Abstract
We consider the moral and social ingredients in physicians' relationships with patients of diminished capacity by considering certain claims made about friendship and the physician's role. To assess these claims we look at the life context of two patients as elaborated examples provided in two novels: Woman on the Edge of Time (1976) by Marge Piercy, a radical feminist; and It's Hard to Leave While the Music's Playing (1977) by I. S. Cooper, a prominent physician-researcher. At issue is how the doctor-patient relationship should be structured. In question is whether the physician's friendship and professional expertise, together with the diminished capacity of the patient, authorize medical paternalism. From our examination, we find compelling insights against appealing to friendship both in good doctor-patient relationships and in more typical, not-so-good ones.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackerman, T. F., ‘Why doctors should intervene’, The Hastings Center Report 12, (1982) 14–17.
American Medical Association, ‘First Code of Medical Ethics’, in S. J. Reiser, A. J. Dyck, and W. J. Curran (eds.), Ethics in Medicine: Historical Perspectives in Contemporary Concerns, MIT Press, Cambridge, 1977, pp. 26–37.
Annas, G., ‘Hospital as a human rights wasteland’, The Civil Liberties Review 1, (1974) 15–35.
Anonymous, ‘Commentary’, Man and Medicine 3, (1978) 267–287.
Balint, M., The Doctor, Patient and His Illness, International Universities Press, New York, 1957.
Blum, L. A., Friendship, Altruism and Morality, Routledge and Kegan Paul, Boston, 1980.
Buchanan, A., ‘Medical paternalism’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 7, (1978) 370–390.
Cooper, I. S., It's Hard to Leave While the Music's Playing, W. W. Norton and Company, New York, 1977. (All quotations from the novel are reprinted by permission of the publisher.)
Culver, C. M., and Gert, B., Philosophy in Medicine: Conceptual and Ethical Issues in Medicine and Psychiatry, Oxford University Press, New York, 1982.
Duffy, J., ‘The physician as a moral force in American history’, in W. B. Bondeson, H. T. Engelhardt, Jr., S. F. Spicker, and J. M. White, Jr. (eds.), New Knowledge in the Biomedical Sciences, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1982, pp. 3–21.
Erde, E. L., ‘On peeling, slicing and dicing an onion: The complexity of taxonomies of values and medicine’, Theoretical Medicine 4, (1983) 7–26.
Goldman, A., The Moral Foundations of Professional Ethics, Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, New Jersey, 1980.
Gorovitz, S., ‘The physician as moral arbiter’, in W. B. Bondeson, H. T. Engelhardt, Jr., S. F. Spicker, and J. M. White, Jr. (eds.), New Knowledge in the Biomedical Sciences, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1982, pp. 23–31.
Ketchum, S. A., and Pierce, C., ‘Rights and responsibilities’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 6, (1981) 271–280.
Ladd, J., ‘Legalism and medical ethics’, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 4, (1979) 70–71.
Lain-Entralgo, P., Doctor and Patient, World University Library, London, 1969.
Lief, H. I., and Fox, R. C., ‘Training for “detached concern” in medical students’, in H. I. Lief et al. (eds.), The Psychological Basis of Medical Practice, Harper and Row, New York, 1963, pp. 12–35.
MacIntyre, A., After Virtue, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, Indiana, 1981.
Meilaender, G., Friendship: A Study in Theological Ethics, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, Indiana, 1981.
Nabokov, V., ‘Nabokov on Dostoyevsky’, New York Times Magazine (August 23, 1981) 35–64.
Parsons, T., The Social System, The Free Press, Glencoe, Illinois, 1951.
Pellegrino, E. D., and Thomasma, D. C., A Philosophical Basis of Medical Practice, Oxford University Press, New York, 1981.
Piercy, M., Woman on the Edge of Time, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1976. (All quotations from the novel are reprinted by permission of the publisher.)
Putnam, H., Meaning and the Moral Sciences, Routledge and Kegan Paul, Boston, 1978.
Rabin, D., with Rabin, P. L., and Rabin, R., ‘Compounding the ordeal of ALS: Isolation from my fellow physicians’, The New England Journal of Medicine 307, (1982) 506–509.
Reiman, J. H., ‘Privacy, intimacy, and personhood’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 6, (1976) 26–44.
Sonn, M., ‘Patient's subjective experiences of psychiatric hospitalization’, in T. C. Manschreck and A. M. Kleinman (eds.), Renewal in Psychiatry, Hemisphere Publishing Company, Washington, DC, 1977, pp. 245–264.
Sterba, J. H., ‘Nobel winner urges wider forensic use of new insulin technology’, New York Times (March 23, 1982) C2.
Toulmin, S., ‘The tyranny of principles’, The Hastings Center Report 11, (1981) 31–39.
Veatch, R. M., ‘Generalization of expertise’, The Hastings Center Studies 1, (1973) 29–40.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Although it cannot be assumed that he is in accord with our argument in this essay, we would like to thank David Thomasma for his criticism of an earlier draft.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Erde, E.L., Jones, A.H. Diminished capacity, friendship, and medical paternalism: Two case studies from fiction. Theor Med Bioeth 4, 303–322 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00489211
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00489211