Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Surgical Endoscopy 11/2003

01-11-2003 | Original article

SAGES Appropriateness Conference: a summary

Authors: R. E. Glasgow, A. Fingerhut, J. Hunter

Published in: Surgical Endoscopy | Issue 11/2003

Login to get access

Excerpt

This conference was organized to assess the relative appropriateness of laparoscopic vs open techniques for four clinical situations commonly encountered in surgical practice. Four topics were discussed—appendectomy, inguinal hernia repair, colon resection, and operations for gastroesophageal reflux disease. The goal was to determine the appropriateness of these procedures through a program of planned talks and panel discussions featuring internationally recognized experts and based on a review of the clinical evidence. For each subject, specific criteria were established a priori to ensure the accuracy and uniformity of the discussions and conclusions. These criteria included precise definitions, a determination as to how well the clinical evidence and the consensus on these topics could be generalized and communicated to the broader medical community, the description and standardization of traditional surgical endpoints, and the strength of the evidence. …
Literature
1.
go back to reference Affleck, DG, Handrahan, DL, Egger, MJ, Price, RR 1999The laparoscopic management of appendicitis and cholelithiasis during pregnancy.Am J Surg178523529CrossRefPubMed Affleck, DG, Handrahan, DL, Egger, MJ, Price, RR 1999The laparoscopic management of appendicitis and cholelithiasis during pregnancy.Am J Surg178523529CrossRefPubMed
2.
go back to reference Attwood, SE, Hill, AD, Murphy, PG, Thornton, J, Stephens, RB 1992A prospective randomized trial of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy.Surgery112497501PubMed Attwood, SE, Hill, AD, Murphy, PG, Thornton, J, Stephens, RB 1992A prospective randomized trial of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy.Surgery112497501PubMed
3.
go back to reference Krisher, SL, Browne, A, Dibbins, A, Tkacz, N, Curci, M 2001Intraabdominal abscess after laparoscopic appendectomy for perforated appendicitis.Arch Surg136438441CrossRefPubMed Krisher, SL, Browne, A, Dibbins, A, Tkacz, N, Curci, M 2001Intraabdominal abscess after laparoscopic appendectomy for perforated appendicitis.Arch Surg136438441CrossRefPubMed
4.
go back to reference Larsson, PG, Henriksson, G, Olsson, M, Boris, J, Stroberg, P, Tronstad, SE, Skullman, S 2001Laparoscopy reduces unnecessary appendicectomies and improves diagnosis in fertile women: a randomized study.Surg Endosc15200202CrossRefPubMed Larsson, PG, Henriksson, G, Olsson, M, Boris, J, Stroberg, P, Tronstad, SE, Skullman, S 2001Laparoscopy reduces unnecessary appendicectomies and improves diagnosis in fertile women: a randomized study.Surg Endosc15200202CrossRefPubMed
5.
go back to reference Lintula, H, Kokki, H, Vanamo, K 2001Single-blind randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy in children.Br J Surg88510514CrossRefPubMed Lintula, H, Kokki, H, Vanamo, K 2001Single-blind randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy in children.Br J Surg88510514CrossRefPubMed
6.
go back to reference Long, KH, Bannon, MP, Zietlow, SP, Helgeson, ER, Harmsen, WS, Smith, CD, Ilstrup, DM, Baerga-Varela, Y, Sarr, MG 2001A prospective randomized comparison of laparoscopic appendectomy with open appendectomy: clinical and economic analyses.Surgery129390400CrossRefPubMed Long, KH, Bannon, MP, Zietlow, SP, Helgeson, ER, Harmsen, WS, Smith, CD, Ilstrup, DM, Baerga-Varela, Y, Sarr, MG 2001A prospective randomized comparison of laparoscopic appendectomy with open appendectomy: clinical and economic analyses.Surgery129390400CrossRefPubMed
7.
go back to reference McCall, JL, Sharples, K, Jadallah, F 1997Systematic review of randomized controlled trials comparing laparoscopic with open appendicectomy.Br J Surg8410451050PubMed McCall, JL, Sharples, K, Jadallah, F 1997Systematic review of randomized controlled trials comparing laparoscopic with open appendicectomy.Br J Surg8410451050PubMed
8.
go back to reference Frazee, RC, Roberts, JW, Symmonds, RE, Snyder, SK, Hendricks, JC, Smith, RW, Custer 3rd, MD, Harrison, JB 1994A prospective randomized trial comparing open versus laparoscopic appendectomy.Ann Surg219725728discussion 728–731PubMed Frazee, RC, Roberts, JW, Symmonds, RE, Snyder, SK, Hendricks, JC, Smith, RW, Custer 3rd, MD, Harrison, JB 1994A prospective randomized trial comparing open versus laparoscopic appendectomy.Ann Surg219725728discussion 728–731PubMed
9.
go back to reference Garbutt, JM, Soper, NJ, Shannon, WD, Botero, A, Littenberg, B 1999Meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials comparing laparoscopic and open appendectomy.Surg Laparosc Endosc91726discussion 728–731CrossRefPubMed Garbutt, JM, Soper, NJ, Shannon, WD, Botero, A, Littenberg, B 1999Meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials comparing laparoscopic and open appendectomy.Surg Laparosc Endosc91726discussion 728–731CrossRefPubMed
10.
go back to reference Golub, R, Siddiqui, F, Pohl, D 1998Laparoscopic versus open appendectomy: a metaanalysis.J Am Coll Surg186545553discussion 728–731PubMed Golub, R, Siddiqui, F, Pohl, D 1998Laparoscopic versus open appendectomy: a metaanalysis.J Am Coll Surg186545553discussion 728–731PubMed
11.
go back to reference Hellberg, A, Rudberg, C, Kullman, E, Enochsson, L, Fenyo, G, Graffner, H, Hallerback, B, Johansson, B, Anderberg, B, Wenner, J, et al. 1999Prospective randomized multicentre study of laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy.Br J Surg864853discussion 728–731CrossRefPubMed Hellberg, A, Rudberg, C, Kullman, E, Enochsson, L, Fenyo, G, Graffner, H, Hallerback, B, Johansson, B, Anderberg, B, Wenner, J,  et al. 1999Prospective randomized multicentre study of laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy.Br J Surg864853discussion 728–731CrossRefPubMed
12.
go back to reference Minne, L, Varner, D, Burnell, A, Ratzer, E, Clark, J, Haun, W 1997Laparoscopic vs open appendectomy: prospective randomized study of outcomes.Arch Surg132708711discussion 712PubMed Minne, L, Varner, D, Burnell, A, Ratzer, E, Clark, J, Haun, W 1997Laparoscopic vs open appendectomy: prospective randomized study of outcomes.Arch Surg132708711discussion 712PubMed
13.
go back to reference Nguyen, DB, Silen, W, Hodin, RA 1999Appendectomy in the pre- and postlaparoscopic eras.J Gastrointest Surg36773discussion 712 Nguyen, DB, Silen, W, Hodin, RA 1999Appendectomy in the pre- and postlaparoscopic eras.J Gastrointest Surg36773discussion 712
14.
go back to reference Ortega, AE, Hunter, JG, Peters, JH, Swanstrom, LL, Schirmer, B 1995A prospective, randomized comparison of laparoscopic appendectomy with open appendectomy. Laparoscopic Appendectomy Study Group.Am J Surg169208212discussion 212–203CrossRefPubMed Ortega, AE, Hunter, JG, Peters, JH, Swanstrom, LL, Schirmer, B 1995A prospective, randomized comparison of laparoscopic appendectomy with open appendectomy. Laparoscopic Appendectomy Study Group.Am J Surg169208212discussion 212–203CrossRefPubMed
15.
go back to reference Pedersen, AG, Petersen, OB, Wara, P, Ronning, H, Qvist, N, Laurberg, S 2001Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy.Br J Surg88200205discussion 212–203PubMed Pedersen, AG, Petersen, OB, Wara, P, Ronning, H, Qvist, N, Laurberg, S 2001Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy.Br J Surg88200205discussion 212–203PubMed
16.
go back to reference Reiertsen, O, Larsen, S, Trondsen, E, Edwin, B, Faerden, AE, Rosseland, AR 1997Randomized controlled trial with sequential design of laparoscopic versus conventional appendicectomy.Br J Surg84842847discussion 212–203PubMed Reiertsen, O, Larsen, S, Trondsen, E, Edwin, B, Faerden, AE, Rosseland, AR 1997Randomized controlled trial with sequential design of laparoscopic versus conventional appendicectomy.Br J Surg84842847discussion 212–203PubMed
17.
go back to reference Sauerland, S, Lefering, R, Holthausen, U, Neugebauer, EA 1998Laparoscopic vs conventional appendectomy—a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.Langenbecks Arch Surg383289295discussion 212–203PubMed Sauerland, S, Lefering, R, Holthausen, U, Neugebauer, EA 1998Laparoscopic vs conventional appendectomy—a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.Langenbecks Arch Surg383289295discussion 212–203PubMed
18.
go back to reference Temple, LK, Litwin, DE, McLeod, RS 1999A meta-analysis of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy in patients suspected of having acute appendicitis.Can J Surg42377383discussion 212–203PubMed Temple, LK, Litwin, DE, McLeod, RS 1999A meta-analysis of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy in patients suspected of having acute appendicitis.Can J Surg42377383discussion 212–203PubMed
19.
go back to reference Wullstein, C, Barkhausen, S, Gross, E 2001Results of laparoscopic vs. conventional appendectomy in complicated appendicitis.Dis Colon Rectum4417001705discussion 212–203PubMed Wullstein, C, Barkhausen, S, Gross, E 2001Results of laparoscopic vs. conventional appendectomy in complicated appendicitis.Dis Colon Rectum4417001705discussion 212–203PubMed
20.
go back to reference MRC Laparoscopic Groin Hernia Trial Group 1999Laparoscopic versus open repair of groin hernia: a randomised comparison.Lancet354185190discussion 212–203PubMed MRC Laparoscopic Groin Hernia Trial Group 1999Laparoscopic versus open repair of groin hernia: a randomised comparison.Lancet354185190discussion 212–203PubMed
21.
go back to reference Barkun, JS, Wexler, MJ, Hinchey, EJ, Thibeault, D, Meakins, JL 1995Laparoscopic versus open inguinal herniorrhaphy: preliminary results of a randomized controlled trial.Surgery118703709discussion 212–203PubMed Barkun, JS, Wexler, MJ, Hinchey, EJ, Thibeault, D, Meakins, JL 1995Laparoscopic versus open inguinal herniorrhaphy: preliminary results of a randomized controlled trial.Surgery118703709discussion 212–203PubMed
22.
go back to reference Bay-Nielsen, M, Kehlet, H, Strand, L, Malmstrom, J, Andersen, FH, Wara, P, Juul, P, Callesen, T 2001Quality assessment of 26,304 herniorrhaphies in Denmark: a prospective nationwide study.Lancet35811241128Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed Bay-Nielsen, M, Kehlet, H, Strand, L, Malmstrom, J, Andersen, FH, Wara, P, Juul, P, Callesen, T 2001Quality assessment of 26,304 herniorrhaphies in Denmark: a prospective nationwide study.Lancet35811241128Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed
23.
go back to reference Felix, EL, Michas, CA, Gonzalez Jr, MH 1995Laparoscopic hernioplasty: TAPP vs TEP.Surg Endosc9984989Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed Felix, EL, Michas, CA, Gonzalez Jr, MH 1995Laparoscopic hernioplasty: TAPP vs TEP.Surg Endosc9984989Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed
24.
go back to reference Ferzli, GS, Frezza, EE, Pecoraro Jr, AM, Ahern, KD 1999Prospective randomized study of stapled versus unstapled mesh in a laparoscopic preperitoneal inguinal hernia repair.J Am Coll Surg188461465Danish Hernia Database CollaborationCrossRefPubMed Ferzli, GS, Frezza, EE, Pecoraro Jr, AM, Ahern, KD 1999Prospective randomized study of stapled versus unstapled mesh in a laparoscopic preperitoneal inguinal hernia repair.J Am Coll Surg188461465Danish Hernia Database CollaborationCrossRefPubMed
25.
go back to reference Fitzgibbons Jr, RJ, Camps, J, Cornet, DA, Nguyen, NX, Litke, BS, Annibali, R, Salerno, GM 1995Laparoscopic inguinal herniorrhaphy: results of a multicenter trial.Ann Surg221313Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed Fitzgibbons Jr, RJ, Camps, J, Cornet, DA, Nguyen, NX, Litke, BS, Annibali, R, Salerno, GM 1995Laparoscopic inguinal herniorrhaphy: results of a multicenter trial.Ann Surg221313Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed
26.
go back to reference Dirksen, CD, Beets, GL, Go, PM, Geisler, FE, Baeten, CG, Kootstra, G 1998Bassini repair compared with laparoscopic repair for primary inguinal hernia: a randomised controlled trial.Eur J Surg164439447Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed Dirksen, CD, Beets, GL, Go, PM, Geisler, FE, Baeten, CG, Kootstra, G 1998Bassini repair compared with laparoscopic repair for primary inguinal hernia: a randomised controlled trial.Eur J Surg164439447Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed
27.
go back to reference Johansson, B, Hallerback, B, Glise, H, Anesten, B, Smedberg, S 1999Laparoscopic mesh versus open preperitoneal mesh versus conventional technique for inguinal hernia repair: a randomized multicenter trial (SCUR Hernia Repair Study).Ann Surg230225231Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed Johansson, B, Hallerback, B, Glise, H, Anesten, B, Smedberg, S 1999Laparoscopic mesh versus open preperitoneal mesh versus conventional technique for inguinal hernia repair: a randomized multicenter trial (SCUR Hernia Repair Study).Ann Surg230225231Danish Hernia Database CollaborationPubMed
28.
go back to reference Juul, P, Christensen, K 1999Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open inguinal hernia repair.Br J Surg86316319Danish Hernia Database CollaborationCrossRefPubMed Juul, P, Christensen, K 1999Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open inguinal hernia repair.Br J Surg86316319Danish Hernia Database CollaborationCrossRefPubMed
29.
go back to reference Korman, JE, Hiatt, JR, Feldmar, D, Phillips, EH 1997Mesh configurations in laparoscopic extraperitoneal herniorrhaphy: a comparison of techniques.Surg Endosc1111021105Danish Hernia Database CollaborationCrossRefPubMed Korman, JE, Hiatt, JR, Feldmar, D, Phillips, EH 1997Mesh configurations in laparoscopic extraperitoneal herniorrhaphy: a comparison of techniques.Surg Endosc1111021105Danish Hernia Database CollaborationCrossRefPubMed
30.
go back to reference Liem, MS, Halsema, JA, van der Graaf, Y, Schrijvers, AJ, van Vroonhoven, TJ 1997Cost-effectiveness of extraperitoneal laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: a randomized comparison with conventional herniorrhaphy: Coala Trial Group.Ann Surg226668675discussion 675–676PubMed Liem, MS, Halsema, JA, van der Graaf, Y, Schrijvers, AJ, van Vroonhoven, TJ 1997Cost-effectiveness of extraperitoneal laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: a randomized comparison with conventional herniorrhaphy: Coala Trial Group.Ann Surg226668675discussion 675–676PubMed
31.
go back to reference Liem, MS, van der Graaf, Y, van Steensel, CJ, Boelhouwer, RU, Clevers, GJ, Meijer, WS, Stassen, LP, Vente, JP, Weidema, WF, Schrijvers, AJ, et al. 1997Comparison of conventional anterior surgery and laparoscopic surgery for inguinal-hernia repair.N Engl J Med33615411547discussion 675–676PubMed Liem, MS, van der Graaf, Y, van Steensel, CJ, Boelhouwer, RU, Clevers, GJ, Meijer, WS, Stassen, LP, Vente, JP, Weidema, WF, Schrijvers, AJ,  et al. 1997Comparison of conventional anterior surgery and laparoscopic surgery for inguinal-hernia repair.N Engl J Med33615411547discussion 675–676PubMed
32.
go back to reference Paganini, AM, Lezoche, E, Carle, F, Carlei, F, Favretti, F, Feliciotti, F, Gesuita, R, Guerrieri, M, Lomanto, D, Nardovino, M, et al. 1998A randomized, controlled, clinical study of laparoscopic vs open tension-free inguinal hernia repair.Surg Endosc12979986discussion 675–676PubMed Paganini, AM, Lezoche, E, Carle, F, Carlei, F, Favretti, F, Feliciotti, F, Gesuita, R, Guerrieri, M, Lomanto, D, Nardovino, M,  et al. 1998A randomized, controlled, clinical study of laparoscopic vs open tension-free inguinal hernia repair.Surg Endosc12979986discussion 675–676PubMed
33.
go back to reference Payne Jr, JH, Grininger, LM, Izawa, MT, Podoll, EF, Lindahl, PJ, Balfour, J 1994Laparoscopic or open inguinal herniorrhaphy? A randomized prospective trial.Arch Surg129973979discussion 675–676PubMed Payne Jr, JH, Grininger, LM, Izawa, MT, Podoll, EF, Lindahl, PJ, Balfour, J 1994Laparoscopic or open inguinal herniorrhaphy? A randomized prospective trial.Arch Surg129973979discussion 675–676PubMed
34.
go back to reference Sarli, L, Iusco, DR, Sansebastiano, G, Costi, R 2001Simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernias: a prospective, randomized study of open, tension-free versus laparoscopic approach.Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech11262267discussion 675–676PubMed Sarli, L, Iusco, DR, Sansebastiano, G, Costi, R 2001Simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernias: a prospective, randomized study of open, tension-free versus laparoscopic approach.Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech11262267discussion 675–676PubMed
35.
go back to reference Stoker, DL, Spiegelhalter, DJ, Singh, R, Wellwood, JM 1994Laparoscopic versus open inguinal hernia repair: randomised prospective trial.Lancet34312431245discussion 675–676PubMed Stoker, DL, Spiegelhalter, DJ, Singh, R, Wellwood, JM 1994Laparoscopic versus open inguinal hernia repair: randomised prospective trial.Lancet34312431245discussion 675–676PubMed
36.
go back to reference Thumbe, VK, Evans, DS 2001To repair or not to repair incidental defects found on laparoscopic repair of groin hernia: early results of a randomized control trial.Surg Endosc154749discussion 675–676 Thumbe, VK, Evans, DS 2001To repair or not to repair incidental defects found on laparoscopic repair of groin hernia: early results of a randomized control trial.Surg Endosc154749discussion 675–676
37.
go back to reference Wellwood, J, Sculpher, MJ, Stoker, D, Nicholls, GJ, Geddes, C, Whitehead, A, Singh, R, Spiegelhalter, D 1998Randomised controlled trial of laparoscopic versus open mesh repair for inguinal hernia: outcome and cost.BMJ317103110discussion 675–676PubMed Wellwood, J, Sculpher, MJ, Stoker, D, Nicholls, GJ, Geddes, C, Whitehead, A, Singh, R, Spiegelhalter, D 1998Randomised controlled trial of laparoscopic versus open mesh repair for inguinal hernia: outcome and cost.BMJ317103110discussion 675–676PubMed
38.
go back to reference Zieren, J, Zieren, HU, Jacobi, CA, Wenger, FA, Muller, JM 1998Prospective randomized study comparing laparoscopic and open tension-free inguinal hernia repair with Shouldice’s operation.Am J Surg175330333discussion 675–676PubMed Zieren, J, Zieren, HU, Jacobi, CA, Wenger, FA, Muller, JM 1998Prospective randomized study comparing laparoscopic and open tension-free inguinal hernia repair with Shouldice’s operation.Am J Surg175330333discussion 675–676PubMed
39.
go back to reference Bouvet, M, Mansfield, PF, Skibber, JM, Curley, SA, Ellis, LM, Giacco, GG, Madary, AR, Ota, DM, Feig, BW 1998Clinical, pathologic, and economic parameters of laparoscopic colon resection for cancer.Am J Surg176554558discussion 675–676CrossRefPubMed Bouvet, M, Mansfield, PF, Skibber, JM, Curley, SA, Ellis, LM, Giacco, GG, Madary, AR, Ota, DM, Feig, BW 1998Clinical, pathologic, and economic parameters of laparoscopic colon resection for cancer.Am J Surg176554558discussion 675–676CrossRefPubMed
40.
go back to reference Curet, MJ, Putrakul, K, Pitcher, DE, Josloff, RK, Zucker, KA 2000Laparoscopically assisted colon resection for colon carcinoma: perioperative results and long-term outcome.Surg Endosc1410621066discussion 675–676CrossRefPubMed Curet, MJ, Putrakul, K, Pitcher, DE, Josloff, RK, Zucker, KA 2000Laparoscopically assisted colon resection for colon carcinoma: perioperative results and long-term outcome.Surg Endosc1410621066discussion 675–676CrossRefPubMed
41.
go back to reference Fleshman, JW, Nelson, H, Peters, WR, Kim, HC, Larach, S, Boorse, RR, Ambroze, W, Leggett, P, Bleday, R, Stryker, S, et al. 1996Early results of laparoscopic surgery for colorectal cancer: retrospective analysis of 372 patients treated by Clinical Outcomes of Surgical Therapy (COST) Study Group.Dis Colon Rectum39S5358discussion 675–676PubMed Fleshman, JW, Nelson, H, Peters, WR, Kim, HC, Larach, S, Boorse, RR, Ambroze, W, Leggett, P, Bleday, R, Stryker, S,  et al. 1996Early results of laparoscopic surgery for colorectal cancer: retrospective analysis of 372 patients treated by Clinical Outcomes of Surgical Therapy (COST) Study Group.Dis Colon Rectum39S5358discussion 675–676PubMed
42.
go back to reference Fleshman, JW, Wexner, SD, Anvari, M, LaTulippe, JF, Birnbaum, EH, Kodner, IJ, Read, TE, Nogueras, JJ, Weiss, EG 1999Laparoscopic vs. open abdominoperineal resection for cancer.Dis Colon Rectum42930939discussion 675–676PubMed Fleshman, JW, Wexner, SD, Anvari, M, LaTulippe, JF, Birnbaum, EH, Kodner, IJ, Read, TE, Nogueras, JJ, Weiss, EG 1999Laparoscopic vs. open abdominoperineal resection for cancer.Dis Colon Rectum42930939discussion 675–676PubMed
43.
go back to reference Franklin Jr, ME, Rosenthal, D, Abrego-Medina, D, Dorman, JP, Glass, JL, Norem, R, Diaz, A 1996Prospective comparison of open vs. laparoscopic colon surgery for carcinoma: five-year results.Dis Colon Rectum39S3546discussion 675–676PubMed Franklin Jr, ME, Rosenthal, D, Abrego-Medina, D, Dorman, JP, Glass, JL, Norem, R, Diaz, A 1996Prospective comparison of open vs. laparoscopic colon surgery for carcinoma: five-year results.Dis Colon Rectum39S3546discussion 675–676PubMed
44.
go back to reference Hoffman, GC, Baker, JW, Doxey, JB, Hubbard, GW, Ruffin, WK, Wishner, JA 1996Minimally invasive surgery for colorectal cancer: initial follow-up.Ann Surg223790796discussion 796–798CrossRefPubMed Hoffman, GC, Baker, JW, Doxey, JB, Hubbard, GW, Ruffin, WK, Wishner, JA 1996Minimally invasive surgery for colorectal cancer: initial follow-up.Ann Surg223790796discussion 796–798CrossRefPubMed
45.
go back to reference Khalili, TM, Fleshner, PR, Hiatt, JR, Sokol, TP, Manookian, C, Tsushima, G, Phillips, EH 1998Colorectal cancer: comparison of laparoscopic with open approaches.Dis Colon Rectum41832838discussion 796–798PubMed Khalili, TM, Fleshner, PR, Hiatt, JR, Sokol, TP, Manookian, C, Tsushima, G, Phillips, EH 1998Colorectal cancer: comparison of laparoscopic with open approaches.Dis Colon Rectum41832838discussion 796–798PubMed
46.
go back to reference Lacy, AM, Garcia-Valdecasas, JC, Pique, JM, Delgado, S, Campo, E, Bordas, JM, Taura, P, Grande, L, Fuster, J, Pacheco, JL, et al. 1995Short-term outcome analysis of a randomized study comparing laparoscopic vs open colectomy for colon cancer.Surg Endosc911011105discussion 796–798 Lacy, AM, Garcia-Valdecasas, JC, Pique, JM, Delgado, S, Campo, E, Bordas, JM, Taura, P, Grande, L, Fuster, J, Pacheco, JL,  et al. 1995Short-term outcome analysis of a randomized study comparing laparoscopic vs open colectomy for colon cancer.Surg Endosc911011105discussion 796–798
47.
go back to reference Lacy, AM, Delgado, S, Garcia-Valdecasas, JC, Castells, A, Pique, JM, Grande, L, Fuster, J, Targarona, EM, Pera, M, Visa, J 1998Port site metastases and recurrence after laparoscopic colectomy: a randomized trial.Surg Endosc1210391042discussion 796–798 Lacy, AM, Delgado, S, Garcia-Valdecasas, JC, Castells, A, Pique, JM, Grande, L, Fuster, J, Targarona, EM, Pera, M, Visa, J 1998Port site metastases and recurrence after laparoscopic colectomy: a randomized trial.Surg Endosc1210391042discussion 796–798
48.
go back to reference Leung, KL, Kwok, SP, Lau, WY, Meng, WC, Lam, TY, Kwong, KH, Chung, CC, Li, AK 1997Laparoscopic-assisted resection of rectosigmoid carcinoma: immediate and medium-term results.Arch Surg132761764discussion 765PubMed Leung, KL, Kwok, SP, Lau, WY, Meng, WC, Lam, TY, Kwong, KH, Chung, CC, Li, AK 1997Laparoscopic-assisted resection of rectosigmoid carcinoma: immediate and medium-term results.Arch Surg132761764discussion 765PubMed
49.
go back to reference Leung, KL, Yiu, RY, Lai, PB, Lee, JF, Thung, KH, Lau, WY 1999Laparoscopic-assisted resection of colorectal carcinoma: five-year audit.Dis Colon Rectum42327332discussion 332–333PubMed Leung, KL, Yiu, RY, Lai, PB, Lee, JF, Thung, KH, Lau, WY 1999Laparoscopic-assisted resection of colorectal carcinoma: five-year audit.Dis Colon Rectum42327332discussion 332–333PubMed
50.
go back to reference Lezoche, E, Feliciotti, F, Paganini, AM, Guerrieri, M, Campagnacci, R, De Sanctis, A 2000Laparoscopic colonic resections versus open surgery: a prospective non-randomized study on 310 unselected cases.Hepatogastroenterology47697708discussion 332–333 Lezoche, E, Feliciotti, F, Paganini, AM, Guerrieri, M, Campagnacci, R, De Sanctis, A 2000Laparoscopic colonic resections versus open surgery: a prospective non-randomized study on 310 unselected cases.Hepatogastroenterology47697708discussion 332–333
51.
go back to reference Liberman, MA, Phillips, EH, Carroll, BJ, Fallas, M, Rosenthal, R 1996Laparoscopic colectomy vs traditional colectomy for diverticulitis: outcome and costs.Surg Endosc101518discussion 332–333 Liberman, MA, Phillips, EH, Carroll, BJ, Fallas, M, Rosenthal, R 1996Laparoscopic colectomy vs traditional colectomy for diverticulitis: outcome and costs.Surg Endosc101518discussion 332–333
52.
go back to reference Marcello, PW, Milsom, JW, Wong, SK, Brady, K, Goormastic, M, Fazio, VW 2001Laparoscopic total colectomy for acute colitis: a case-control study.Dis Colon Rectum4414411445discussion 332–333PubMed Marcello, PW, Milsom, JW, Wong, SK, Brady, K, Goormastic, M, Fazio, VW 2001Laparoscopic total colectomy for acute colitis: a case-control study.Dis Colon Rectum4414411445discussion 332–333PubMed
53.
go back to reference Nelson, H 2001Laparoscopic colectomy for colon cancer—a trial update.Swiss Surg7248251discussion 332–333PubMed Nelson, H 2001Laparoscopic colectomy for colon cancer—a trial update.Swiss Surg7248251discussion 332–333PubMed
54.
go back to reference Santoro, E, Carlini, M, Carboni, F, Feroce, A 1999Colorectal carcinoma: laparoscopic versus traditional open surgery: a clinical trial.Hepatogastroenterology46900904discussion 332–333 Santoro, E, Carlini, M, Carboni, F, Feroce, A 1999Colorectal carcinoma: laparoscopic versus traditional open surgery: a clinical trial.Hepatogastroenterology46900904discussion 332–333
55.
go back to reference Weeks, JC, Nelson, H, Gelber, S, Sargent, D, Schroeder, G 2002Short-term quality-of-life outcomes following laparoscopic-assisted colectomy vs open colectomy for colon cancer: a randomized trial.JAMA287321328discussion 332–333PubMed Weeks, JC, Nelson, H, Gelber, S, Sargent, D, Schroeder, G 2002Short-term quality-of-life outcomes following laparoscopic-assisted colectomy vs open colectomy for colon cancer: a randomized trial.JAMA287321328discussion 332–333PubMed
56.
go back to reference Wu, JS, Birnbaum, EH, Kodner, IJ, Fry, RD, Read, TE, Fleshman, JW 1997Laparoscopic-assisted ileocolic resections in patients with Crohn’s disease: are abscesses, phlegmons, or recurrent disease contraindications?Surgery122682688discussion 688–689PubMed Wu, JS, Birnbaum, EH, Kodner, IJ, Fry, RD, Read, TE, Fleshman, JW 1997Laparoscopic-assisted ileocolic resections in patients with Crohn’s disease: are abscesses, phlegmons, or recurrent disease contraindications?Surgery122682688discussion 688–689PubMed
57.
go back to reference Young-Fadok, TM, Radice, E, Nelson, H, Harmsen, WS 2000Benefits of laparoscopic-assisted colectomy for colon polyps: a case-matched series.Mayo Clin Proc75344348discussion 688–689PubMed Young-Fadok, TM, Radice, E, Nelson, H, Harmsen, WS 2000Benefits of laparoscopic-assisted colectomy for colon polyps: a case-matched series.Mayo Clin Proc75344348discussion 688–689PubMed
58.
go back to reference Young-Fadok, TM, Hall Long , K, McConnell, EJ, Gomez Rey, G, Cabanela, RL 2001Advantages of laparoscopic resection for ileocolic Crohn’s disease: improved outcomes and reduced costs.Surg Endosc15450454discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed Young-Fadok, TM, Hall Long , K, McConnell, EJ, Gomez Rey, G, Cabanela, RL 2001Advantages of laparoscopic resection for ileocolic Crohn’s disease: improved outcomes and reduced costs.Surg Endosc15450454discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed
59.
go back to reference Bais, JE, Samsom, M, Boudesteijn, EA, van Rijk, PP, Akkermans, LM, Gooszen, HG 2001Impact of delayed gastric emptying on the outcome of antireflux surgery.Ann Surg234139146discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed Bais, JE, Samsom, M, Boudesteijn, EA, van Rijk, PP, Akkermans, LM, Gooszen, HG 2001Impact of delayed gastric emptying on the outcome of antireflux surgery.Ann Surg234139146discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed
60.
go back to reference Bais, JE, Bartelsman, JF, Bonjer, HJ, Cuesta, MA, Go, PM, Klinkenberg-Knol, EC, van Lanschot, JJ, Nadorp, JH, Smout, AJ, van der Graaf, Y, et al. 2000Laparoscopic or conventional Nissen fundoplication for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: randomised clinical trial. The Netherlands Antireflux Surgery Study Group.Lancet355170174discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed Bais, JE, Bartelsman, JF, Bonjer, HJ, Cuesta, MA, Go, PM, Klinkenberg-Knol, EC, van Lanschot, JJ, Nadorp, JH, Smout, AJ, van der Graaf, Y,  et al. 2000Laparoscopic or conventional Nissen fundoplication for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: randomised clinical trial. The Netherlands Antireflux Surgery Study Group.Lancet355170174discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed
61.
go back to reference Eubanks, TR, Omelanczuk, P, Richards, C, Pohl, D, Pellegrini, CA 2000Outcomes of laparoscopic antireflux procedures.Am J Surg179391395discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed Eubanks, TR, Omelanczuk, P, Richards, C, Pohl, D, Pellegrini, CA 2000Outcomes of laparoscopic antireflux procedures.Am J Surg179391395discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed
62.
go back to reference Farrell, TM, Richardson, WS, Trus, TL, Smith, CD, Hunter, JG 2001Response of atypical symptoms of gastro-oesophageal reflux to antireflux surgery.Br J Surg8816491652discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed Farrell, TM, Richardson, WS, Trus, TL, Smith, CD, Hunter, JG 2001Response of atypical symptoms of gastro-oesophageal reflux to antireflux surgery.Br J Surg8816491652discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed
63.
go back to reference Heikkinen, TJ, Haukipuro, K, Bringman, S, Ramel, S, Sorasto, A, Hulkko, A 2000Comparison of laparoscopic and open Nissen fundoplication 2 years after operation: a prospective randomized trial.Surg Endosc1410191023discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed Heikkinen, TJ, Haukipuro, K, Bringman, S, Ramel, S, Sorasto, A, Hulkko, A 2000Comparison of laparoscopic and open Nissen fundoplication 2 years after operation: a prospective randomized trial.Surg Endosc1410191023discussion 688–689CrossRefPubMed
64.
go back to reference Hinder, RA, Filipi, CJ, Wetscher, G, Neary, P, DeMeester, TR, Perdikis, G 1994Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is an effective treatment for gastroesophageal reflux disease.Ann Surg220472481discussion 481–83PubMed Hinder, RA, Filipi, CJ, Wetscher, G, Neary, P, DeMeester, TR, Perdikis, G 1994Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is an effective treatment for gastroesophageal reflux disease.Ann Surg220472481discussion 481–83PubMed
65.
go back to reference Hofstetter, WL, Peters, JH, DeMeester, TR, Hagen, JA, DeMeester, SR, Crookes, PF, Tsai, P, Banki, F, Bremner, CG 2001Long-term outcome of antireflux surgery in patients with Barrett’s esophagus.Ann Surg234532538discussion 538–539CrossRefPubMed Hofstetter, WL, Peters, JH, DeMeester, TR, Hagen, JA, DeMeester, SR, Crookes, PF, Tsai, P, Banki, F, Bremner, CG 2001Long-term outcome of antireflux surgery in patients with Barrett’s esophagus.Ann Surg234532538discussion 538–539CrossRefPubMed
66.
go back to reference Hunter, JG, Smith, CD, Branum, GD, Waring, JP, Trus, TL, Cornwell, M, Galloway, K 1999Laparoscopic fundoplication failures: patterns of failure and response to fundoplication revision.Ann Surg230595604discussion 604–596PubMed Hunter, JG, Smith, CD, Branum, GD, Waring, JP, Trus, TL, Cornwell, M, Galloway, K 1999Laparoscopic fundoplication failures: patterns of failure and response to fundoplication revision.Ann Surg230595604discussion 604–596PubMed
67.
go back to reference Jobe, BA, Horvath, KD, Swanstrom, LL 1998Postoperative function following laparoscopic collis gastroplasty for shortened esophagus.Arch Surg133867874discussion 604–596CrossRefPubMed Jobe, BA, Horvath, KD, Swanstrom, LL 1998Postoperative function following laparoscopic collis gastroplasty for shortened esophagus.Arch Surg133867874discussion 604–596CrossRefPubMed
68.
go back to reference Laine, S, Rantala, A, Gullichsen, R, Ovaska, J 1997Laparoscopic vs conventional Nissen fundoplication: a prospective randomized study.Surg Endosc11441444discussion 604–596CrossRefPubMed Laine, S, Rantala, A, Gullichsen, R, Ovaska, J 1997Laparoscopic vs conventional Nissen fundoplication: a prospective randomized study.Surg Endosc11441444discussion 604–596CrossRefPubMed
69.
go back to reference Lundell, L, Miettinen, P, Myrvold, HE, Pedersen, SA, Thor, K, Lamm, M, Blomqvist, A, Hatlebakk, JG, Janatuinen, E, Levander, K, et al. 2000Long-term management of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease with omeprazole or open antireflux surgery: results of a prospective, randomized clinical trial. The Nordic GORD Study Group.Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol12879887discussion 604–596PubMed Lundell, L, Miettinen, P, Myrvold, HE, Pedersen, SA, Thor, K, Lamm, M, Blomqvist, A, Hatlebakk, JG, Janatuinen, E, Levander, K,  et al. 2000Long-term management of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease with omeprazole or open antireflux surgery: results of a prospective, randomized clinical trial. The Nordic GORD Study Group.Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol12879887discussion 604–596PubMed
70.
go back to reference Lundell, L, Miettinen, P, Myrvold, HE, Pedersen, SA, Liedman, B, Hatlebakk, JG, Julkonen, R, Levander, K, Carlsson, J, Lamm, M, et al. 2001Continued (5-year) followup of a randomized clinical study comparing antireflux surgery and omeprazole in gastroesophageal reflux disease.J Am Coll Surg192172179discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed Lundell, L, Miettinen, P, Myrvold, HE, Pedersen, SA, Liedman, B, Hatlebakk, JG, Julkonen, R, Levander, K, Carlsson, J, Lamm, M,  et al. 2001Continued (5-year) followup of a randomized clinical study comparing antireflux surgery and omeprazole in gastroesophageal reflux disease.J Am Coll Surg192172179discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed
71.
go back to reference Luostarinen, ME, Isolauri, JO 1999Randomized trial to study the effect of fundic mobilization on long-term results of Nissen fundoplication.Br J Surg86614618discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed Luostarinen, ME, Isolauri, JO 1999Randomized trial to study the effect of fundic mobilization on long-term results of Nissen fundoplication.Br J Surg86614618discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed
72.
go back to reference Myrvold, HE, Lundell, L, Miettinen, P, Pedersen, SA, Liedman, B, Hatlebakk, J, Julkunen, R, Levander, K, Lamm, M, Mattson, C, et al. 2001The cost of long term therapy for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: a randomised trial comparing omeprazole and open antireflux surgery.Gut49488494discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed Myrvold, HE, Lundell, L, Miettinen, P, Pedersen, SA, Liedman, B, Hatlebakk, J, Julkunen, R, Levander, K, Lamm, M, Mattson, C,  et al. 2001The cost of long term therapy for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: a randomised trial comparing omeprazole and open antireflux surgery.Gut49488494discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed
73.
go back to reference Nilsson, G, Larsson, S, Johnsson, F 2000Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open fundoplication: blind evaluation of recovery and discharge period.Br J Surg87873878discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed Nilsson, G, Larsson, S, Johnsson, F 2000Randomized clinical trial of laparoscopic versus open fundoplication: blind evaluation of recovery and discharge period.Br J Surg87873878discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed
74.
go back to reference Ortiz, A, Martinez de Haro, LF, Parrilla, P, Morales, G, Molina, J, Bermejo, J, Liron, R, Aguilar, L 1996Conservative treatment versus antireflux surgery in Barrett’s oesophagus: long-term results of a prospective study.Br J Surg83274278discussion 179–181PubMed Ortiz, A, Martinez de Haro, LF, Parrilla, P, Morales, G, Molina, J, Bermejo, J, Liron, R, Aguilar, L 1996Conservative treatment versus antireflux surgery in Barrett’s oesophagus: long-term results of a prospective study.Br J Surg83274278discussion 179–181PubMed
75.
go back to reference Pessaux, P, Arnaud, JP, Ghavami, B, Flament, JB, Trebuchet, G, Meyer, C, Huten, N, Champault, G 2000Laparoscopic antireflux surgery: comparative study of Nissen, Nissen-Rossetti, and Toupet fundoplication. Societe Francaise de Chirurgie Laparoscopique.Surg Endosc1410241027discussion 179–181PubMed Pessaux, P, Arnaud, JP, Ghavami, B, Flament, JB, Trebuchet, G, Meyer, C, Huten, N, Champault, G 2000Laparoscopic antireflux surgery: comparative study of Nissen, Nissen-Rossetti, and Toupet fundoplication. Societe Francaise de Chirurgie Laparoscopique.Surg Endosc1410241027discussion 179–181PubMed
76.
go back to reference Rantanen, TK, Salo, JA, Salminen, JT, Kellokumpu, IH 1999Functional outcome after laparoscopic or open Nissen fundoplication: a follow-up study.Arch Surg134240244discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed Rantanen, TK, Salo, JA, Salminen, JT, Kellokumpu, IH 1999Functional outcome after laparoscopic or open Nissen fundoplication: a follow-up study.Arch Surg134240244discussion 179–181CrossRefPubMed
77.
go back to reference Rydberg, L, Ruth, M, Abrahamsson, H, Lundell, L 1999Tailoring antireflux surgery: a randomized clinical trial.World J Surg23612618discussion 179–181PubMed Rydberg, L, Ruth, M, Abrahamsson, H, Lundell, L 1999Tailoring antireflux surgery: a randomized clinical trial.World J Surg23612618discussion 179–181PubMed
78.
go back to reference Spechler, SJ 1992Comparison of medical and surgical therapy for complicated gastroesophageal reflux disease in veterans. The Department of Veterans Affairs Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Study Group.N Engl J Med326786792discussion 179–181PubMed Spechler, SJ 1992Comparison of medical and surgical therapy for complicated gastroesophageal reflux disease in veterans. The Department of Veterans Affairs Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Study Group.N Engl J Med326786792discussion 179–181PubMed
79.
go back to reference Spechler, SJ, Lee, E, Ahnen, D, Goyal, RK, Hirano, I, Ramirez, F, Raufman, JP, Sampliner, R, Schnell, T, Sontag, S, et al. 2001Long-term outcome of medical and surgical therapies for gastroesophageal reflux disease: follow-up of a randomized controlled trial.JAMA28523312338discussion 179–181PubMed Spechler, SJ, Lee, E, Ahnen, D, Goyal, RK, Hirano, I, Ramirez, F, Raufman, JP, Sampliner, R, Schnell, T, Sontag, S,  et al. 2001Long-term outcome of medical and surgical therapies for gastroesophageal reflux disease: follow-up of a randomized controlled trial.JAMA28523312338discussion 179–181PubMed
80.
go back to reference Wenner, J, Nilsson, G, Oberg, S, Melin, T, Larsson, S, Johnsson, F 2001Short-term outcome after laparoscopic and open 360 degrees fundoplication: a prospective randomized trial.Surg Endosc1511241128discussion 179–181PubMed Wenner, J, Nilsson, G, Oberg, S, Melin, T, Larsson, S, Johnsson, F 2001Short-term outcome after laparoscopic and open 360 degrees fundoplication: a prospective randomized trial.Surg Endosc1511241128discussion 179–181PubMed
81.
go back to reference Wetscher, GJ, Gadenstaetter, M, Klingler, PJ, Weiss, H, Obrist, P, Wykypiel, H, Klaus, A, Profanter, C 2001Efficacy of medical therapy and antireflux surgery to prevent Barrett’s metaplasia in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease.Ann Surg234627632discussion 179–181PubMed Wetscher, GJ, Gadenstaetter, M, Klingler, PJ, Weiss, H, Obrist, P, Wykypiel, H, Klaus, A, Profanter, C 2001Efficacy of medical therapy and antireflux surgery to prevent Barrett’s metaplasia in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease.Ann Surg234627632discussion 179–181PubMed
82.
go back to reference Park, RE, Fink, A, Brook, RH, Chassin, MR, Kahn, KL, Merrick, NJ, Kosecoff, J, Solomon, DH 1986Physician ratings of appropriate indications for six medical and surgical procedures.Am J Public Health76766772PubMed Park, RE, Fink, A, Brook, RH, Chassin, MR, Kahn, KL, Merrick, NJ, Kosecoff, J, Solomon, DH 1986Physician ratings of appropriate indications for six medical and surgical procedures.Am J Public Health76766772PubMed
Metadata
Title
SAGES Appropriateness Conference: a summary
Authors
R. E. Glasgow
A. Fingerhut
J. Hunter
Publication date
01-11-2003
Publisher
Springer-Verlag
Published in
Surgical Endoscopy / Issue 11/2003
Print ISSN: 0930-2794
Electronic ISSN: 1432-2218
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00464-003-8125-x

Other articles of this Issue 11/2003

Surgical Endoscopy 11/2003 Go to the issue

Letter to the editor

The author replies