Analysis of the Factors Affecting the Success of Weight Reduction Programs

The prevalence of obesity is increasing in the Korea as well as around the world.1 Obesity is a risk factor for numerous health problems such as coronary heart disease, hypertension, diabetes, stroke, osteoarthritis and cancer.2-4 Behavior modification is the foundation of obesity treatment.5-7 Behavior modification refers to changes in eating behavior and the level of physical activity.5-7 The weight reduction program in our study was directed by a doctor, a dietitian, a nurse and a exercise programmer. The weight reduction program included an interview on the patients' diet, physical activity and medical condition. Sibutramine or orlistat were also prescribed to complement the behavioral therapy.8, 9 It is clinically important that we can predict which factors are related to reduction of body weight after weight loss intervention. The aim of the present study was to identify the parameters associated with successful weight reduction.

The percentage of people who lost weight on the weight reduction program was 36.6% (45/123) and percentage of people who failed to loose weight was 63.4% (78/123). One hundred twenty three persons (94%) among the total number surveyed (131 persons) were included into the final multiple logistic regression analysis. All persons had been given medication (sibutramine or orlistat) in the early period of the weight reduction program. The baseline characteristics of the success group and failure group, according to outcome of weight reduction are shown in the Table 1. The subjects were divided into the success group (n = 45) and the failure group (n = 78). There were no significant differences in age, gender and education between the 2 groups (Table 1). The follow up period and the frequency of medical visits between the 2 groups were significantly different (p = 0.0004 and p = 0.0005, respectively). However, the mean follow-up interval was not different between failure and success group (p = 0.3) (Table 1).

Table 1
The Baseline Characteristics of the Success Group and the Failure Group According to the Weight Reduction Outcome

• Click for larger image

Table 2 illustrates the association of the selected risk factors with the outcome of weight reduction. All of them were not significant.

Table 2
Association with the Selected Risk Factors between the Success Group and the Failure Group According to the Outcome of Weight Reduction

• Click for larger image

The prevalence of obesity is increasing around the world.1 The clinical significance of obesity is that obesity is a risk factor for numerous health problems such as cardiovascular disease and diabetes mellitus.2-4 Because of the public health burden of obesity, it is not surprising that enormous sums of money are spent annually on diet aids and treatment approaches. Any short-term weight losses are generally temporary with relapse.11 Only long-term behavior-modification strategies can substantially enhance and maintain weight lost, so obesity treatment can have a good outcome.12 A modest reduction in calories and a small increase in activity may be the optimal way to achieve weight reduction.12-15 Although the mechanisms of pharmacotherapy and behavior modification are different, they complement each other and enhance the treatment outcome.8, 9 The combination of medication plus behavior modification was superior to either approach when they were used separately.8, 9 All subjects in this study population had medication in the early period or they took medicine intermittently.

In this study, the total follow up period and high frequency of medical visits were powerful predictor of successful weight reduction. Our result suggested that strong motivation is the most important factor for successful weight reduction. Many obese patients enrolled on the first visit time were prompt to drop out from the weight reduction program since they had suffered hardships to modify their behavior, for example, to exercise and reduce their caloric intake.

A high initial body weight by itself has a possibility to provide strong motivation to participate in the program. While males subjects had a busier social schedule as a consequence of their occupations, female subjects showed better behavior modification of their life style, for example, less frequent eating-out and taking sufficient time for exercise. Obesity is positively associated with insulin resistance and increased serum concentrations of vascular inflammatory markers.16, 17 It is well known that CRP is elevated in obese adults.17 In this study, we didn't observe any relationship with initial body weight and CRP level. In previous studies, the current smokers are known to have higher metabolic rates than none-smoker.18 Current smokers have a tendency to also have other inappropriate life style factors, for example, inappropriate stress coping strategies.18 Fatty liver and diabetes are obesity related illness.2, 3 Diagnosed obesity related illnesses were significant sources of motivation for the participants.2 The subjects who have a family history of obesity and obesity in childhood seemed to have more difficulty for weight reduction.19 The subjects who have a high RMR and high VO₂max seemed to loose weight more easily.10 This study failed to demonstrate a significant association between the outcome of weight reduction and any risk factors.

This study has some limitations. The number of subjects who participated in weight reduction programs and registered in the weight control program DB, based on the outcome of weight reduction was only 123. Due to the small number of study subjects, there was limited statistical power to evaluate certain main effects of most risk factors. Second, this study was not a clinical trial with random allocation and blinding method. Thus, the interpretation was limited by the lack of qualified measures. We need the further research using clinical trial design. Third, the success group is defined by people who attained more than 5% weight reduction during the follow-up period. By defining the success group as those people who attained more than 5% weight reduction, that is, considering just a change to a lower weight category only, we couldn't exactly analyze which parameter was really associated with the extent of successful weight reduction, that is, changes that might occur within the same category. This definition could underestimate the real weight reduction, especially in the severe obese patients. In present study, the dietary components, including carbohydrates, proteins, fats and calories, were not associated with weight reduction. The additional limitation of our study is that a validated dietary survey was not used.

The present study identified the predictors for successful weight reduction. Total follow up period and high frequency of medical visits were the significant predictors of successful weight reduction. Our result suggested that strong motivation is the most important factor for successful weight reduction.