Abstract
Conclusions from empirical research employing the Health Belief Model (HBM) to investigate breast and cervical cancer and women's preventive health behaviors have been inconsistent and sometimes addressed contradictory, leading scholars to question utility of the model. Therefore we address utility of the HBM by conducting a comprehensive literature review. Using 10 electronic databases, we identified 39 published studies applying the HBM to mammographic and/or Papanicolaou (pap) screening. Overall, we found strongest support for the HBM's perceived benefit and barrier constructs, compared to other constructs. Weakest support was found for the HBM's perceptions of the disease construct. More recently collected data from nationally representative and ethnically/racially diverse samples, as well as more sophisticated methodological approaches are necessary to further evaluate the HBM.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aiken, L.S., West, S.G., Woodward, C.K. and Reno, R.R. (1994) Health beliefs and compliance with mammography-screening recommendations in asymptomatic women. Health Psychology 13: 122–129.
Aiken, L.S., Fenaughty, A.M., West, S.G., Johnson, J.J. and Luckett, T.L. (1995) Perceived determinants of risk for breast cancer and the relations among objective risk, perceived risk, and screening behavior over time. Women's Health: Research on Gender, Behavior, and Policy 1: 27–50.
Allison, P.D. (1999) Multiple Regression: A Primer. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
American Cancer Society. (2009) Estimated New Cancer Cases and Deaths by Sex, US, 2009. Atlanta, GA: American Cancer Society.
Asher, H.B. (1976) Causal Modeling. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
Ashing-Giwa, K. (1999) Health behavior change models and their socio-cultural relevance for breast cancer screening in African American women. Women & Health 28: 53–71.
Austin, L.T., Ahmad, F., McNally, M.J. and Stewart, D.E. (2002) Breast and cervical cancer screening in Hispanic women: A literature review using the Health Belief Model. Women's Health Issues 12: 122–128.
Becker, M.H (ed.) (1974a) The Health Belief Model and Personal Health Behavior. Thorofare, NJ: Charles B. Slack Inc.
Becker, M.H. (1974b) The Health Belief Model and personal health behavior. Health Education Monographs 2: 324–473.
Bloom, J.R., Grazier, K., Hodge, F. and Hayes, W.A. (1991) Factors affecting the use of screening mammography among African American women. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention 1: 75–82.
Buki, L.P., Borrayo, E.A., Feigal, B.M. and Carrillo, I.Y. (2004) Are all Latinas the same? Perceived breast cancer screening barriers and facilitative conditions. Psychology of Women Quarterly 28: 400–411.
Burack, R.C. and Liang, J. (1989) The acceptance and completion of mammography by older Black women. American Journal of Public Health 79: 721–726.
Champion, V. (1991) The relationship of selected variables to breast cancer detection behaviors in women 35 and older. Oncology Nursing Forum 18: 733–739.
Champion, V. (1992) Compliance with guidelines for mammography screening. Cancer Detection and Prevention 16: 253–258.
Champion, V. (1995) Development of a benefits and barriers scale for mammography utilization. Cancer Nursing 18: 53–59.
Champion, V. (1999) Revised susceptibility, benefits, and barriers scale for mammography screening. Research in Nursing & Health 22: 341–348.
Champion, V. and Menon, U. (1997) Predicting mammography and breast self-examination in African American women. Cancer Nursing 20: 315–322.
Champion, V. and Scott, C.R. (1997) Reliability and validity of breast cancer screening belief scales in African American women. Nursing Research 46: 331–337.
Champion, V.L. et al (2008) Measuring mammography and breast cancer beliefs in African American women. Journal of Health Psychology 13: 827–837.
Cockburn, J., Murphy, B., Schofield, P., Hill, D. and Borland, R. (1991) Development of a strategy to encourage attendance for screening mammography. Health Education Research 6: 279–290.
Curry, S.J. and Emmons, K.M. (1994) Theoretical models for predicting and improving compliance with breast cancer screening. Annals of Behavioral Medicine 16: 302–316.
Duke, S.S., Gordon-Sosby, K., Reynolds, K.D. and Gram, I.T. (1994) A study of breast cancer detection practices and beliefs in Black women attending public health clinics. Health Education Research 9: 331–342.
Fulton, J.P., Rakowski, W. and Jones, A.C. (1995) Determinants of breast cancer screening among inner-city Hispanic women in comparison with other inner-city women. Public Health Reports 110: 476–482.
Fulton, J.P. et al (1991) A study guided by the Health Belief Model of the predictors of breast cancer screening of women ages 40 and older. Public Health Reports 106: 410–420.
Gillam, S.J. (1991) Understanding the uptake of cervical cancer screening: The contribution of the Health Belief Model. British Journal of General Practice 41: 510–513.
Hennig, P. and Knowles, A. (1990) Factors influencing women over 40 years to take precautions against cervical cancer. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 20: 1612–1621.
Hochbaum, G.M. (1958) Public participation in medical screening programs: A socio-psychological study. PHS publication 572. Washington DC: Government Printing Office.
Holm, C.J., Frank, D.I. and Curtin, J. (1999) Health beliefs, health locus of control, and women's mammography behavior. Cancer Nursing 22: 149–156.
Hyman, R.B., Baker, S., Ephraim, R., Moadel, A. and Philip, J. (1994) Health Belief Model variables as predictors of screening mammography utilization. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 17: 391–406.
Ingledue, K., Cottrell, R. and Bernard, A. (2004) College women's knowledge, perceptions, and preventive behaviors regarding human papillomavirus infection and cervical cancer. American Journal of Health Studies 19: 28–34.
Janz, N.K., Champion, V.L. and Strecher, V.J. (2002) The Health Belief Model. In: K. Glanz, B. K. Rimer and F. M. Lewis (eds.) Health Behavior and Health Education: Theory, Research, and Practice. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, pp. 45–66.
Jepson, C., Kessler, L.G., Portnoy, B. and Gibbs, T. (1991) Black-White differences in cancer prevention knowledge and behavior. American Journal of Public Health 81: 501–504.
Kash, K.M., Holland, J.C., Halper, M.S. and Miller, D.G. (1992) Psychological distress and surveillance behaviors of women with a family history of breast cancer. Journal of the National Cancer Institute 84: 24–30.
Ko, C.M., Sadler, G.R., Ryujin, L. and Dong, A. (2003) Filipina American women's breast cancer knowledge, attitudes, and screening behaviors. BMC Public Health 3: 27.
Kurtz, M.E., Given, B., Given, C.W. and Kurtz, J.C. (1993) Relationships of barriers and facilitators to breast self-examination, mammography, and clinical breast examination in a worksite population. Cancer Nursing 16: 251–259.
Lerman, C., Caputo, C. and Brody, D. (1990) Factors associated with inadequate cervical cancer screening among lower income primary care patients. The Journal of the American Board of Family Practice 3: 151–156.
Long, J.S. (1983) Covariance Structure Models. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Mandelblatt, J., Traxler, M., Lakin, P., Kanetsky, P., Kao, R. and the Harlem Study Team (1992) Mammography and Papanicolaou smear use by elderly poor Black women. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 40: 1001–1007.
Mandelblatt, J., Traxler, M., Lakin, P., Kanetsky, P., Kao, R. and the Harlem Study Team (1993) Targeting breast and cervical cancer screening to elderly poor black women: Who will participate? Preventive Medicine 22: 20–33.
McFarland, D.M. (2003) Cervical cancer and pap smear screening in Botswana: Knowledge and perceptions. International Nursing Review 50: 167–175.
Mikhail, B. (1981) The Health Belief Model: A review and critical evaluation of the model, research, and practice. Advances in Nursing Science 4: 65–82.
National Center for Health Statistics. (2009) Health, United States, 2008. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Orbell, S. (1996) Cognition and affect after cervical screening: The role of previous test outcome and personal obligation in future uptake expectations. Social Science & Medicine 43: 1237–1243.
Pearlman, D.N., Clark, M.A., Rakowski, W. and Ehrich, B. (1999) Screening for breast and cervical cancers: The importance of knowledge and perceived cancer survivability. Women & Health 28: 93–112.
Phillips, J.M. and Wilbur, J. (1995) Adherence to breast cancer screening guidelines among African-American women of differing employment status. Cancer Nursing 18: 258–269.
Price, J.H., Desmond, S.M., Slenker, S., Smith, D. and Stewart, P.W. (1992) Urban Black women's perceptions of breast cancer and mammography. Journal of Community Health 17: 191–204.
Rimer, B.K. (1995) Audiences and messages for breast and cervical cancer screenings. Wellness Perspectives: Research, Theory, and Practice 11: 13–39.
Rimer, B.K., Trock, B., Engstrom, P.F., Lerman, C. and King, E. (1991) Why do some women get regular mammograms? American Journal of Preventive Medicine 7: 69–74.
Rosenstock, I.M. (1960) What research in motivation suggests for public health. American Journal of Public Health 50: 295–302.
Rosenstock, I.M. (1974) Historical origins of the Health Belief Model. In M. H. Becker (ed.) The Health Belief Model and Personal Health Behavior. Thorofare, NJ: Charles B. Slack, pp. 1–8.
Rutledge, D.N., Hartmann, W.H., Kinman, P.O. and Winfield, A.C. (1988) Exploration of factors affecting mammography behaviors. Preventive Medicine 17: 412–422.
Sadler, G.R., Ryujin, L.T., Ko, C.M. and Nguyen, E. (2001) Korean women: Breast cancer knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors. BMC Public Health 1: 7.
Savage, S.A. and Clarke, V.A. (2001) Factors associated with breast and cervical cancer screening behaviours. Health Education 101: 176–186.
Schulmeister, L. and Lifsey, D.S. (1999) Cervical cancer screening knowledge, behaviors, and beliefs of Vietnamese women. Oncology Nursing Forum 26: 879–887.
Seow, A., Wong, M.L., Smith, W.C.S. and Lee, H.P. (1995) Beliefs and attitudes as determinants of cervical cancer screening: A community-based study in Singapore. Preventive Medicine 24: 134–141.
Stein, J.A., Fox, S.A., Murata, P.J. and Morisky, D.E. (1992) Mammography usage and the Health Belief Model. Health Education & Behavior 19: 447–462.
Taplin, S., Anderman, C. and Grothaus, L. (1989) Breast cancer risk and participation in mammographic screening. American Journal of Public Health 79: 1494–1498.
Thomas, L.R., Fox, S.A., Leake, B.G. and Roetzheim, R.G. (1996) The effects of health beliefs on screening mammography utilization among a diverse sample of older women. Women & Health 24: 77–94.
Vadaparampil, S.T., Champion, V.L., Miller, T.K., Menon, U. and Skinner, C.S. (2003) Using the Health Belief Model to examine differences in adherence to mammography among African-American and Caucasian women. Journal of Psychosocial Oncology 21: 59–79.
Vernon, S.W. (1999) Risk perception and risk communication for cancer screening behaviors: A review. Journal of the National Cancer Institute Monographs 25: 101–119.
Watson, E.K., Henderson, B.J., Brett, J., Bankhead, C. and Austoker, J. (2005) The psychological impact of mammographic screening on women with a family history of breast cancer – A systematic review. Psycho-Oncology 14: 939–948.
Weissfeld, J.L., Brock, B.M., Kirscht, J.P. and Hawthorne, V.M. (1987) Reliability of health belief indexes: Confirmatory factor analysis in sex, race, and age subgroups. Health Services Research 21: 777–793.
Yarbrough, S.S. and Braden, C.J. (2001) Utility of Health Belief Model as a guide for explaining or predicting breast cancer screening behaviours. Journal of Advanced Nursing 33: 677–688.
Yi, J.K. and Prows, S.L. (1996) Breast cancer screening practices among Cambodian women in Houston, Texas. Journal of Cancer Education 11: 221–225.
Zapka, J.G., Stoddard, A.M., Costanza, M.E. and Greene, H.L. (1989) Breast cancer screening by mammography: Utilization and associated factors. American Journal of Public Health 79: 1499–1502.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Tanner-Smith, E., Brown, T. Evaluating the Health Belief Model: A critical review of studies predicting mammographic and pap screening. Soc Theory Health 8, 95–125 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1057/sth.2009.23
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/sth.2009.23