Published in:
01-05-2015 | Emergency Radiology
Mandatory imaging cuts costs and reduces the rate of unnecessary surgeries in the diagnostic work-up of patients suspected of having appendicitis
Published in: European Radiology | Issue 5/2015
Login to get accessAbstract
Objective
To evaluate whether mandatory imaging is an effective strategy in suspected appendicitis for reducing unnecessary surgery and costs.
Methods
In 2010, guidelines were implemented in The Netherlands recommending the mandatory use of preoperative imaging to confirm/refute clinically suspected appendicitis. This retrospective study included 1,556 consecutive patients with clinically suspected appendicitis in 2008–2009 (756 patients/group I) and 2011–2012 (800 patients/group II). Imaging use (none/US/CT and/or MRI) was recorded. Additional parameters were: complications, medical costs, surgical and histopathological findings. The primary study endpoint was the number of unnecessary surgeries before and after guideline implementation.
Results
After clinical examination by a surgeon, 509/756 patients in group I and 540/800 patients in group II were still suspected of having appendicitis. In group I, 58.5% received preoperative imaging (42% US/12.8% CT/3.7% both), compared with 98.7% after the guidelines (61.6% US/4.4% CT/ 32.6% both). The percentage of unnecessary surgeries before the guidelines was 22.9%. After implementation, it dropped significantly to 6.2% (p<0.001). The surgical complication rate dropped from 19.9% to 14.2%. The average cost-per-patient decreased by 594 € from 2,482 to 1,888 € (CL:−1081; −143).
Conclusion
Increased use of imaging in the diagnostic work-up of patients with clinically suspected appendicitis reduced the rate of negative appendectomies, surgical complications and costs.
Key Points
• The 2010 Dutch guidelines recommend mandatory imaging in the work-up of appendicitis.
• This led to a considerable increase in the use of preoperative imaging.
• Mandatory imaging led to reduction in unnecessary surgeries and surgical complications.
• Use of mandatory imaging seems to reduce health care costs.