974). Contemporary Reform responsa. Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press.

Freehof, S. B. (1983). Allowing a terminal patient to die. In W. Jacob (Ed.), American Reform responsa. collected responsa of the Central Conference of American Rabbis, 1889–1983 (pp. 257–260). New York: CCAR.

Gesundheit, B. (2010). Reflections on the Golubchuk case. The American Journal of Bioethics, 10(3), 73–74.PubMedCrossRef

Gesundheit, B., Steinberg, A., Glick, S., Or, R., & Jotkovitz, A. (2006). Euthanasia: An overview and the Jewish perspective. Cancer Investigation, 24, 621–629.PubMedCrossRef

Gielen, J., Van den Branden, S., & Broeckaert, B. (2009). Religion and nurses attitudes to euthanasia and physician assisted suicide. Nursing Ethics, 16(3), 303–318.PubMedCrossRef

Glick, S. (1999). The Jewish approach to living and dying. In E. Pellegrino & A. I. Faden (Eds.), Jewish and catholic bioethics. An ecumenical dialogue (pp. 43–53). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

Goldsand, G., Rosenberg, Z. R. S., & Gordon, M. (2001). Bioethics for clinicians. Jewish bioethics. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 164(2), 219–222.PubMed

Green, R. M. (1999). Jewish teaching on the sanctity and quality of life. In E. Pellegrino & A. I. Faden (Eds.), Jewish and Catholic bioethics. An ecumenical dialogue (pp. 25–41). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

Jacob, W. (1987). Contemporary American Reform responsa. New York: CCAR.

Jacob, W. (1995a). Euthanasia. In W. Jacob & M. Zemer (Eds.), Death and euthanasia in Jewish law. Essays and responsa (pp. 127–130), Vol. 4 of Studies in Progressive Halakhah, Pittsburgh. Tel Aviv: Rodef Shalom Press.

Jacob, W. (1995b). Quality of life and euthanasia. In W. Jacob & M. Zemer (Eds.), Death and euthanasia in Jewish law. Essays and responsa (pp. 131–133), Vol. 4 of Studies in Progressive Halakhah, Pittsburgh. Tel Aviv: Rodef Shalom Press.

Jacob, W. (1998). Quality of life and euthanasia. In W. Jacob & M. Zemer (Eds.), Aging and the aged in Jewish law. Essays and responsa (pp. 153–156), Vol. 7 of Studies in Progressive Halakhah, Pittsburg. Tel Aviv: Rodef Shalom Press.

Jacob, W. (2004). “The law of the lord is perfect”. Halakhah and antinomism in Reform Judaism. CCAR Journal: A Reform Jewish Quarterly, 51(3), 72–84.

Jage-Bowler, K. (1999). Fragen des Lebensendes. Spuren und Wurzeln jüdisch-medizinischer Ethik, Vol. 19 of Studien zur systematischen Theologie und Ethik. Münster: Lit Verlag.

Jakobovits, I. (1959). Jewish medical ethics. A comparative and historical study of the Jewish religious attitude to medicine and its practice. New York: Bloch Publishing Company.

Jotkowitz, A., Glick, S., & Zivotofsky, A. Z. (2010a). The case of Samuel Golubchuk and the right to live. The American Journal of Bioethics, 10(3), 50–53.PubMedCrossRef

Jotkowitz, A., Glick, S., & Zivotofsky, A. Z. (2010b). The secret caring for Mr. Golubchuk. The American Journal of Bioethics, 10(3), W6–W7.PubMedCrossRef

Kellner, M. M. (1978). The structure of Jewish ethics. In M. M. Kellner (Ed.), Contemporary Jewish ethics (pp. 3–18). New York: Sanhedrin Press.

Kellner, M. M. (1995). The structure of Jewish ethics. In E. N. Dorff & L. E. Newman (Eds.), Contemporary Jewish ethics and morality. A reader (pp. 12–24). New York: Oxford University Press.

Kinzbrunner, B. M. (2004). Jewish medical ethics and end-of-life care. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 7(4), 558–573.PubMedCrossRef

Knobel, P. (1995). Suicide, assisted suicide, active euthanasia. A halakhic inquiry. In W. Jacob & M. Zemer (Eds.), Death and euthanasia in Jewish law. Essays and responsa (pp. 27–59), Vol. 4 of Studies in Progressive Halakhah, Pittsburgh. Tel Aviv: Rodef Shalom Press.

Kravitz, L. (1995). Euthanasia. In W. Jacob & M. Zemer (Eds.), Death and euthanasia in Jewish law. Essays and responsa (pp. 11–25), Vol. 4 of Studies in Progressive Halakhah, Pittsburgh. Tel Aviv: Rodef Shalom Press.

Kravitz, L. (2006). ‘Some’ Jewish reflections on Jewish tradition and the end-of-life patient. In P. J. Hurwitz, J. Picard, & A. Steinberg (Eds.), Jewish ethics and the care of end-of-life patients. A collection of rabbinical, bioethical, philosophical and juristic opinions (pp. 75–97). Jersey City: KTAV Publishing House.

Küng, H. (1992). Judaism. Between yesterday and tomorrow. New York: Continuum.

Leichtentritt, R., & Rettig, K. D. (1999). Meanings and attitudes toward end-of-life preferences in Israel. Death Studies, 23, 323–358.PubMedCrossRef

Mackler, A. L. (Ed.). (2000). Life and death responsibilities in Jewish biomedical ethics. New York: The Jewish Theological Seminary of America.

Mackler, A. L. (2003). Introduction to Jewish and catholic bioethics. A comparative analysis. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

Margalith, I., Musgrave, C. F., & Goldschmidt, L. (2003). Physician-assisted dying. Are education and religious beliefs related to nursing students’ attitudes? Journal of Nursing Education, 42(2), 91–96.PubMed

Mishcon, A., Cohen, A. (Trans.), & Epstein, I. (Ed.). (1988). Hebrew-English edition of the Babylonian Talmud. ‘Abodah Zarah. London: Soncino Press.

Musgrave, C. F., Margalith, I., & Goldsmith, L. (2001). Israeli oncology and nononcology nurses’ attitudes toward physician-assisted dying. A comparison study. Oncology Nursing Forum, 28(1), 50–57.PubMed

Neusner, J. (1975). Between time and eternity. The essentials of judaism. California: Dickenson.

Neusner, J. (2002). The halakhah. Historical and religious perspectives, Vol. 8 of The Brill Reference Library of Ancient Judaism. Leiden: Brill.

Newman, L. E. (1992). Jewish theology and bioethics. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 17, 311–316.

Newman, L. E. (1995). Learning to be led. Reflections on Reform ethics and halakhah. In E. B. Borowitz (Ed.), Reform ethics and the halakhah. An experiment in decision making (pp. xiii–xxi). West Orange: Behrman House.

Newman, L. E. (2005). An introduction to Jewish ethics. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall.

Plaut, W. G., & Washofsky, M. (Eds.). (1997). Teshuvot for the nineties. Reform Judaism’s answers for today’s dilemmas. New York: CCAR.

Reconstructionist Rabbinical College. (2002). Behoref Hayamim/In the winter of life. A values-based Jewish guide for decision making at the end of life. Wyncote, PA: Reconstructionist Rabbinical College Press.

Reisner, A. I. (1991). A halakhic ethic of care for the terminally ill. Conservative Judaism, 3, 52–89.

Reisner, A. I. (2000). Care for the terminally ill. Halakhic concepts and values. In A. L. Mackler (Ed.), Life and death responsibilities in Jewish biomedical ethics (pp. 239–264). New York: The Jewish Theological Seminary of America.

Rosner, F. (1986). Modern medicine and Jewish ethics. Hoboken, NJ: KTAV.

Rosner, F. (1991). Jewish perspectives on death and dying. Jewish Medical Ethics, 2(1), 38–45.PubMed

Rosner, F. (1999). The imperative to heal in traditional Judaism. In E. Pellegrino & A. I. Faden (Eds.), Jewish and catholic bioethics. An ecumenical dialogue (pp. 99–105). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

Schostak, Z. (1991). Ethical guidelines for treatment of the dying elderly. Journal of Halacha & Contemporary Society, 22, 62–86.

Schulweis, H. M. (1995). Judaism. From either/or to both/and. In E. N. Dorff & L. E. Newman (Eds.), Contemporary Jewish ethics and morality. A reader (pp. 25–37). New York: Oxford University Press.

Shachter, J., Freedman, H. (Trans.), & Epstein, I. (Ed.). (1969). Hebrew-English edition of the Babylonian Talmud. Sanhedrin. London: Soncino Press.

Shapiro, D. S. (1978). The doctrine of the image of god and Imitatio Dei. In M. M. Kellner (Ed.), Contemporary Jewish ethics (pp. 127–151). New York: Sanhedrin Press.

Sherwin, B. L. (1990). In partnership with god. Contemporary Jewish law and ethics. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.

Sherwin, B. L. (1995). A view of euthanasia. In E. N. Dorff & L. E. Newman (Eds.), Contemporary Jewish ethics and morality. A reader (pp. 363–381). New York: Oxford University Press.

Sherwin, B. L. (1998). Euthanasia as a halakhic option. In K. J. Kaplan & M. B. Schwartz (Eds.), Jewish approaches to suicide, martyrdom and euthanasia (pp. 80–97). Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson.

Sherwin, B. L. (2000). Jewish ethics for the twenty-first century. Living in the image of god. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.

Simon, M. (Trans.), & Epstein, I. (Ed.). (1963). Hebrew-English edition of the Babylonian Talmud. Gittin. London: Soncino Press.

Sinclair, D. B. (1989). Tradition and the biological revolution. The application of Jewish law to the treatment of the critically Ill. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Sinclair, D. B. (2003). Jewish biomedical law. Legal and extra-legal dimensions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Tendler, M. D. (1996). Responsa of Rav Moshe Feinstein: Care of the critically ill. Hoboken, NJ: KTAV Publishing House.

Tendler, M. D., & Rosner, F. (1993). Quality and sanctity of life in the Talmud and the Midrash. Tradition, 28(1), 18–27.PubMed

Teutsch, D. (2005). A guide to Jewish practice. Bioethics. Reinvigorating the practice of contemporary Jewish ethics. Wyncote, PA: Reconstructionist Rabbinical College Press.

Thomasma, D. C. (1999). The sanctity-of-human-life doctrine. In E. D. Pellegrino & A. I. Faden (Eds.), Jewish and catholic bioethics. An ecumenical dialogue (pp. 54–73). Washington: Georgetown University Press.

Wenger, N. S., & Carmel, S. (2004). Physicians’ religiosity and end-of-life care attitudes and behaviors. Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine, 71(5), 335–343.PubMed

Zemer, M. (1999). Evolving halakhah. A progressive approach to traditional Jewish law. Woodstock, VT: Jewish Lights Publishing.

Zlotnick, D. (Ed. & Trans.). (1966). The tractate Mourning (Semahot). Regulations relating to death, burial, and mourning. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Zohar, N. (Ed.). (2006). Quality of life in Jewish bioethics. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Zoloth-Dorfman, L. (1995). Face to face, not eye to eye: Further conversations on Jewish medical ethics. The Journal of Clinical Ethics, 6(3), 222–231.PubMed

Title: ‘There is a Time to be Born and a Time to Die’ (Ecclesiastes 3:2a): Jewish Perspectives on Euthanasia
Authors: Goedele Baeke
Jean-Pierre Wils
Bert Broeckaert
Publication date: 01-12-2011
Publisher: Springer US
Published in: Journal of Religion and Health / Issue 4/2011
Print ISSN: 0022-4197
Electronic ISSN: 1573-6571
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-011-9465-9

At a glance: The ONWARDS insulin icodec trials

Springer Medicine

‘There is a Time to be Born and a Time to Die’ (Ecclesiastes 3:2a): Jewish Perspectives on Euthanasia

Abstract

At a glance: The ONWARDS insulin icodec trials

Springer Medicine

Abstract

Please log in to get access to this content

Other articles of this Issue 4/2011

Mindfulness and Levels of Stress: A Comparison of Beginner and Advanced Hatha Yoga Practitioners

Religious Influences on the Reproductive Health Decisions of HIV-Positive Latinas on the Border

Special People? An Exploratory Study into Re-entering Missionaries’ Identity and Resilience

The Virgin of Guadalupe as an Ancillary Modality for Treating Hispanic Substance Abusers: Juramentos in the United States

The Influence of Religious Factors on Drinking Behavior Among Young Indigenous Sami and Non-Sami Peers in Northern Norway

Examination of the Psychometric Properties of the Spiritual Fitness Assessment