http://orcid.org/0000-0002-4478-5597
Figures
Abstract
Objective
Mortality in very low birth weight infants following microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections varies with the type of causative pathogen. Given evidence from other studies that infections with gram negative bacteria and fungi cause a higher case fatality risk. We tried to confirm this in a nation-wide multi-center trial.
Methods
A cohort of 55,465 very low birth weight infants from 242 neonatal departments participating in the German national neonatal infection surveillance system NEO-KISS was used to investigate differences in the case fatality risk of microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections according to individual pathogens. Cox proportional hazard regression analyses were performed with the outcomes death and time from microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections. The results were adjusted to the recorded risk factors and hospital and department characteristics.
Results
A total of 4 094 very low birth weight infants with microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections were included in the analysis. The crude case fatality risk was 5.7%. The Cox proportional hazard regression analysis with adjustment for available risk factors revealed that microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections caused by Klebsiella spp. (HR 3.17 CI95 1.69–5.95), Enterobacter spp. (HR 3.42 CI95 1.86–6.27), Escherichia coli (HR 3.32 CI95 1.84–6.00) and Serratia spp. (HR 3.30 CI95 1.44–7.57) were associated with significantly higher case fatality risk compared to Staphylococcus aureus. After adjusting, case fatality risk of Candida albicans causing microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections was not higher than that of S. aureus.
Conclusion
In very low birth weight infants, bloodstream infections caused by gram negative pathogens have an increased case fatality risk compared to bloodstream infections caused by gram positive pathogens. This should be considered for prevention and therapy. Further research should address the specific risk factors for case fatality of C. albicans bloodstream infections.
Citation: Piening BC, Geffers C, Gastmeier P, Schwab F (2017) Pathogen-specific mortality in very low birth weight infants with primary bloodstream infection. PLoS ONE 12(6): e0180134. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0180134
Editor: Umberto Simeoni, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, FRANCE
Received: December 22, 2016; Accepted: June 10, 2017; Published: June 22, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Piening et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: Data are available from the German National Reference Center for Surveillance of Nosocomial Infections Data Access Committee for researchers who meet the criteria for access to confidential data and accept to be bound by a non disclosure agreement regarding the publication of unaggregated data. The data are collected due to German laws and the National Reference Center for Surveillance of Nosocomial Infections is bound by a non disclosure agreement with the hospitals participating in the system. We are not allowed to publish unaggregated data which might lead to identification of individual hospitals directly or through a third party. Researchers who want to obtain the data set which is required to reproduce our findings are asked to direct their request to: Data Access Committee Nationales Referenzzentrum (NRZ) für Surveillance von nosokomialen Infektionen am Institut für Hygiene und Umweltmedizin Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin Hindenburgdamm 27 12203 Berlin Tel.: +49 30 450577612 Fax: +49 30 450577920 Email: nrz@charite.de.
Funding: The authors are members of the German national reference center for surveillance of nosocomial infections which is funded by the governmental Robert-Koch-Institut (http://www.rki.de/DE/Content/Infekt/NRZ/nrz_node.html). The funder had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. However besides the general funding of the national reference center which enables it to serve its mission of promoting surveillance of nosocomial infections in German hospitals the authors received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Nosocomial bloodstream infections in infants with a birthweight below 1500 g (very low birth weight infants; VLBW) are an important cause of neonatal mortality. Case fatality risk (CFR) of these infections depends on patient factors, department factors and the type of pathogen. Earlier studies identified a higher CFR of nosocomial bloodstream infections when the causing pathogens were gram negative bacteria or fungi [1], [2], [3]. Three studies even determined a significant difference between gram positive and gram negative pathogens after adjusting for several risk factors [4], [5].[6] Multidrug resistant pathogens have also been shown to be associated with increased mortality [6–8]. However, only two published studies investigated the differences of various pathogen species in terms of mortality [6, 9] which is probably due to the large sample sized needed to perform such an analysis.
Patients and methods
The surveillance component for VLBW infants of the German national nosocomial infection surveillance system (NEO-KISS) is one of the largest databases for health care associated infections in neonates worldwide [10, 11]. A total of 242 neonatal departments are participating and providing their data on a regular basis for ongoing quality assurance. Therefore, this database offers a good opportunity to determine the influence of specific pathogens on the CFR of nosocomial bloodstream infections in VLBW infants. All data in the NEO-KISS database were obtained from medical records in a fully anonymized and de-identified manner according to German data protection laws. None of the researchers and authors had access to identifying information.
The methods and definitions of NEO-KISS are described elsewhere [10]. According to the surveillance protocol, laboratory confirmed and clinical cases of late-onset (>72h postnatal) primary bloodstream infections are recorded and the follow up of patients ends with the occurrence of first of the following three events: 1. the actual weight of the child reaches or exceeds 1800g; 2. the child is transferred to another department; 3. the child dies.
This analysis focuses on microbiology confirmed primary bloodstream infections (MCBSI) only. Their definitions are as follows:
- A recognized pathogen other than coagulase-negative staphylococci (CoNS) cultured from blood or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF; this is included in the definition because in this age group meningitis usually develops haematogenously); and at least two of the following signs: temperature >38 or <36.5°C or temperature instability, tachycardia or bradycardia, apnoea, extended capillary refill time (CRF), metabolic acidosis, hyperglycaemia, other sign of sepsis such as apathy; and the organism is not related to an infection at another site.
- Coagulase negative Staphylococcus (CoNS) is cultured from blood; and at least two of the following signs: temperature >38 or <36.5°C or temperature instability, tachycardia or bradycardia, apnoea, extended CRF, metabolic acidosis, hyperglycaemia, other sign of sepsis such as apathy; and patient has one of the following signs: C-reactive protein >2.0 mg/dL, immature/total neutrophil ratio (I/T ratio) >0.2, leukocytes <5/nL, platelets <100/nL;and the organism/infection is not related to an infection at another site
VLBW infants with MCBSI recorded in NEO-KISS in the period from January 1st of 2005 to December 31st of 2013 were used for this study. The following exclusion criteria were used:
- Patients with length of stay of less than 3 days (MCBSI happening within the first 3 days after admission is excluded per protocol so we also had the exclude those patients from the denominator who couldn’t acquire a MCBSI by definition)
- Patients with MCBSI with incorrect/missing date of infection
- Patients with MCBSI with more than one microorganism specified
- Patients with missing data about the relevant risk factors gestational age, mode of delivery and gender
A flow diagram with included VLBW infants with MCBSI in the analysis is shown in Fig 1.
LOS, length of stay; VLBW, very low birth weight; NI, nosocomial infection; MCBSI, microbiological confirmed bloodstream infection.
In the descriptive analysis (Table 1), numbers and percent values were calculated; differences were tested by Chi-square test. In the multivariable analysis, Cox proportional hazard regression analysis was performed with the outcome death and the time (days) from the date of the last MCBSI until the end of follow up which may happen due to one of the following three reasons according to the NEO-KISS protocol: 1. death, 2. achievement of a weight of 1800g or 3. discharge or transfer from the department. Cox regression (or proportional hazards regression) is a method for investigating the effect of several variables on the time a specified event (e.g. mortality) takes to happen. We calculated hazard ratios with 95% confidence intervals where the hazard ratio can be interpreted as the predicted change in the hazard for a category to the reference category in the analyzed variable.
In the multivariable analysis, the variable selection was stepwise forward with p = 0.05 for including a parameter in the model and p = 0.10 for excluding a parameter from the model.
The 8 most frequently identified organisms in mono-microbial MCBSI were analyzed: coagulase negative Stahylococci (CoNS), S. aureus, E. coli, Enterobacter spp., Enterococcus spp., Klebsiella spp., C. albicans, Serratia spp.. All other microorganisms were summarized as other mono-microbial MCBSI. While it is common to use,the factor occurring most frequently as reference in a regression model, we decided to use the second most frequent pathogen–S. aureus as reference. This decision was made because the most frequent pathogens, coagulase negative taphylococci are often regarded as contaminants and no real pathogens causing MCBSI [9]. There also was no interaction term included in the model.
In addition, crude and adjusted cumulative survival functions were calculated using Kaplan-Meier method with the time from the last MCBSI to death/discharge/1800g stratified according to the type of microorganism.
The following patient based risk factors were considered in the analysis: birth weight (250g steps: <500g/500g-749g/750g-999g/1000g-1249g/1250g-1499g)), gestational age (GA) (<24 weeks /25-26 weeks /27-28 weeks /29-30 weeks />30weeks), gender (male/female), mode of delivery (planned Caesarean Section/emergency Caesarean Section/vaginal), multiple birth (singleton/multiples), location of delivery (inhouse/admission < = 72h/admission >72h/missing) and time from admission to MCBSI (< = 7/8-14/15-21/> = 22 days). Moreover, small for gestational age (SGA) was defined as birth weight <10th percentile; appropriate for gestational age (AGA) as 10–90% percentile, and large for gestational age (LGA) as >90th percentile based on population-based percentiles, separately for males/females and for singletons/twins [12]. Twin percentiles were used for all multiples because at the time of the study there were no published percentiles for higher-order multiples in the German population. In addition, the following department associated confounder were used in the analysis: care level of the center according to the criteria of the German “Gemeinsamer Bundesausschuss” where Level I is the highest Level and obstetrical hospital is the lowest (I/II/neonatal center, obstetrical hospital), type of hospital (university hospital, academic teaching, others), size of hospital (< = /> 562 beds(median)), size of department (< = />17 beds(median)) and annual volume of VLBW infants (<30/30-59/> = 60).
Results
A total of 55,465 VLBW infants from 242 neonatal departments were included in the analysis. The overall CFR (until achieving 1800g or transfer from the unit) was 6.4%. 54,204 VLBW infants stayed longer or equal 3 days (CFR 4.8%) with the incidence of MCBSI of 8.1 (infants with > = 1 MCBSI) per 100 VLBW infants and the incidence density of 2.3 MCBSI per 1000 patient days.
After considering the exclusion criteria, a total of 4,094 VLBW infants with MCBSI remained (Fig 1). This patient group had an overall CFR of 5.7%. The characteristics of the VLBW infants in the study cohort are described in Table 1. The organisms that were identified most frequently were CoNS, followed by S. aureus, E.coli, Enterobacter spp., Enterococci, Klebsiella spp., C. albicans and Serratia spp.. All other microorganisms had a percentage of less than 1% each (Fig 2). The crude pathogen specific CFR following MCBSI is shown in Fig 3. The lowest CFR was identified for CoNS, followed by S. aureus and Enterococci. The CFR of E.coli, Enterobacter spp., Klebsiella spp., Serratia spp. and C. albicans was much higher with minor differences among these microorganisms.
Whiskers represent 95% confidence intervals; CoNS, coagulase negative staphylococci; other*, other pathogens than listed in the figure.
The results of the multivariable Cox proportional hazard regression are shown in Table 2. The multivariate analysis confirmed male gender, birth weight, gestational age, device use, t to infection and birth location as significant risk factors. The Cox proportional hazard regression analysis with adjustment for all available risk factors for death revealed that MCBSI caused by Klebsiella spp. (HR 3.17 CI95 1.69–5.95), Enterobacter spp. (HR 3.42 CI95 1.86–6.27), E. coli (HR 3.32 CI95 1.84–6.00) and Serratia spp. (HR 3.30 CI95 1.44–7.57) were associated with significantly higher CFR compared to S. aureus. After adjusting to risk factors, C. albicans was not a significant risk factor for death. This is also illustrated by Fig 4 which shows the adjusted pathogen specific hazard ratios. The Kaplan Meier survival curve (Fig 5) shows the adjusted survival curves as results of multivariable Cox proportional hazard analysis.
S.aureus was used as reference value; Whiskers represent 95% confidence intervals; CoNS, coagulase negative staphylococci; other*, other pathogens than listed in the figure.
Adjusted by significant parameters of the multivariable Cox-regression model (see Table 2).
Discussion
While bloodstream infections in general increase mortality in in VLBW infants [13], this study shows a more than 3 fold increased adjusted CFR of MCBSI caused by gram negative bacteria compared to the CFR of S. aureus infections. Almost no differences between the specific gram negative microorganisms were detected. With NEO-KISS being a surveillance system that focuses on prevention of infections in neonatology departments, only late-onset infections are recorded, because in most cases the potential for prevention of early-onset infection lies outside the neonatology department. As both pathogen distribution and mortality differs between early-onset and late onset BSI in neonates, this limits our findings to patients with late-onset BSI. While pathogen factors are supposed to be the same for same pathogens in early- and late onset BSI, their interaction with the different physiology of the host in the prepartal phase may lead to different outcomes.
Beside the results concerning the pathogens causing MCBSI, Table 2 shows some additional well-known risk factors for MCBSI and adverse outcomes amongst neonates [9, 14]. Male gender is a well-established risk factor for adverse outcome in preterm neonates[15, 16] as are bad starting conditions like emergency cesarean section[17, 18] and transport to another center in the immediate postnatal period[19–21]. Here the mortality risk in emergency section and postnatal transport may not only come from those unplanned actions themselves but also from the severe patient conditions leading to the respective actions. The fact that PVC use and no use of any intravascular device are protective in our model seem to be a surrogate for relatively better general conditions of the affected children at the time of onset of BSI. Similarly the time from admission to BSI as protective factor is probably due to the age dependent decrease of in hospital mortality in the neonatal population. Finally one might notice that birth weight below 750g significantly increases mortality risk whereas low gestational age is no additional independent risk factor. This may be explained by the approximately linear correlation between gestational age and birth weight in neonates where a deviation from this correlation towards a lower birth weight (small for gestational age) is known to be a risk factor for adverse outcomes including mortality[22].
With follow-up of patients formally ending upon transfer to another department there is a potential risk of losing patients that died in the admitting department for our analysis. While this is a fact and we cannot, by any means, re-identify the patients in the admitting department, we estimate, that this has little impact on the results of our study. NEO-KISS includes all German high level neonatology centers and even almost every German NICU at all, so only very few patients (dying during transport, being transferred to departments in other countries, non-compliance to the surveillance protocol) are not followed up until reaching 1800g or dying.
Our results regarding increased CFR of MCBSI caused by gram-negative bacteria may have implications for the treatment and prevention of BSI in VLBW as probably is worthwhile to focus on gram-negative pathogens from the beginning.
Differences between multi drug resistant organisms (MDRO) and their corresponding drug sensitive counterparts were not investigated in this study, because MDRO infections are still rather rare in the cohort investigated. According to a study from Tsai et al. performed in a NICU in Taiwan, a region with much higher rates of multidrug resistance in gram negative bacteria (18.6%), bacteremia caused by multi drug resistant gram negative bacteria was independently associated with a higher overall case-fatality risk in neonates [8]. Two recent studies, one from the same group, confirmed these findings [6, 7]. This may have an additional impact in the future because of the worldwide increase of antibiotic resistance.
In Taiwan and in another study from Israel, P. aeruginosa was the pathogen causing the highest CFR of MCBSI [5, 7, 9]. Our study also did not consider P. aeruginosa as a causative microorganism, because it is a rare pathogen in the German neonatal population which causes less than 1% of MCBSI.
In addition, two of these studies also identified C. albicans as a significant risk factor for death [8, 9]. While we also observed an increased CFR of C. albicans MCBSI in our crude analysis, it was equal to that of S. aureus after considering the most important confounding factors. This could be explained by the fact that in our setting the underlying general conditions of patients with C. albicans infections are worse, but the micro-organism itself is not more virulent. Another factor could be the widespread use of fluconazole prophylaxis [23] in German NICUs which might not prevent infections in all cases but improve the outcome of some infected patients dependent on risk factors.The major strength of our study is the large database with patient parameters allowing for comprehensive adjusting according to the most important risk factors for VLBW. However, our study also has some limitations. We were unable to include appropriateness of initial antibiotic therapy that was administered at the onset of bloodstream infection in the multivariate analysis. As delayed or inappropriate empiric antibiotic therapy is a major driver of mortality this might explain differences when trying to compare our findings to local results. On the other hand, due to the high coverage of German neonatology departments in our surveillance system, our study probably matches the average clinical situation in current German NICUs.
In addition to this limitation, not all conditions of the VLBW at the onset of infection could be considered and information about susceptibility of pathogens to antimicrobial agents was also not included in the analysis as already mentioned.
The significantly higher risk of death following MCBSI due to E.coli, Enterobacter spp., Klebsiella spp. and Serratia spp. should cause special attention on prevention and treatment of bloodstream infections with these pathogens. While the specific causes of this increase in mortality are still not fully understood, endotoxin release [24] and inappropriate initial therapy are likely to be amongst them. Whether routine microbiological surveillance cultures of patients, that may help to identify colonized patients and to initiate early appropriate treatment and further prevention measures, are an appropriate way to prevent these infections is currently debated in the German neonatological community.
Conclusion
While we were able to confirm the increased CFR of MCBSI caused by gram-negative pathogens irrespective of the specific species, we could not determine an increased CFR for Candida albicans infections compared to S. aureus after adjusting for common risk factors.
Current strategies for the initial treatment of suspected BSI should focus on the most common gram negative pathogens of the newborn to prevent adverse outcomes. While it seems obvious that the delay in treatment of fungal BSI should influence its CFR this might not be the case in all settings. Further research should be directed towards the outcomes of fungal infections in different settings and under different prophylactic regimens.
Author Contributions
- Conceptualization: FS CG PG.
- Data curation: PG CG BCP.
- Formal analysis: FS.
- Funding acquisition: PG CG BCP.
- Investigation: PG CG BCP FS.
- Methodology: FS CG PG.
- Project administration: FS BCP.
- Resources: PG.
- Software: BCP FS.
- Supervision: PG CG.
- Validation: CG PG BCP.
- Visualization: FS.
- Writing – original draft: FS.
- Writing – review & editing: BCP.
References
- 1. Hornik C, Fort P, Clark R, Watt K, Benjamin DJ, Smith P, et al. Early and late onset sepsis in very-low-birth-weight infants from a large group of neonatal intensive care units. Early Hum Dev. 2012;88 Suppl2:S69–74.
- 2. Levit O BV, Li FY, Shabanova V, Gallagher PG, Bizzarro MJ. Clinical and laboratory factors that predict death in very low birth weight infants presenting with late-onset sepsis. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2014;33:143–46. pmid:24418836
- 3. Prieto C, Colomer B, Sastre J. Prognostic factors of mortality in very low-birth-weight infants with neonatal sepsis of nosocomial origin. Am J Perinatol. 2013;30:353–58. pmid:22893550
- 4. Stoll B, Hansen N. Infections in VLBW infants: studies from the NICHD Neonatal Research Network. Semin perinat. 2003;27:293–301.
- 5. Tsai M, Hsu J, Chu S, Lien R, Huang H, Chiang M, et al. Incidence, clinical characteristics and risk factors for adverse outcome in neonates with late-onset sepsis. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2014;33:e7–e13. pmid:23899966
- 6. Hsu JF, Chu SM, Huang YC, Lien R, Huang HR, Lee CW, et al. Predictors of clinical and microbiological treatment failure in neonatal bloodstream infections. Clinical microbiology and infection: the official publication of the European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases. 2015;21(5):482 e9-17. pmid:25749002.
- 7. Tsai MH, Wu IH, Lee CW, Chu SM, Lien R, Huang HR, et al. Neonatal gram-negative bacillary late-onset sepsis: A case-control-control study on a prospectively collected database of 5,233 admissions. American journal of infection control. 2016;44(2):146–53. pmid:26559734.
- 8. Tsai M, Chu S, Hsu J, Lien R, Huang H, Chiang M, et al. Risk factors and outcomes for multidrug-resistant Gram-negative bacteremia in the NICU. Pediatrics. 2014:Feb;133(2):e322–9. pmid:24420803
- 9. Makhoul I, Sujov P, Smolkin T, Lusky A, Reichman B, Israel Neonatal Network. Pathogen-specific early mortality in very low birth weight infants with late-onset sepsis: a national survey. Clin Infect Dis 2005. 2005;40:218–24. pmid:15655738
- 10. Geffers C, Bärwolff S, Schwab F, Gastmeier P. Incidence of healthcare-associated infections in high-risk neonates: results from the German surveillance system for very-low-birthweight infants. J Hosp Infect. 2008;Mar 4.
- 11. Gastmeier P, Geffers C, Schwab F, Fitzner J, Obladen M, Rüden H. Development of a surveillance system for nosocomial infections: The component for neonatal intensive care units in Germany as an example. J Hosp Infect. 2004;57:126–31. pmid:15183242
- 12. Voigt M, Schneider K, Jahrig K. Analysis of a 1992 birth sample in Germany. 1.New percentile values of the body weight of newborn infants. Geburtshilfe Frauenheilkd. 1996;56:550–58. pmid:9036070
- 13. Schwab F, Zibell R, Piening B, Geffers C, Gastmeier P. Mortality due to bloodstream infections and necrotizing enterocolitis in very low birth weight infants. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2015;34(3):235–40. pmid:25742073.
- 14. Leistner R, Thürnagel S, Schwab F, Piening B, Gastmeier P, Geffers C. The impact of staffing on central venous catheter-associated bloodstream infections in preterm neonates—results of nation-wide cohort study in Germany. Antimicrob Resist Infect Control. 2013;Apr 4;2(1):11. pmid:23557510
- 15. Roy P, Kumar A, Kaur IR, Faridi MM. Gender differences in outcomes of low birth weight and preterm neonates: the male disadvantage. J Trop Pediatr. 2014;60(6):480–1. pmid:25096219.
- 16. Townsel CD, Emmer SF, Campbell WA, Hussain N. Gender Differences in Respiratory Morbidity and Mortality of Preterm Neonates. Front Pediatr. 2017;5:6. pmid:28194395; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPMC5276811.
- 17. Benzouina S, Boubkraoui Mel M, Mrabet M, Chahid N, Kharbach A, El-Hassani A, et al. Fetal outcome in emergency versus elective cesarean sections at Souissi Maternity Hospital, Rabat, Morocco. Pan Afr Med J. 2016;23:197. pmid:27347286; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPMC4907743.
- 18. Suwal A, Shrivastava VR, Giri A. Maternal and fetal outcome in elective versus emergency cesarean section. JNMA J Nepal Med Assoc. 2013;52(192):563–6. pmid:25327227.
- 19. Hohlagschwandtner M, Husslein P, Klebermass K, Weninger M, Nardi A, Langer M. Perinatal mortality and morbidity. Comparison between maternal transport, neonatal transport and inpatient antenatal treatment. Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2001;265(3):113–8. pmid:11561737.
- 20. Kaneko M, Yamashita R, Kai K, Yamada N, Sameshima H, Ikenoue T. Perinatal morbidity and mortality for extremely low-birthweight infants: A population-based study of regionalized maternal and neonatal transport. J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2015;41(7):1056–66. pmid:25809407.
- 21. Modanlou HD, Dorchester W, Freeman RK, Rommal C. Perinatal transport to a regional perinatal center in a metropolitan area: Maternal versus neonatal transport. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1980;138(8):1157–64. pmid:7446624.
- 22. Francis JH, Permezel M, Davey MA. Perinatal mortality by birthweight centile. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol. 2014;54(4):354–9. pmid:24731210.
- 23. Cleminson J, Austin N, McGuire W. Prophylactic systemic antifungal agents to prevent mortality and morbidity in very low birth weight infants. The Cochrane database of systematic reviews. 2015;10:CD003850. pmid:26497056.
- 24. Sharma R, Tepas JJ, 3rd, Hudak ML, Mollitt DL, Wludyka PS, Teng RJ, et al. Neonatal gut barrier and multiple organ failure: role of endotoxin and proinflammatory cytokines in sepsis and necrotizing enterocolitis. Journal of pediatric surgery. 2007;42(3):454–61. pmid:17336180.