Summary
From 1971 to 1985, 44 cases of self-induced factitious disorders were observed in the Medical Department of a University Hospital. The diseases were often severe, one patient even died. The various symptoms and diseases presented by the patients, the methods of producing them, and the diagnostic and therapeutic aspects of these cases are described.
Patients were analysed with regard to age, sex, profession, psychosocial adaptation, number and duration of hospitalisations, presentation of complaints, behaviour on the ward, relation to the doctor, self-destructive tendencies, readiness to suffer and possible motivations. According to the criteria of the DSM-III, seven patients were malingerers (DSM-III: V 65.20) and 37 had a “chronic factitious disorder with physical symptoms” (DSM-III: 301.51). However, the findings in the patients of the latter group strongly suggest that they form an extremely heterogeneous population. Therefore we propose a subclassification of the DSM-III category 301.51 as follows:
-
Type A.
Muenchausen syndrome in the proper sense; dramatic deception of mainly acute illness; pseudologia fantastica; social maladaptation, chaotic life situations; many, mostly short hospitalisations; many interventions; at first well adapted, later hostile; mostly men.
-
Typ B.
Self-induced, mainly chronic illness; behaviour adequate, highly compliant; often little emotion, contrasting with the sometimes severe illness; socially adapted; history remarkably blank with regard to psychosocial stress; several often long-lasting hospitalisations and many interventions; almost exclusively younger women from (para-)-medical professions.
-
Type C.
Willfull interference with the healing of wounds, cutaneous ulcers, abscesses or dermatological artefacts; history with marked personal losses or severe chronic medical problems; at first well adapted, later hostile, passive/aggressive; women prevail.
A conversion syndrome (DSM-III: 300.11) was not observed.
In contrast to malingering, the basis of the disorder in types A, B and C is unconcious in origin, thus similar to the conversion syndrome. Contrary to the latter, however, the production of physical symptoms is under voluntary control. The proposed subclassification represents a hypothesis for testing which might facilitate the analysis of the basic personality disorder, so far lacking. The investigation of the psychopathology of these patients and their treatment is difficult if not impossible because most refuse psychiatric exploration and therapy. Consequently follow-up studies and data on the prognosis are rare.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literatur
Aduan RP, Fauci AS, Dale DC, Herzberg JH, Wolff SM (1979) Factitious fever and self-induced infection. Ann Intern Med 90:230–242
Asher R (1951) Munchausen's syndrome. Lancet I:339–341
Battegay R (1984) Psychiatrische Aspekte des Münchhausen-Syndroms. Schweiz Rundschau Med 73:1203–1207
Beck D (1977) Das „Koryphäen-Killer-Syndrom“. Dtsch med Wochenschr 102:303–307
Berne E (1967) Spiele der Erwachsenen. Rowohlt, Reinbek
Berney TP (1973) A review of simulated illness. S Afr Med J 47:1429–1434
Bleuler E (1983) Lehrbuch der Psychiatrie. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Bock KD, Overkamp F (1985) Vortäuschung von Krankheit — eine Analyse von 28 Fällen und Vorschlag einer Klassifikation. Klin Wochenschr (Suppl IV):30
Bräutigam W, Christian P (1981) Psychosomatische Medizin. Thieme, Stuttgart
Breuer N, Balzer K, Goebell H (1985) Faktitielle Diarrhoe. medwelt 36:9–12
Cavenar JO, Maltbie AA, Hillard JR, Worchel BJ, O'Shanick GJ (1980) Cardiac presentation of Munchhausen syndrome. Psychosomatics 31:946–948
Changeux JP (1984) Der neuronale Mensch. Rowohlt, Reinbek
Chapman JS (1957) Peregrinating problem patients — Munchausen's syndrome. J Amer Med Ass 165:927–933
Clarke E, Melnick SC (1958) The Munchausen syndrome or the problem of hospital hoboes. Am J Med 25:6–12
Cramer B, Gershberg MR, Stern M (1971) Munchausen syndrome. Its relationship to malingering, hysteria, and the physician-patient relationship. Arch Gen Psychiat 24:573–578
Creutzfeldt W, Frerichs H (1969) Hypoglycaemia factitia. Dtsch med Wochenschr 94:813–818
Daily WJR, Coles JM, Creger WP (1963) Factitious anemia. Ann Intern Med 58:533–538
Diagnostisches und statistisches Manual psychischer Störungen — DSM-III (1984) (Deutsche Bearbeitung von Köhler K und Sass H) Beltz, Weinheim Basel
Ford CV (1973) The Munchausen syndrome: A report of four new cases and a review of psychodynamic considerations. Psychiatry Med 4:31–45
Ford CV (1983) The somatizing disorders. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Ford CV, Abernethy V (1981) Factitious illness: A multidisciplinary consideration of ethical issues. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 3:329–336
Frame B, Jackson GM, Kleerekoper M, Rao DS, DeLorenzo AJD, Garcia M (1981) Acute severe hypercalcemia a la Münchausen. Am J Med 70:316–319
Gavin H (1863) Feigned and fictious diseases chiefly of soldiers and seamen. Churchill Ltd, London
Grosspietzsch R, Grosspietzsch SM, Müller G (1985) Die gutachterliche Beurteilung von artefiziellen Erkrankungen und Krankheitsverlängerungen. Der med Sachverst 81:32–35
Gurwith M, Langston C (1980) Factitious Munchausen syndrome. N Engl J Med 302:1483–1484
Haenel T, Rauchfleisch U, Schuppli R (1982) Die Bedeutung von Hautartefakten. Schweiz med Wochenschr 112:326–333
Haenel T, Rauchfleisch U, Schuppli R, Battegay R (1984) The psychiatric significance of dermatitis artefacta. Eur Arch Psychiatr Neurol Sci 234:38–41
Hale V, Evseichick O (1943) Fraudulent fever. Am J Nurs 43:992–994
Hamolsky MW (1982) Truth is stranger than facitious. N Engl J Med 307:436–437
Harnoss CM, Harnoss BM, Lode H, Dissmann TH (1984) Münchhausen-Syndrom — chronisch rezidivierendes Fieber bei sechs Patientinnen. Verh dtsch Ges inn Med 90:813–815
Heinrich HC, Gabbe EE (1978) Whole body59fe-elimination rates and corresponding blood losses in patients with factitious anemia induced by self-blood letting. Klin Wochenschr 56:1057–1065
Hollender MH, Abram HS (1973) Dermatitis factitia. South Med J 6:1279–1285
Ireland P, Sapira JD, Templeton B (1967) Munchausen' syndrome — review and report of an additional case. Am J Med 43:579–592
Janus L (1972) Persönlichkeitsstruktur und Psychodynamik bei dermatologischen Artefakten. Z psychosom Med Psychoanal 18:21–28
Justus PG, Kreutziger SS, Kitchens CS (1980) Probing the dynamics of Munchhausen's syndrome. Detailed analysis of a case. Ann Int Med 93:120–127
Jutz P, Clavadetscher P, Wegmann T (1976) Laxantieninduzierte Diarrhöe — eine Form von Selbstmutilation. Schweiz med Wochenschr 106:1015–1019
Katz FH, Eckert RC, Gebott MD (1972) Hypokalemia caused by surreptitious self-administration of diuretics. Ann Intern Med 76:85–90
Kerr DNS, Wilkinson R, Horler AR, Schapira K, Walls J (1980) Factitious hematuria and urinary tract infection. Arch Intern Med 140:631–633
Korting GW, Heidbüchel U (1984) Das sog. chronisch-traumatische Handödem. medwelt 35:750–753
Lyell A (1979) Cutaneous artifactual disease. Am Acad Dermatol 1:391–407
MacNeal WJ (1939) Hyperthermia genuine and spurious. Arch Intern Med 64:800–808
Mariotti S, Martino E, Cupini C, Lari R, Giani C, Baschieri L, Pinchera A (1982) Low serum thyroglobulin as a clue to the diagnosis of thyrotoxicosis factitia. N Eng J Med 307:410–412
Maur von K, Kenneth RW, DeFord MJW, Caranasos GJ (1973) Munchausen's syndrome: A thirty-year history of peregrination par excellence. South Med J 66:629–632
Nadelson T (1979) The Munchhausen spectrum. Borderline character features. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 1:11–17
Nordmeyer J, Zick R, Avenarius HJ, Mielke H, Anagnou J, Mitzkat HJ, Freyberger H (1984) “Factitious disease”: Psychodynamik und Patientenumgang. Med Klin 79:501–503
Petersdorf RG, Bennett jr IL (1957) Factitious fever. Ann Intern Med 46:1039–1062
Pitt E, Pitt B (1984) Cardiopathia fantastica. Am Heart J 108:137–141
Plassmann R, Teising M, Freyberger H (1985) Ein ‚Mimikry‘-Patient: Bericht über den Behandlungsversuch einer selbstgemachten Krankheit. Prax Kinderpsychol Kinderpsychiat 34:133–141
Rechenberger I (1971) Artefakte aus psychogener Ursache. Z Haut-Geschl Kr 46:795–801
Reed JL (1978) Disorders of conscious awareness, compensation neurosis and Münchhausen syndrome. Brit J Hosp Med 19:314–321
Reich P, Gottfried LA (1983) Factitious disorders in a teaching hospital. Ann Intern Med 99:240–247
Rieger HJ (1975) Allgemeines Persönlichkeitsrecht und Schweigepflicht bei der Behandlung von Simulanten. Dtsch med Wochenschr 100:567–568
Scarlett JA (1977) Factitious hypoglycemia. N Engl J Med 297:1029–1032
Scharfetter C (1984) Automanipulation von Krankheit. Schweiz med Wochenschr 114:1142–1149
Schnur S (1940) Malingering responsible for long-continued, unexplained fever. South Med J 33:768–769
Schulte W, Tölle R (1979) Psychiatrie. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Scully RE, Mark EJ, McNeely BO (1984) Case records of the massachusetts general hospital. N Engl J Med 311:108–115
Seijffers MJ, Welner A (1969) Massive rectal bleeding in a malingering patient. Dis Colon Rectum 12:347–350
Service FJ, Palumbo PJ (1974) Factitial hypoglycemia. Arch Intern Med 134:336–340
Sjöberg SG (1951) Munchausen's syndrome. Lancet I:1073
Sneddon I, Sneddon J (1975) Self-inflicted injury: A follow-up study of 43 patients. Brit Med J 3:527–530
Sonenthal IR (1944) Malignering in nurses with hysteria. Ill Med J 85:17
Spiro HR (1968) Chronic factitious illness — Munchausen's syndrome. Arch Gen Psychiat 18:569–580
Steinbeck AW (1961) Haemorrhagica histrionica — the bleeding Munchausen syndrome. Med J Aust 48:451–456
Thompson CW, Shuster J, Williams RL, Kaye M (1964) Munchausen syndrome: a cause of pyrexia of unknown origin. Can Med Assoc J 91:1021–1023
Trew P, Anderson DE (1970) Munchausen syndrome masquerading as pulmonary embolism. Med J Aust 57:637–641
Uexküll von T (1981) Lehrbuch der psychosomatischen Medizin. Urban & Schwarzenberg, München
Weitbrecht HJ (1973) Psychiatrie im Grundriss. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Wesiack W (1980) Psychoanalyse und praktische Medizin. Grundzüge der Neurosenlehre, Psychotherapie und psychosomatischen Medizin. Klett — Cotta, Stuttgart
York JR (1960) A case of „Munchausen's syndrome“ with an unusual presenting symptom. Med J Aust 47:538–539
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Herrn Professor Dr. O.H. Arnold zum 75. Geburtstag gewidmet
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bock, K.D., Overkamp, F. Vorgetäuschte Krankheit. Klin Wochenschr 64, 149–164 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01713456
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01713456