Published in:
Open Access
28-06-2023 | Brain Death | Critical Perspectives
Abortion, Brain Death, and Coercion
Author:
Michael Nair-Collins
Published in:
Journal of Bioethical Inquiry
|
Issue 3/2023
Login to get access
Abstract
A “universalist” policy on brain death holds that brain death is death, and neurologic criteria for death determination are rightly applied to all, without exemptions or opt outs. This essay argues that advocates of a universalist brain death policy defend the same sort of coercive control of end-of-life decision-making as “pro-life” advocates seek to achieve for reproductive decision-making, and both are grounded in an illiberal political philosophy. Those who recognize the serious flaws of this kind of public policy with respect to abortion must apply the same logic to brain death.