Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Neuroethics 1/2024

01-04-2024 | Original Paper

Ethical Implications of the Impact of Fracking on Brain Health

Authors: Ava Grier, Judy Illes

Published in: Neuroethics | Issue 1/2024

Login to get access

Abstract

Environmental ethicists and experts in human health have raised concerns about the effects of hydraulic fracking to access natural oil and gas resources found deep in shale rock formations on surrounding ecosystems and communities. In this study, we analyzed the prevalence of discourse on brain and mental health, and ethics, in the peer-reviewed and grey literature in the five-year period between 2016 and 2022. A total of 84 articles met inclusion criteria for analysis. Seventy-six percent (76%) mentioned impacts on brain (e.g., neural tube defects, neurological symptoms), and mental health (e.g., negative psychological effects, stress, depression) briefly; 11 reports dedicated substantive discourse to either or both together. References to safety (77%) dominated the ethics context. Discussion of environmental injustices as fracking sites disproportionately affect vulnerable communities appeared in 38% of the papers. We examine the findings through the lens of environmental neuroethics that brings human-made changes to the environment, brain and mental health, and ethics together into three interwoven lines of inquiry.
Literature
4.
go back to reference Hassett, K., and A. Mathur. 2013. Benefits of Hydraulic Fracking. Oil and Natural Gas, Oxford Energy Forum. 91: 11–14. Hassett, K., and A. Mathur. 2013. Benefits of Hydraulic Fracking. Oil and Natural Gas, Oxford Energy Forum. 91: 11–14.
5.
go back to reference Loomis, J., and M. Haefele. 2017. Quantifying Market and Non-market Benefits and Costs of Hydraulic Fracturing in the United States: A Summary of the Literature. Ecological Economics. 138: 160–167.CrossRef Loomis, J., and M. Haefele. 2017. Quantifying Market and Non-market Benefits and Costs of Hydraulic Fracturing in the United States: A Summary of the Literature. Ecological Economics. 138: 160–167.CrossRef
7.
go back to reference Thomas, M., N. Pidgeon, D. Evensen, T. Partridge, A. Hasell, C. Enders, B.H. Harthorn, and M. Bradshaw. 2017. Public perceptions of hydraulic fracturing for shale gas and oil in the United States and Canada: Public perceptions of hydraulic fracturing. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 8: E450. https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.450.CrossRef Thomas, M., N. Pidgeon, D. Evensen, T. Partridge, A. Hasell, C. Enders, B.H. Harthorn, and M. Bradshaw. 2017. Public perceptions of hydraulic fracturing for shale gas and oil in the United States and Canada: Public perceptions of hydraulic fracturing. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 8: E450. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1002/​wcc.​450.CrossRef
8.
go back to reference Brown, E., K. Hartman, C. P. Borick, B. G. Rabe, and T. M. Ivacko. 2013. The national surveys on energy and environment public opinion on fracking: Perspectives from Michigan and Pennsylvania. Center for Local, State, and Urban Policy (CLOSUP), Survery Report: Climate Policy Options. SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2313276. Brown, E., K. Hartman, C. P. Borick, B. G. Rabe, and T. M. Ivacko. 2013. The national surveys on energy and environment public opinion on fracking: Perspectives from Michigan and Pennsylvania. Center for Local, State, and Urban Policy (CLOSUP), Survery Report: Climate Policy Options. SSRN: https://​ssrn.​com/​abstract=​2313276.
9.
go back to reference Theodori, G. 2009. Paradoxical perceptions of problems associated with unconventional natural gas development. Journal of Rural Social Sciences 24 (3): Article 7. Theodori, G. 2009. Paradoxical perceptions of problems associated with unconventional natural gas development. Journal of Rural Social Sciences 24 (3): Article 7.
14.
go back to reference Concerned Health Professionals of New York and Physicians for Social Responsibility, “Compendium of Scientific, Medical, and Media Findings Demonstrating Risks and Harms of Fracking and Associated Gas and Oil Infrastructure (Ninth Edition),” 2023. http://concernedhealthny.org/compendium/. Concerned Health Professionals of New York and Physicians for Social Responsibility, “Compendium of Scientific, Medical, and Media Findings Demonstrating Risks and Harms of Fracking and Associated Gas and Oil Infrastructure (Ninth Edition),” 2023. http://​concernedhealthn​y.​org/​compendium/​.
17.
go back to reference McHenry, K. 2021. Getting Fracked: Gender Politics in Fracking Discourse. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 47, 191 – 207. McHenry, K. 2021. Getting Fracked: Gender Politics in Fracking Discourse. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 47, 191 – 207.
25.
go back to reference Chen, H., and K.E. Carter. 2017. Characterization of the chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing fluids for wells located in the Marcellus Shale Play. Journal of Environmental Management 200: 312–324.CrossRef Chen, H., and K.E. Carter. 2017. Characterization of the chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing fluids for wells located in the Marcellus Shale Play. Journal of Environmental Management 200: 312–324.CrossRef
30.
go back to reference U.S. EPA. 2016. Hydraulic fracturing for oil and gas: Impacts from the hydraulic fracturing water cycle on drinking water resources in the United States (final report). Washington, DC, EPA/600/R-16/236F: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. U.S. EPA. 2016. Hydraulic fracturing for oil and gas: Impacts from the hydraulic fracturing water cycle on drinking water resources in the United States (final report). Washington, DC, EPA/600/R-16/236F: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
33.
go back to reference Kassotis, C.D., K.C. Klemp, D.C. Vu, C. Lin, C. Meng, C.L. Besch-Williford, L. Pinatti, R.T. Zoeller, E.Z. Drobnis, V.D. Balise, C.J. Isiguzo, M.A. Williams, D.E. Tillitt, and S.C. Nagel. 2015. Endocrine-disrupting activity of hydraulic fracturing chemicals and adverse health outcomes after prenatal exposure in male mice. Endocrinology 156 (12): 4458–4473. https://doi.org/10.1210/en.2015-1375.CrossRef Kassotis, C.D., K.C. Klemp, D.C. Vu, C. Lin, C. Meng, C.L. Besch-Williford, L. Pinatti, R.T. Zoeller, E.Z. Drobnis, V.D. Balise, C.J. Isiguzo, M.A. Williams, D.E. Tillitt, and S.C. Nagel. 2015. Endocrine-disrupting activity of hydraulic fracturing chemicals and adverse health outcomes after prenatal exposure in male mice. Endocrinology 156 (12): 4458–4473. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1210/​en.​2015-1375.CrossRef
34.
go back to reference Webb, E., J. Moon, L. Dyrszka, B. Rodriguez, C. Cox, H. Patisaul, S. Bushkin, and E. London. 2018. Neurodevelopmental and neurological effects of chemicals associated with unconventional oil and natural gas operations and their potential effects on infants and children. Reviews on Environmental Health 33 (1): 3–29. https://doi.org/10.1515/reveh-2017-0008.CrossRef Webb, E., J. Moon, L. Dyrszka, B. Rodriguez, C. Cox, H. Patisaul, S. Bushkin, and E. London. 2018. Neurodevelopmental and neurological effects of chemicals associated with unconventional oil and natural gas operations and their potential effects on infants and children. Reviews on Environmental Health 33 (1): 3–29. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1515/​reveh-2017-0008.CrossRef
35.
go back to reference Alawattegama, S. 2013. Survey of Well Water Contamination in a Rural Southwestern Pennsylvania Community with Unconventional Shale Gas Drilling (Master’s thesis, Duquesne University). Retrieved from https://dsc.duq.edu/etd/285 Alawattegama, S. 2013. Survey of Well Water Contamination in a Rural Southwestern Pennsylvania Community with Unconventional Shale Gas Drilling (Master’s thesis, Duquesne University). Retrieved from https://​dsc.​duq.​edu/​etd/​285
36.
go back to reference Wollin, K.M., G. Damm, H. Foth, A. Freyberger, T. Gebel, A. Mangerich, U. Gundert-Remy, F. Partosch, C. Rohl, T. Schupp, and J.G. Hengstler. 2020. Critical evaluation of human health risks due to hydraulic fracturing in natural gas and petroleum production. Archives of Toxicology 94 (4): 967–1016. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00204-020-02758-7.CrossRef Wollin, K.M., G. Damm, H. Foth, A. Freyberger, T. Gebel, A. Mangerich, U. Gundert-Remy, F. Partosch, C. Rohl, T. Schupp, and J.G. Hengstler. 2020. Critical evaluation of human health risks due to hydraulic fracturing in natural gas and petroleum production. Archives of Toxicology 94 (4): 967–1016. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s00204-020-02758-7.CrossRef
40.
go back to reference Silbergeld, E.K. 2016. Drinking water and the developing brain. Cerebrum. cer-09–16. Silbergeld, E.K. 2016. Drinking water and the developing brain. Cerebrum. cer-09–16.
41.
go back to reference Fontenot, B.E., L.R. Hunt, Z.L. Hildenbrand, D.D. Carlton Jr., H. Oka, J.L. Walton, D. Hopkins, A. Osorio, B. Bjorndal, Q.H. Hu, and K.A. Schug. 2013. An evaluation of water quality in private drinking water wells near natural gas extraction sites in the Barnett Shale formation. Environmental Science and Technology 47 (17): 10032–10040. https://doi.org/10.1021/es4011724.CrossRef Fontenot, B.E., L.R. Hunt, Z.L. Hildenbrand, D.D. Carlton Jr., H. Oka, J.L. Walton, D. Hopkins, A. Osorio, B. Bjorndal, Q.H. Hu, and K.A. Schug. 2013. An evaluation of water quality in private drinking water wells near natural gas extraction sites in the Barnett Shale formation. Environmental Science and Technology 47 (17): 10032–10040. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1021/​es4011724.CrossRef
43.
go back to reference Soyer, M., K. Kaminski, and S. Ziyanak. 2020. Socio-psychological impacts of hydraulic fracturing on community health and well-being. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 17 (4): 1186.CrossRef Soyer, M., K. Kaminski, and S. Ziyanak. 2020. Socio-psychological impacts of hydraulic fracturing on community health and well-being. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 17 (4): 1186.CrossRef
44.
go back to reference Hirsch, J.K., K. Bryant Smalley, E.M. Selby-Nelson, J.M. Hamel-Lambert, M.R. Rosmann, T.A. Barnes, D. Abrahamson, S.S. Meit, I. GreyWolf, S. Beckmann, and T. LaFromboise. 2018. Psychosocial impact of fracking: A review of the literature on the mental health consequences of hydraulic fracturing. International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction 16: 1–15.CrossRef Hirsch, J.K., K. Bryant Smalley, E.M. Selby-Nelson, J.M. Hamel-Lambert, M.R. Rosmann, T.A. Barnes, D. Abrahamson, S.S. Meit, I. GreyWolf, S. Beckmann, and T. LaFromboise. 2018. Psychosocial impact of fracking: A review of the literature on the mental health consequences of hydraulic fracturing. International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction 16: 1–15.CrossRef
46.
go back to reference Gorski-Steiner, I., K. Bandeen-Roche, H.E. Volk, S. O’Dell, and B.S. Schwartz. 2022. The association of unconventional natural gas development with diagnosis and treatment of internalizing disorders among adolescents in Pennsylvania using electronic health records. Environmental Research 212 (Pt A): 113167.CrossRef Gorski-Steiner, I., K. Bandeen-Roche, H.E. Volk, S. O’Dell, and B.S. Schwartz. 2022. The association of unconventional natural gas development with diagnosis and treatment of internalizing disorders among adolescents in Pennsylvania using electronic health records. Environmental Research 212 (Pt A): 113167.CrossRef
47.
go back to reference Hays J., McCawley M., and S.B.C. Shonkoff. 2017. Public health implications of environmental noise associated with unconventional oil and gas development. Sci Total Environ. Feb 15;580:448–456. Hays J., McCawley M., and S.B.C. Shonkoff. 2017. Public health implications of environmental noise associated with unconventional oil and gas development. Sci Total Environ. Feb 15;580:448–456.
48.
go back to reference Aryee, F., A. Szolucha, P.B. Stretesky, D. Short, M.A. Long, L.A. Ritchie, and D.A. Gill. 2020. Shale gas development and community distress: Evidence from England. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 17 (14): 5069.CrossRef Aryee, F., A. Szolucha, P.B. Stretesky, D. Short, M.A. Long, L.A. Ritchie, and D.A. Gill. 2020. Shale gas development and community distress: Evidence from England. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 17 (14): 5069.CrossRef
49.
go back to reference Schultz, P. 2002. Environmental attitudes and behaviors across cultures. Online Readings in Psychology and Culture, 8(1). Schultz, P. 2002. Environmental attitudes and behaviors across cultures. Online Readings in Psychology and Culture, 8(1).
51.
go back to reference Menzies, C. 2006. Traditional Ecological Knowledge and Natural Resource Management. Traditional Ecological Knowledge and Natural Resource Management. 1–273. Menzies, C. 2006. Traditional Ecological Knowledge and Natural Resource Management. Traditional Ecological Knowledge and Natural Resource Management. 1–273.
52.
go back to reference Coffey, Y., N. Bhullar, J. Durkin, M.S. Islam, and K. Usher. 2021. Understanding eco-anxiety: A systematic scoping review of current literature and identified knowledge gaps. J. Clim. Change Health. 3: 100047.CrossRef Coffey, Y., N. Bhullar, J. Durkin, M.S. Islam, and K. Usher. 2021. Understanding eco-anxiety: A systematic scoping review of current literature and identified knowledge gaps. J. Clim. Change Health. 3: 100047.CrossRef
53.
go back to reference Moore, M., S. von der Porten, and H. Castleden. 2016. Consultation is not consent: hydraulic fracturing and water governance on Indigenous lands in Canada: Consultation is not consent. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water 4. https://doi.org/10.1002/wat2.1180. Moore, M., S. von der Porten, and H. Castleden. 2016. Consultation is not consent: hydraulic fracturing and water governance on Indigenous lands in Canada: Consultation is not consent. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water 4. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1002/​wat2.​1180.
54.
go back to reference Gochfeld M, and J. Burger. 2011 Disproportionate exposures in environmental justice and other populations: the importance of outliers. Am J Public Health. ;101 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):S53–63 Gochfeld M, and J. Burger. 2011 Disproportionate exposures in environmental justice and other populations: the importance of outliers. Am J Public Health. ;101 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):S53–63
56.
go back to reference Johnston, J.E., K. Chau, M. Franklin, and L. Cushing. 2020. Environmental justice dimensions of oil and gas flaring in South Texas: Disproportionate exposure among Hispanic communities. Environmental Science & Technology 54 (10): 6289–6298.CrossRef Johnston, J.E., K. Chau, M. Franklin, and L. Cushing. 2020. Environmental justice dimensions of oil and gas flaring in South Texas: Disproportionate exposure among Hispanic communities. Environmental Science & Technology 54 (10): 6289–6298.CrossRef
57.
go back to reference Cotton, M. 2016. Fair fracking? Ethics and environmental justice in United Kingdom shale gas policy and planning. International Journal of Justice and Sustainability. 22(2): Cotton, M. 2016. Fair fracking? Ethics and environmental justice in United Kingdom shale gas policy and planning. International Journal of Justice and Sustainability. 22(2):
58.
go back to reference Omidire, K. 2020. Access to courts by vulnerable persons in relation to hydraulic fracturing in South Africa. Commonwealth Law Bulletin. 46 (4): 662–688.CrossRef Omidire, K. 2020. Access to courts by vulnerable persons in relation to hydraulic fracturing in South Africa. Commonwealth Law Bulletin. 46 (4): 662–688.CrossRef
59.
go back to reference Behn, C. 2020. Fracking. Ecological Justice. kairoscanada.org Behn, C. 2020. Fracking. Ecological Justice. kairoscanada.org
62.
go back to reference Bondy, S.C., and A. Campbell. 2017. Water Quality and Brain Function. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 15 (1): 2.CrossRef Bondy, S.C., and A. Campbell. 2017. Water Quality and Brain Function. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 15 (1): 2.CrossRef
64.
go back to reference Aker, A.M., K.W. Whitworth, D. Bosson-Rieutort, G. Wendling, A. Ibrahim, M. Verner, A.C. Benoit, and E. Caron-Beaudoin. 2022. Proximity and density of unconventional natural gas wells and mental illness and substance use among pregnant individuals: An exploratory study in Canada. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health 242: 113962. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheh.2022.113962.CrossRef Aker, A.M., K.W. Whitworth, D. Bosson-Rieutort, G. Wendling, A. Ibrahim, M. Verner, A.C. Benoit, and E. Caron-Beaudoin. 2022. Proximity and density of unconventional natural gas wells and mental illness and substance use among pregnant individuals: An exploratory study in Canada. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health 242: 113962. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1016/​j.​ijheh.​2022.​113962.CrossRef
66.
go back to reference Casey, J.A., D.E. Goin, K.E. Rudolph, B.S. Schwartz, D. Mercer, H. Elser, E.A. Eisen, and R. Morello-Frosch. 2019. Unconventional natural gas development and adverse birth outcomes in Pennsylvania: The potential mediating role of antenatal anxiety and depression. Environmental Research 177: 108598. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2019.108598.CrossRef Casey, J.A., D.E. Goin, K.E. Rudolph, B.S. Schwartz, D. Mercer, H. Elser, E.A. Eisen, and R. Morello-Frosch. 2019. Unconventional natural gas development and adverse birth outcomes in Pennsylvania: The potential mediating role of antenatal anxiety and depression. Environmental Research 177: 108598. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1016/​j.​envres.​2019.​108598.CrossRef
67.
go back to reference Tesluk, J., J. Illes, and R. Matthews. 2017. Neuroethics: Perspectives on brain health from a world of change. In Neuroethics: Anticipating the future, 455. Tesluk, J., J. Illes, and R. Matthews. 2017. Neuroethics: Perspectives on brain health from a world of change. In Neuroethics: Anticipating the future, 455.
68.
go back to reference Aczel, M. and K. Makuch. 2019. Shale, Quakes, and High Stakes: Regulating Fracking-Induced Seismicity in Oklahoma, USA and Lancashire, UK. Case Studies in the Environment. 3. Aczel, M. and K. Makuch. 2019. Shale, Quakes, and High Stakes: Regulating Fracking-Induced Seismicity in Oklahoma, USA and Lancashire, UK. Case Studies in the Environment. 3.
69.
go back to reference Boyle, M.D., D.C. Payne-Sturges, T. Sangaramoorthy, S. Wilson, K.E. Nachman, K. Babik, C.C. Jenkins, J. Trowell, D.K. Milton, and A. Sapkota. 2016. Hazard ranking methodology for assessing health impacts of unconventional natural gas development and production: The Maryland case study. PLoS One 11(1):e0145368.CrossRef Boyle, M.D., D.C. Payne-Sturges, T. Sangaramoorthy, S. Wilson, K.E. Nachman, K. Babik, C.C. Jenkins, J. Trowell, D.K. Milton, and A. Sapkota. 2016. Hazard ranking methodology for assessing health impacts of unconventional natural gas development and production: The Maryland case study. PLoS One 11(1):e0145368.CrossRef
70.
go back to reference Haswell, M. R., and A. Bethmont. 2016. Health concerns associated with unconventional gas mining in rural Australia. Rural Remote Health. 2016 ;16(4):3825. Haswell, M. R., and A. Bethmont. 2016. Health concerns associated with unconventional gas mining in rural Australia. Rural Remote Health. 2016 ;16(4):3825.
82.
go back to reference Montpetit, É., E. Lachapelle, and A. Harvey. 2016. Advocacy coalitions, the media, and hydraulic fracturing in the Canadian Provinces of British Columbia and Quebec. In Policy debates on hydraulic fracturing, eds. C. Weible, T. Heikkila, K. Ingold, and M. Fischer. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-59574-4_3.CrossRef Montpetit, É., E. Lachapelle, and A. Harvey. 2016. Advocacy coalitions, the media, and hydraulic fracturing in the Canadian Provinces of British Columbia and Quebec. In Policy debates on hydraulic fracturing, eds. C. Weible, T. Heikkila, K. Ingold, and M. Fischer. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1057/​978-1-137-59574-4_​3.CrossRef
90.
go back to reference Kern, T.A. 2011. A human rights assessment of hydraulic fracturing for natural gas. Environmental and Human Rights Advisory Kern, T.A. 2011. A human rights assessment of hydraulic fracturing for natural gas. Environmental and Human Rights Advisory
Metadata
Title
Ethical Implications of the Impact of Fracking on Brain Health
Authors
Ava Grier
Judy Illes
Publication date
01-04-2024
Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Published in
Neuroethics / Issue 1/2024
Print ISSN: 1874-5490
Electronic ISSN: 1874-5504
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12152-024-09546-5

Other articles of this Issue 1/2024

Neuroethics 1/2024 Go to the issue