Introduction

Musculoskeletal disorders are the leading cause of years lived with disability and the fifth most common cause of disability-adjusted life years worldwide in 2017 according to estimates from the Global Burden of Diseases [1,2,3]. Musculoskeletal disorders cause pain and functional disability [4,5,6], and their burden on individuals and society has been increasing worldwide [2, 3, 7]. Therefore, public interest in musculoskeletal disorders during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic should be assessed to develop effective measures for the management of musculoskeletal disorders.

Within the rheumatology community, Google search data have been integrated into research [8, 9]. In the past few years, it was used to assess trends in several rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases such as osteoarthritis [10], fibromyalgia [11], gout [12], ankylosing spondylitis [13], and rheumatoid arthritis [14]. In the context of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, in two intriguing studies we evaluated the public interest in anti-rheumatic drugs [15] and rheumatic diseases [16]. In the previous study, we mainly focused on inflammatory, autoimmune, connective tissue/vasculitis diseases because patients with this group of rheumatic diseases may be at a higher risk of acquiring severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) [16]. As the prevalence of soft tissue, regional and degenerative musculoskeletal diseases is much higher than the other rheumatic diseases (i.e. inflammatory, autoimmune, connective tissue/vasculitis), the public interest in these musculoskeletal disorders also needs to be investigated.

The present study aimed to assess the public interest in musculoskeletal symptoms and disorders during the COVID-19 pandemic. It is essential for clinicians to understand the modifications and trends in public responses in looking for information about musculoskeletal symptoms and disorders, and to determine the informational needs of public during the COVID-19 pandemic. This information will help rheumatologists develop effective strategies in order to deliver better care for people with musculoskeletal disorders during the pandemic.

Methods

Google search data

The Google Trends tool can provide data on search queries users enter into the Google search engine. It normalizes the data to all queries in a region and a timeframe selected and presents the relative popularity of search queries [17,18,19]. Then, Google Trends scales the resulting numbers ranging from 0 to 100 based on selected search query’s frequency to overall frequency of search queries. This scaling process allows the relative search volume between years to be compared, because otherwise the later years’ searches would be higher than those of the earlier years due to the increase in internet use over the years. In other words, this process controls the possible impact of total amount of internet use over time. On this scale, 100 indicates the maximum popularity for the search query, and others indicate a percentage of it. For example, a score of 60 indicates a 60% of the maximum popularity for the search query [20, 21]. We determined a broad spectrum of search queries corresponding to general musculoskeletal symptoms (e.g. fatigue, joint pain, joint stiffness, and joint swelling), and spinal, shoulder, elbow, wrist, hand, hip, knee, ankle, and foot symptoms/disorders. The whole list of 118 search queries is provided in Table 1 (Electronic Supplementary Material online). We searched Google Trends for the search queries within the United States, with a timeframe of January 1, 2016 to November 22, 2020, and in “All categories”.

Statistical methods

To assess both initial and short-term public interest we compared two timeframes in 2020 (March 15–July 4 and July 5–October 31) to similar timeframes over the four prior years from 2016 through 2019 with the use of the generalized estimating equations selecting a gamma model. The threshold for statistical significance was considered as a P value smaller than 0.05. The statistical analyses were conducted on SPSS (version 21.0; IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA). Recently published review guided the statistical data presentation [22].

Results

Analysis of the initial timeframe, March 15–July 4, revealed a statistically significant decrease in Google search volume of 71 among 118 queries and a statistically significant increase in Google search volume of 2 queries (i.e. myalgia [% change: +87.55%; p < 0.001] and toe swelling [+16.96%; p: 0.013]) in the year 2020 as compared with similar timeframes over the four prior years (Electronic Supplementary Material).

Analysis of the July 5–October 31, timeframe revealed a statistically significant decrease in Google search volume of 26 (i.e. tendonitis [−10.81%; p < 0.001], fasciitis [−13.53%; p < 0.001], bursitis [−6.06%; p: 0.001], spondylolisthesis [−8.34%; p: 0.008], herniated disc [−5.71%; p: 0.002], bulging disc [−18.07%; p < 0.001], spinal stenosis [−10.32%; p < 0.001], scoliosis [−3.78%; p: 0.032], neck disc [−13.99%; p < 0.001], de Quervain [−14.32%; p: 0.005], hip bursitis [−7.94%; p: 0.002], trochanteric bursitis [−11.83%; p: 0.007], iliopsoas syndrome [−18.48%; p: 0.039], knee swelling [−7.38%; p: 0.010], knee popping [−12.78%; p: 0.006], knee locking [−16.59%; p: 0.012], knee tendonitis [−25.91%; p < 0.001], patellar tendonitis [−26.26%; p < 0.001], prepatellar bursitis [−15.93%; p: 0.049], infrapatellar bursitis [−24.32%; p: 0.009], Hoffa syndrome [−21.28%; p: 0.001], meniscus tear [−13.24%; p < 0.001], foot pain [−6.41%; p < 0.001], heel pain [−9.54%; p < 0.001], plantar fasciitis [−8.72%; p < 0.001] and bunion [−4.84%; p: 0.015]) among 118 queries and a statistically significant increase in Google search volume of 21 queries (i.e. fatigue [+12.37%; p < 0.001], joint pain [+5.65%; p: 0.002], muscle pain [+5.60%; p: 0.001], myalgia [+136.70%; p < 0.001], spondylosis [+7.29%; p: 0.015], radiculopathy [+7.12%; p: 0.013], myelopathy [+10.29%; p: 0.049], neck pain [+5.28%; p < 0.001], neck strain [+32.17%; p < 0.001], lower back strain [+21.79%; p < 0.001], sciatica [+4.41%; p: 0.016], shoulder pain [+7.05%; p < 0.001], frozen shoulder [+15.25%; p < 0.001], elbow pain [+8.13%; p < 0.001], lateral epicondylitis [+10.60%; p: 0.011], wrist pain [+5.03%; p: 0.029], carpal tunnel [+6.73%; p < 0.001], hand pain [+4.46%; p: 0.024], finger pain [+6.56%; p: 0.012], trigger finger [+26.79%; p < 0.001] and Morton’s neuroma [+19.04%; p: 0.020]), in the year 2020 as compared with similar timeframes over the four prior years (Electronic Supplementary Material).

Discussion

This study has demonstrated a statistically significant decrease in Google search volume of 60% of search queries in the early phase of pandemic, March 15–July 4. However, in the July through October phase a statistically significant decrease was detected in only 22% of search queries; there was no difference for 60% of search queries between 2020 and 2016–2019 suggesting a return to their prior levels for the most of search queries that were decreased in the early phase. Interestingly, the search volume of 18% of search queries, namely, fatigue, joint pain, muscle pain, myalgia, spondylosis, radiculopathy, myelopathy, neck pain, neck strain, lower back strain, sciatica, shoulder pain, frozen shoulder, elbow pain, lateral epicondylitis, wrist pain, carpal tunnel, hand pain, finger pain, trigger finger, and Morton’s neuroma, was significantly increased in July through October 2020 as compared with four prior years.

In the previous study analyzing Google search data, we found a significant decrease in public interest in the majority of inflammatory, autoimmune, and/or, vasculitis/connective tissue rheumatic diseases in the early phase of the pandemic [16]. In line with the previous study, the present results showed a general downward trend in internet searches for most of the soft tissue, regional, and degenerative musculoskeletal diseases in the initial pandemic period. It is possible that focusing on COVID-19 has led to a disregard of non-COVID-19 health conditions. This decreased interest may have individual and healthcare system implications. First, the outcomes and severity of musculoskeletal disorders might worsen. Second, after the resolution of the pandemic, a surge in demand for musculoskeletal care could overwhelm the healthcare system’s capacity. Therefore, rheumatologists should address this decreased interest to minimize its potential adverse consequences.

In the initial period, internet searches for myalgia and toe swelling showed a significant increase. As myalgia is among the common symptoms of COVID-19 [23, 24], this observation was not unexpected. Furthermore, the increase in toe swelling was probably related to media coverage of chilblains associated with COVID-19, called as “COVID toe” [25,26,27]. In the second pandemic period, internet searches for toe swelling was not statistically significantly different compared to prior years, which might be due to that public accessed the information on this condition in the early pandemic and reduced their information intake after this period. Regardless, these findings indicate that the public has focused on COVID-19 and sought online information for COVID-19 symptoms in the early pandemic.

In July through October 2020, phase, internet searches for only 22% of all search queries remained low; however, the others were either not statistically significantly different or increased compared to prior years. This finding may reflect the recovery of public interest in musculoskeletal symptoms and disorders. Detailed inspection of this period showed an overall upward trend in symptoms (i.e. fatigue, joint pain, muscle pain, neck pain, shoulder pain, elbow pain, wrist pain, hand pain, and finger pain), and some colloquial terms/well-known conditions (i.e. myalgia, spondylosis, radiculopathy, myelopathy, neck strain, lower back strain, sciatica, frozen shoulder, lateral epicondylitis, carpal tunnel, and trigger finger). However, a decreased relative search volume for certain specific diagnoses (e.g. herniated disc, bulging disc, spinal stenosis, spondylolisthesis, neck disc, and de Quervain) was noted. It is possible that the reductions in outpatient visits [28,29,30,31] led to a decrease in the detection of these certain specific diagnoses, which in turn lessened their internet searches. Considering the trends observed in this study (an upward trend in symptoms and some colloquial terms/well-known conditions coupled with a downward trend in general musculoskeletal disorder terms and certain specific diagnoses) and still ongoing pandemic, rheumatologists should address the increased informational demand for musculoskeletal symptoms and develop effective strategies in delivering clinical care to minimize the potential detrimental impact of the pandemic on outcomes of patients with musculoskeletal disorders. Among these strategies, telerheumatology is gaining specific interest and being rapidly implemented in clinical practice during the pandemic [32,33,34,35,36,37].

Limitations and strengths

One limitation is that Google Trends only provides information on Google search engine data; in other words the internet searches performed through other engines (e.g. Bing, Yahoo!, DuckDuckGo) were not included. However, since about 90% of internet searches are performed on Google [38], its data probably represent all online search queries. Furthermore, Google Trends does not provide demographic characteristics of users; therefore interest cannot be assessed by dividing into subcategories based on age or sex. Hence, the trends observed in our study should be interpreted as an interest of the general public. The strengths of the present study involve an exhaustive list of search terms representing a wide spectrum of musculoskeletal symptoms/disorders; and a long period of investigation that allowed assessment of interest in both initial and short-term stages of the pandemic.

Conclusion

Public interest has focused on COVID-19 and sought online information for COVID-19 symptoms in the early pandemic. In the July through October period, there was an upward trend in musculoskeletal symptoms and some colloquial terms/well-known musculoskeletal conditions and a downward trend in general musculoskeletal disorders-terms and certain specific diagnosis. This information may help rheumatologists understand public interest in musculoskeletal symptoms and disorders and address the needs of patients to mitigate the negative impact of the pandemic on outcomes.