Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Intensive Care Medicine 6/2010

01-06-2010 | Legal and Ethical Issues in Clinical Research

Triaging for adult critical care in the event of overwhelming need

Authors: Nigel Eastman, Barbara Philips, Andrew Rhodes

Published in: Intensive Care Medicine | Issue 6/2010

Login to get access

Abstract

Introduction

Predictions of the need for critical care within the H1N1 influenza pandemic suggested overwhelming need beyond potential resources, necessitating rationing of care via triaging.

Method

The triage model described was derived from informed discourse within a conjoined NHS and University Clinical Ethics Committee, supplemented by specialists in intensive care and infectious diseases.

The Model

The triage methodology described is justified ethically primarily upon ‘utilitarian’ principles within an aggregate public health model, with additional reference to ‘fairness’. Advantages of such a model, which partially suspends usual clinical judgment applied to individuals in favour of also utilizing organ failure scores, include minimization of aggregate influenza morbidity and mortality, and minimization of psychological stress upon staff making triaging decisions. Legally, in England and Wales, the model is uncontentious as regards rationing of admission to critical care; however, the law adopts ‘futility’ as the core justification for withdrawal of treatment, applied to the individual, thus failing to allow for rationing through triaging individuals out of critical care in the interest of other patients with better chances of survival. There is therefore a mismatch between a clinically and ethically acceptable model of triaging, based upon a public health approach, and the law, based upon the paradigm of the individual patient.

Conclusion

The good fortune that the H1N1 pandemic was less severe than predicted, allowing time for calm consideration, debate and decision making about what model of triaging should be adopted whenever it might be necessary in the future. It is in the interest of the health of the nation, and government, to decide upon a critical care triaging model while there is not an imminent health service crisis.
Literature
1.
go back to reference Webb SAR, Seppelt IM, the ANZIC Influenza Investigators (2009) Pandemic (H1N1) 2009 influenza (“swine flu”) in Australian and New Zealand intensive care. Crit Care Resusc 11:170–172PubMed Webb SAR, Seppelt IM, the ANZIC Influenza Investigators (2009) Pandemic (H1N1) 2009 influenza (“swine flu”) in Australian and New Zealand intensive care. Crit Care Resusc 11:170–172PubMed
2.
go back to reference Jamieson DJ, Honein MA, Rasmussen SA, Williams JL, Swerdlow DL, Biggerstaff MS, Lindstrom S, Louie JK, Christ CM, Bohm SR, Fonseca VP, Ritger KA, Kuhles DJ, Eggers P, Bruce H, Davidson HA, Lutterloh E, Harris ML, Burke C, Cocoros N, Finelli L, MacFarlane KF, Shu B, Olsen SJ, Novel Influenza A (H1N1) Pregnancy Working Group (2009) H1N1 2009 influenza virus infection during pregnancy in the USA. Lancet 374:451–458CrossRefPubMed Jamieson DJ, Honein MA, Rasmussen SA, Williams JL, Swerdlow DL, Biggerstaff MS, Lindstrom S, Louie JK, Christ CM, Bohm SR, Fonseca VP, Ritger KA, Kuhles DJ, Eggers P, Bruce H, Davidson HA, Lutterloh E, Harris ML, Burke C, Cocoros N, Finelli L, MacFarlane KF, Shu B, Olsen SJ, Novel Influenza A (H1N1) Pregnancy Working Group (2009) H1N1 2009 influenza virus infection during pregnancy in the USA. Lancet 374:451–458CrossRefPubMed
3.
go back to reference Perez-Padilla R, de la Rosa-Zamboni D, Ponce de Leon S, Hernandez M, Quiñones-Falconi F, Bautista E, Ramirez-Venegas A, Rojas-Serrano J, Ormsby CE, Corrales A, Higuera A, Mondragon E, INER Working Group on Influenza (2009) Pneumonia and respiratory failure from Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) in Mexico. N Engl J Med 361:680–689CrossRefPubMed Perez-Padilla R, de la Rosa-Zamboni D, Ponce de Leon S, Hernandez M, Quiñones-Falconi F, Bautista E, Ramirez-Venegas A, Rojas-Serrano J, Ormsby CE, Corrales A, Higuera A, Mondragon E, INER Working Group on Influenza (2009) Pneumonia and respiratory failure from Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) in Mexico. N Engl J Med 361:680–689CrossRefPubMed
4.
go back to reference Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus Investigation Team (2009) Emergence of a Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) virus in humans. N Engl J Med 360:2605–2615CrossRef Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus Investigation Team (2009) Emergence of a Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) virus in humans. N Engl J Med 360:2605–2615CrossRef
5.
go back to reference Rello J, Rodriguez A, Ibanez P, Socias L, Cebrian J, Marques A, Guerrero J, Ruiz-Santana S, Marquez E, Del Nogal-Saez F, Alvarez-Lerma F, Martínez S, Ferrer M, Avellanas M, Granada R, Maraví-Poma E, Albert P, Sierra R, Vidaur L, Ortiz P, Prieto del Portillo I, Galván B, León-Gil C, H1N1 SEMICYUC Working Group (2009) Intensive care adult patients with severe respiratory failure caused by Influenza A (H1N1) in Spain. Crit Care 13:R148CrossRefPubMed Rello J, Rodriguez A, Ibanez P, Socias L, Cebrian J, Marques A, Guerrero J, Ruiz-Santana S, Marquez E, Del Nogal-Saez F, Alvarez-Lerma F, Martínez S, Ferrer M, Avellanas M, Granada R, Maraví-Poma E, Albert P, Sierra R, Vidaur L, Ortiz P, Prieto del Portillo I, Galván B, León-Gil C, H1N1 SEMICYUC Working Group (2009) Intensive care adult patients with severe respiratory failure caused by Influenza A (H1N1) in Spain. Crit Care 13:R148CrossRefPubMed
6.
go back to reference Ercole A, Taylor BL, Rhodes A, Menon DK (2009) Modelling the impact of an influenza A H1N1 pandemic on critical care demand from early pathogenicity data: the case for sentinel reporting. Anaesthesia 64:937–941CrossRefPubMed Ercole A, Taylor BL, Rhodes A, Menon DK (2009) Modelling the impact of an influenza A H1N1 pandemic on critical care demand from early pathogenicity data: the case for sentinel reporting. Anaesthesia 64:937–941CrossRefPubMed
12.
go back to reference Christian MD, Hawryluck L, Wax RS, Cook T, Lazar NM, Herridge MS, Muller MP, Gowans DR, Fortier W, Burkle FM (2006) Development of a triage protocol for critical care during an influenza pandemic. CMAJ 175:1377–1381PubMed Christian MD, Hawryluck L, Wax RS, Cook T, Lazar NM, Herridge MS, Muller MP, Gowans DR, Fortier W, Burkle FM (2006) Development of a triage protocol for critical care during an influenza pandemic. CMAJ 175:1377–1381PubMed
13.
go back to reference British Infection Society; British Thoracic Society; Health Protection Agency; Department of Health (2006) Pandemic flu. Clinical management of patients with an influenza-like illness during an influenza pandemic. J Infect 53:S1–S58 British Infection Society; British Thoracic Society; Health Protection Agency; Department of Health (2006) Pandemic flu. Clinical management of patients with an influenza-like illness during an influenza pandemic. J Infect 53:S1–S58
17.
go back to reference Society of Critical Care Medicine Ethics Committee (1994) Consensus statement on the triage of critically ill patients. JAMA 271:1200–1203CrossRef Society of Critical Care Medicine Ethics Committee (1994) Consensus statement on the triage of critically ill patients. JAMA 271:1200–1203CrossRef
18.
go back to reference Vincent JL, Moreno R, Takala J, Willatts S, De Mendonça A, Bruining H, Reinhart CK, Suter PM, Thijs LG (1996) The SOFA (sepsis-related organ failure assessment) score to describe organ dysfunction/failure. On behalf of the working group on sepsis-related problems of the European Society of intensive care medicine. Intensive Care Med 22:707–710CrossRefPubMed Vincent JL, Moreno R, Takala J, Willatts S, De Mendonça A, Bruining H, Reinhart CK, Suter PM, Thijs LG (1996) The SOFA (sepsis-related organ failure assessment) score to describe organ dysfunction/failure. On behalf of the working group on sepsis-related problems of the European Society of intensive care medicine. Intensive Care Med 22:707–710CrossRefPubMed
19.
go back to reference Jones AE, Trzeciak S, Kline JA (2009) The sequential organ failure assessment score for predicting outcome in patients with severe sepsis and evidence of hypoperfusion at the time of emergency department presentation. Crit Care Med 37:1649–1654CrossRefPubMed Jones AE, Trzeciak S, Kline JA (2009) The sequential organ failure assessment score for predicting outcome in patients with severe sepsis and evidence of hypoperfusion at the time of emergency department presentation. Crit Care Med 37:1649–1654CrossRefPubMed
20.
go back to reference Khan Z, Hulme J, Sherwood N (2009) An assessment of the validity of SOFA score based triage in H1N1 critically ill patients during an influenza pandemic. Anaesthesia 64(12):1283–1288CrossRefPubMed Khan Z, Hulme J, Sherwood N (2009) An assessment of the validity of SOFA score based triage in H1N1 critically ill patients during an influenza pandemic. Anaesthesia 64(12):1283–1288CrossRefPubMed
21.
go back to reference Christian MD, Hamielec C, Lazar NM, Wax RS, Griffith L, Herridge MS, Lee D, Cook DJ (2009) A retrospective cohort pilot study to evaluate a triage tool for use in a pandemic. Crit Care 13:R170CrossRefPubMed Christian MD, Hamielec C, Lazar NM, Wax RS, Griffith L, Herridge MS, Lee D, Cook DJ (2009) A retrospective cohort pilot study to evaluate a triage tool for use in a pandemic. Crit Care 13:R170CrossRefPubMed
22.
go back to reference White DB, Angus DC (2009) Preparing for the sickest patients with 2009 Influenza A (H1N1). JAMA 302:1905–1906CrossRefPubMed White DB, Angus DC (2009) Preparing for the sickest patients with 2009 Influenza A (H1N1). JAMA 302:1905–1906CrossRefPubMed
23.
go back to reference Guest T, Tantam G, Donlin N, Tantam K, McMillan H, Tillyard A (2009) An observational cohort study of triage for critical care provision during pandemic influenza: ‘clipboard physicians’ or ‘evidenced based medicine’? Anaesthesia 64:1199–1206CrossRefPubMed Guest T, Tantam G, Donlin N, Tantam K, McMillan H, Tillyard A (2009) An observational cohort study of triage for critical care provision during pandemic influenza: ‘clipboard physicians’ or ‘evidenced based medicine’? Anaesthesia 64:1199–1206CrossRefPubMed
Metadata
Title
Triaging for adult critical care in the event of overwhelming need
Authors
Nigel Eastman
Barbara Philips
Andrew Rhodes
Publication date
01-06-2010
Publisher
Springer-Verlag
Published in
Intensive Care Medicine / Issue 6/2010
Print ISSN: 0342-4642
Electronic ISSN: 1432-1238
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00134-010-1862-0

Other articles of this Issue 6/2010

Intensive Care Medicine 6/2010 Go to the issue