Clinical features of vestibular schwannomas in patients who experience hearing improvement after surgery

Postoperative improvements in hearing in patients with vestibular schwannoma are extremely rare. We reviewed nine cases retrospectively to investigate the clinical features of these cases. Hearing improvement was defined as an improvement in hearing class according to American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) criteria. The nine patients comprised five men and four women with a mean age of 40.4 years. Of the nine tumors, three were solid and six cystic; mean tumor size was 29.7 mm. Mean pure tone average (PTA) and mean speech discrimination scores (SDS) were 47.5 dB and 22.8 %, respectively, preoperatively and 29.6 dB and 83.9 %, respectively, postoperatively. AAO-HNS class distribution was class B:1 and D:8, preoperatively, and class A: 5 and B:4, postoperatively. A lateral suboccipital retrosigmoid approach with a lateral (park bench) position was used in all nine patients. Clinical features of these vestibular schwannomas included (1) large cystic tumors, (2) sudden onset hearing loss, (3) the presence of a valley shape in the middle-pitch area on preoperative audiograms, (4) almost intact preoperative inner ear function, (5) a low SDS relative to PTA preoperatively, (6) surgical treatment via a lateral suboccipital approach within 6 months of the most recent exacerbation of hearing loss, (7) observation of I waves in preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative auditory brainstem response (ABR) recordings, and (8) postoperative improvement in mainly the middle-pitch range and SDS. For surgical treatment of vestibular schwannomas with the above clinical features, a translabyrinthine approach and cochlear nerve section (unless the I wave on the intraoperative ABR trace disappears) should be avoided, regardless of the patient’s preoperative hearing level, if a surgeon hopes to maximize the chances of preserving or improving hearing.