Skip to main content
Top
Published in: World Journal of Surgery 3/2012

Open Access 01-03-2012

The Life of John Wishart (1850–1926): Study of an Academic Surgical Career Prior to the Flexner Report

Authors: Emily Claydon, Vivian C. McAlister

Published in: World Journal of Surgery | Issue 3/2012

Login to get access

Abstract

Background

The 1910 Flexner Report on Medical Education in the United States and Canada is often taken as the point when medical schools in North America took on their modern form. However, many fundamental advances in surgery, such as anesthesia and asepsis, predated the report by decades. To understand the contribution of educators in this earlier period, we investigated the forgotten career of John Wishart, founding Professor of Surgery at Western University, London Ontario.

Methods

Archives at the University of Western Ontario, University of Toronto, London City Library, and Wellington County Museum were searched for material about Wishart and his times.

Results

A fragmented biography can be assembled from family notes and obituaries with the help of contemporary documents compiled by early 20th century medical school historians. Wishart assisted Abraham Groves in the first reported operation for which aseptic technique was used (1874). He was considered locally to perform pioneering surgery, including an appendectomy in 1886. Wishart was a founding member of the medical faculty at Western University in 1881, initially as Demonstrator of Anatomy and subsequently as its first Professor of Clinical Surgery, which post he held until 1910. Comprehensive notes from his undergraduate lectures demonstrate his teaching style, which mixed organized didacticism with practical advice. The role of the Flexner review in the termination of his professorship is hinted at in minutes of Faculty of Medicine meetings. Wishart was a foundation fellow of the American College of Surgeons and a founding physician of London’s Catholic hospital, St. Joseph’s, despite his own Protestant background.

Conclusions

Wishart’s career comprised all the elements of modern academic surgery, including pioneering service, research, and teaching. Surgery at Western owes as much to Wishart as it does to university reorganization in response to the Flexner report.
Literature
3.
go back to reference Anonymous (1867) Toronto lying-in hospital, course certificate (March 10, 1867). Wishart collection. University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London Anonymous (1867) Toronto lying-in hospital, course certificate (March 10, 1867). Wishart collection. University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London
5.
go back to reference Barr ML (1977) A century of medicine at western. The University of Western Ontario, London Barr ML (1977) A century of medicine at western. The University of Western Ontario, London
6.
go back to reference Obituary (1926) Dr. John Wishart dies after four months’ illness. London Free Press, London, pp 1–7 Obituary (1926) Dr. John Wishart dies after four months’ illness. London Free Press, London, pp 1–7
7.
go back to reference Obituary (1926) Dr. John Wishart. London Advertiser, London, November 4 Obituary (1926) Dr. John Wishart. London Advertiser, London, November 4
8.
go back to reference Groves A (1934) All in the day’s work; leaves from a doctor’s case-book. Macmillan, Canada Groves A (1934) All in the day’s work; leaves from a doctor’s case-book. Macmillan, Canada
9.
go back to reference Geddes CR, McAlister VC (2009) A surgical review of the priority claims attributed to Abraham groves (1847–1935). Can J Surg 52:E126–E130PubMed Geddes CR, McAlister VC (2009) A surgical review of the priority claims attributed to Abraham groves (1847–1935). Can J Surg 52:E126–E130PubMed
10.
go back to reference Cook JM (1937) Letter to Dr. Edwin Seaborn. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 1000. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Cook JM (1937) Letter to Dr. Edwin Seaborn. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 1000. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
11.
go back to reference Bayly B. Reminiscence by Ben Bayly. Seaborn collection. Vol: Reminiscences 33. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Bayly B. Reminiscence by Ben Bayly. Seaborn collection. Vol: Reminiscences 33. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
12.
go back to reference Anonymous (1881) Johannem Wishart, doctoris in medicina et magistri in chirurgia. Trinity College, Toronto. Wishart collection, University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London Anonymous (1881) Johannem Wishart, doctoris in medicina et magistri in chirurgia. Trinity College, Toronto. Wishart collection, University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London
13.
go back to reference Anonymous. Chronicles of St. Joseph’s Hospital, London, ON. Vol 1: 1888–1942. Sisters of St. Joseph of London Archives, London Anonymous. Chronicles of St. Joseph’s Hospital, London, ON. Vol 1: 1888–1942. Sisters of St. Joseph of London Archives, London
14.
go back to reference Anonymous (1898) Lectures to nurses at city (Victoria) hospital. Wishart collection. University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London Anonymous (1898) Lectures to nurses at city (Victoria) hospital. Wishart collection. University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London
15.
go back to reference Stephen RA, Smith LM (1988) The history of St. Joseph’s hospital: faith and caring. St. Joseph’s Health Centre, London Stephen RA, Smith LM (1988) The history of St. Joseph’s hospital: faith and caring. St. Joseph’s Health Centre, London
16.
go back to reference Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Hospitals 940. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Hospitals 940. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
17.
go back to reference Seaborn E (1944) The march of medicine in western Ontario. Ryerson Press, Toronto, p 368 Seaborn E (1944) The march of medicine in western Ontario. Ryerson Press, Toronto, p 368
18.
go back to reference Anonymous. Ontario, Canada marriages 1857–1924. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Anonymous. Ontario, Canada marriages 1857–1924. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
19.
go back to reference Wishart J. Crane index. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Wishart J. Crane index. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
20.
go back to reference Anonymous (1881) Census of Canada. Library and Archives Canada, Ottawa Anonymous (1881) Census of Canada. Library and Archives Canada, Ottawa
22.
go back to reference Winslow RM (1938) Letter from R.M. Winslow of the Canada Trust Company to Dr. Edwin Seaborn re estate of Dr. John Wishart. Seaborn Collection. Vol: Doctors 1603. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Winslow RM (1938) Letter from R.M. Winslow of the Canada Trust Company to Dr. Edwin Seaborn re estate of Dr. John Wishart. Seaborn Collection. Vol: Doctors 1603. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
23.
go back to reference Anonymous. Register of cemetery transcriptions. Woodland Cemetery, London Anonymous. Register of cemetery transcriptions. Woodland Cemetery, London
24.
go back to reference Wishart J (1926) New York Times. November 5 Wishart J (1926) New York Times. November 5
25.
go back to reference Elliott JH (1942) Osler’s class at the Toronto school of medicine. CMAJ 47:161–165 Elliott JH (1942) Osler’s class at the Toronto school of medicine. CMAJ 47:161–165
28.
go back to reference Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Reminiscences 426. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Reminiscences 426. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
29.
go back to reference Kelly HA, Hurdon E (1905) The vermiform appendix and its diseases. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp 43–44 Kelly HA, Hurdon E (1905) The vermiform appendix and its diseases. Saunders, Philadelphia, pp 43–44
30.
go back to reference McKibben PS (1928) The Faculty of Medicine of the University of Western Ontario: history. University of Western Ontario, London McKibben PS (1928) The Faculty of Medicine of the University of Western Ontario: history. University of Western Ontario, London
31.
go back to reference Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 674. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 674. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
32.
go back to reference Godfrey CM (1979) Medicine for Ontario: a history. Mika Publishing, Belleville Godfrey CM (1979) Medicine for Ontario: a history. Mika Publishing, Belleville
33.
go back to reference Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Reminiscences 593. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Anonymous. Seaborn collection. Vol: Reminiscences 593. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
36.
go back to reference Anonymous (1910) Faculty of medicine minutes 1881–1913 (September 19, October 13, October 27). University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London Anonymous (1910) Faculty of medicine minutes 1881–1913 (September 19, October 13, October 27). University of Western Ontario Archives and Research Collections Centre, London
37.
go back to reference Anonymous (2004) Tweedsmuir history books, Belwood Women’s Institute, Belwood/West Garafraxa Township, Vol 5, pp 206, 341–345. Wellington County Museum & Archives, Fergus Anonymous (2004) Tweedsmuir history books, Belwood Women’s Institute, Belwood/West Garafraxa Township, Vol 5, pp 206, 341–345. Wellington County Museum & Archives, Fergus
38.
go back to reference Hennessey G (Sister). Chronicles of the Sisters of St. Joseph of the Diocese of London, Ontario, 1868–1932. Sisters of St. Joseph’s of London Archives, St. Josephs Hospital, London Hennessey G (Sister). Chronicles of the Sisters of St. Joseph of the Diocese of London, Ontario, 1868–1932. Sisters of St. Joseph’s of London Archives, St. Josephs Hospital, London
39.
go back to reference Cline C. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 1599. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Cline C. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 1599. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
40.
go back to reference Dearness N. Notes of Dr. John dearness. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 1600. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London Dearness N. Notes of Dr. John dearness. Seaborn collection. Vol: Doctors 1600. Ivey Family London Room, Central Library, London
Metadata
Title
The Life of John Wishart (1850–1926): Study of an Academic Surgical Career Prior to the Flexner Report
Authors
Emily Claydon
Vivian C. McAlister
Publication date
01-03-2012
Publisher
Springer-Verlag
Published in
World Journal of Surgery / Issue 3/2012
Print ISSN: 0364-2313
Electronic ISSN: 1432-2323
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-011-1407-x

Other articles of this Issue 3/2012

World Journal of Surgery 3/2012 Go to the issue