Abstract
Objective: To determine whether health maintenance organizations (HMOs) have monopsony power in the markets for ambulatory care and inpatient hospital services.
Data Sources: A pooled time-series of data on all HMOs operating in the United States from 1985 through 1997. Information reported to InterStudy on HMO market areas and enrollment is linked to financial data reported to state regulators and county characteristics from the Area Resource File (ARF).
Study Design: We use a two-stage design to test for the existence of monopsony power. First, we estimate regression equations for the prices paid by HMOs for ambulatory visits and inpatient hospital days. The key independent variable is a measure of the importance of an individual HMO as a buyer of ambulatory care or hospital services. Second, we estimate regressions for the utilization of ambulatory visits and inpatient hospital days per HMO enrollee, as a function of HMO buying power and other variables.
Principal Findings: Increased HMO buying power is associated with lower price and higher utilization of hospital services. Buying power is not related to ambulatory visit price or utilization per member.
Conclusions: Our findings are not consistent with the monopsony hypothesis. They suggest that managed care organizations have contributed to a welfare-increasing breakup of hospital monopoly power. The role of HMOs as buyers of ambulatory services is more complex. We discuss possible reasons why buying power may not affect price or utilization of ambulatory visits.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ahern, M., R. Rosenman, M. Hendryx, K. Siddharthan and G. Silverstein. (1996). “Predictors of HMOEfficiency. ” Applied Economics 28, 1381–1390.
Alexander, J. A. and M. A. Morrisey. (1988). “Hospital Selection in Multihospital Systems. ” Medical Care 26(2), February, 159–176.
Alexander, J. A. and M. A. Morrisey. (1989). “AResource-Dependence Model of Hospital Contract Management. ” Health Services Research 24(2), June, 259–284.
Benham, L., A. Maurizi and M. W. Reder. (1968). “Migration, Location and Remuneration of Medical Personnel: Physicians and Dentists. ” Review of Economics and Statistics 50, August, 332–347.
Booton, L. and J. Lane. (1985). “Hospital Market Structure and the Return to Nursing Education. ” Journal of Human Resources 20(2), Spring, 184–196.
Carlton, D. W. and J. M. Perloff. (1990). Modern Industrial Organization. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman.
Feldman, R., H.-C. Chan, J. Kralewski, B. Dowd and J. Shapiro. (1990a). “Effects of HMOs on the Creation of Competitive Markets for Hospital Services. ” Journal of Health Economics 9(2), September, 207–222.
Feldman, R., J. Kralewski, J. Shapiro and H.-C. Chan. (1990b). “Contracts Between Hospitals and Health Main-tenance Organizations. ” Health Care Management Review 15(1), Winter, 47–60.
Feldman, R., D. Wholey and J. Christianson. (1996). “The Effect of Mergers on Health Maintenance Organization Premiums. ” Health Care Financing Review 17(3), Spring, 171–189.
Feldman, R., D. Wholey and J. B. Christianson. (1998). “Do Medicare HMOs Cost-Shift?” Inquiry 35(3), Fall, 315–331.
Feldman, R., D. Wholey and J. Christianson. (1999). “Health Maintenance Organization Consolidations: Recent Developments and Implications for Public Policy. ” Health Affairs 18(4), July/August, 96–104.
Foreman, S. E., J. A. Wilson and R. M. Scheffler. (1996). “Monopoly, Monopsony, and Contestability in Health Insurance: A Study of Blue Cross Plans. ” Economic Inquiry 34(4), October, 662–677.
Hausman, J. A. (1978). “Specification Tests in Econometrics. ” Econometrica 46 November, 1251–1271.
Hirsch, B. T. and E. Schumacher. (1995). “Monopsony Power and Relative Wages in the Labor Market for Nurses. ” Journal of Health Economics 14(4), October, 443–476.
Hurd, R. W. (1973). “Equilibrium Vacancies in a Labor Market Dominated by Non-Profit Firms: The ‘shortage’ of Nurses. ” Review of Economics and Statistics 55, May, 234–240.
Kralewski, J. E., E. C. Rich, R. Feldman, B. E. Dowd, T. Bernhardt, C. Johnson and W. Gold. (2000). “The Effects of Medical Group Practice and Physician Payment Methods on Costs of Care. ” Health Services Research 35(3), August, 591–613.
Makuc, D. M., B. Haglund, D. D. Ingram, J. C. Kleinman and J. J. Feldman. (1991). “Health Service Areas for the United States. ” Vital Health Statistics 112(2), November, 1–102.
McCarthy, T. R. and D. I. Kass. (1983). “The Effect of Certificate of Need Regulation on Investor-Owned Hospital Market Share, ” paper presented at the American Economic Association annual convention, San Francisco, CA, December.
Pauly, M. V. (1998). “Managed Care, Market Power, and Monopsony. ” Health Services Research 33(5), Part II December, 1439–1460.
Rosenman, R., K. Siddharthan and M. Ahern. (1997). “Output Efficiency of Health Maintenance Organizations in Florida. ” Health Economics 6, 295–302.
Rubenstein, E. L., K. A. Schulman, J. Hadley and J. Escarce. (1995). “HMOs and the Provision of Tertiary Care Services: Site Reports, ” Institute for Health Care Research and Policy, Georgetown University, May.
Sales, A. E. B. (1998). Estimating Wages and Returns to Education in Nursing, unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Minnesota.
Simon, C. J., D. Dranove and W. D. White. (1998). “The Effect of Managed Care on the Incomes of Primary Care and Specialty Physicians. ” Health Services Research 33(3), Part I, August, 549–570.
Sloan, F. A. (1978). Equalizing Access to Nursing Services: The Geographic Dimension. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, DHEW Publication HRA, 78–51, March.
Sullivan, D. (1989). “Monopsony Power in the Market for Nurses. ” Journal of Law and Economics 32(2), Part 2, October, S135–178.
Weiner, J. P. (1994). “Forecasting the Effects of Health Reform on US Physicians Workforce Requirement. ” Journal of the American Medical Association 272(3), July 20, 222–230.
Wholey, D., R. Feldman and J. B. Christianson. (1995). “The Effect of Market Structure on HMO Premiums. ” Journal of Health Economics 14(1), May, 81–105.
Wholey, D., R. Feldman, J. B. Christianson and J. Engberg. (1996). “Scale and Scope Economies Among Health Maintenance Organizations. ” Journal of Health Economics 15(6), December, 657–684.
Yett, D. E. (1970). “The Chronic ‘shortage’ of Nurses: A Public Policy Dilemma, ” in Empirical Studies in Health Economics, ed. by Herbert K. Klarman, Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins Press, 357–389.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Feldman, R., Wholey, D. Do HMOs Have Monopsony Power?. International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics 1, 7–22 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011595820483
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011595820483