Differences in the relationship between body fat and body mass index between two different Indonesian ethnic groups: The effect of body build

Abstract

Objective: To study the relationship between body fat percent (BF%) and body mass index (BMI) in two different Indonesian ethnic groups (Malays and Chinese) and to relate differences in the relationship to differences in body build and slenderness.

Design: Cross-sectional study.

Subjects: Except for ethnicity, not specially selected populations living on Java (Depok, south of Jakarta: Malay Indonesians, n=117) and on Sulawesi (Makale, north of Ujung Pandang: Chinese Indonesians, n=109).

Measurements: Weight, height, sitting height, waist and hip circumferences and skeletal widths were measured. BMI was calculated and BF% was predicted from BMI, age and sex using a (Dutch) Caucasian prediction formula. Slenderness was expressed as the ratio of weight:sum of knee and wrist width. BF% assessed by deuterium oxide dilution was used as a reference.

Results: BF% in the male and female Malay Indonesians was 24.6±7.0 and 35.6±5.6% respectively which was not significantly different from the values in the male and female Chinese Indonesians (24.0±4.3 and 33.8±6.9%). BMI and age were significantly lower in the Malay Indonesians. Malay Indonesians had a more slender body build in terms of skeletal widths compared to the Chinese Indonesians, and they had a higher slenderness index. BF% predicted from BMI using a Caucasian prediction formula was underestimated by 5.8±4.8% and 7.7±3.8% in the male and female Malay Indonesians but only by 1.3±3.0% and 1.7±3.7% in the male and female Chinese Indonesians. After correction for differences in age, sex and BF% the Malay Indonesians had a 1.7±0.3 kg/m² (P<0.0001) lower BMI than the Chinese Indonesians. After correcting for body build and relative sitting height the difference lowered to 0.9±0.4 kg/m² (P<0.02).

Conclusions: The study confirmed the results of an earlier study that Indonesians have a higher BF% at the same BMI compared to Caucasians, but that there are apparently also differences among Indonesian subgroups. These differences are at least partly related to differences in body build.