Skip to main content
Top

29-01-2025 | Pneumonia | chest

Diagnostic accuracy of ultra-low-dose chest CT vs chest X-ray for acute non-traumatic pulmonary diseases

Authors: Maadrika M. N. P. Kanglie, Inge A. H. van den Berk, Tjitske S. R. van Engelen, Shandra Bipat, Patrick M. M. Bossuyt, Jan M. Prins, Jaap Stoker, on behalf of the OPTIMACT study group

Published in: European Radiology

Login to get access

Abstract

Objectives

To compare the diagnostic accuracy of ULDCT to CXR for detecting non-traumatic pulmonary diseases at the emergency department (ED) and to study diagnostic confidence levels.

Methods

Secondary analysis of the prospective OPTIMACT trial (2418 ED participants randomly allocated to ULDCT or CXR). Diagnoses at imaging at the ED were compared to the reference diagnosis on day 28. Ratios of positive diagnoses, true positives (TP), false positives (FP), false negatives (FN), and positive predictive values (PPV) were assessed with 95% confidence intervals (CI). The diagnostic confidence levels of the radiologists were studied.

Results

One thousand one hundred sixty-one ULDCT participants (mean age, 59 years ± 18 [standard deviation], 587 female) and 1151 CXR participants (mean age, 59 years ± 18 [standard deviation], 561 female) were evaluated. With ULDCT, pneumonia was 1.55 times (95% CI: 1.33–1.80) more often diagnosed at imaging at the ED, with significantly more TP (ratio 1.50; 95% CI: 1.26–1.76) and fewer FN (0.61; 95% CI: 0.37–0.99) but more FP (1.75; 95% CI: 1.19–2.58); a similar pattern was observed for other lower respiratory tract infections (LRTI). Pulmonary congestion was less often observed with ULDCT (0.45; 95% CI: 0.34–0.61), with fewer TP (0.50; 95% CI: 0.34–0.73), and FP (0.40; 95% CI: 0.24–0.65). PPVs were not significantly different. With ULDCT, radiologists were more often certain in diagnosing pneumonia (ULDCT 121/324, 37% vs CXR 48/208, 23%), LRTI (84/192, 44% vs 18/63, 29%), and no established disease (350/382, 92% vs 447/544, 82%).

Conclusion

Compared to CXR, ULDCT led to more TP but also more FP in detecting pneumonia and LRTI, while fewer TP and FP were found for pulmonary congestion. PPVs were comparable.

Key Points

Question Is ultra-low dose CT (ULDCT) more accurate than chest X-ray (CXR) for identifying non-traumatic pulmonary diseases in patients presenting at the ED?
Findings ULDCT detects more pulmonary infections in patients presenting at the ED with non-traumatic pulmonary complaints, while CXR detects more pulmonary congestion.
Clinical relevance ULDCT is superior to CXR in detecting pneumonia and other LRTI in ED patients, while CXR is superior in detecting pulmonary congestion. ULDCT can be an alternative for CXR in a selected group of patients.

Graphical Abstract

Appendix
Available only for authorised users
Literature
3.
go back to reference Wassipaul C, Janata-Schwatczek K, Domanovits H et al (2023) Ultra-low-dose CT vs. chest X-ray in non-traumatic emergency department patients - a prospective randomised crossover cohort trial. EClinicalMedicine 65:102267CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral Wassipaul C, Janata-Schwatczek K, Domanovits H et al (2023) Ultra-low-dose CT vs. chest X-ray in non-traumatic emergency department patients - a prospective randomised crossover cohort trial. EClinicalMedicine 65:102267CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral
5.
go back to reference Meyer E, Labani A, Schaeffer M et al (2019) Wide-volume versus helical acquisition in unenhanced chest CT: prospective intra-patient comparison of diagnostic accuracy and radiation dose in an ultra-low-dose setting. Eur Radiol 29:6858–6866CrossRefPubMed Meyer E, Labani A, Schaeffer M et al (2019) Wide-volume versus helical acquisition in unenhanced chest CT: prospective intra-patient comparison of diagnostic accuracy and radiation dose in an ultra-low-dose setting. Eur Radiol 29:6858–6866CrossRefPubMed
6.
go back to reference Debray MP, Dauriat G, Khalil A et al (2016) Diagnostic accuracy of low-mA chest CT reconstructed with model based iterative reconstruction in the detection of early pleuro-pulmonary complications following a lung transplantation. Eur Radiol 26:3138–3146CrossRefPubMed Debray MP, Dauriat G, Khalil A et al (2016) Diagnostic accuracy of low-mA chest CT reconstructed with model based iterative reconstruction in the detection of early pleuro-pulmonary complications following a lung transplantation. Eur Radiol 26:3138–3146CrossRefPubMed
7.
go back to reference Martini K, Barth BK, Nguyen-Kim TD, Baumueller S, Alkadhi H, Frauenfelder T (2016) Evaluation of pulmonary nodules and infection on chest CT with radiation dose equivalent to chest radiography: prospective intra-individual comparison study to standard dose CT. Eur J Radiol 85:360–365CrossRefPubMed Martini K, Barth BK, Nguyen-Kim TD, Baumueller S, Alkadhi H, Frauenfelder T (2016) Evaluation of pulmonary nodules and infection on chest CT with radiation dose equivalent to chest radiography: prospective intra-individual comparison study to standard dose CT. Eur J Radiol 85:360–365CrossRefPubMed
8.
go back to reference de Margerie-Mellon C, de Bazelaire C, Montlahuc C et al (2016) Reducing radiation dose at chest CT: comparison among model-based type iterative reconstruction, hybrid iterative reconstruction, and filtered back projection. Acad Radiol 23:1246–1254CrossRefPubMed de Margerie-Mellon C, de Bazelaire C, Montlahuc C et al (2016) Reducing radiation dose at chest CT: comparison among model-based type iterative reconstruction, hybrid iterative reconstruction, and filtered back projection. Acad Radiol 23:1246–1254CrossRefPubMed
9.
go back to reference van den Berk IAH, Kanglie MMNP, van Engelen TSR et al (2023) Ultra-low-dose CT versus chest X-ray for patients suspected of pulmonary disease at the emergency department: a multicentre randomised clinical trial. Thorax 78:515–522CrossRefPubMed van den Berk IAH, Kanglie MMNP, van Engelen TSR et al (2023) Ultra-low-dose CT versus chest X-ray for patients suspected of pulmonary disease at the emergency department: a multicentre randomised clinical trial. Thorax 78:515–522CrossRefPubMed
10.
go back to reference van Engelen TSR, Kanglie MMNP, van den Berk IAH et al (2023) Limited clinical impact of ultralow-dose computed tomography in suspected community-acquired pneumonia. Open Forum Infect Dis 10:ofad215CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral van Engelen TSR, Kanglie MMNP, van den Berk IAH et al (2023) Limited clinical impact of ultralow-dose computed tomography in suspected community-acquired pneumonia. Open Forum Infect Dis 10:ofad215CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral
11.
go back to reference van den Berk IAH, Lejeune EH, Kanglie MMNP et al (2023) The yield of chest X-ray or ultra-low-dose chest-CT in emergency department patients suspected of pulmonary infection without respiratory symptoms or signs. Eur Radiol 33:7294–7302CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral van den Berk IAH, Lejeune EH, Kanglie MMNP et al (2023) The yield of chest X-ray or ultra-low-dose chest-CT in emergency department patients suspected of pulmonary infection without respiratory symptoms or signs. Eur Radiol 33:7294–7302CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral
12.
go back to reference van den Berk IAH, Kanglie MMNP, van Engelen TSR et al (2018) OPTimal IMAging strategy in patients suspected of non-traumatic pulmonary disease at the emergency department: chest X-ray or ultra-low-dose CT (OPTIMACT)-a randomised controlled trial chest X-ray or ultra-low-dose CT at the ED: design and rationale. Diagn Progn Res 2:20CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral van den Berk IAH, Kanglie MMNP, van Engelen TSR et al (2018) OPTimal IMAging strategy in patients suspected of non-traumatic pulmonary disease at the emergency department: chest X-ray or ultra-low-dose CT (OPTIMACT)-a randomised controlled trial chest X-ray or ultra-low-dose CT at the ED: design and rationale. Diagn Progn Res 2:20CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral
17.
go back to reference Brady AP, Bello JA, Derchi LE et al (2021) Radiology in the era of value-based healthcare: a multi society expert statement from the ACR, CAR, ESR, IS3R, RANZCR, and RSNA. J Am Coll Radiol 18:877–883CrossRefPubMed Brady AP, Bello JA, Derchi LE et al (2021) Radiology in the era of value-based healthcare: a multi society expert statement from the ACR, CAR, ESR, IS3R, RANZCR, and RSNA. J Am Coll Radiol 18:877–883CrossRefPubMed
Metadata
Title
Diagnostic accuracy of ultra-low-dose chest CT vs chest X-ray for acute non-traumatic pulmonary diseases
Authors
Maadrika M. N. P. Kanglie
Inge A. H. van den Berk
Tjitske S. R. van Engelen
Shandra Bipat
Patrick M. M. Bossuyt
Jan M. Prins
Jaap Stoker
on behalf of the OPTIMACT study group
Publication date
29-01-2025
Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Keyword
Pneumonia
Published in
European Radiology
Print ISSN: 0938-7994
Electronic ISSN: 1432-1084
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-024-11223-3